Encompass Independent Insurance Company v. Dombrosky et al
Filing
34
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/10/17. (sas)
nl A sorFl E u.s, s .
FRK'
c
T
DlT cciARkorl vu ,
t
u
VA
FIED
L
FEB 12 2 1
27
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W EF ERN DI TRI OFVI NI
S CT
RGI A
ROA N OK E D I I ON
V SI
2U
BK
. UD
,CLERK
P
ENCOM PASS W DEPENDENT
W SU R AN CE COM PAN Y ,
Pl n ifcountr f nda ,
aitf/
e de e nt
TAN Y A N .D OM BRO SK Y ,
Ci lAc i N o.7: 6CV00272
vi ton
1
M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O
De e n / os de e nt
f nda tcr s f nda
By: on. l n E.Corr d
H
Ge
la
Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge
M A TTH EW T.G M EN
De e ntcr s l i a /
f nda / os c am nt
Co e c a m a
unt r l i nt
I t s i ur nc co r ge diput Enc
n hi ns a e ve a
s e,
ompas I pe nt I u a e Co n ny
s nde nde ns r nc
n pa
(En o s' s e a d caao yj d me tt a i h sno o lg to t d fnd o id mnf
G c mpa s' e ks e lrt r u g n h t t a
l
)
b iain o ee r n e iy
Ta y Do r s y (Do r s y' i c n e to wih a pes n lij r a to t a M ate
n a mb o k ç mb o k ' n o n cin t
c
)
ro a nu y cin h t th w
Gre (Gr e ' flda an tDo r s yi Vignasaec u tThec s i p e e tyb f r t e
e n 1 e n' ie g i s mb o k n r ii tt o r.
ç
)
a e s rs n l eo e h
c u to co smoins fr p ril s mmay j d me tfld b Enc mpa s Do r s y a d
o r n r s- to o a t u r u g n ie y o s, mb o k , n
a
Gr e Fort r as s tf t beow,e h m otonwilbeg a ed i pa ta de e i pa t
e n.
he e ons e orh l
ac
i
l
r nt n r nd nid n r.
B ackzround
1
.
St e e ofFac s
at m nt
t
The f c s i t s ca e a e no he viy di put I 2007,D o br ky a he m o he ,J
a t n hi s r t a l s ed. n
m os nd r t r o
Ar Dul (UoAnn' move i wihDo os sgrndpae s Bet Dunn ($ ty' a J
m m $
'
)
d n t mbr ky' a rnt, ty
ç t ' nd oe
Be )
Dlnn (Coe'.Att ttme J who ha acae ri i ur nc e ie arpr e ai fo
l t '
J )
ha i , oe,
d re n ns a e, mald e esnttve r m
Enc pas i rng a ut t r e s i polci .J Ann D e 45: 46: J r ce ved a
om s nquii bo hei xi tng i es o
p. 15- 23. oe e i
n
e alsa i t c di t Polc defnii t da t rgr ndda t ra e c i r d f miy
m i t tng, t or ng o iy i tons he ugh e / a
Ac
ugh e r onsde e n l
me be sr sde r l tve a t r or c r ge wil e e t t m as l
m r/e i nt e ai s nd he ef e ove a
l xt nd o he
ong a t y a e
s he r
r i ng i t ho e l a t tme of a l s' Em alf o R' c- s t Pegg Pe te W e
esdi n he us ho d t he i
os .
'
i r m M Ea t o
y tr y, d.
Oc .31,200 Doc tN o.1 5.J ga t e ai c i t J Ann,t d J Al t ts a
t
7, ke
7- oe ve he m l han o o
ol o m ha he nd
D om br ky w er c r d, a t d J Ann t t s s d kee t e a l e ha
os
e ove e nd ol o
ha he houl
p he m i xc nge f r he
o r
r co ds Se Jo Ann De 45:5- 23.J pa s a y pror t t e nt gi ng rs t t
e r . e
p. 1 46: oe s ed wa i o he ve s vi ie o he
i t n di put .
ns a t s e
On J
une 5, 201 Do br ky a Be t viie Fis Tea Hyunda i Roanoke
5, m os
nd ty std r t
m
i n
,
Vign a wh r Be t p r h s da20 3Hy n a Veo tr(h G l se' frDo r s y Bet
r ii, ee ty u c a e
1 u d i lse t e s o tr' o mb o k . ty
ve
)
pai t f 1 ptr ha eprc ,whih i ude t velc e' fr toi c nge a almie wa r n y.
d he ' 1 lc s i e
u
c ncl d he lil s is 1 ha
nd i td r a t
Se Ha soc De ,Ex.1 p.0000069,Doc t21 4.J Ann piked up t Vel trf o Fis
e r t k p.
,
ke - o
c
he ose r m rt
Te m Hpm da t e da lt r on J 8 201
n
i hr e ys a e , une , 5.
O ve t ne ni da ,Be t dr t vel c e t o,pos i y t e tm e .Eac tm e s
r he xt ne ys ty ove he li l w
s bl hr e i s
h i he
us d t Veose ,s d o i t t gr er so e, c wasa tf l orfvem iesa y.See
e he l t r he r ve t o he oc y t r whih
bou otr i
l wa
Be t Dt De 9: 1 2,Docke No.21 6.Bet a s pai t putgasi t ca o o t ce.
ty mn p. 3- 0:
t
ty l o d o
n he r nce r wi
Se i 8: 9: J Ann putga i t ve c e onc Se J Ann D e 26: 9- D oc tN o.21 3.
e d. 9- 2. o
s n he hi l
e. e o
p. 1 20, ke
-
Ats
ome poi ,J Ann d ove t Veose t W e tVigi a Be t pad f t g us d on t t
nt o
r
he l tr o s r ni . ty i or he as e
ha
ti Se t.58: 1 W he no i us t ve cl wa ke i t gaage,a t ke weeke
rp. e la 6-9. n t n e,he hi e s pt n he r
nd he ys r pt
i t c r Se i 21: - 20.
n he a . e d. 21 22:
N o one f l t t Be' ne de pe s i n t drve t Veose ,but Be t d d i o
et ha ty e d nniso o i o l tr
t
ty i nf nn
D o br ky o a pl nne us . Se J Ann D uml D e 54: 6; Be t Dl n D e 29: 8;
m os
f ny a d e e o
p. 2ty m
p. 6-
Do b os De 31: 4- 9.De pie Be t pur ha i t Ve ose f Do br ky' us a
m r ky p. 1 1
s t
ty
c sng he l t r or m os s e, nd
Be t c i rng t V e os e t be Dom br ky' ve c e Dom br ky ne ded pe s i t
ty ons de i he l t r o
os s hi l ,
os
e
nni s on o
d i t Veose .Se Be t Dul De 1 4- J Ann De 54: 3- 5.Do b os dr t
rve he l t r e ty m
p. 6: 6; o
p. 1 1
m r ky ove he
ve ce a las t eetmespdort t a c de .Se Dombr ky D e 1 8- 24.I add to t
hi l t e t hr i
o he c i nt e
os
p. 9: 22: n ii n o
t Vel t r a Toyot 1AV4 tte i J Al ' na a aToyot Ava on tte i Be t sna e
he ose ,
at
il d n o m s me nd
a
l il d n ty' m
we eke i t g r ge.Se J Al Dunn De 1 1 22. f miy co i r d t RAV4 t be
r pt n he a a
e o m
p. 3: 6- The n l nsde e he
o
J Ann' ve ce a t Aval t be Be t sve c e. eBe t Dul De 1 22- 3.
o
s hi l nd he
on o
ty' hil Se ty m p. 5: 16:
On J
une 1 2015 ni da afe he mot r pi ke up t Ve ose fo Fis Te
7,
, ne ys tr r he c d
he l t r r m r t am
Hyunda ,Dombr ky wasi ve i a m o orve ce ac i ntwhie drvi t Veose .The
i
os
nvol d n
t
hi l c de
l i ng he l t r
a i ntlf Gr e pe m a nty pa a yz d fom t c s do He s eq nty c me d a
ccde e t e n r ne l r l e r he he t wn.
ubs ue l om nce
p ro a ij r s i i Vigni saec t' cami $75milo i d ma e . t et o t
es n l n u y ut n r i a tt out li ng . l n n a g s At h i f he
,
i
me
ac i nt t Ve ose wastte i J Al ' na e a i tr d by alU SA A a o polcy.W he
c de , he l t r
il d n o m s m nd nsle
l
ut
i
n
USA A pa df t t a e V eose , o Ann s cfe t tt c c bepa d t Be t 1 64:i or he ot l d l tr J
pe i d ha he he k
i o ty. d. 1 2.
