Hess v. Viers

Filing 22

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/14/2016. (tvt)

rdFRKS OFFI U. DI PAUW
CE S. ST.
A ROANOKE,
T
VA
9! iI
#2'
. h

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TI E W E STER N DI
'
I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O
D O NA LD LEE H E SS,

2C1 1i 2 1
'
26
JULI C, '
' C
BY:

CA SE N O .7: 6C V 0 2
1
026

Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

BA RR Y V I S,
ER

By: G l n E.C onrad
e
C hi fU nie St t sD i t i tJudge
e
t d a e sr c

Dee n t)
fnda ts.
D onal Le H e s pr e ng pr K ,dl a c vi r ght co pl nt pur ua t 42 U . C.
d e s , oc edi
o
ed i l i s m ai , s nt o
S.
.

j 1 3, l i a c rtd.Tli matri befr t cou tupon dee tsM oto t Dimis
98 whie nc r eae zs te s oe he r
fndan ' in o s s ,
fl d Se e r9,201 On Se e be 1 2015,t c tm al d a notc ad sng He st t
ie pt mbe
6.
ptm r 2,
he our ie
ie vii
s ha

t c two d gi hi 21 da t s i a f rhe c e - f vis or ot r r l va
he our ul ve m
ys o ubm t ny u t r ountr a sda t
he e e nt
e de eco r di tng,e ani o a di de e nt e de ebef er lng on def nda s
vi nc nta ci xpl i ng r voi ng f nda s' vi nc
or ui
e nt '
m oton. Theno i wa ne He s
i
tce r d s :
I Pl ntf doesno r s
f ai if
t e pond t De e ntspl a ngs t Cour wilas um et t
o f nda ' e di , he
t l s
ha
Pli if has l ti e es i t c e,a / t t Pli if a e wih wha t
antf
os nt r t n he as nd or ha antf gr es t
t he

Dee d n sae i (h jrs o sv p e dng s.I Plitf wih s t c n iu
fn a t tts n t e e p n ie la i t) f an if s e o o tn e
wih t c e,i i ne s a y t t Pl i if r s nd i a a opra e f s on.
t he as t s ce s r ha antf e po n n ppr it a hi
Pli ifm a wih t r s ld wih c mt - fi aviso ot ra tona e de e
antf y s o e poi t ot era fd t r he ddii l vi nc
a o lne a
s uti d bove.Howe r i Pl ntf doe notfl s e r s ns wihi t
ve . f ai if s
ie om e po e t n he

t nt one ( ) da pe i t Cour mav dimi s t c e f f itr t
we v21 y rod. he
t
s s he as or a lle o
pr
osecut
e.

( tc ,ECF No 1 )(mp ssi o ii a. Snc mal g t e n tc t He s te c u tha
Noie
. 6 e ha i n rg n l i e ii h o ie o s, h o r s
)
n
r cevedno f rhe c
e i
u t r ommlnia i fom hi a
l c ton r
m boutt sc e,a t de i f rhi r s
hi as nd he adlne o s e pons t
eo

d fn a t ' to h sp se . Ac o dn l t c u tfn t a, u s a tt Rue41b o te
ee d ns moin a a s d c r igy,he o r ids h t p ru n o l ( ) f h
Fede a Rul ofCi lPr dur ,He sha f ie t pr ec et saci Se g Ba lr v.
r l es
vi oce e s s a ld o os ut hi ton. e en. la d

Calo 8 2F.d9 (t Ci.1 8 )
rs n, 8 2 3 4 h r 9 9 .

# L
ERK

M o eo r He shasnotpr dedt c twih hi c r nta e s By o de e e e
r ve , s
ovi he our t s ure ddr s .
r r nt r d
J 7,201 t c ur ad s He st tf l et upda eam alng add e swilr ul i
une
6, he o t vied s ha aiur o
t
ii
r s l es t n
dimis loft sa ton.The c tsmaii da e Se e be 26,201 t pli ifa t a es
s sa
hi c i
our'
lng t d ptm r
6, o antf t he ddr s
hepr de wih hi c pl ntha bee r t ne ast lve a e.
ovi d t s om ai s n eur d mde i r bl

Th r fr , o ter a o ssae ,h c u t l ds s tea to wi o tp eudc .S e
ee o e f r h e s n ttd te o r wi imis h cin t u rj ie e
l
h
I . t9 (ttn p o. ltg n sa es b e t otmer q ie n sa r s c frc u t r esa d
d a 6 saig r K i a t r u j c t i e urme t nd epe t o o r o d r n
i
ds sa wih u p eu iei a a p o raes n to f rn n c mpl nc l Domel v. oms
imis l t o t rj dc s n p r p it a cin o o -o i e ; z l J l a
v
M g vi eSae Cp p.6 7F.d3 9 3 0 41( dCi.1 8 )(e o nzn adsrc c u t y s a
n l ls r , 7 2 3 , 4 - 3 r 9 2 r c g iig itit o r ma u
l
-

s n ed s s a a to pu s n t Fe R. v. 41b) Ana p o it o d rwil n e ti
po t imis n ci n rua t o d. Ci P. ( ). p r prae r e le tr h s
da
y.
He si a s d t ti he i e t pr e d wih t sadi n,he mus pe ii t c t
s s dvi e ha f nt nds o oc e t hi
o
t tton he our

wihi 30 da of t e r of t s o de f a r nsaeme oft s aci n. Any m o i f
tn
ys he nty
hi r r or ei t t nt hi to
ton or
r i tt m e s d pr de s cfce a ton f rhi f itr t r pond i atm ey f hi n t
ensa e nt houl ovi pe ii xplna i o s a lle o es
n i l as o o
de e ntsdipostvemoton a t pr vi t c t t a upda e add e s
f nda ' s ii
i nd o o de he our wih n
td r s .
The Clr i die t t s nd a c oft sor rt t pli ifa t c
e k s r ced o e
opy hi de o he antf nd o ouns ofr c d
el e or
f t de e nt
or he f nda .

ENTER:

vhi
s

t dyo- tbrzol6.
+ a focoe
-

Chi fUn'e Stt DititJ
e
t d a es src udge