Snodgrass v. Gilbert et al

Filing 34

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 21 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 30 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; denying 32 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/17/2017. (tvt)

c E rsO FC usas ou
Ln FIE . mc /
A RFI ox A .
T o N kv '
A
.
è
LED
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N DI
STRI T O F W R G I I
C
N A
ROANOKE DI SI
W ON
K EW N SN O D G R ASS,

MA2 1? 2 1
27
#U ( U
;

BY;

C A SE N O . 1 V 00091
7: 6C

Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

CHRI TOPHER GI
S
LBERT, & ,
c

By:Gln E. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnie St e Dit itJudge
e
t d at s s rc

Dee da t)
f n nts.
l a or nc wih t a ompa ng m e a um opi o i i he e
n cc da e t he cc
nyi
mor nd
ni n, t s r by
AD JU D G ED A N D O RD ER ED
asf l s
olow '
.

Pli tf m o i f r onsde a i r r ng hi s e e a
a n ifs
ton or ec i r ton ega di
s upplm nt l

c mpan ( No.3 ) a d h s moi n f rp rilsl l j d me t
o li t ECF
2 n i to o a t l
a mma' u g n
y
( No 3 )aeDENI
ECF . 0 r
ED;

Dee d ns moi n f rs mmayj d me t( No. )i GRANTED
fn a t' to o u r u g n ECF 21 s
I PART AND DENI
N
ED I PART; t m o i i DENI
N
he ton s
ED a t
s o

pl ntf scli unde 28 U. C.j1 t tt f l ng defnda s
ai if ams
r
S.
983 ha he olowi
e nt
c pied t de a hi pr e s t r ug t se do
ons r o l y s ogr s h o h he tp- wn pr n i
ogr m n
r t lai f hi e r ie o t rght t a ce s t c t : Ra f r
e ai ton or s xe cs f he i
o c s he ours io d,
K e ey, W as ngt A da s Ba ks e H a it
gl
hi on,
m , r dal , m lon, Swi y, G ibe t
ne
l r,
Dunc n, St wm , Stl, Pon on, a Gali r a t moton i
a
e
il
t
nd
lha ; nd he
i
s
GR ANTED o t gr
n he ound ofqua ii d i u t a t a1 of pli ifs
lfe mm niy s o l
a ntf

ohe j 1 8 camsa an t ld f n a t whoj i di t emo in;
t r 9 3 li g is al ee d n s
one n h to 1
Pli i scli s a ns t G d Ori m aloom saf a e s
a ntY
am gai t he û
Re lon ir
t f' r umm a iy
rl

DI M I
S SSED wi o tp eu keu d r28U. C.j1 5 b ()a lg ly
t u rj d n e
h
S. 91 A() 1 s e al
âi l ;
vo ous

4.

Pl ntf s cai u r sae 1w a e DI I ED wih u p eudc
ai if l ms nde t t a r
SM SS
t o t rj ie

t r28U. C.j 1 c ( ,( ) a
mde
S.
367()2) 3 ; nd

1 Thecl k s l e naet f l ngdefnda saspa te t t slws t RedOni maloom saf,J. ese ,
er halt nui t he olowi
e nt
ris o hi a ui'
.
on ir
t f M sr
S. a J Fanni M . Count,C.De , M a es C. m B.Le s andH .Clr
D y, .
n, L.
s
elF, pl , Pa
wi,
a ke.

: '

.

5.

Thi m a tri he e REFERRED t t Hon.Pnme a M ea Sa ge ,
s te s r by
o he
l
de r nt
Unie St t M ag sr t J
t d aes
itae udge f t W ese n Ditit of Vigi a,
or he
tr
src
r ni

p ru n t 2 U. C.j6 6 b ( )B) f ra p o rae c u tp oc e i g
u s a t o 8 S.
3 ( )1( , o p r p it o r r e d n s
a pr pa a i of a r por s ti f t a opra e indi of f c ,
nd e r ton
e t e tng orh ppr it
ngs
at
c l i of l a a r omm e d diposton f t r i ng
oncusons
aw, nd ec
nde s ii or he ema ni
cai .
l ms

ENTER:Thi I # da ofM ac 201
sN
y
rh, 7.

ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

2