I.
I
The I ur e Polc e
ns anc
i is
Ataltme rlv n ,Be' manan d a $ 5 milo p ro a l rla p lc (h
1 i s ee a t t
t itie
y
2. lin e s n l l el oiy t e
mb
l r l Po iy' a d a $ 5 ,0 a t p lc (he E t Poiy),wh c icu e a
ç el lc ' n
umb a
)
2 00 0 u o oiy t s o lc '
Au
ih n ld d n
t tn e No own d Co ea e'e d r e n te ç o s me f'.Th Umb el Poiy
s e d d n- e
Ex
v r g ' n o s me t(h t r e n ) e
End
r la lc
oblga es Enc pa s t G dn a f r w hi h a c r d pe s be m e l galy la e due t
i t
om s o t
pay m ges o
c
ove e r on co s e l i bl
o
a o c re c rs lig i p ro a ij r ,b dl ij r ,o p o e t d ma e u t telmi o
n c u rn e e utn n e s n l n u y o iy nu y r r p ry n g , p o h i t f
la lt s
i biiy hown i t Cove ag Summ a y . . .' Enc
n he
r e
r
'
ompas Um b ela Polc I urng
s
r l
i y ns i
Ag e me t3 Do k tNo 1 1 (mp a i o te ) The Umb el Po iy e u rtd c ran
re n , c e . - e h ss mitd .
r la lc n meae e ti
l s st tt polc doesnotç r I pe tne pa tt Umbr l Polc doe notc r
os e ha he iy
ove . n ri nt r, he
ela iy s
ove :
1 Bodiy i ur ornr pe t dn ac a ii o oft owne s p;mai e nc ,
2.
l ni v
o ry m e rsng ut he
r hi
nt na e'
us ;oc upa
e c ncy;r ntng'l ni e r tng;l i or u oa ng of a m o or
e i , oa ng; ntusi oad ng
nl di
ny t
ve ce ...,o he t n:...
hi l
t r ha
e A m ot ve cl you m a nt n orr gul l us w hi h i
.
or hi e
i ai
e ary e
c s:
()Ownedbyafmivme ra no s
1
n l mbe nd t hown i t Co rgeSlmmay;
n he vea l r
or
()Fu n s e o a alb ef r h r g lrus o a yf mi me e .
2 r ih d r v ia l o t e e ua e f n a l mb r
y
3
En o s Umb el Poiy I s rn Ag e me t6 (mp a i d noe dei e tr ) Th r i
c mpa s r la lc n u ig re n e h ss e ts fn d e ms. ee s
no d t t tDo br k i a ç n iy m e r'ort tt Ve ose i a û o ve ce' a
ebae ha m os y s ç m l
f
mbe '
ha he l t r s ç r hi l ' s
mot
de i d by t polc
fne
he i y.
The A ut Polc s a e ,i r l va pa t
o i y t t s n e e nt r :
A.
W e wilpa dn gesf bodiy i ur orpr pe t da a f whi h a
l y ma
or
l ni y
o rv m ge or c ny
i ur d bec
ns e
omesl ga l r s i ebe us ofa a o ac de .W ewils tl or
e ly e ponsbl ca e n ut ci nt
l e te
de e a we c i r a oprae,a c am ors ta ki f d geswhih
f nd, s
onsde ppr it ny l i
ui s ng or ama
c
a epa bl unde t tr soft spolc ....
r ya e
r he e m
hi i y
B.
W e do no pr de Li biiy Cove a f r t ow ne s p,m a nt na or
t ovi
a lt
r ge o he
r hi
i e nce
us of ...
e :
2. l ve cl ,ot rt n yo c r d a o,whi h i :
Azy hi e he ha ur ove e ut
c s
a. wne by you;or
O
d
b.Fu nihe ora ia ef yolrr ul rus
r s d va lbl or z eg a e.
3.Anyve cl,ot rt n vo c r d a o,whih i
hi e he ha ur ove e ut
c s
a.
Owne by aw f m iym e
d
l n l mber or
;
b.Funts d ora ia e f t r gul rus ofa f m iy m e ber
i he
va l bl or he e a e
a l
m .
Ho v r t i Excuso ( 3 d e n t a py t y u whl y u a e
we e , hs l in B.) o s o p l o o
ie o r
m ai ai ng oroc
nt ni
cupyi a ve c e whi h i :
n: ny hi l
c s
a. Ownedbya f m iy me be ;or
a l m r
b. Furls d ora ia ef t r guarus ofaf m iy m e r
rihe
va lbl or he e l e
n l mbe .
Pes na Aut Polc 2- Doc tNo.1 1(mphassde e dei dtr ) ç 'a AYo '
ro l o iy 4, ke
- e
i nots fne e ms.t
You' nd ç ur'
m e ns t ç med i ur ' I a 1.Be' i lse a t na e i ur d i t Cove age
a he t
nn
ns ed. d. t
'
ty s it d s he m d ns e n he
t
r
Sum m a y.Se Cove ag Slm m a y 1, oc tN o.1 2.
r
e
r e l r D ke
-
The Endor e nt t t Aut Polc pr de ,G-he Extnde Nons me o he
o i y ovi s s
f
e d
owne Cove age
d
r
pr ded by t s e s m e t doe not a f d cove a ...f a ac i nti vi ...a
ovi
hi ndor e n
s
for
r ge
or ny c de nvol ng
ve c e om l d by a m e be of t s m e hous hol ' Ext nded N o owne Cove age
hi l
e
m r
he a
e d.
'
e
nd
r
Endor e e , D oc t N o. 1 2. The Endor e e a s pr des G e w il pr de Li biiy
s m nt
ke
s m nt l o ovi , 1
W
l ovi
a lt
Cove ag f a ve ce,o he t n yourc r d a o, c i flnihe o aval bl f t
r e or ny hi l t r ha
ove e ut whih s tr s d r ia e or he
4
r a us oft na e i vi l' I Fi ly,t e r e e saest tt Aut Polcy'
egulr e he m d ndi dua .' d. nal he ndo s m nt t t ha he o i s
ç 2. Excuson,'whih e l s c r ge f a ve c e fu s d or a l e f t
t b. l i '
B.
c xc ude ove a or ny hf l tmihe
vaiabl or he
i lrd' r gulrus doe no prcudec r gebyt Endore ntJ
nsze s e a e, s t e l ove a
he
s me .Z
1
11.
The I antA cti
nst
on
Afe Gre c mme c d t u e lig p ro a ij r s i,En o s b o g t te
tr e n o n e he nd ryn es n l n u y ut c mpa s r u h h
i tnta ton s e ng a de a a i t tnet rt Um br laPolc no t Aut Polc r quie
nsa c i e ki
clr ton ha ihe he
el
iy r he o i y e r s
Enc
ompa st de e o i mniy Dombr ky wih r s tt a cai sas e td a ns he a
s o f nd r nde f
os
t e pec o ny l m s re gai t r s
a r s l o te a cd n .Th de lrtr j d me ta to i n w b f r t c u to co s
eut f h c ie t e caao y u g n ci n s o eo e he o r n r s -
moi n f r sl r j g n fld b Do r s y Gre a d Enc mp s. Gr e a
to s o l
mmay ud me t ie y mb o k , e n, n
o a s e n nd
Do os ur t c tt co l t tDo br ky i e il d t la lt co r ge unde
mbr ky ge he our o ncude ha m os s ntte o i biiy ve a
r
bo h polc e .Enco pa s a kst c tt dec a e t cove a i notow e t D o b os The
t
iis
m s s he our o l r hat
r ge s
d o m r ky.
m oto ha be n f l bre e a a erpef r viw .
i ns ve e uly i f d nd r i or e e
St
andard ofR e e
vi w
S mmay j d me t i a p o rae wh n Eh p e dng ,t e d so e y a d sl sle
u r u g n s p r p it e G e la i s h ic v r nd ico t
t
r
ma e i s o fl a a a sda t s w t tt r i no ge ne is ast a m ae i lf t
t ral n ie, nd ny f vis ho ha he e s
nui s ue o ny t ra ac
a d t a t mo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatro lw. Fe .R.Ci P.5 () F ra
n h t he v n s n ild o u g n s
te f a ' d
'
v. 6 a . o
pat se ie et r ieag n n is o maeilfc,tmus b l u h t tar a o b ej r
ry' vd nc o as e uie sue f tra a t i t e ç c ha e s na l ' y
s
u
c d r t n aver c f t nonoul e ur
dit or he
movi pary. Ande s v. be t Lobby. nc,477 U. 242,
ng t '
'
r on Li ry
I .
S.
2 ( 98 ) W h n d cdn wh t e t ga tamoin f rs mmayj d me t t e c u tmu t
48 1 6 . e e i ig eh r o r n
to o u r u g n, h o r s
viw t r or i t lghtm os f vo a e t t none he ec d n he i
t a r bl o he
movi pa t a d a al r as bl
ng ry nd r w 1 e ona e
i e e s i hi f vo .I a 255;s e al o Te r s Fl Fas ons l v. llng on I
nf r nce n s a r d. t
e s r v' oor hi . nc. Btr i t ndus sI ,
. nc.
763F. 604,61 (t Ci.1 .
2d
0 4h r 985)
ln a d caao y j d me ta to a is rn e c ni r ma a p o raey mo f r
t ' e lrt r u g n cin, n n u a c a e y p r p itl ve o
l
s mmayj g n t d tr n wh t e i i o lg tdt prviec v r g t a i u e , ee
u r ud me t o ee mi e eh r t s b iae o o d o e a e o n ns rd wh r
5
. . .
t r a e no ma e i l a g tes i t polc ' St Pa Re ns a e Co.Lt v.Oli '
he e r
t ra mbi uii n he iy. . ul i ur nc
'
d.
le s
S a o d Grle a d BasLLC,2 2F. D.3 8 3 2 ( S. 2 0 )(ii Hihln sI . v.
e f o il n r
4 R. 4 , 5 D. C. 0 7 ctng g a d ns Co.
Geb rPr d .Co,7 2 F.S p 1 9 1 0 ( Md.1 8 ).l fc,G st r j d me ti
re o s . 0
u p. 0 , 1 D.
9 8) n a t d lt y u g n s
g mma
pa tc a l wels td f r t r s uto of i ur nce c r ge diput be us t
ri ulry
l-uie o he e ol i n
ns a
ove a
s es ca e he
c tuc i ofi ur nce co r c s i a l lquesi ' Na i de M ut l .Co.v.Ove l k.
onsr ton ns a
nta t s ega
ton. tonwi
'
. ns
roo
LLC,78 F.S p 2 5 2 51 ( D. . 01 ) s e as Trn c n ie tlI s Co v.
5 u p. d 0 , 2 E. Va 2 1 ; e lo a s o tn n a n . . RBM W .
I . 5 1S. 2d31 , 7 ( . 01 (t l tpr tto o t ep o so so a is rn ec nr c
nc, 5 E. 3 31 Va 20 ) çln e eain f h r viin f n n u a c o ta t
g
prs nt aquesi of1 ....)
ee s
ton aw
'.
'
Di
scussi
on
1.
A pplcabl L aw
i e
A f de alc tsti i di r iy mus a y t c c oflw r e of t sa e i
e r our itng n ve st
t ppl he hoie- -a ul s
he t t n
w hi h t t c ti l a e K l xon Co.v.St nt r El c.M f Co. I ,31 U . 48 496c ha our s oc t d. a
e o e
g. s nc. 3 S. 7,
97
( 9 ) Va Co e j 3 .- 3 (A1 i u a e c n rcs o o wih r s e tt te o e s i
1 41; . d
82 31 ç l ns rnc o ta t n r t e p c o h wn rhp,
$
mait na e orus ofpr ry i t s Comm onweat s l be dee
n e nc ,
e
ope t n hi
1h hal
med t ha bee m a i
o ve n de n
a d s al ec nsnldi a c r a c wiht elwso t sCo n at ' s eas Bu h n n
n h lb o t e n c o d n e t h a f hi mmo we l ); e lo c a a
h.
v Do ,4 1S. 2 28 ,2 ( .1 9 )(h 1w o te saei whc a i u a c c nr c i
. e 3 E.d 9 91 Va 9 3 te a f h tt n ih n ns rn e o ta t s
wrte a dei rd govensisi e eai .I Vigi a ûc t i eprti urnc polce ,
itn nd lvee
r t ntprtton) n r ni,Gours ntr e ns a e iis
lke o he c r cs i a cor nc wih t i e i oft pa tesglane fom t wor t y
i t r onta t, n c da e t he ntnton he ri e d r he
ds he
us d i t doc e . Tr ns ntne a ,551 S. 2d a 31 s Bl Cr s & Bl Shi l v.
e n he um nt' a co i nt l
'
E. t 8; ee ue os
ue e d
Kele ,450 S. 2d 1 1 ( .1 4)(:Ajco tmus ad r t t tr ofa c tac of
lr
E. 36, 40 Va 99 <( ur
t hee o he ems
onr t
i ur nc aswrte i t y a epli a c e ra no i vi a i of1w ori nsse wih
ns a e
itn, f he r a n nd l a nd t n olton a
nco it nt t
publcpolc ' .d hco
i iy.' GEac mpone ofa i urnc c tac çhoul bec i r da c tue
)
nt n ns a e onr t s d onsde e nd onsr d
t t ra s e i y c lc i pr s onsha
oge he nd e m ngl onfi tng ovi i
nnoni d w he t tca be r as na y done s
ze
n ha n
e o bl
,o
6
a t e f c u t t i e i oft pa tesasex e s t r n.'Tr ns ontne a ,5 S. 2d a
s o f e t a e he nt nton he ri
pr s ed he ei '' a c i nt l 51 E. t
31 (uoig S g sv.TheLieI s Co.o Vicn a 1 7 S. 2 7 7 7 0 ( .1 6 :.Poiy
8 q tn u c
f n.
f r ii, 4 E.d 0 , 1 Va 9 6
lc
e usons a e lke s co tue a or ng t t i pli lng ge.Se Tr vco I Co.v.
xcl i
r i wie nsr d cc di o her an a ua
e a
ns.
W ad 7 6S. 2 3 , 2 ( . 01 )
r , 3 E.d 21 3 9 Va 2 2 .
Be us i ur r ge r l dr tpolc l ng
ca e ns e s ne aly af i y a uage t m s l w ihouta i
he e ves t
ny nput f om t
r he
i ur d, ny a g te i t tlng gea ege r l r ol d i f voroft i ur d:
ns e a mbi uii s n ha a ua r ne aly es ve n a
he ns e
g u' tn ji fv ro t a itprtto wh c g a t c vea e rt e ta
co ls i d n a o f h t ne eain ih rn s o rg , ah r h n
t
t t whi h w ihhol i .W he e t o c t u tons a e e ly pos i e,t tm os
ha
c
t ds t
r w ons r c i
r qua l
s bl ha
t
f vor bl t t i ur d w il be a
a a e o he ns e
l
dopt d. La
e
ngua i a polc pup or i t
ge n
iy
tng o
e l c ran e nt fom c a wilbe c tu m osl sr ngl a i t
xc ude e ti ve s r
over ge l
onsr ed
ty to y gans
t i ur r
he ns e .
1 ( i PBM Nutii lsLLC v.Le ndon I .Co.724 S. 2d 707,71 ( .201 ) çA
d. quotng
rtonas
xi
ns ,
E.
