Haga v. New River Valley Regional Jail

Filing 17

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 6/2/2016. (tvt)

ctERK' OFFI U.s. Sm COURT
- s
CE
DI
ATRoM oc ,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI STATES DI TRI COURT
N
TED
S CT

JrN g2 g j
gg

FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

'
:
BY:

R O B ER T D AV I H A G A ,
D
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

By:

H on.M i
chaelF.U rbans
ki
Unied St e D it i tJudge
t
at s s r c

Robe t vi Haga aVig ni i m a epr ee ngpr K , ie a cvi rght co pl nt
r Da d
, r i a n t oc di
o fld i l i s m ai

pu s n t 42U.. j1 3.Plitf n me teNe lie ValyRe in l al ç a1)a te
rua t o
SC. 98 anif n s h w kv r l
e go a J i (J i' s h
& '

d fn n a fldamo int j i teJ i' Su rne d n , r l M c a a a oh r
ee da t pd ie
to o on h als peitn e t Gead pe k, s n t e
d fn a t Th smatri b f r t ec u t o s re n , u s n t 28U.. 51 5 Afe
ee d n . i te s e oe h o r f r ce nig p rua t o
SC. 91 A. tr
r ve n P an ifss b s in ,h c u t rn st moi nt j i a dd s se tec mpan
e iwi g litf u miso s t e o r g a t he to o on n imiss h o lit
wi o t rj d c f rf ingt saeacam u n wh c rle ma b g a td.
t u p eu ie o al o tt li po ih eif y e r ne
h
i
1.

An t e imaea t eJ i b o ePlitf jw a n s a o n 50 p. o Fe r a y
o h r n t t h al r k anifs a nd o e r u d :0 m. n b u r
'

p: '

CLERK '

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI

NEW W VER VALLEY REGI
ONAL
JA IL,etal,
.
D ef
endant
s.

U

C i lA c i N o.7: c
vi t on
16- v-

V.

.

j
,

1 20l Pli ifwases ore t t J i' m e ca de rm e whe ehe di notr c i a
5, 6. antf
c td o he als di l pa t nt r
d
e e ve ny

me ia a ssa c t i 1 3 p. whe an rec n ime teij re b td dno p o iea y
dc l s itn e mtl 0:0 m. n u s o fr d h nu is u i t r vd n
pa n r le . Pl i ifw asnott a po t d t a hos t ' e e g y de rt e t tl
i e i f a ntf
r ns r e o
pials m r enc pa m nt m i
a oxi a e y 2: p. . he ne da The e e ge y r
ppr m t l 00 m t
xt y.
m r nc oom phys ci n al o c im e t
i a s onfr d he

iju e a p e ci e a a tboi, lq i d e, ndap e cito f r75ml f r o whc
n ti s nd r srb d n ni itc a i ud ita
r s rp in o . o Noc , ih
i ac
s ombi ton ofa t mi phe a hydr
na i
ce a no n nd
ocodo ,e r sx ho s.
ne ve y i ur
'

.

Pl i ifr t ne t t J i by 4: p. .a w a t d hi pai m edi a i w oul notbe
a ntf e ur d o he a l
30 m nd s ol s n
c ton
d
pr ded untlt ne da bec us t pha m a y t tJ i us d w a t boutt c os ' W he he
ovi
i he xt y a e he r c ha a l e
sç
a
o l e.
'
n
di r e ve pa n m e c ton,i w asno t N or o pr c i d by t e e ge y r m phys c a
d ec i
i
di a i t
t he
c es r be
he m r nc oo
i i n.

I t a t J i' physcin,al ge y pur ua t J i E iy,'s tt t hal apilof
nse d,he a ls
i a le dl
s nt o a l t c ' ubsiu ed f l
pol
hyd oc
r odone#10 e r sx ho sf 7. mlofNor e r sx holr . Pli ifaloge r ly
ve y i ur or 5
co ve y i zs antf s ne al

c mpli t t J in relc e t ea t o i t c a j t ep e c ie lq i d e i a
o ans ha a al u s a k d h u h rt o h n e h r s rb d i ud it n n
y
uns c se w a
pe i d y.
II.

