Crawley v. Mitchell et al

Filing 36

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/12/2017. (slt)

CLERKSOFFI U.S. SI COUR)
CE
DI
AT RoANoc ,
VA
FI ED
L

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W R GI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

J 12 2 1
UL
27
JULW . UD
CLERK
BY:
' n
v
c

V.

J. I A EL PA R SO N S,etaI,
M CH
.
D ef
endant
s.
D A W D CM W LEY ,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

M R .M I
TCH EL L,e àl,
t .
Dee
f ndant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

C i lA c i N o.7: 5- vvi ton
1 c 00647

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

D AV I CR AW LEY ,
D
Pl ntf
ai if,

Ci lA c i n N o.7: c 00211
vi t o
16- v-

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Hon. ihae F.Ur ki
M c l
bans
ChifUnied St e Dit itJudge
e t ats src

M EM OM NDUM O PI ON
NI
By:

H on. ihaelF.Ur
M c
bans
ki
Chi f Uni e St e D i t i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

D a d Cr wl y,aVigi ai a eand a ad r nto t Hous ofYa h f ih,fl d
vi a e
r ni nm t
n he e f he
e
hwe at ie

t s acinspr K unde 42U. C.j1 3.Ther mai ngdeenda i c e7:5-vhe e to o
r
S. 98
e ni f ntn as 1 c 00647i
s

Cha li M i h l o teW aln Rig SaePrs n(: RS ', n t ed fn a t i c s 7:6
pan t el f h le s d e tt io : P' a d h e e d n s n a e 1 c
W
)
c 00211a eCha an M ic l;Le leFl ng,t W a de ofW RSP;He y Po on,a
vr
pl i t he l si emi he r n
nr nt
l

Vign aDe a t n o Co rcin (VDOC' Re i n l mi srtr a Da i Ro is n
r ii p rme t f re to s 1
ç
' go a Ad nitao ; nd v d bn o ,
)
t eVDOC' Chi fofCone tonsOper tonsl Pl i ifal ge t tt ede e nt vi a e
h
S e
ci
ai . antf le s ha hes f nda s olt d
t Fis a Foure nt Am e e t oft Unie St t sConsiu i by pr ven i hi
he r t nd
te h
ndm n s he t d a e
tt ton
e tng s

' anif a as c mme e atidato a o ttesmesbe t te a an t n o tesme
Plitfh d lo o nc d hr cin b u h a uj c matr g is ma y f h a
dee nt i Cr wlv v.
fnda s n a e Robi on.e al,No. 1 cvns t .
7:5- 00648.Robi o Flm i a anI tt tonalPr a s
ns n, e ng, nd nsiu i
op m

M a a e CI M' ween me a dee d nsi 7:5c -0 48b t o Ch pli Mi h l Byame rn u
n g r $P ' r a d s fn a t n 1 -v0 6 u n t a an t el
)
c .
moa d m

o ni a o de e t r i 7: c 00648,hecou co l d t Robi o Flmi a t I we ee il
pi on nd r r n eed n 15-vt
rt ncude hat ns n, e ng, nd he PM r ntted

t s mmayjdg n.Bytesmeme rn u o i o a od rta wa as e trdi 7:5c - 0 47 t
o u r u me t
h a
moa d m pnin nd re h t s lo nee n 1 -v 0 6 ,he
c u t o cu e ta Po tnwa as e tte t s mmayj g n .Th st ec u t a ara yFa tdsl r
o r c n ld d h t no s lo n i d o u r ud me t u ,h o rh s le d ne l
l
mmay
j g n t Ro i o , e n , n Po tni 7 1 -v 0 6 7a 7:5c -0 4 f rh smecamsalg d
ud me t o bnsn Flmig a d no n :5c - 0 4 nd 1 -v0 6 t o te a li le e
a ns t m a n i 7:6- v- 211.Neve t es 7:5- 00647 rmai pendi agans Chapli M ic l
gai t he gai n 1 c 00
rhel s, 1 cve ned
ng i t
an thel.

pa tci ton i t prs sobs r nc ofPa s ri Aprl201 and t Fe tofTa m a l s
ri pa i n he ion' e va es
s ove n
i
5
he as
be c e
i se e be 201 2
n ptm r 5.

Th s t c s saerpef rtec u tsr ve t a j d c t Ch p anM ic els
e e wo a e r i o h o r' e iw o du iae a li th l'

s p lme tlmo inf rsl r j g n i c s 7:5 c - 0 4 a Cha li M ic el
u p e n a to o l
mma y ud me t n a e 1 -v 0 6 7 nd pan th l,
Flmi , n o a dRo i o sfrtmo inf rsl r j d me ti c s 7:6 c 0 21 .
e ng Po tn, n bns n' is to o l
mma y u g n n a e 1 -v- 0 1
l a cor ncewih t c tsprorm e a
n c da
t he our' i
mor ndum o ni n e e e i c e 7: 5- vpi o ntr d n as s 1 c
00647 a 7: cvnd 15- 00648,Fl mi Po on,a Robi on a e e il t qua i i lniy a
e ng, nt nd
ns r ntted o lied mm l t nd

s mma yj d me tfra1 li a an the Fu te, ld f n a t a ee tte t q ai d
u r u g n o l cams g is t m. rh r a1 e e d n s r n i d o u l
l
ûe
i liya sl r u pn n a o t h Fe s o Ta e ce .Ho v r t ecamsa u
mml t nd l
n
mma yj d e t b u t e a t f b ma ls we e ,h li bo t
Pa s v ra an t panM i hels al r c e t j r til
so e g is Cha li t l h lp o e d o u y ra.
c
1.
A.

