Harris v. Virginia Department of Corrections et al

Filing 32

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/17/2017. (tvt)

'

cœ v s OFFI U. DI COURT
CE s. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

J 1 ?2 1
Ad
27
I T H E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T CO UR T J
C
u

ou E CL RK
x E

FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI UF W RGI AB ;'
CT
NI Y
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O
CH AR LE S M .H AR R I
S,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

CL RK
E

C i lA c i N o.7: 6- vvi ton
1 c 00205

M EM O R AN D UM O PIN IO N

VI G I I DEPAR TM E NT O F
R N A
C O RR EC TI N S,e a1,
O
t .
D ef
endant
s.

By:

H on.M i
chaelF.U rbansl
d
U nie St t sD i t i tJudge
td a e src

Cha l sM . ri ,aVigi ai aepr e ngpr K , ied a c vi r g s a ton
re
Ha rs
r ni nm t oce di
o fl
i l i ht c i
.

ptrua t 42U. C.j1983, mi saf o t Vigi aDe rme ofCore tonsa
ls nt o
S.
na ng t f f he r ni pa t nt
rci s

d fnd ns OnNo mb r29 2 6 t ed f n a t fldamoinf rs mmayj d me t On
ee a t.
ve e , 01 ,h e e d n s ie
to o u r u g n .
t en x d y t Clr is e aNo ie a v sngPlitf t a amo inf rsl r j d me t
h e t a ,he ek su d tc , d ii anif h t to o l
mma y u g n
wasfl d a t theha t nt o da fom t Notc t fl ar s e.TheN o i f rhe
ie nd ha
d we y- ne ys r he ie o ie e pons
tce u t r
a s d:
dvi e
f a ntf
t e pond t D e e nt s l pl a ngs t Cour w ila sz e t t
o f nda ' El e di , he
l Pl i ifdoesno r s
t l s lm ha
Pl i if has l t i e e ti t c s ,a / t t Pl ntf a e wih wha t
antf
os nt r s n he a e nd or ha ai if gr es t
t he

Dee a t sae i ter (ij r s o sv p e dng s. l Pli t f wih s t
fnd n tts n h i sc e p n ie la i t) f ani s e o
f
c tnue w ih t c e, i i ne s a y t t Pl i if r s nd i a a o i t
on i
t he as t s ce s r ha a ntf e pp n n ppr pr a e
f s on . .. Howe r i Pl ntf doesno fl s er s ns wihi t t nt
a hi .
ve s f ai if
t ie om e po e t n he we y-

o ( )da pe i t Co utm a dim ist c ef f iur t pr e ut
ne 21 v rode he t ' v s s he as or al e o os c e.

Notc ( no.30)(rgi e
ie ECF
oi nal mpha i)
ss.

Plitf d dno rs n t t Noieo t emoinf rsl r u g n ,heNo ie
an if i t epo d o he tc r h to o l
mma yj d me t t
tc
wasnotr t dt t c t undelve a e,a Pl i ifha notwrte t t c r snc J y
eunw o he our as
i r bl nd antf s
itn o he ou t i e ul
201 Pur ua t t N otc ent r o N ove be 30, 6, he c t i t tPl i ifha
6. s nt o he i e e ed n
m r 201 t our f nds ha a ntf s

fie t p o e u eti c s .Ac o dn l,h c mp an i d s se wi u p eudc p ru n
ald o r s c t h s a e c r igy te o lit s imis d t t rj ie u s a t
ho
t Fed. Ci P.41b)d t Pli ifsf l et pr e ut,a a1pe ngmotonsaedeze
o
R. v. ( ue o antf aiur o os c e nd 1 ndi
i r lid
: ec ut tst ta1d fn a t fldtemoinfrs mmayj g n.
Th o rnoe ha 1 ee d n s ie h to o u x ud met

'!

J

wih u p eu iea mo t S eLik v W a a hR. Co.37 U. 6 6 6 0 31( 9 2 (û'e
t o t rj dc s o . e n . b s R. , 0 S. 2 , 3 - 1 6 ) û h
f
a hort ofac tt dim iss s ef lc ofpr ec i ha ge r l bee c i r
ut iy
our o s s ua pont or a k
os uton s ne aly n onsde ed
a tnhe e po r'... c s rl ve t i c t t m a get i own afar s a t ac e
n i r nt we y ne es a iy sed n ours o na he r
f is o s o hive

t o d rya e p dto ds sto o c s s'
he r el nd x e i us ipo iin f a e .
i
).
ENTER: s /? da ofJ nuay, 2017.
Thi
y a r
*
.

#
în'.)::1 1.
i / ..-.
è L.;q. 2.
è . -.q .
'1r '
,i
?

.

......
-. :.
.

.

f
'

..
.
.

.

..
.

f, . .
. .
,r -.
. ..'q .
. .
' .

.

$

i..

.
.

:
.

'

Um'e St t sDititJ dge '
t d a e src u
'

' .
,