Hubbard v. Ratledge

Filing 12

ORDER granting 4 Motion to Dismiss; Certificate of Appealability is DENIED. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/7/2017. (tvt)

rdFRK' OFFI U, DI COUX
S
CE S. SX
AT rr2'OKE, A
? '.1
.
V
.
);. ..
.(zt
t. ;
.

FE 27 2 1
B
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COI RT
CT
J
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O AN OK E DI SI N
W O
CR EA DELL H UBBA RD ,

Pe ii r
ttone ,
Y.

CH ARIES M TLEDGE,W ARDEN,
,
Res
pondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

JUL
BY;

D k' 'Y C
w'
'. '
'

CASE NO.7:
16CV00188

FI
NAL ORDER
By:GlnE. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnt d S a e DititJ e
e ie t t s src udg

I ac or ewih t a c pa ngm e o a
n c danc t he c om nyi
m r ndum opi on,i i he e
ni t s r by
A D JUD G ED A ND O R D ERE D

t tt moton t dim isi GR ANTED;t pe ii f awrtofha asc pus pur ua t 28
ha he
i o s s s
he tton or
i
be or , s nt o

U.. j2 41 i DI M I ED; n t i a to i src e fo t ea t d c to t c u t
SC. 2 , s S SS a d h s cin s tik n r m h ci o ke f he o r.
ve
Furhe ,fndi t tpeii rha f l t m a a s tntals
t r i ng ha ttone s aied o ke ubsa i howi oft de a ofa
ng he ni l

c n tmto a rg t a rq ie b 28 U. C. j 2 3 c () a c riiae o a pe lb l y i
o si in l ih s e ur d y
S.
25 () 1, et c t f p aa ii s
f
t
D ENI .
ED

ENTER:Thi N
s

d yo Fe nzr , 2017.
a f b ay

Chi U ie Stt sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge