Farabee v. Clarke et al
Filing
37
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/2/2016. (slt)
CLERK' OFFI U.6. ST COURT
S
CE
DI .
ATROANOG ,VA
FI
LED
I TI E UNI
N I
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I RI O F W R G I I
ST CT
N A
R OA N O K E D I SI N
W O
DE2 g5 2 1
25
J
BY;
. DLEM CLERK
D
PUW CLERK
BRI FAM BEE,
AN
C i lA c i N o.7: 6- v- 325
vi t on
1 c 00
Pl ntf
ai it
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
HAROLD CLARKE,etal,
.
D ef
endant .
s
By:
Hon.M i hae F.Urba li
c l
nsk
Unie St esDit i tJudge
t d at
src
Bran Fa a ,aVigi ai t pr ee ng pr K ,fl d aco ai ptr ua t 42
i
r bee
r ni nma e oc di
o
ie
mpl nt ls nt o
U. C. 1 8 .Pr sn l b fr tec u t sPlitf' t to f rij n tv r le by
S. j 9 3 e e ty e o e h o r i an ifs ç in o n u ci e eif
mo
d caao yj dg n , whiht c u t o tu sa amoi nf ratmp rr r srii go d r
e lrt r u me t' c he o r c nsr e s to o e o ay etan n r e
'
(1-Lh)
ç1?!'
-I('
Pli ifha be n f undno guit byr a on ofi a t a c vil c
a ntf d e o
t ly
es
ns niy nd i ly omm itd t t
te o he
Comm isone oft Vigi aDe rm e ofBe vi a Heat a De l pm e a Se v c s
s i r he r ni pa t nt
ha or l lh nd ve o nt l r i e
(G mmiso e ' f rte t n , u heh ssn eb e ta fre it t ec t d o t e
ç
co sin r' o r ame tb t a i c e n rnser d n o h uso y f h
)
Vigni De a t n o Co rcins(1
r i a p rme t f re to t
VDOC' d t t r v c to o as p n e sn e ei
' ue o he e o ain f us e d d e tnc n
)
N ove r201 Pl i ifdoesnotbei vet thi pr s ntc i m e i t VDOC i
mbe
5. antf
le ha s e e onfne nt n he
s
c
onduci t hi physc ,e o i na,a ps hol c lhe lh,a he a kst s rv hi s ntnc
ve o s
ial m to l nd yc ogi a at nd
s o e e se e e
i t c t y oft Comm isone i t a
n he us od
he
s i r nse d.
Th p r s o aTRO i t p ee v t esau q a da oi po sb eirpaa l ijly
e u po e f
s o r sr e h tts uo n v d sil re rb e nt
r
t apa t untlahe dng ma bec
o ry i
a
y
onduc e Se St khous .I v. t ofRa eqh,1 ê.
t d. e en
e nc. Civ
l i 66 3d
6 4 6 7( t Ci.1 9 )CTh g a to itrm g jmci qrle i a e ta r i ayrme y
3 , 3 4h r 9 9
e r n f nei i t tve eif s n x ro d n r e d
n
i vi t e r s ofave yf rr ac ng powe ,whih i t bea id onl i t lm ied
nvol ng he xe cie
r a -e hi
r
c so
pple
y n he i t
cr umsa e whihclaryde ndi.) A c tma is aTRO wiho pr dignoi
ic tnc s c e l ma t'. our y sue
'
t ut ovi n tce
whe e çs cii f c s i a afi vi ora ve ii d c pl i c e r y s
r lpe f c a t n n tda t
r fe om a nt l a l how t ti m e a e a
ha m di t nd
irpaa l ij r ,o s o d ma ewi r s t ot emo n b f r t ea v rep ryc nbeh ad
re rb e n u y ls , r n g l eult h va t eo e h d es a t a
l
er
R Ci
i o po iing '1 Fed. . v P. 5 b ( )A) A mo a tmus as etb ih( ) h t i lk l
n p sto .'
)
6 ( )1( .
vn
t lo sa ls 1 t a he s i ey
.
t s c e do t emeis ()t theb ln eo e ute tpsi h sfvo , n ( )t ta
o u c e n h rt,2 ha t aa c f q iis i n i a r a d 3 ha n
ijmcini i t ep b i itrs.W itrv Na 'Re . fn eComcl l .5 5U. 7, 9 2
n t to s n h u lc n ee t n e . tl s Dee s l ipnc, 5 S. 1 - 2
(0 8.