7: 5- v1 c 00647

Th c u t rv o syh dg a tds mmayj d me tt d fn a t Pa s n , n o , n
e o r p e i u l a rn e u r u g n o ee d n s ro s Po t n a d
Fl mi i ca e7:5- ve ng n s 1 c 00647 be a et y ha notvi aeda f de alrg ,l vi Cha an
c us he d
olt
e r i ht ea ng
pl i
M ic l a t onl r mai ng def nda .Pl i ifc am st tCha an M ic l r f e t
thel s he y e ni
e nt antf l i ha
pl i t he l e us d o
honorhi r quesst the bei l d on t 201 Pa s rls i a co danc wihpolc whih
s e t ha
ncude
he 5 s ove it n c r e t
i y, c
pr ve e Pli iffo r cevi Pas ove mea sorm a ng Pa s rr lt co mi s r
e nt d a ntf r m e i ng s r l
ki
s ove -ea ed m s a y
pur has .
c es

On Aprl9,201 Pli iffld a i or lc
i
5, antf ie n nf ma ompli ,sa hl
ant t t g:

I t e mo t o M a lhq 201 a d Ap 3 d tr u h 1 t 2 5 l wa
n h
n h f rc
5 n
dl r h o g 0h, 01 ,
s
dici nae a ns a mbirrl de i dqofmy rghtt fe l e rie
s rmi td gai t nd taiy prvel
i o r ey xecs
r lgi
ei ous bei f be us of my c e f t Ya h. Afe s ndi
le s ca e
hos n aih, hwe
tr e ng
2Pl ntf di noti ntf t Fe s ofTa r cl i t c
ai if d
de iy he a t
bena es n he ompl ntbuti t d c l i t çolowai
nsea aled t he i l up
f
f s. Heas cald i t çma up'Pa s rf s i a nitai greva s AAe defnda sfld amoi
eat'
'
lo le t he s ke- ' s ove ea t n dmi srtve i nce .
r e nt ie
ton

frsmmayj d me tPli ifcaiidta rfrn e t t çolw-p' rR k -p'e s men teFe s o
o u r u g n, antf lrfe h t eee c s o heç lo u 'o ma eu 'fat a th at f
f

Ta nace i Se em be 201
ber ls n pt
r 5.

a p o i tl )1 r q e ts t t eCh pli ( ic el b t e Au u t 2 4
p r xlmaey 2 e u sgq o h a an M th l ewe n ggs) 01
)
t rug M a gh) 2 5 a d t E- is fo my c t eo lq Ro e a1
h o h rc 01 , n wo mal rm
oms lry s , l
i tuci t Cha ljnt a myna t t Ya h' PASSOVER ls.1
nsr tng he plai o dd
me o he hwe s
it ,
n rmy c t eo g rc ie arpl. Theeo e i Ma lh 2 5 Iwa d n e
o
omsl r, e ev d e y
q
rf r n rc ) 01
s e id
m y r lgi usprvieg t or rKos rie sa tc t t Ya h Pas o r
ei o
i l es o de
he t m ta hed o he hwe
s ve
cee a i a lot pe mit t pa tcpae i my r i ous f ih c l br t d
lbr ton nd ï
r ted o rii t n
elgi
at e e a e

Pa s v rme l fe c mpyngwih E rtn P o e u e(OP'q8 .(.
so e a a tr o li t opeaig r c d r û ' 413 4
ç )
De e ntCha ai M ic l r s nde o Aprl1 201 a trPa s re d,m ii ç n'
f nda
pl n thel e po d n
i 3, 5, fe s ove nde
tng, ç y,
so

you we enoton t Lit'
r
he s .
'
Pl i iffl d ar a gre nc m ii
antf ie egulr i va e, tng:

Th ra o my n meinto t els t p rii t i . . s o r(sbe a s )
e e sn
n s ' n h it o a t pae n . Pa s ve i c u e
c
t e Cha lln a W RSP f is t a we r q e t o e is a d fis t
h
pla i t
al o ns r e u s r mal, n al o
a k o e e my rlg o a s ia l t wo s i Thi Ch p lln d en'
c n wldg
eiin s utbe o rhp.
s a lai o s t
pr de lt r tle f Ya w e wor hi r , nor e r ma r
ovi ie a tr or h h
s pe s
ve
ke ounds i t
n he
s r gai uniss a ofe rc n m a i uii sa utr lgi ma t s
eg e ton t o ny f nde a
ke nq re bo e i ous ter .
Hi f iur t f l a polc i s e y t r as 1wasar ta iy de
s al e o olow ny i y s oll he e on
bir rl pdve of
d

pat iaig i . .Pa s v r a wh as M a gh 2 5 I wa s b e tt
ri p tn n . so e, nd y lo rc q 01
c
s u jc o
dic i na i whe de e my rg t or rPa s rie s
s rmi ton n nl d
i ht o de s ove t m .

W a de Fl mi de m e t g va Cmf mde 'a Pl ntf al ge i t a a
r n e ng e d he de nce t ot d,' nd ai if le d n he ppe l
t
oft r gul rgre nce:
he e a i va

On ( c mbe 2 ,2 1 )a d ( rh 1 ,2 5 Iha Coms lr Ro e s n
De e r 9 0 4 n Mac 6 01 ) d t eo s e d
e is s cfc l if r n ( a li) M i hel t a d my nn t t e
mal pe iial n o mig Ch p an t l o d
y
c
me o h
Pa s r ls be a e . .Cha ai M ic l wa r f i t r s
s ove it c us .
pl n t he l s e usng o e pond t my
o

rques. Pe 8 3 4. Pr dur,A.Acc s t Rei ous Se vce ,S.K.o
e t r 41. ) oce e
e s o lgi
ri s - n
pa 4,tsa e t Cha ai wilbepr de ac
ge i tt s he
pl n l
ovi d omput ra a1sa r ofi e
e nd 1 t nda d fc

s p le i o d rt c ryo tt i (ijd te . Theeo e (s Co ms lrRo e
u p is n r e o ar u her sc u is
rf r , iq t eo s
a s l ng a
lo yi bouts ndi E- a l,o a e you now goi t s y t Cha ai
e ng m is r r
ng o a he
pl n

wan' p o i e a c mpu gjgj Yo c n c n a tComs lrRo e a o tmy
s t r v d d o ter'
?
u a o tc t eo s b u
e f t a hi E- l t t Cha ai a
fors nd s mais o he pl n boutt Pa s r
he s ove .
Pont n uphed W a de Fl mi sdecson,notngPl i ifsca m co d notbe s tnta e
o
l
r n e ng'
ii
i
antf li ul
ubsa it d.
TheVDOC is d M e o a
s ue
m r ndum /04- 5 on J r 26,
/ 201
mma y 2015, bo t VDOC'
a ut he
S