3 Va 2).1
polc pr son i a bi
i y ovii s m guous whe i co e , i i c pa e of m or t n o r a o bl
n, n nt xt t s a bl
e ha ne e s na e
me ni ' Res Ba hae Cop.v.St Pa M eczy l .Co. 407 F. 631 636 ( h Ci.
a ng.' . nks rs
. ul rlr ns ,
3d ,
4t r
2 0 ) No ehee s d o rsmu tn tsri t fn n iui e . 1 .t n r cu l r v so ae
0 5 . n t ls,l u t s o tan o id mb g t s' d t ta t a p o iins r
c
i ' co
not n bi uous m er l be a e t pa tes di a e about t i m e ni ' N e e W I Le e
m g
e y c us he r i
s gr e
he r a ng. xt l P as
'
Cor v. undes 666S. 2d31 321( .2008 .
p. Sa r,
E. 7, Va
)
W ih t sl ga fn e r i m i t c twilno c i rwhe he Enc
t hi e l r m wo k n nd, he our l w onsde
t r ompa smus
s
t
de e ori mniyD o br ky i t unde l ng sa e c ul a i The c r wilfrte m i
f nd nde f
m os n he
ryi tt o ' cton.
t
ou t l is xn ne
Enc
ompa s oblga i unde t Umbr l Polc a t n tz' t is d i unde t Aut
s ' i tons
r he
ela iy, nd he 'l o t utes
tn
r he o
Polc a t Endor e e .
i y nd he
s m nt
11.
Coveraze under t Um brela Polc
he
l
iv
I g nea tr ,h Umb el Poiye ld sc vea ef ra yb dl ij r o p o e t
n e rl ems t e
rla lc xcu e o rg o n o iy nu y r r p ry
da age a i i o of t G ne s p;m a nt na e;us oc upa y;. ..of a m ot ve c e
m
r sng ut he l
ow r hi
i e nc
e; c nc
ny
or hi l
'Th Umb el Pol y t n e c p sfo t i e cuso b d l ijzy a d p o e t d ma
' e
r la i he x e t r m hs x l in o iy nl n r p ry n ge
c
r
. . . .
aii fom a ac i nti vi a ve cl t ti ( )manti orr al usd by t
rsng r n cde nvol ng
hi e ha s 1 i aned egulry e
he
7
n me i l e a d ( )i et e o db afmi me e o a ia l f rt ergua u eo a
a d nsz d; n 2 s i r wne y n l mb r r valbe o h e lz s f
r
h
y
fmiy me e .S e En o a s Umb el Poiy l s rn Ag e me t 6 (mp ss o te )
a l mb r e c mp s
r l l n u ig r e n e ha i mitd .
a c
Ac or ng y,t Umbr l Polc wilr quie Enco pa st de e ori mniy Dombr ky i
c di l he
ela i y l e r
m s o f nd nde f
os f
Bet m ant i d orr ulry us d t Ve ose a t Ve oserwa eihe owne by J Ann or
ty i ane
eg a l e he l t r nd he l t
s t r
d
o
Dombr ky ora ia ef et rJ Ann orDombr ky' r gulrus
os
va lbl or ihe o
os s e a e.
l V igi a t pe s t who a ve c e i tte i t o ne .H a lI v.Em pie Fie
n r ni , he r on o
m
hi l s il d s he w r l nc.
r r
& M ai I .Co.448 S. 2d 633,635( 1 (ç- owne ofa a omobiei t pa t
rne ns ,
E.
Va. 994) sl
-he
r n ut
l s he ry
whoh slg l i et i.)(iigVa Co ej4 2 1 0 . r ,h Veo trwa tte i J An j
a e a tt o t' ctn . d 6.- 0 ) Hee t e lse s i d n o n'
l
'
l
na e At t tm e J AM was a f m iy m e r as de
m .
he i , o
a l
mbe
sned by t Umbr la Polcy.
he
el
i
Ac or ngl t Vel t r wa G
c di y, he
ose
s s
owne 'by a f l m e r as c e a e by t polcy.
d'
amiy mbe
ont mplt d
he i
The e o e t co tbe i ve t tt di pos tve i s i t m e ni oft w o d t a n a n.
r f r , he ur le s ha he s ii s ue s he n ng he r d i t i '
m
'
Not bl i t ni da bet e t pur ha e of t ve c e a t a c de , t
a y, n he ne ys we n he c s
he hil nd he c i nt he
V eose ha no r par ne ds a wa no s n t a a o s p.I t e ni da ,howe r
l tr d
e i e nd s t e t o n ut ho n hos ne ys
ve ,
Be t f led up t ga t nk a l a t onc a l whe not i us t V e os e r m ai d i t
ty il
he s n
t es
e, td,
n
n e, he l t r e ne n he
ga ag oft ho e Be t owned.Furhe ,t pur has prc oft Vel t r whih Be t pa d,
r e he m
ty
t r he c e i e he ose , c
ty i
i ude a c
ncl d oupon f r an oi c ng i addii n t a lmie wa r nt Th ,Dombr ky a
o
l ha e n
to o i t d ra y. us
os nd
Gr n tr t c tt fnd t tBe t m ait i d t Veose ,whih woul gi rs t a d y
ee tge he our o i ha ty
n ane he l t r
c
d ve ie o ut
t de end o i m niy unde t Um br laPolc
o f
r nde f
r he
e l i y.
Enc pa s a g s t t t m e ng of t w o d d a nt i 'm us be unde s ood a i
om s r ue ha he ani
he r G i a n'
m
t
rt
sn
r l ton t a m o or ve c e.Se St t Fn m M ut Aut l .Co.v.Po el,318 S. 2d 393,397
ea i o
t
hi l
e ae r
. o. ns
w l
E.
( 198 (l-lhe l rhi mantna ,orus pr vii s ul beco t e i t lght
Va. 4) ig
f ownes p, i e nce
e' o son ho d
nsnzd n he i
o te s be tmatrwihwh c t epa t sa ed aig tetr o t poiys o l b gv n
f h u j c te t ih h ri r e ln ; h e ms f he l h ud e ie
e
c
t i nau a a o di r mea ng. Therf e Enco s c e ,Gmanan'mus me n
her tr l nd r nay ni '
). eor,
mpa s ontnds ç iti ' t a
8
G ant na , s h a sa e i pe tons tr r t tons oi c nges a t lke.Enc m pas
ç i e nce' uc s t t ns c i , ie o a i , 1 ha , nd he i
m
'
o
s
c a m st tt w o d s d no be unde s ood t m e m e e y ga agi a f lng.
l i ha he r houl t
rt
o an r l r ng nd ' i
ue
Fe c t ha a e s d t is ofwha c tt e m ant na o a mot ve ce.
w ours ve ddr s e he s ue
t onsiut s i e nce f
or hil
Gr e a Dombr ky r y on a c e i whi h t Unied Stt sCour ofAppe l f t Fourh
e n nd
os el
as n
c he t
ae
t
a s or he
t
Cic t a e s d t m e ni of i nt n' i r a i t a a oma i s i e s t m .Se
r ui ddr s e he a ng l
mai ai ' n elton o n ut tc prnklr yse
e
Brtm LLC v Grp cArsMu .n .Co, 4 F. p' 5 8 6 2 0 (t Ci. 1 . tn t
eo
. a hi t t l s .4 6 Ap x 9 , 0 - 3 4h r 201 ) Ciig o
Blc s La Di to r t Fourh Cic t c l d t t t wor t ant i ' c d be
a k' w
ci na y, he
t r ui oncude ha he
d f i an' oul
m
undesoodi mor t nonewa JJ l co dras bl bei eprt t me nha ngar ulr
rt n e ha
y... t ul e ona y ntr eed o a vi
I
eg a
r paroblgai n.I On t o he hand,ç nt n' c ul alo r as bl bet de sood t m e n
e i i to d. he t r
i
mai ai ' o d s e ona y m rt
o a
t tt i ur smpl ha t ha a s i e s t m i t ld,asi t ke p i i e se e.I
ha he ns ed i y d o ve prnklr yse nsale
n o e t n xit nc d.
The Fourh Cic t bele d t e t t r tnd ngs s
t
r ui
ive hes wo mde sa i
uppore a fndi of a guiy,
td
i ng
mbi t
r q rn i t a p ya i tr r tto t a wo l ef cu t c v r g . ei (iig M olna e
e uiig t o p l n nep eain h t ud fe tae o e a e Se d. ctn
l ur
e
v. to wieM u .n . , 9 SE.d5 , 9 ( .1 7 ).
Nain d tI s Co.1 8 . 2 91 5 2 Va 9 3 )
Gr n a Do br ky alo po ntt a handf ofo - - ic tsa e- t ' de ii t t
ee nd m os
s i o
ul utofcr ui tt co ut c sons ha
ha a e s d t i s ofwha i m e ns t G ant i 'a ve cl For e m pl t Supr me
ve ddr s e he s ue
t t a o s i an'
m
hi e.
xa e, he
e
Cou t of Pe y va a ha de e mi d t t mai e nc S rs t pr e ve or ke p i a
r
nns l ni s t r ne ha
ntna e t l o es r
mea
e n n
e si sa e o co ii n a e a e a t ofr para o he a t t pr ve a de lne lps ,
xitng t t r ndto nd mbr c s c s e i nd t r c s o e nt
ci , a e
or c s a i fom t t s a e or c ndii n. M o rs v.Am .Li b.& Sur t Co. 185 A .201 202
e s ton r
ha t t
o to ' r i
'
a
ey
,
,
( 1 .Adoptngt slngua t SuprmeCour ofTe f
Pa. 936)
i hi a ge, he
e
t
xas ound i çne c pa et tt
t i s a bl ha he
i
r plce ntof f lwhih ha bee e use wih us a wihoutwhih a mot r ve ce i
e a me
ue
c s n xha t d t e nd t
c
o hi l s
i pe a i ,i a s ci s of m ai e nc .... St t Fn M ut Aut I .Co.v.Pa A m .I .
no r tve s pe e
nt na e
' a e nn
'
. o. ns
n
ns
Co.437 S. . 542,545( x.1 .Fi ly,Gr e a Dombr kynot t tt ditonay
,
W 2d
Te 969) nal e n nd
os
e ha he ci r
9
m e ni oft wor m e ns:ç1.t kee i a sae ofr par e fce orvai t pr s r e fo
a ng he d a & o p n t t
e i, fi incy
ldiy: e e v r m
f l eorde lne ...4.t pr def :be rt e ns of s
aiur
ci
o ovi or a he xpe e : uppor ....'W e t ' Thid New
t
' bsers r
I tl cin r 1 6 ( 9 6 .
n ' Dito ay 3 2 1 8 )
Li i Br t t c tbele s t tt pa te pr f r t dif r nta r as bl
ke n e on, he our ive ha he ris ofe wo f e e nd e ona e
unde s a ng of t w o d t a nt i ' Thi s ges s t t t t r i n bi
r t ndi s
he r û i a n.
m
' s ug t ha he e m s m guous Se Br t
. e e on,
4 F. p' a 6 3($ h wo d û iti d ybeu d rt di mo eta o ewa , whc
46 Ap x t 0 çT) e r man an' ma
g
n e soo n r h n n y' ih
s
upporsafndi ofa g t ' (ii Saz v.Va.Fn Blr a M ut I .Co. 556 S. 2d
t i ng mbiuiy.' ctng li
)
nn ze u . ns ,
E.
758,760( 2002).M orove ,whiet Umb el Polc a t spr son i pa tculr i
Va.
)
e r l he
r la iy, nd hi ovii n ri a, s
rpe wih de i d tr ,Enc
i
t fne e ms
ompa s de lned t des G n ai 'i t ag e n e t Se i
s ci
o tne d t n' n he r e l n . e d.
mai
(Absn a y ca iain i te p lc ,we c ncu e t t l iti i n g o s hee' .
ç e t n ldfc to n h o iy
t
o ld ha manan' s mbiu u r .)
'
Acc r ngl t c ti bo md by Vigi a 1 w t i epr tt t r i f
o di y, he our s t
r ni a o nt r e he e m n avorofc r .Se
ove age e
Trv ,7 6 S. 2 a 3 9 (W h r t c n tu to sa ee u lypo sbl,ha mo tfv rbl
a co 3 E.d t 2 G e e wo o sr ci n r q al si e t t s a o a e
s
t t ei s z dwil ea o td'
o h n u e lb d pe .)
'
W ih t s prncpl s i m i t c tbei ve t tBe' m ant i t Vel t rf
t he e i i e n nd, he our le s ha ty i aned he ose or
t
pur e o t Umbr l Polc Tesi
pos s f he
ela i y. tmony de
monsr t st tt Ve ose sa d i t gar ge
ta e ha he l t r t ye n he a
whe not beng us d, s le i i fom t e e e s M or over t s decson t ke t
n
i
e het rng t r
he lm nt .
e , hi
ii o ep he
V e os e i t g a w asa a fr a i one,a Be t t tfe t ta l as one ve c e w a ke
l t r n he ar ge
n f i m tve
s ty es ii d ha t e t
hi l s pt
on t drveway.Se Bety Dt De 29: 30: Be t and J Ann bo h sa e t tkee ng t
he i
e t mn p. 34- 2. ty
o
t tt d ha
pi he
V e os e i t ga a he pe t s ur t V e ose a pr ec i f om adve s we t r Se
l t r n he r ge l d o ec e he l t r nd ot t t r
r e a he . e
Bet Dl nDe 311 - (trb tn t er a o h rTo oaAv lnwa i t x eln s pe'o
ty l
n p. :0 21 a t u ig h e s n e y t ao s n G c le t ha 't
i
e
bebe a ei wa ke i t ga a ) J Ann Dunn De 22: - 614- 5.Si lry,t co t
c us t s pt n he r ge; o
p. 2123; : 1 mial he ur
be ives t t ga a ng t ve cl i ve ca i f r t Vel t r G or pur e of .
le
ha r gi he hi e nvol d rng o he
ose t
f
pos s
a pe rnc . Blc sLa Dito a v1 3 (t e 2 0 ) Fu te mo e Be t d dmo eta j s
p aa e' a k' w cin r 0 9 9h d. 0 9 . rh r r , ty i r h n u t
'
g a t Veoser She f l d t ca a las onc al Be t pad f f elwhe J Ann dr
ar ge he l t .
ue e he r t e t e, ld ty i or u
n o
ove
teVeo trt W e tVigna S e W e se ' Thr Ne I ' Dito a y 1 6 ( 9 6 (e iig
h lse o s r ii. e b trs id w ntl cin r 3 2 1 8 ) d fnn
manti as ço pr de f :be t expe e of'.Addii l t purhas prc oft
i an l ovi or ar he
t
ns )
tonaly, he c e ie he
ve c e, hi Be t pa d,i l d t fr toi c nge a a lm ie w a r nt
hi l w ch ty i nc ude he i s 1 ha
nd i t d r a y.
I alo a r t tDo br ky,J Ann,and Bet e t Bel t c rbut t ce ti
t s ppea s ha m os o
ty xpeced ty o onti e o ran
upke p e ns , s h a oi c nge a tr r t tons For e mpl , Be t a J ha
e xpe es uc s 1 ha s nd ie o a i .
xa e ty nd oe d
c rbutd t wa dst s e ns s f r J Ann' lAV4.SeeJ Ann Dlnn De 52: 1 Be t
onti e o r he e xpe e o o
sl
o
l
p. 9- 0; ty
Dt De 20: 11.Bet had pr vi usy plr ha e a vehil f r a t r gr ndda ht r She
mn p. 9ty
e o l zc s d
c e o no he a
ug e .
ha pur ha e tr s w i hi l w i r ,a ga olne f t tve c e.Se Be t D un D e 27:
d c s d ie , nds e d pe s nd s i or ha hi l
e ty
n p. 6-
9.Be t a s a
ty lo cknowl dge t tDo br ky di notha s c e f ndst pa f t s s t
e d ha m os
d
ve ux i nt u
o y or he e ors
ofe ns ,a s e ce t hep J Al c rt m.Se L. 32: 7.Fo t era ons t
xpe es nd he xpe td o l o m ove he
e d 4-1 r hes e s ,hç
.
c t be ive t t Be t s aci a o mt d t tmait ni ' t Ve ose . Co e ue ty,
our le s ha
ty' tons m t e o i n ai ng' he l t r ns q n l
a co di t t l ngua oft Um b e l polc Enc pa s ha a dut t de e ori m niy
c r ng o he a
ge he
r la i y, om s s
y o f nd nde f
Do br ky.Se Enc
m os
e ompa sUmbr la Polc l urng Agr e e 6.
s
el
iy ns i
e m nt
11
1.
C o r unde t A ut Polc
ve aze
r he
o iv
Gr e and Dombr ky alo as t c tt de l r t tEnc
en
os
s k he our o c a e ha
ompa sha a dut t de e
s s
y o f nd
o i m niy Dom br ky pur ua t t t r s o t A u o Polc t Endo s m e , o bot
r nde f
os
s nt o he e m f he t
i y, he
r e nt r h.
Enc
ompa ss e a de a a i t ti ha no s h d y.The Aut Polc e l s c r e f
s e ks
clr ton ha t s
uc ut
o i y xc ude ove ag or
ç an v hil, te t a y u c v r da t , c i:. . unih do a albeo y t r g lr
l j y e ce oh r h n o r o ee u o whih s . fr s e r v i l r ol e u a
g
a
r
us ' Pe s
e. ronalAut Polc 4.TheEndor e ntc ve outa e pto t t se l i sa i
'
o iy
s me ar s
n xce i n o hi xcuson, ttng
t tEncom pa s twilpr de Li biiy Cove ag f r a ve c e ot r t n yolr c r d a o,
ha
s ç l ovi
a lt
r e o ny hi l , he ha
z ove e ut
w hi h i f l s d or a l bl f t r gul r us of t na e i vi ual' Ext nde N onc s u mihe
vaia e or he e a e
he m d ndi d .
' e d
O wne Cove a 1.H ow e r t r i a r e nt e pto t t Endor e e c r ge:tf
d
r ge
ve , he e s el va xce i n o he
s m nt ove a
s he
-
11
Exe e No own d Cov rg p o ie b ( e e d re nt o sno af r c v r g . .o
tnd d n- e
e a e r vd d y t j n o s me d e t fo d o ea e . f r
h
a ac i n i vi ...a ve ceowne by am e roft s m ehous hol '1
ny c de t nvol ng:
hi l
d
mbe
he n
e d.' d.
Asa t r hol ma tr Enc pa s a gue t tt Endo s m e doe nota y be a e
l es d te , om s r s ha he
z
r e nt s
ppl c us
t Sc dul lse o t Endor e ntdoe no ls a S m e i vi ua . ç c c
he he e it d n he
s me
s t it t
nn d ndi d l' l h ompo ntof
' Ea
ne
a i tr nc c r tG houl be c i r a c t ue t t r ....' Tr ns ntne a ,551
n nsl a e ontac s d
ons de ed nd ons r d oge he
'' a co i nt l
S. 2 a 3 8( u tn S c v Th LieI s Co o Vi n a 1 7 S. 2 7 7 71 ( .1 6 ).
E.d t 1 q oi g ug s . e f n . . f mii, 4 E.d 0 , 0 Va 9 6)
Thus e s m e t t tm odiy a unde l ng polc l ho d be c i r d a c nsnz d' i
, ndor e n s ha
f n
ryi
iy ç ul
s
onsde e nd o t e ' n
c n u to wi s i u d ryn poiy. u as 1 S. 2 a 71 lW j e ete ei d u ta t
o j ncin t ad n el ig lc S a , 47 E.d t 0.ç h r h r s o b s o
h
g
ghe)me ni 't c ti co tane t co tuet lng geçn fvoroft ti eprtto
t
a ng, he our s nsr i d o nsr he a ua s a
'
i
ha ntr eain
whi h gr nt c r ge,r t rt n t whi h wihhol i. St PaulFie & M a
c a s ove a
ahe ha hat c t ds t' .
'
r
dne I .Co.v.
ns
S. Nus a m & Co.I c, 1 S. 2 7 4, 3 ( . 98 )
L. b u
, n .3 6 E.d 3 7 6 Va 1 4 .
Looki a t Endo s m e i pe nty a t t Aut Polc coleci l t c t
ng t he
r e nt nde nde l nd o he o iy l tvey, he our
bei ve t t t pa tes i e
le s ha he ri nt nded Be t t be t t m e i vi . See Se s v.Ere l .
ty o
he G
nn d ndi dual'
'
al
i ns
Ex h.6 4S. 2 8 0, 6 ( . 0 9 (Ea h p rs a dca s o a i s r n ec nr c s o l
c , 7 E.d 6 8 2 Va 2 0 ) G c h a e n lu e f n n u a c o ta t h u d
t
be c i r d a consr d t t r ... s as t e f c uae t i e i of t pa te a
onsde e nd
tue ogehe
o
o fe t t he nt nton
he ri s s
e e s d t r n.) On t Cove a Summay,Bet i lse a t ç d i urd.
xprs e heei ' .
'
he
r ge
r
ty s itd s he t
nnme ns e '
'
Addtonal i r lton t t Aut Polc Be' i lse unde i rve I br to ' Se
ii ly, n ea i o he
o
iy, ty s it d
t
r o i r nt mai n. e
'
Cove a Sum m ar 1 D oc tN o. 1 2. Si ia l t Co r ge Slm m a y nùt s t t t A ut
r ge
y ,
ke
m l ry, he ve a
l
r
e ha he
o
Po iyi iu j c't teEn o s me t I . t4. rh r r, ieEnc mpa si c re tta n
lc s l b e t'o h d re n .d a Fu te mo e whl o s s o rc h t o
s
o i s c fcal ls e a t ç m e i vi ua' o t Sc dul f t Endor e e ,t r i
ne s pe ii ly it d s he t
na d ndi d l' n he he e or he
s m nt he e s
a E ' ne t I n e I vi la Fa iy M em be s' N e t Ifo a Pr m i ' o t s m e
n S ' xt o t m d ndi dua nd m l
X
N
r .' xt o s t l e um ' n he a
-
s he e i $$ I
c dul s 1 NCLUDED.'Se Ext nde Non' e e d
owned Cove a 1 Ac or ngl t c t
r ge . c di y, he our
bele s t t Endor e e i a ia e a t t t r lva quesi i whe he t
ive ha
s m nt s pplc bl nd ha he ee nt
ton s
t r he
Endor e e pr vi s c r
s m nt o de ove age.
12
I Stt Fam M u .Auo I .Co.v J ne ,38 S. 2 7 4 ( .1 8 ) t e S p e
n ae r
t t. ns
. o s 3 E.d 3 Va 9 9 , h u rme
Cou tofVigi a ha t opporuniy t e m i t m e ni ofç u nihe ora ia ef t
r
r ni d he
t t o xn ne he a ng ç r s d
f
va lbl or he
r gul rus ' i t c extof a a om obie i tr nce polc Spe f c ly,t Cour r e l t
e a e ' n he ont
n ut
l nsla
i y. cii a l he
t e va ua ed
a e zird cso S aeFam M u. t v S t ,1 2 S. 2 5 2 ( .1 6 ) i whc i h d
n ale e iin, tt r
t Auo. . mi 4 E.d 6 Va 9 5 , n ih t a
h
de e m i d t t t ve ce i que ton was notf r s o a lbl f r ulr us of t
t r ne ha he hi l n
si
u nihed r vaia e or eg a e
he
i u e Th Co r o s r e t a S t ( mp sz dta E i u e )e ecs dnod miin o
ns rd. e u t b ev d h t mi ç ha ie h t t ns rd x r ie
he
he
o no r
c r ove t c rand ne rope a e i f r a pur e wihoutfrtobt i ng pe mi so '
ontol r he a
ve
r t d t o ny pos t
is
ani
r s i n.