Theco tmus dim isa a ton orc am fld by a i aei t cour de e mi st t
ur
t s s n ci
l i ie
n nm t f he
t t r ne ha

t a to o ca m i fi ousorf ist sae ac am o whi h r le m a begr nt d. Se 28
he c i n r li s rvol
al o t t l i n
c ei f y
a e
e

U. C. j1 5e( ) 1 1 A( )1 ; 2U. C. 1 9 ec .Thefrtsa adicu e cams
S. j 91 ()2 , 9 5 b ( ) 4 S. j 9 7 ()
is tnd r n l d s li
ba ed upon ç n i s abl me il s l ga t or ' < l msofi rnge ntofa lga i e e t
s
G ndiput y rte s e l he yy ç ai
a
'c
nfi me
e l ntr s

whih cea l doe no e s ' cli swhe et Gf c ta co e i a ecla l ba ees '
c l ry s t xit'or am
r he ça tz l nt ntons r e ry s l s.
'

Netk v W ila , 0U. 31 , 27( 9 9 .Th s c n sa adi tefmiirsa d r f r
i e . lims 49 S. 9 3 1 8 ) e e o d tnd r s h n la tn ad o
z
amotont dimisunde Fedea Rul ofCi lPr ed e 1 b)6) a ce i apl ntf'
i o s s
r rl e
vi oc ur 2( ( , c ptng ai ifs
'

f c ua a l to astue.A c
a t l legai ns r
ompli ne dsç s r a pl n sa e e oft ca m s wi
ant e û ho t nd ai t tm nt he li ho ng
a

t a tepla e i e tte t r l f' n s fiin t ta t a alg to . . or iearg tt
h t h e d r s n i d o ei a d u fce tsl cu l l ains . t as i h o
l
e
g
e
rle a
eif bovet s ultvelve .... BelAt.Co . Two v,550U. 5 555( 7)
he pec ai e l ' l l p v. mbl
'
S. 44, 200

(ne a q o ain makso te ) p an ifsb ssfrr le çe u rsmo et a lb l a d
itnll u tto r mitd .A litf a i o eif l q ie r h n a es n
r
c l i .... I The e or apl i ifmus tal gef t s fc e t sae a1t elm e s
oncusons
' d. r f e, antf
'
t sle acs ufi i nt o t t 1 he e nt
'
s
o gh jcam.1 Ba sv. .. upontdeN em our & Co., 3 4F.d7 , 6 ( t Ci. 0 )
f te li ' s E I D
2 3 61 7 5 4h r 20 3 .

l tnni ng whehe acompl ntsatsaplusbl cl m f r i i E co e -pe fct k t tr quies
Dee ni
t r
ai t e
a i e ai or elef s $ ntxts cii as ha e r
a

terve hgc u toda o i j dca e p re c a dc mmo s ne' As co v.q l5 6U.. 6 6 87
h e iwi o r t rw n t q iil x e in e n o n e s. h r A Iba, 5 S 6 2, 7 -9
s
'
(0 9 .Th s ac u t cenigac mpan u d r l 1 ()6 cnie tf pla ig ta aeno e tt dt a
2 0 ) u , o r sre n o lit n e Rue 2b () a d niy e dn s h t r t nil o n
e
as
s umpton oft t be us t y c s ofno mor t lbesa c usons.l A lho t c tlbe al
i
ruh ca e he onsit
e han a l nd oncl i
d. t ugh he our i r ly
c tuespr .
ons r
oK

c mpans Han sv Ken r 4 4U. 5 9 5 - (9 2,h c u t o sno a t sa imaes
o lit, ie . r e, 0 S. 1 , 2021 1 7 )te o r d e t c a n n t'

a
dvocae s s ede opi sa uor andco tt i cl msno cl ryr s i acompl nt SeeBr kv.
t, ua oont vel ng tt t y
nsiutonal ai
t ea l aied n
ai .
oc

Car l 1 7F.d2 1 2 3(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti, .c n u i g ; a et . t o Ha tn 7 5F. 1 7 ,
rol 0 3 4 , 4 4h r 1 9 ) Lu t J, o c n n l Beud tv Ciy f mpo , 7 2d 2 4
,
g
1 8( hCi.1 8 )s eas God nv. e e 5 4F.d 1 4 ,1 51( t Ci.1 7 )(e o nzn ta adsrc
27 4t r 9 5; e lo r o Le k , 7 2 1 7 1 4h r 9 8 rc g iig h t itit
c ti note cedt a s et r eofadvoc t f rapr . pli if.
our s
xpe t o s um he ol
ae o
oK ant )
f

2

Tosaeacam u d rj1 3, plitf mus alg th v oaino arg ts c rdb
tt li n e 98 a an if t le e t e ilto f ih e u e y
t
t Consiutona lwsoft Unie Stts a mus s t tt alge de i to was
he
tt i nd a
he td ae , nd t how ha he le d /rvain

c mmitdb ap ro a t u e c lro saelw. W etv Atis 4 7U. 4 48(û 8.
o te y esn ci nd r oo f tt a ' s . kn , 8 S. 2, 1 8 )
ng
'
Howe r t J i i notaç ron'f pupos sofj1
ve ,he al s
t s 'or
pe
e
983.Se Prva v.Re 5 F.Supp.
e e l
no, 7
2d