Pasove obs r a s he ze i Aprl201 (heG sove M e r ndlm' ThePasove
s r e v nce c dtld n i 5 t ç s r mo a l ).
pa
s r
M e or ndlm de c i t pr n mi a r gul to f G wih, e sa cJ wih,
m a l s rbed he ogr m ng nd e ai ns or ve s M s ini e s
3

Ya wio o s o Ya we a dPhld lhi Chzc o Go ( mae )wh aeo tepa sls
h s u e f h h n ia ep a l h f d i ts o r n h s it
r
n
f t er lg ons'a wa t pa tcpae i Pas ove holda ThePa s ve M e a l
or hes ei i ' nd nt o rii t n s r i y.
s o r mor ndlm

rquie i t tde ii t o evePa s r(olma t i i e insknowni m ii
e r d nmaes i srng o bs r sove t ke her ntnto
n tng,

icu i whc me l lnte d sr ,ot ( a d n o d sg e a la t3 d y p i r ote
n ldng ih a p a h y e ie t he W r e j r e in e t e s 0 a s ro t h
be nni ofPa s . Thei aeswho sg d up vi t W a de ordesg we e as
gi ng
s over'
'
nm t
i ne
a he r n
i nee r lo
a l e t buy c r a n ç os rf Pa s r'f
low d o
e t i l he or s ove ' oods f o t c m i s r I a e w ho ale dy
K
r m he om s a y. nm t s
ra

we er evi Comm o Fa ea had sgne up f Pa s rwoul as r cevet s c a
r ec i ng
n r nd
i d
or s ove
d lo e i he pe i l
Pas ove m e l
s r a.
ThePas ove M e o a l wasf wa de t Chapli M ic l who is d li own
s r m r ndlm
or r d o
a n thel,
s ue ls
m e t i t son J nua y 29,201 ilor ngt m oft Pas o rs r i e 'daesa tm e .
mo o nma e
a r
5, rf mi he
he s ve e v c s t nd i s
Copi ofboh me oswe et beposed i t housngunis a t t me os t sgnes
t m
r o
t n he
i
t, nd he wo m , he i up
f ms a co mi s r or rf mswe et beg ve t Housng Uni M a ge s Tr a m e t
or , nd m s a y de or
r o
i n o
i
t na r . e t n
c ms l r we et dt diti et f r t i aesa m ant i co esoft i es
ot e o s r ol o srbut he o ms o nm t nd i an pi
he nmat '
c plt d pa tcpai n r ques f nns
om e e rii to e t o .TheSe r t r ofTr am e wasr uie t m ant i t
ceay
e t nt
eq r d o i an he
ls ofi aeswho fl d pM ii to f r sandt n f wa d t ls t t Cha an.I t s
it nm t
ie
cpai n o m
he or r he it o he pl i nma e
we eno r quie t beon aM ase Pa sLitt or rkos rf rPas ove f
r t e rd o
t r s s o de
he o
s r oodsfom t
r he
c nr i s r
or n s a y.

Cha a nM ic l a r t theha
pli t hel ve s ha
ndedoutt Pas ove sgn- f m st i t si
he s r i up or o nma e n
s gr to lkePl i if a t tW RSP i aesco d s nd c
e egai n, i
antf, nd ha
nm t ul e omplt dr que tf r t t r
e e e s o ms o hei
c
ouns or , o t prs sI tt tona Pr n sM a
el s t he ion' nsiu i l op m
nage ,ort hi diecl Theprs s
r o m r ty.
ion'
l tt i na Pr n sM a ge a st ts hasr vi w e al doc e sa ia et he a
ns iuto l ogr m
na r ver ha he
e e d 1 um nt va l bl o r nd

di no fnda r que tf by Pli ift pa tci t i Pas o rort or Kos rf Pas o r
d ti
e s onn
antf o ri pa e n s ve
o der he or s ve
f
oods Cha an M ic la r t thedi notr c i ar ue tfo Pl ntf o pa tcpaei
. pli t hel ve s ha
d
e e ve eq s r m ai ift rii t n
4

t Pa s ve obs r nc Cha an M ic l not t thewoul s nd t i a eaf m t
he s o r e va e.
pl i t he l es ha
d e he nm t or o
co pl t w he he w oul r c ve t i a e' r que ta t the w oul a t ti a e' nnm e
m ee
n
d e ei he nm t s e s nd ha
d dd ha nm t s

t t Pas ove pa tcpai ls onc her c i d t i t sc
o he s r rii ton it e e eve he nma e' ompl t d f m .Cha an
e e or
pli
M ic l alo a r t thehasno i ve e wih r q s f nnsf c mis r or r .
t he l s ve s ha
nvol m nt t e ue t o
or om s a y de s
B.

7; 6- v1 c 00211
Cas 7: 6- v- 211 a i ltga e c a m s a
e 1 c 00
ga n ii t s l i bout2015 Pas o robs r a e a ns
s ve
e v nc gai t

Cha a n M ic l,Fl mi Pont n,a Robi o a i me ey de i tveofca e 7: 5- vpli thel e ng,
o nd
ns n nd s r l rva i
ss 1 c

006 and 7: 5- v- 48. Theonl not bl dif r nc be wee t s c esi a sng er f r nc
47
1 c 006
y a e fe e e t n he e as s i l e e e e
t t Fe s ofTa m a l si Se e be 2015.
o he a t
be c e n ptm r

Ro ns n is daM e a um onJme1 201 tte ç r Qua tr201 Rei ous
bi o sue
mornd
t 2, 5,ild,Thid re 5 lgi

Hol Da '(het-hid Qua trM e ',ti or rt a sleasa r z a t f m
y ys't û r
f
re mo' in de o str tnda died nd mior
)
polc ...r ai t t ThidQua tr201 rlgi hol da frMusi Nai ofIlm,
iy
eltve o he r
re 5 ei ous y ys o
lm, ton sa

M o rs S inc Te l, sa ain, e s , e sn i J wih, h s,gn )Phld lh a
o ih ce e mp e Ra tfra J wih M sin c e s Ya wit a d ia ep i
Ch rh o Go of n eswhoaeo t pa sls f rt s r lgo s' Th Thr Qu re M e
u c f d fe d r
r n he s it o hee ei in . e id a tr mo
'
di a ho ie s i s r i sf rYa s a o he J wih i a e t c e a e i e a i t
d ut rz pecal e vce o hwit nd t r e s nm t s o elbr t , nt r la, he

FeatofTa r cls butt ThidQua trM e di nota horzea s ca me lf t t
s
bena e , he r
re mo d
ut i ny pe il a or ha
J wih holda Pl ntf al geshewast bl t pa tci t i t Fe s ofTa r l bec us
e s
i y. ai if le
ma e o ri pa e n he a t
be naces a e

W RSP Food Se vc r c ve apM i i ton ls fom t Cha ai t tdi noti l hi
r ies e ei d
cpa i it r he
pl n ha d
ncude s
nam e.

Pl i iffl d a i o malc
antf ie n nf r
ompli on Se e r25,201 m ii çl t m ont of
ant
pt mbe
5, tng,çn he
h

Se gmber 201 Iwa ar taiy dele myE rt Ame ntrg t fe ye r iemy
pte j 5 s birrl rid
Fisq ndme iht o rel xecs

r l i na aYa witj lwa n t r vd dtePa s v rf lo u f a tr ya t eo h rJ wsa
ei o s h sl. s o p o ie h so e ol w p e s ta s h t e e t
g
W RS whc s b e t met d srmi ai na we1'A n n d f n a t epo e , oi f o
P, ih u j cs o ic i n to s l. o - e e d n r s nd d n tng o d
'
5

s r i r le on t pa tcpa tls pr dedby t Cha an a t tPli ifsna ewa no
e vce e id he rii n it ovi
he pl i nd ha antf
m
s t
on t ls .
he i t

Pli iffld ar gulrg iva ea utt Pàs ove ls,no t d s o rf l w up
antf ie e a re nc bo he s r it t he t s ve olo
pa
f as ta ' de i i t i or c
e t r y'i ntfed n he nf mal ompl i :
ant

Ch p an M i helh sabtaiyrf s gqt a d myna t t Pa s v rls.
a li t l a r irrl e u ed o d
c
me o he so e it
l ha e we t t r u h t e g iv n e r g r i ben a Ya wit ( u e o
v
n h o g h re a c e adng ig
h s Ho s f
Ya we )svea tme . Gre a c #0 26 a d 0 28 ,ao wi amz ro
h h e rl i s iv n e 0 6 n 0 9 lng t
h mbe f
rq e ts,a d si Im b i g d n e my Fisj Ame d n rg tt fe l
e u slq n tl ' en e id
l
rt
n me t ih o r ey
e r iemy r i ouspr ci ePas ove f as.
xe cs
elgi
a tc
s re t
W a de Fl m i de m e t gre nc a utt Pas ove ls t ot d, tng:
r n e ng e d he iva e bo he s r it mf mde no i
Ar i tga i i o yotr c
l nvesi ton nt
l ompl i i c t Pa slss a Pr n Si n-n
ant ndi aes s it nd op m g l
She t a e es e ilt mai ai ofe
e s r s nta o
nt n f nder a co t biiy a s l be us d t
c un a lt nd ha l
e o
c r and doc l e pM i i ton i a1 r lgi
ont ol
lm nt
c pa i n 1 e i ous s vi es a pr n s
er c
nd ogr m .
Cha an M ic l r porsr c ds s
pl i
the l e t e or how yo a e note ole i a r lgi
u r
nr ld n ny ei ous
s r i . You we enoton t ls f raf as ta
e vce
r
he it o e t r y.
Pl i ifa a e uns c s ul on Nove r4,201 a lgi
antf ppe l d uc es f ly
mbe
5, le ng:

Th W ad n ivetg to wee gi)fk . W RSP d e n' p o i es r ie f r
e r e n siain r sc a e
o s t r v d e vc s o
m y r lgi Ya i t The e or t r s no s r c f m e t atend.... Al o,
e i on. hw s .
r f e. he e'
e vi e or
o t
s
a s tl me on 7/ 1 sa e by Ator y Ge r la sgned,s yi e r ne
e te nt
29/ 4 tt d
t ne
ne a nd i
a ng ve m
a W RSP w o d bei o d t t1m Ya s. So why a tr4 g va sa a
t
ul
nf nne ha '
hwit
fe de nce nd
l ui s tl m e , y nn e s ilha n' bee pl e o t sls t ts a e 1 m a
aws t e te nt m
m tl s t n ac d n hi i t ha t t s '
Y a it
hw s .

Po on uphe d W a den Fl m i sde e m i ton on De e be 23,201
nt
l
r
e ng' t r na i
cm r
5.
Ther s oft cai si c s 7: c 00 a em e ey de i tveofc s 7: - ve t he l m n a e 16-v- 211 r r l rva i
a es 15 c
00647 a 7: 5- vnd 1 c 00648. Pli ifco pl nst tW a de Flm i wasG nf med
a ntf m ai ha
r n e ng
t or
i
be or ha 't tCha an M ic l wa r f sng t puthi on t Pa s rls a di not ng
f e nd' ha
pl i t he l s e u i o
m
he s ove it nd d hi
t i t r e . Pl i t f c pl i t tPo on di notr q r W R SP t alow Pl i t f t or r
o n e v ne a n if om a ns ha nt
d
e uie
o l
a n if o de
Pa s rie s f m a out i ve r m adng Pon on a pa tci nti t Fis Am e
s ove t m w
n s de ndo , l
t
ri pa n he r t
ndm e t
n
vi a i n. N one oft gr e nce i t r c d s
ol to
he i va s n he e or ugge t Fl m i s a Pon on' pe s l
s s e ng' nd
t s r ona
i ve e be or Pas ove e d orRobi on' pe s na i ve e ata tm e.
nvol m nt f e s r nde
ns s r o l nvol m nt ny i
6

I
I.

Dee d n sfldmo in f rs mmayj dg n , r uigt tte aee tte t
fn a t ie to s o u r u me t ag n ha h y r n ild o
quaii i
lfed mmuniy.Qualfedi lt per t Gg nme of il pe f mi dic einay
t
ii mmuriy mis lover nt fcas ror ng sr to r

f n to s. .t b qs ile fo la ii f rcvl n g si o a a t erc nd c d e n t
u cin . (o e h ed d r m iblt o i id ma e ns fr s h i o u t o s o
y
vi ae cea l esa ihed sam or o c tt to lrght ofwhih ar as bl pe s wo d
ol t l ry t bls
t t y r onsiu i na i s
c e ona e r on ul

h v kn wn. Hal w v. tz r l, 57U. 8 0 81 ( 9 2 ; e P i hetv Alo d 9 3F.d
a e o ' ro Fiz e ad 4
'
S. 0 , 8 1 8 ) s e rt t . f r , 7 2
c
3 7 31 ( t Ci.1 9 )( ic s igt er q st lv l fa aysso t rg t.Th Fis
0 , 4 4h r 9 2 ds u sn h e uii e e o n l i f he ih ) e rt
e
Ame e ' Fr eExe c s Clus pr e t prs r fom t ea o bl btr nson asnce eyndm nts e
r ie a e ot c s ione s ' mr s na e lde
r
i rl

h l r l i u e ecs .Se . ..O' n v Esaeo S b z , 8 U. 3 2, 4849(98 )
ed ei o s x r ie e ea, Lo e . tt f ha a z 4 2 S. 4 3 - 1 7 9
g
Tu n rv. aly, 2U. 7 , 9( 9 7 .Th Folte t Ame d n ' Eq l oe to Clu e
r e S fe 48 S. 8 8 1 8 ) e t e n h
r
n me ts ua Pr tcin a s
pr ecsprs r fom i di dic i na i Se e. ,W olfv. c me l 418U. 53
ot t ione s r nvi ous s rmi ton. ee g.
f M Doz l,
S. 9,

5 6( 9 4 ; o s nv Gar z t , 9F.d6 8 6 4( t Ci. 0 )
5 1 7 ) M nio . ra h v 23 3 4 , 5 4h r 2 01.

A pat i e tte t sl r ud me t f h p e dn s t d s ls dmaeil o fl,
ry s n ild o l
mma yj g n i t e la ig ,he ico e tras n ie
a a a fdaviss w t tt r i no g nui diput a t a m aera f c . Fe R.Ci P.
nd ny f
t ho ha he e s
e ne s e s o ny t il a t d.
v.

5 () M aeil a t aet o ene e sr t etbiht eee nso ap ry' c u eo a to
6 a . tra fcs r h s c say o sa ls h lme t f a t s a s f cin.
An es n v Lie t Lo b l .4 7U. 2 2 2 8( 9 6 .A g n n ds u eo mae ilfc
d ro . b ry b v.nc, 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) e uie ip t f tra a t
e ssi,i viwi t r c d a a1r a o bl i e e e dr wnt r fom i alg mos
xit f n e ng he e or nd l e s na e nf r nc s a he er n i ht t
f vor bl t t non- ovi pa t ar as bl f tfnde c d r t r ave ditf t nona a e o he
m ng ry, e ona e acr oul e u n
r c or he
m ovant I
.=
d
111.

Cl i s i ca e 7: 6- v- 11 a
a m n s 1 c 002 boutt Fe s ofTa m a e
he a t
be cl s

Fo aFis Ame e feq e r iec am ,ac tmus decdet t e hol quesi n o
r rt
ndm nt r - xe cs l i
our
t i he hr s d
to f
whehe a pli ifsnc r y he dt a
t r a ntf i e el l he vowedbelefa whehe t belefi,i apl i ifso
i nd
t r he i s n antf wn
7

s h meo t n s rlgo s Uni dS ae v. e g r 3 0U. 1 3 1 5( 9 ) Onyapes n l
c e f hig , ei iu . t tts S e e , 8 S. 6 , 8 1 65 . l
e
ro a
pr tc t ti bot snc r l he d a r t i r lgi bei fi pr e t W i c i v.
aci e ha s h i e e y l nd oo ed n e i ous le s ot ced. s onsn

Yo e, 0 U. 20 , 5 1 ( 9 2 .
d r 4 6 S. 5 21 - 6 1 7 )
Pl ntf al t e t bls asnc r l hel r lgi ne d t obs r t Fe tof
ai iff is o sa ih i e ey- d e i ous e o e ve he as
Tabe na e i Se e be 201 The f c ot ri a esw ho a r t J w i h f ihspa tc pa e
r cl s n pt m r 5.
a t he nm t
dhe e o e s a t
ri i t d

i t tc lbr ton doe notesa ih Pl ntY si vi l snc r a r lgi usne t
n ha ee ai
s
t bls ai i ndi dua , i e e, nd e i o
ed o
c l br t t tholda t
e e a e ha i y, oo.Se e. ,
e. g.Thomasv. viw Bd.ofI a Empl m e Se urt
Re e
ndina
ov nt c iy

Di.4 0U. 7 7 71 - 6( 9 )(e omiigac u t ho l n tmp t apa t u a rlg o s
v, 5 S. 0 , 5 71 1 81 r c g zn o r s ud o i u e ri lr ei iu
c
n e c mmo t ar lgo ss c t apes n wh ma ie tf wi t ts c) s eas 4 U. C.
e d o n o eii u e t o ro o y d n iy t ha e t; e lo 2 S.
h
j2 0 c5(e og znga idviu l eii u p a tc i n td fn db t ep a tc so oh r
00 c - rc nii n n i d a r l o s r cie s o ei e y h r cie f t e s
g
i t ec n e to teReiiusLa dUs a dI ttto aie Pes nsAc)
n h o tx f h l o
g
n e n nsi in l d ro
u
z
t.
Furhe mor ,Pl n iff l t e t bls ho notpm ii tng i t Fe s ofTa m aces
t r e aitf ais o sa ih w
c pa i n he a t
be l
i Se e r201 c tt ed as t n i lbtr n.A ç ubsa i lbm de 'on r lgouse r ie
n pt mbe
5 onsim
ubsa ta lde
E t nta
s
n' e i i
xe c s

o czsi iç u ljs bsa ta p e s r o a a hee t omo iyh sbe a ira dt v oaehs
c l f tç ts u tnil r sl e n n d rn t d f i h v o n o i lt i
r
p
z
be i s or... or esape s t c
lef,
f c
r on o hoos be we n f l ng t pr c pt ofhe r lgi n and
e t e olowi he e e s
r ei o

f retn (o e n n alb n ft, nt eo eha d a da n o igo eo t ep e e t o h r
o fii g g v r me tl e eis o h n n , n ba d nn n f h r c p s f e
r l in . . nt eohe h n ' v lc v. e 47 F.d 1 4, 8 ( t Ci. 0 6 (n en l
ei o . o h t r a d.
g
'Lo ea e Le , 2 3 7 1 7 4h r 2 0 ) itr a
q o ainso te ) Fo t a hoia t eTh r QuatrM e alwe J wihi mae t b
u tto mitd . r h t l y,h id re mo lo d e s n ts o e
d
e us d t r wor s hoola pr mns a t y s ul be a f r d tm ef rpr ye a
xc e & om
f
k, c
nd ogr , nd he ho d
fo de i o a r nd

su y(ndvd a)d ngt ee tr p ro .Nos e ilme l.Sevc a t rz d Da 1a do
t d i iiu l mi h n ie e id
p ca as r ie uhoie , y n /r
2, ... nd no s r i esda 3- ' Th ,Pl i ifwasnotde i ofas c a m e lbe aus
a
e vc
ys 7. us antf
'
prved
pe i l a c e
none w a of e ed. Fur he m or ,Pl i ifacc l dge i hi g i va e a a on N ove be 4,
s fr
t r e a ntf lnow e d n s ' e nc ppe l
r
m r
2015 t tt r w a no m as e pa s ls f Y a i t be us t r w e e no gr H ous of
, ha he e s
t r s i t or hw s s ca e he e r
oup
e
8

Ya h s r ce .Pl i iff ist e t bls ho notpa tcpa i asaYa s,i a g oup
hwe e vi s antf al o sa ih w
ri i tng,
hwit n r
r lgi s r cewih non- hwit c tm t as t nta bur n t hi pe s lr lgi
e i ous e vi
t
Ya ss onsi ed ubsa i l de o s r ona ei ous
pr c ie.M or ve ,Pli tf doe notcai t tdtrngt Fe to Ta r c e hewa
a tc
eo r a n if s
l m ha li he as f be na l s
s
pr ve e fom i vi ua pr yera s t orwa c
e nt d r ndi d l a
nd tz
dy
s ompeled et rt wor ort pm i i t i
l ihe o
k o
cpa e n
s hoolorpr n s
c
ogr m .
I sl ,Pl i iff ist des rbea snc r l hed r i o nee t obs r t Fe tof
n lm antf a l o c i
i e e y- l elgi us d o e ve he as
Ta m a l sa f ist e a nhow notpa tci tng wih i t so o he f ihsdurng t
be c e nd a l o xpli
ri pa i
t nma e f t r a t
i he
holda c tt t d a s t nta bur n t hi f ih.Ac di y, f nda sa ee il dt
i y onsiu e ubsa i l de o s at
cor ngl De e nt r ntte o

q lfe i mi a s mmayj g n f rt ecam a o theFe s o Ta en ce i c s
uai d mmt t nd u r ud me t o h li b u t a t f b r a ls n a e
i
y
7: cv16- 00211.

B. Re ani cam si c e 7:6- vm i ng li n as 1 c 00211agans Flm i Po on,a Robi o
i t e ng, nt nd
ns n
Pl i ifa us sFl mi Po on,a Robi on ofvi ai t Fr eExe c s Clus of
antf cc e e ng, nt nd
ns
oltng he e
rie a e
t Fis Ame m e a Eq lPr t c i Cl us oft Foure nt Am e
he r t
nd nt nd ua o e ton a e he
te h
ndme by no a l ng
nt
t lowi
hi t pa tcpa ei t VDOC' Pa s ro er nc i Aprl201 alhough i a e o o he
m o ri i t n he
S s ove bs va e n
i 5 t
nm t s f t r
J wihf ihspa tci t d.On M a c 1 201 t c ur gr t d t m oton f rs ma y
e s at
ri pa e
r h 4, 7, he o t mle he i o um r

j d me a u te es mecamsa ans d fn a t Flmiga dPo t ni c s 7 1 -v- 0 47
u g nt bo t h s a li g i t ee d ns e n n n o n a e :5 c 0 6
a ag ns de e nt Flm i a Robi on i c e 7: 5- 00648.The c t i t tt
nd ai t f nda s e ng nd
ns n as 1 cvour fnds ha he

g a t fsl r j g n i fvo o Flmi , no a Ro n o i t s c s si e u ly
rn o l
mmay ud me t n a r f e ng Po tn, nd bis n n ho e a e s q al
wa r nt i ca e7: 6- v- 211
r a ed n s 1 c 00 .
The e i no hi i t r c d t s
r s t ng n he e or o ugges t tFlm i Pont orRo ns ha a
t ha e ng, on,
bi on d ny
pe s li ve e a tw he herPl i ifw oul be au horze t pm i pa e i Pa s ve or
r ona nvol m nt bou
t
a ntf
d
t i do
ci t n s o r

t Fe tofTa na e . I f c ,Pli ifsgre nc s r l pl et blm eon Cha an
he as
ber cls n a t antf ' iva es qua e y ac he a
pl i

M ic la no o e s Pli ifspa sngr f r nc st c pli shem a t Fl mi and
t hel nd
ne le. antf
s i e e e e o op a nt
de o e ng
9

Po t naei s fiin t i o ej1 3la ii o t m.S e eg, h r f v I b l 5 6U..
n o r n u fce t o mp s 98 ib ly n he e . ..As c o t . q a, 5 S
t
6 2 6 6( 0 9 .Th s p io a mi srtr ma n tb h l vc ro syla l t e j1 3
6 , 7 2 0 ) e e rs n d nitao s y o e ed ia iu l ib e md r 98
f f ii ofo he prs n sa f s h a t cam e f l e ofCha ai M ichelt r s
or alngs t r i o t f, uc s he li d aiur
pl n t l o e pond t
o
Col s l Ros se al,whih Pl i ifcai c us dhi nott bei l
m eor e' m is
c antf l ms a e m
o ncuded o t 2015
n he

P so e l t I (t e a evia iu l bit i ia p ia et . . 1 8 s is ap an if
a s v r i . d.çBl c us c ro s i l y s n p lc bl o . j 9 3 u t, litf
s
l
a i
m us pl d e h Go r e - scilde e nt t ough t ofk i lsown i vi la tons
t ea ac
ve nm ntof a f nda , hr
he t a '
ndi dua c i ,
ha vi a e t Cons iuto ., . I s Pli ifhasnoa tona ecli a i tFlmi
s ol t d he
tt i n , 3 n um, antf
)
ci bl am gans e ng,

Po t n o Ro is n a dt e aee t ldt q aii di ni a d sl r u g n .
n o , r bn o , n h y r ni e o u lfe mmu t n l
t
y
mmayj d me t
C. Re ani cai i ca e 7: 6- vm i ng l ms n s s 1 c 00211a 7: 5- vnd 1 c 00647 a ns Cha an M ic l
gai t pl i t hel
a
boutPas ove i Aprl201
s rn
i
5

I c s 7: 5- vn a e 1 c 00647,t c t de e Cha ai M ic l' m o i f s
he our had nid pl n thels ton ot umm a y
r

j d me tb c u ef rh rfcu l e lp n wa n c saya trc mp rn P an ifs
u g n e a s u te a t a d veo me t s e e sr fe o ai g litf
al ga i t Cha an M ic lsa fd t Cha a n M ic lhad fl a a fda tsai :
le tons o
pli t hel' fi avi. pli t hel
ied n fi vi t tng,1
I

ke p co esofa lofe rr quessr r ng pa tgpa in i holda obs r nce . 1di not
e pi
1 f nde e t ega di
rii to n i y e va s
d
r c vea r ques f nnsc e i Cr wly pa tci tng i Pa s r201 5 Pl ntf
e ei ny e t o
onc m ng a e ri pa i n s ove
5.' ai if
c e e t the s itd ofe rr que t t Couns l rRos as ngt thebe i l d on
ount r d ha
ubm te f nde e ss o
eo
e ki ha
ncude
t Pas ove ls. Ac or ngt docz e t pr edby Pl ntf o
he s r it c di o lm n s oduc
ai if pposng t m oton f r
i he i o

s mma yj d me t Co n eo Ro ep r re l sn e i t Ch pli M i helsai t a
u r u g n , u s lr s u po tdy e t mql o a an t l ttng h t
s
c
Pl i ifwa e t sgn up f rPas o r
antf nt d o i
o
s ve .

3Furhe , t t exentt tPl ntf' cl m a ns Flm i o Pon o r i on t i r pons t hi afe t r o he t ha ai ifs ai gai t e ng r t n eles her es es o s tr
t -a tgre nc ,i i una ii Pl ntf hasR c tt i rgh t pa tcpaei gre ncepr eedi .'
he fc iva es t s valng. ai if
no onsi onal i t o rii t n iva
m
oc ngs'

Ad msv Iie 4 F.d7 75(t Ci. 99 ) Lie s ,d eeinola ii u d rj1 8 frap io
a .tc , 0 3 2, 4h r 1 4 . k wie th r s ibly n e 9 3 o rsn
t
t
a i sr t ' r po et agre nc ora al' Br v.Va. e tofCom , o.6:7c
dm nitaors es ns o iva e ppe . own
'
D o'
N
0 v33,2009W L 8
7459,a
t

*1 ( . Va Jn. , 0 9 .Flmig' a dPo tn' E fe-h -atd nil faFiv nc fl frso t f
3 W D. . a 9 2 0 ) e n s n no st trtefc e a o
a
e a e al a h r o
s
etbl hngj1 8 l bit ' De oav Ra , 7:2 v1 9 2 3WL 4 51 3 , t* ( . Va J l 2 , 1 )
sa i i
s
9 3 i ly. pa l . v No. 1 c 3 , 01
a i '
4 2 6 a 8 W D. .uy 2 20 3
( ag n, J)(ii Bro svBe r,1 7F. p' 9 3 9 5(1 Ci. 0 ).
S r e tM.. ct
ng o k
ad 6 Ap x 2 , 2 3- r20 6)
d
10