'
J s 38 S. 2d a 735; s as Herc v.Gov' Emps I .Co. No.97659, 1
one , 3 E. t
ee lo tik
t
. ns
,
991 W L
1 01 4 2 a * ( .Ci.Ct M a 9 9 )(Th ca sfc to o t e c aa tro u e wa
1 5 2 , t 1 Va r . y ,1 91 $ e lsiiain f h h rce f s s
ç
s cGc l a a d n d i J ne ,wh r t Co r ise d u g d t a i i c nto (o whae r
pe i al b n o e n o s e e he u t n ta r e h t t s o r l fr tve
y
pupo e t ti d tr nai o te ulrus .' .Th f cs i J ne c mp le ,h we e,t e
r s ) ha s ee mi t f r g a e'' e a t n o s o eld o v r h
ve
)
Cour t c et adif r ntc l i n.I J s t Supr m e Co tofVigi a dee mi t t
t o om o fe e oncuso n one , he
e
ur
r ni tr ned ha
t i ur d ha de o taed s h C r que ,dal a e e i us ,do i on,a c r of
he ns e d m nsr t uc ç e nt ly, nd xt nsve e m ni nd ontol
f
t g ce't tt ve cewa c i r t bef r s ora l ef rgul us oft
he vehill'ha he hil s onsdeed o ' nihed vaiabl or e ar e he
u
i vi l J
ndi dua . ones 38 S. 2d a 736.
, 3 E. t
Ot rsa e c t wihi t Fourh Cic tha alo a e s d whehe a a t o l i
he tt ours t n he
t r ui ve s ddr s e
t r n u om bie s
C ur s d o a ia e f t r ulrus ' of a i vi l For e m pl i Am e ia St t s
t nihe r val bl or he eg a e' n ndi dua .
f
xa e, n
rc n a e
I s Co v.Tn n r 5 3 S. 2 8 5 ( .Va 0 2 ,t S p e Co r o Ap e l o W e t
n. .
n e , 6 E.d 2 W
.2 0 ) he u rme u t f p as f s
V igi a no e
r ni t d:
The phr s ç- r s d f r gul r us '...doesno i pl t m n r of us ,t t
a e l t ni he or e a e '
fz
t m y he nne
e ha
i , ti t a om p l t t s m e us t whi h a i ur d w oul us hi own
s pu tng he ut bie o he a
es o
c n ns e
d e s
a t o l bu i ple a r g t t r cul r us of t a o obie i t s ns
u om bie, t m i s i ht o he e a e he ut m l n he e e
t t t r i a e e s o i id unde sa ng wih t owne of a
ha he e s n xpr s ed r mple
rt ndi
t he
r
n
a t o l t tt i ur d co d ha t us o t pari ul r a om obie ...i
u om bie ha he ns e ul ve he e f he tc a ut
l
f
a ia e
va l bl .
1 a 831(mpha i a
d. t
e
ss dded) sealoNai deMut I .Co.v.Shoe ke,965F.Su 700,
; e s tonwi
. ns
ma r
pp.
7 6 ( D. .1 9 ) afd 1 9 F. 1 6 ( dCi.1 98 ( b e vn ta Gndcao r g lru e
0 E. Pa 9 7, f', 3 3d 1 5 3 r 9 ) o sr ig h t s ii f e ua s
i
13
gn ld j ( )b n k tp r s in t us tç c rr te t n h vngt rq e tp r si n e c
i cu e : 1 ln e e miso o e h a ah r ha a i o e u s e miso a h
tmea ( a a ia estofke ' .
i nd 2) n valbl e
ys'
)
l t i t n ca e Be t d ove t Ve ose t t t eetm esi t ni dayst f m iy
n he nsa t s , ty r
he l t r wo o hr i
n he ne
he n l
pos e s t c rprort t a i nt No one be ived t Be t ha t as pe m iso t us
s s ed he a i o he ccde .
le
hat ty d o k r s i n o e
t Vel t r i i wasa ia e. o Ann Dunn De 54: 6.Bet Dl n De 29: 8,Do br ky
he ose , f t
va lbl J
p. 2- , ty m
p. 6- . m os
De 31:4- 9.M or over t keyswe eke i i t Ve ose - notwih Dombr ky.J Ann
p. 1 1
e , he
r pt nsde he l t r
t
os o
D unn D e 22: 2- D om br ky D e 24: 6- 7. A ddii ly, t r w e e no r s r c i ns on
p. 1 20;
os
p. 1 1
tona l he e r
e ti to
wha Be t c d d wih t Vel t r Be t Dt De 29: 1
t ty oul o t he ose . ty mn p. 9- 3.
The c r beleve t s f c s a e s fce t e tbls t tt Vel t rwasa ia e
ou t i s he e a t r ufi int o sa ih ha he ose
val bl
f rBe t sr gul us .Ast Supr m e Co 'ofVigi aha e
o ty' e ar e
he
e
ul
t
r ni s mphasz d,domi on a c r
ie
ni nd ontol
o rt ve cl a e i
ve he hi e r mporan f t s i de e mi ng whe he a ve ce i a lbl f r g a
t t acor n t r ni
t r
hi l s vaia e or e ulr
us .S eJ n s 3 3 S. 2 a 7 5. ty as ce ry h dç 1 b n k tpemiso t us t ec r
e e o e , 8 E.d t 3 Be' lo lal a ( ) ln e r si n o e h a
t
(
r te ta ha ig t rq s pemiso e c tmea d ()a a ia l s to ke s'a teke s
ah r h n vn o e uet r s in a h i n 2 n valb e e f y ' s h y
we e lf i t Ve ose .Shoe a r 965 F.Supp.a 706.Thus t Aut Polc pr vii n t t
r e t n he l t r
m ke ,
t
, he
o i y o so ha
e l s c a f S ny ve ce,ot r t n you co r d a o,whih i:...f r s d o
xcude over ge or ç
a
hi l he ha
r ve e ut
c s
u nihe r
ava l bl or yo r ul r us 'a i s Pe s l Aut Polc 4.A dd t o ly,t Endor e e
ia e
ur eg a e' pple . r ona
o iy
ii na l he
s m nt
pr son whi h pr vi s a e pto t t se l i i a s a ia e.Se Ext nde N o
ovi i
c o de nd xce i n o hi xcuson s lo pplc bl
e e d nOwne Cove age 1.
d
r
Enc
ompas ,ho
s weve ,poi sou t tt Endor e ntGdoe no a f d c r ...f r
r nt t ha he
s me l s t for ove age
o
a a i nt i vi ...a ve c e ow ne by a m e be o t s m e ho e d.'1 J Ann
ny cc de nvol ng
hi l
d
m r f he a
us hol ' d. o
ow ne t V el t r a lve w ih Be t Thi e l i a a s t a y.H ow e r D om br ky
d he os e nd i s t ty. s xc us on ppe r o ppl
ve ,
os
a Gr e ur e t c tt fnd t ttzse l i r d i c e wih t e ieEndor e e ,
nd e n g he our o i ha li xcuson, ea n ont xt t he ntr
s m nt
c e t sac lc t tm us ber s ve i f voroft i ur d.
r a e onti t ha
t e ol d n a
he ns e
GAn e epto t ts r st ne t t a i a lt ofonepa tc a e l i doe not
$ xc i n ha e ve o ga e he pplc biiy
ri ulr xcuson s
c e t a i onfit wih a he polc e uson .... PBM Nutii l ,7 S. 2dat71 çA.
r a e c lc ' t not r i y xcl i
'
'
rtona s 24 E.
3.$ n
e e i t a e uson onl ha be rng on t te l i s a i abiiy.'I I s t ç r
xc pton o n xcl i
y s ai
ha xc uson' pplc lt ' d. n hol ç l
a
e e i t a e uson doesno ce t c veag whee none e ss' l (ii Nai de
xc pton o n xcl i
t rae o r e r
xit.' d. ctng tonwi
M u .n . . W e e, 8SE.d 8 4 8 6( .1 1)
t Is Co v. na r 27 . 2 7 , 7 Va 98 ).
