Kiser v. SWVRJA

Filing 32

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 1/17/2017. (tvt)

ct ' o- t e u : of s te
aRKs
o
m œ j

A D N ,A
T A MQiV
FI
LED

1 1? 2 1
AN
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W VSTERN DI
STRI O F W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI SI
W ON
RI
CKY KI
SER,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

SW VRJA ,
De e
f ndant
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

JU
BY:

.
D
D

@

L
EY
C

RK
K

Ci lA c i N o.7: 6- v- 29
vi t on
1 c 001

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By:

H on.Jac o L.K i e
ks n
sr
Se or U ni e St t sD i t c Judge
ni
t d a e s ri t

Riky Kie , Vigi aprs rpr e ngpr â ûld a cvi rg sa tonplrua t
c
s r a r ni ione oce di
o q, e
i l i ht ci zs nt o
.

4 U. C. 1 8 , a n t So t we tVignaRe in l alAu h rt a t s l d fn a t
2 S. j 9 3 n mig he u h s r ii go a J i t o i s he oe e e d n .
y

OnOco e 31 201 ,h d fn a tfldamoinf rs
tb r , 6 t e ee d n ie
to o umma yj d me t Ont en x d y t
r u g n . h e t a ,he
Clr is e aNp iet a a v s dPlitf t a amoinf rs mma yj d me twa sldo
ek su d tc h t d ie an if h t to o u r u g n s e n
Oc o r31 201 a t tPl i ifha t nt oneda fom t Nè i et fl ar s ns . The
t be , 6, nd ha antf d we yys r he tc o ie e po e
No i f rhe a s
tce ' t r dvied:
u
I Pl ntf doe no r pond t De e n ' pladi ,t Cour wilasume t t
f ai if s t es
o f nda ts e ngs he
t l s
ha
Pl i if has l t i e s i t c e,a or t tPl ntf a e wih wha t
antf
os nt m t n he as nd/ ha ai if gr es t
t he

De e a t sae i t i (ij rs nsve pla ig s..I Plitf wih s t
fnd n tt s n her sc epo i e dn t) f anif s e o
c i wih t c e i i ne e s r t t Pli tf r s
ontnue t he as , t s c s a y ha a n if e pond i a a opra e
n n ppr it
f s on .... Howe .i Pl i ifdoe notfl s m e r s
a hi
ver f àntf
s
ie o
e pons wihi t t nt
e t n he we vo ( )da pe i t Cour m a dimist c s f f iur t pr ec e.
ne 21 v rod. he
t y s s he a e or a l e o os ut
,

Noie( n 31 ( rgn l mp ss.
t ECF o. ) o iia e hm i)
c
Plitf ddno rs n t t Noieo t emoinf rsl r j d me ta dt e
an if i t epo d o he tc r h to o l
mmay u g n , n h
Notc wasnotr tzne t t c ta t i a e. Pur ua t t Notc e e e on
ie
e t d o he our s mdelver bl
r
s nt o he ie ntr d
Nove be 1 201 Ifnd t tPli ifhasf ie t pr ec et sc e.Ac di y, he
m r , 6, i ha antf
a ld o os ut hi as
cor ngl t

c mpan i ds s e wi u p eu ief rPlitf f izet p o e u e pu s n t Fe R.
o lit s imis d t t rj d c o anifs alr o r s c t, rua t o d.
ho
l
Ci P. () a dal e dngmo in aed n e wi o t rj d c a mo t S eLil v
v. 41b , n l p n i
to s r e id t u p eu ie s o. e r .
h
k
F a a hR. Co.3 0U. 6 6 6 0 31( 9 2 (Th a t o iyo ac u t od s s s as o t
b s R. , 7 S. 2 , 3 - 1 6 ) d e u h rt f o r t imis u p ne
t

f l c ofpr e uto ha ge r l bee c i r d a tnhe e po r'... c s dl ve t
or a k
os c i n s ne aly n onsde e n i r nt we , ne es a y sed
i c t t m a e t rown a f r s ast a hi t o de l a e
n ours o nag hei
fais o o c eve he r ry nd xpedto diposton of
ii us s ii

C e .)
aS S'.
'

E E T il = dyoJnay21.
NT R:hs
a faur,07
k

î n rUntds ae I i J g
se
ie tts krc ud e

2