Aferc i rng t se de e, heco tc l d t tPl i ifsca m agans
t onsde i hi vi nc t
ur oncude ha antf li
i t
Cha an M ic l n ot edt m o et n ba ea s ri nsgi n t ge ne is off c diput d
pli t hel m mt o r ha r s e to
ve he nui s ue a t s e
by t pa te . The c tct d Pli ifsr que t t beplce ont Pas ove ls asbolt i
he ris
our ie antf' e ss o
a d he s r it
serng
hi cli ofdic i nai n be ndt r l ofme e c l or ac us tons Re r ng
s am
s rmi to yo he eam
r oncus y c a i . ga di
Cha an M ic lsa me t tPl i ifdi nota k t r c vePas ove mea s t c t
pl i t hel' ver nt ha antf d
s o e ei
s r l, he our
f rherc ude t tt diput d que ton ofwhehe Cha an M ic l di ordi no r ceve
u t oncl d ha he s e
si
t r pl i t hel d
d te i

Plitf sr q s i i pp o it f rrs lto o sl r u g n .Th c u t o e lsl
anif e uet s na rprae o e ou in n l
mma yj d me t e o r n td a ty
t th c s wo l p o e dt j r tili Ch panM i helddn t eas p lme tl to
ha te a e u d r c e o u y ra f a li t l i o 5l u p e na moin
c

f rsl r j d me t
o lmma y u g n .
Alho h Cha a n M ichelfl t ts e nt lm o i n a a tc d hi s c
t ug
pli t l ed ha uppl me a to nd ta he s e ond
a fda t t s ond a fda ti lr l unc nged fom hi fr tafi vi. Theo y pe tne
f vi, he ec
fi vi s a ge y ha
r
s s fda t
nl ri nt
a to a et f lowi sa e e s
ddii ns r he o l ng t t m nt :
l Cr wly s ntr ques f r s Iwoul ha a d hi t t ls .... Ido no
f a e e e t om ,
d ve dde m o he it
t
r alr ei ng a e alfom Com s l rRos r ga di Cr wly' r ques f
ec l ec vi n m i r
l eo
e e r ng a e s e t or
Pa s r lno l erha ac es t my 201 e l. Eve i Cot eorRos
s ove .
ong
ve c s o
5 mais
n f ms l
e
e a ld me,VDOC polc woul ha r quie Cr wl y t s nd i a r ue t
m ie
iy
d ve e r d a e o e n eq s
f m t m e whih hedi notdo.... Asa Cha nn,ldo nots r h outwayst
or o , c
d
pl i
ea c
o
de prs r fom t ki pa t i r lgi
ny ione s r
n ng r n ei ous pr n mi
ogr m ng. I di no
d t
i e i l pr ve tCr wl y fo pa tcpai i Pa s r201
ntntonaly e n a e r m rii tng n s ove
6.
Ther co d i no matral dif r ntnow wih t s cond a fdavi a c
e r s t e i ly fe e
t he e
fi t s ompa e t whe
rd o
n

t c u t adtelg l ndf cu l sue we ei r pe f rrs lto o s
he o r si h e a a a ta is s r mp o r o e oui n n umma yj d me t
r ug n
bas o t fr ta fda t Fort r a onsar dy sa e i t c tspro m e o a lm
ed n he is fi vi.
he e s
lea t t d n he our' i r m r nd l

o i ina o d r ad s u eo maeil a tp e ld ss mmayj d me ta t wh t r
p no nd r e , ip t f tra fc rcu e u r u g n s o ehe
Cha an M ic lvi a e t Fis Am e
pl i t hel olt d he r t
ndme ' Fr eExe cieClus a t Foure nt
nts e
r s a e nd he
te h
Ame
ndm e ' Eq Pr t ton Cl us by nota l ge y pr e s ng Pl i if s pur t
nt s ual o ec i
a e
le dl oc s i
a ntf '
pored

a i to t pm ii t i Pa s ri Aprl201 n a or ncewih t c tspro
pplcai n o
cpae n s ove n
i 5.I cc da
t he our' i r

d cso , p anM ic elsn t n ildt q l idi liya ds
e ii n Cha li th l i o e tte o uai e mml t n umma yj d me tf r
f
n
r ug n o
c am sabo Pa s ri Aprl201 Ther m ani cai sa ns Cha an M ic lfom
li
ut s ove n
i
5.
e i ng l m gai t pl i t hel r
c es7: 5- vas
1 c 00647 a 7: 6- vnd 1 c 00211wilbec oldae f tilpurua t Fede a Rul of
l
ons i td or ra
s nt o
rl e

Ci lPr e le42( .
vi oc dtr a)
I .
V

Fo t ef r g igra o ,hec u t e isDee d n s moinsf rs mmayj d me t
r h o e on e s ns t o r d n e fn a t' to o u r u g n
a t t Fis a Fouree h Ame m e cai a i tCha ai M ic l a
s o he rt nd
t nt
nd nt l ms ga ns
pl n t he l boutPas ove i
s rn
Apr l201 butg a t t m otons i a 1o he r pe t . The r m a ni c a m s a i tCha ai
i
5
r n s he
i
n l t r es c s
e i ng l i ga ns
pl n

M ic l a ec olda e f ti li t Bi St neGa Di son.
thel r ons i t d or ra n he g o
p vii
ENTER: Thi
s

l

dyfu,07.
aoJl21.
y

,,
*rA m .z
' .,1
..

.

.
.

ChifUnie S a e s . J
e
td tts
i udge

1
2

.

.
,

.