I t i t ntca e t c tcn
n he nsa
s , he our nnotfnd a c lc be we n t Endor e ntpr vii .
i
onfit t e he
s me
o sons
On t one ha t Endor e e ca e outa e e i t t Aut Polc e l i n f r
he
nd, he
s m nt v s
n xc pton o he
o i y xc uso o
ve cls f nzs d o a lbl f r Be t s r gul rus Se Ext nde Nonhi e a ihe r vaia e o ty' e a e. e e d
owne Cove age 1.
d
r
On t o he ha t Endor e e doe no pr de co r ge f a ac i nt i vi a
he t r nd, he
s m nt s t ovi
ve a or n c de nvol ng
ve cl o ne by a m e be of t s e ho e d.Co e nty,de pie t Endor em e '
hi e w d
m r
he am
us hol
ns que l
s t he
s nt s
e e i t t r l va A ut Polc e us on, t e e i n ca
xc pton o he e e nt o
i y xcl i he xc pto
nnot G r a e c r ge w he e
G e t ove a
c
r
no e ss' PBM Nutii nas 724 S. 2d a 71 The Endor e ntuna bi
ne xit .
'
rto l,
E. t 3.
s me
m guousy e l
l xcudes
c r f ra i nt i vi vehil sowned byf miym e be s
ove age o ccde s nvol ng
ce
a l m r.
C ! i ur nce c pa ba e is polc a pr m i on is e ua i o t f e nc
c I ns a
A.
om ny s s t
i y nd e um
t val ton f he r que y
a opporuniy f r ars t pr uc a l s' J ne ,383 S. 2d a 469.The rs wilobvi usy
nd
t t o ik o od e os .' o s
E. t
ik l
o l
g ow whe ave cl a ia ef t r gul us oft i lr d i owne by s m e who lve
r
n
hi e va lbl or he e ar e he nsze s
d
o one
i s
i t s me ho e d.Furhe ,i i a rs t t t Endor e e t c e ry he es t o h t
n he a
us hol
t r t s ik ha he
s m n l a l dg hr ug he
r lv n c v r g e cuso .Se Ex e e No owne Co ea e (1 e Extn e No ee a t o e a e x l ins e tnd d nd v rg
t
Th
ed d n
Owne Cove a pr vi d by t s e r e e doe not a f r c r ge . ..f r a a c de
d
r ge o de
hi ndo s m nt s
f o d ove a
o ny c i nt
i v lig:.. av hil o e b ame ro te s meh u e o d' .Th r fr ,t e c u t
n ovn
e ce wn d y
mbe f h a o s h l .) e eo e h o r
'
c ude t tEnc
oncl s ha
ompas i no r quie t de e or i m niy Do br ky plr ua t t
s s t e r d o f nd
nde f
m os
zs nt o he
A ut Polc o isEndor e e .
o iy r t
s m nt
Gr e a D om br ky co e t t e n i t t r s of t polc do not pr de
e n nd
os
nt nd ha ve f he e m
he
iy
ovi
co r ge,Enc pas i es o d f om de ng cove a $ pe s i es o d f o de ng
ve a
om s s t ppe r
nyi
r ge. ç
A r on s t ppe r m nyi
t c eque esofhi c
he ons nc
s onduc whe et tc
t r ha onduc ha bee s h a t i e a he t c nge
t s n uc s o nduc not r o ha
hi posto i g
s ii n n ood f t or s h t t a r as bl m a woul r l upon t r pr s ntto
aih
uc ha
e ona e n
d ey
he e e e ai ns
ma e' Htn l Oi & Re.Co.v.F d l y & Ca .Co,4 2 F.d 8 3 8 8 ( t Ci.1 6 )
d . u be 1
'
f
i ei
t
s . 0 2 9 , 9 4h r 9 8 .
Dombr k a Gr e bele t tt e al be wee J a Enc
os y nd e n ive ha he m is t n oe nd
ompa st qui a l s
s me voc ly how
t t Enco pa s a fnna i l r pr s nt d t is na e i ur t t Dombr ky, a r sde
ha
m s fi tvey e e e e o t m d ns ed ha
os
e i nt
r l tve ha c r
e ai , d ove age unde t polc M o e r Do br ky ur s t t r la e i
r he
iy. r ove , m os
ge ha e inc s
de o tae be a eJ i tu t d J Am1t ke p t e i c i and t d J Al t ts al
m nsr td c us oe nsr c e o
o e he ma l han
ol o m ha he rd
Do br ky we ec r
m os
r ove ed.
Enco pa sa s lst ti i note t d fom de ng c r gebe a e ç ove a ofa
m s s e' ha t s
t
soppe r
nyi ove a
c us ç r ge n
c
i ur nc co r c m a no bee e
ns a e nta t y t xt nded by e t lori i d wa ve t i l rs e e sy
soppe
mple
i r o ncude iks xpr s l
e cu e ' S a p v.Rih nd L f I .Co,1 3 S. 2 1 2 1 5 ( .1 71.Th sr l h s
x ld d. h r
'
c mo ie ns . 8 E.d 3 , 3 Va 9 ) i ue a
pr cude c r gei c s si whih t i lr nc co ni swe s f rasslng af sai
e l d ove a n a e n c he nsza e mpa e nt o a
i
onn t tng
t t is tpolcy was i f r a e f c a c r t d r' Se M ul v Cons . I v.
ha t t i
n o ce nd fe t nd ove ed he dve . è
'
ve
t. nc.
Bi n u Ca . r , 7 F. p' 1 0 1 8(t Ci. 01 )( ic s igNo ma v I . . f
mmio s s Co p.5 1 Ap x 5 , 5 4h r 2 4 d su sn r n .ns Co o
N. .2 9 S. 2 9 2, 0 ( .1 79) TheFo rh Cic i u h l adsrc c u tsd na o
Am , 3 E.d 0 9 8 Va 9 ).
u t r ut p ed itit o r' e il f
e endi cove age unde t docrne of e t l e n whe c rii t s of i ur nce satng
xt ng
r
r he ti
soppe ve
n e tfca e
ns a
ti
t tt r pa te we e adde a addii na i ur ds we e is des t t f c t tt t r
ha hid ri s r
d s
to l ns e
r s ued pie he a t ha he hid
pate weene ra t ly a dt t undel ng i tr nc polc Se i.a 1 60( di
ris r ve cual dde o he
ryi nsza e iy. e /s t 58- hol ng
t ha t diti c tdi no e ri r f sng t a y eso lt e e t si tr nc polcy'
ç t he srct our d t r n e u i o ppl t ppe o xt nd hi nsla e i s
t
c r be
oveage yond istnns'.As dic s t Endore nte ude c r f a i nt
t e '
l
s used, he
sme xcl s oveage or ccde s
i vi a ve c e ow ne by a m e be o t s m e hous hol Se Ext nde N on- ne
nvol ng
hi l
d
m r f he a
e d. e
e d
ow d
Co r g 1 Ac o dngy,t c u tma no S x e d b etp l.. .Eh s )rs se p e sy
vea e . c r i l he o r y t û tn y so pe
e
t e e ik x r sl
e l
xcuded.'Sha p, 1 S. 2d a 1 The e or , Encompas i not e t ppe fom de ng
'
r 83 E. t 35. r f e
s s
so d r
nyi
16
co r ge t rt Aut Polc a Endo s me .The c twilt g a i pa ta de i
ve a mde he o iy nd
r e nt
our l hus r nt n r nd ny n
par Dom br ky a Gr n' m oto a g anti par a deny i pa tEnco pas 'm oto
t
os nd ee s i ns nd r n t nd
n r
m s
i n.
Concl on
usi
Fo t er a o sae ,Do r s y a d Gr e ' mo in f rsl r j d me twilbe
r h e s ns ttd mb o k n e n s to s o l
mma y u g n l
gr nt d i pa' a de ed i pa t Enc
a e n l nd ni n r. ompa s m o i n wilbe g a t i pa ta de e i pa t
t
s ' to l
r n ed n r nd nid n r .
The Cl r i diec ed t s nd c r ii c e of t s m e or ndum opi on a t
ek s r t
o e
e tfed opi s
hi
m a
ni
nd he
a ompa ng or r t a1c ms lofr co d.The Clr i f rhe die t d t c os t sm a tr
cc
nyi
de o l ot e
e r
ek s u t r r c e o l e hi te
a srke i fom t a tvedoc toft c t
nd ti t r he c i
ke he our.
oA Tso :Thi
s
' d orFebrua y,2017.
/v ay
r
Chi Unie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?