3 7 31 ( D. .1 9 )(ç hePid n Re ina J i i n t ç ro 'a dt rf r n t
0 , 0 E. Va 9 9 :T) e mo t g o l als o a t s nr n heeo e o
(
pe '
n na l t s i u d r4 U. C. 1 8 .) afdL p r a drv' L p r, 0 F.d8 (t Ci.
me be o u t n e 2 S. j 9 3', f' q a t n e d q a t2 3 3 21 4 h r
'
2000 , e t i f ltxtf ma a 200 U. App.
) rpored n ul-e or t t 0 S.
LEXI 465,a *3,2000W L 20591, t*1
S
t
a
(t c talopr pel deemi dt tt Pidmon Re o J i i notal s n'a i
s
The our s o ry tr ne ha he e
t ginal al s
pero nd s

t eeo eno a n b et s i u d rj1 3g ' .
h rf r t me a l o ut n e 98 .'
1)
Pl i ifa s f l t sat a cai ag ns Su rnt nde M c ak. Pli ifdoesnot
antf lo ais o t e l m ai t pe i e nt pe
antf
ale a pe s na i ve e wih t alege te t e t orl k t r of ofPli if s
l ge ny r o l nvol m nt t he l d r a m n , ac he e ,
a ntf

ijlis S e ec, s e v. a hn tnM er . e TrnstAu h r, 9 F.d 1 3 , 1 2 4
nt e . e . ..Fih r W s igo to Ara a i t o .6 0 2 1 3 1 4 - 3
r
(t Ci. 9 2 .Al u h S peitnd n M c a r s nd dt s v r l fPli tf g iva e ,
4 h r 1 8 ) t g u rn e e t pe k epo e o e e a o anifs re nc s
ho
ça s p ro ' a trt,-a td n a o ag iv nc f l f.s r o e tbls i j1 8 la ii '
t q u ei rs fe-hef c e il f re a e al a ho t f sa ihng 9 3 ib ly.
l
s r
t'
De
paol v.
a Ray, o. 1 v001 201 U . D i t LEX I 11 2,a * 201 W L 4451
N 7: 2c
39, 3 S. s .
S 718 t 23, 3
236,a
t

* ( . Va J y2 , 01 )( r e tM .. (iigBr o sv. ad 1 7F. p' 9 3 9 5(r
8 W D. . ul 2 2 3 Sag n , J) ctn o k Be r , 6 Ap x 2 , 2 3d
Ci. 0 6 ) Plitf d e alg p sigyt a aJ i ç oiy' a s dteJ i' ph sca t
r 2 0 ). anif o s le e a sn l h t ali lc 'c u e h als y iin o
p
s tt eonehydr
ubsiut
ocodonete m e f a t rt m a epan.Howe r Pl ntf doe no
r at nt or no he o nag i
ve , ai if s t
a lge Superntnde M c ak' ivol m e wiht m odii to t t pr c i i n o lqui
le
i e nt pe s n ve nt t he
fcai ns o he es rpto r i d

de, n , r u n o aj i' us o afr lr d e n tn u tt d l eaei dfee c t
it a d a g e d , als e f o muay o s o mo n o ei rt n ifr n e o
b
Pl i if s c tt i na r g s Se e. ,M one lv.D e tofSoc. r . 436 U . 658,690a ntf ' ons iuto l i ht . ee g.
l
p'
Se vs ,
S.
94

( 9 8 .Ac o dngy tec mp an fist saeacam u nwh c rle ma b g a td.
1 7 ) c r i l,h o lit al o tt li po ih eif y e rn e
3

11
1.

Fo t f r g i ra o s tec u t imisstec mp an wih u p eu iefrfiig
r he o e ong e s n ,h o r ds se h o lit t o t rj dc o aln
t sa eacli upon whih r le ma begr nt Be a ePl i ifma pos i y sae ac am
o tt
am
c ei f y
a ed. c us antf y sbl t t l i
a i tadif e pary,he i g a t d l a f t ry da t n e t c
ga ns
fer nt t
s r n e e ve or hit ys o m nd he ompl i i a or nc
ant n cc da e
wih Fe r Rul so Ci lPr e e 1 1 1 a 20t sae ac am a i tadif r n pa t
t de al e f vi oc dur 5, 8, 9, nd
o t t l i gans
fe e t ry.

ZW' dyo
V a

E T R: h
N E Ti
s

,

21.
06
/
+/

4 >

.

Unied Stt Diti tJ
t
a es slc ud

4

.