20)
Afe weihi t s c i r to ,t c t i t tPl ntf i note il d t a TRO.
tr g ng he e onsde ai ns he our fnds ha ai if s
ntte o
Pli ifdoe no de o taet lke i
a ntf
s t m nsr t he i lhood ofi e aea ir pa a eha m be o et
mm dit nd re r bl r
f r he
de e nt fl a a we ,a Pli ifdoe notesa ih t the i lkey t s ce d on t
f nda s ie n ns r nd antf
s
t bls ha
s i l o uc e
he
mert ofhi cli s Forexa e Pli ifas e t rg safo de de anee unde t
is
s am .
mpl , a ntf s rs i ht f r d t i s
r he
Fo re n hAme d n , u h a k o e g sh i ap io rs b e tt t Eih h
u te t
n me tb t e c n wld e e s rs ne u j c o he g t
Ame m e ' c ue a t ualpunihme sca e.Furhe
nd nts r l nd mus
s nt lus
t nnor ,Pl ntf a s t s r i o y
e ai if s ers upe v s r
la lt cli sa i tde e ntErcM a e aps hol it f re nt t tocc r d i 2009
i biiy am ga ns f nda
i
ds n, yc og s, o ve s ha
ure n
a 201 buthec me e t sa ton i 201
nd 2,
om nc d hi ci n 6.W liePl i ifwoul pr f rt r c i
ll antf
d e e o e e ve
c m s lng i t a ofm e cai , prs ne ' di a e m e wih m e c lpe s
ot e i nse d
di tons a io rs s gr e nt t di a r onne ove t
l r he
c u s o te t n d e n t tt aj 1 8 cam.W rc tv Coln , 6 F.d 8 , 49(t Ci.
o re f r ame t o s o sae
9 3 li
ih . lis 7 6 2 41 8 4 h r
1 8 ) Rusel Sh fe , 28F.d31 , 9(t Ci. 9 5 ( e c rn .
9 5 ; s l v. efr 5 2 8 31 4h r 1 7 ) p r u im)
The baa eofe te pr s ntytpsi def nda s f vorbec us t y a emor abl
lnc
quiis e e l i n e nt ' a
a e he r
e e
t n Pl i ifort c t opr s nty de i how t a l a er s c t moniora te t
ha antf he our t e e l c de
o loc t e our es o
t nd r a
Pli ifsphysc l e o i ,a m e alne ds nvol ng af de a co ti t da t da
antf
ia , m tonal nd nt e .I vi
e r l ur n he y-o- y
a miitaino ap io i ac u s t j d cayg neal d sp r ve o tkng S e ec,
d nsrto f rs n s o re he u iir e rly ia p o s f a i . e p ..
Bel W ofs 4 U.. 2 , 4 n.3 5 8n2 ( 9 9 (x lii t a man aln s c rt
lv. lih, 41 S 5 0 5 0 2 , 4 .9 1 7 ) e p anng h t iti g e u iy
1Pl ntf dnotce tf i wrtng a ef r hema t gi adefnda notc oft motonf aTRO,
ai ifdi
riy n ii ny fo t
de o ve
e nt ie he i or
a dhedi n t x anwh n t es udn t erq ie Fe . Ci. 6 ()1( ;t J ud nv Jbe 9 F.d
n
d o e pli y oi ho l o b e urd. d R. v P. 5b( )B) se o ra . a , 51 2
c
1 8 1 9 1 (t Ci.1 91 (odn ta apo. lia ti n t nie t s e ilc n ieaint e u eafile
0 , 0 -0 6h r 9 ) h lig h t r j ig n s o e tld o p ca o sd rto o xc s alr
- t
q
t
t
t f lw asrihfm adpo e t a rq ie n ta alyp ro c nc mp e n a e sl a alwy r.
o ol
o tag to r rc dl l e urme th t a esn a o rhe d s ai s a e)
r
y
2
a or ra o r tng i tt i i ma ge bl f hi n a eco i r tonspe ula l wihi
nd de nd pe a i nsi on n na a e as o r nsde a i
m
c iry t n
t ep o i ea dp o e so l x rieo c re to so tcas.Th p blcsitr s i betr
h r vnc n r f sina e pets f o rcin fiil) e u i' ne et s te
s r dby notpr en l i t r e i wih pe la i sr to
e ve
es ty n e f rng t na dm nitai n.Acc di y, ai ifsm o i n f r
or ngl Pl ntf ' to o
aTRO i de e
s ni d.
ENTER: i Z# a o Dee e,0 6 *
Th!
y f cmbr2 1 .
'Z > 'r' . .#
.
.
-.
*
. .
.. .-
U nie St t s D it tJ dge
t d a e s dc
'
'
'
q .Yj . , ,
p .j. ,.
., ,
,
2.
$
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?