Farabee v. Clarke et al

Filing 79

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/18/2017. (tvt)

?

.

cl
- s OFFI U. . DI cour
Ee
CE s ST.
AT m
ou ,
VA
FI K
L
'
.

I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT
N
TED
S CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON

AF2 18 2 1
27
J w .
uu
BY
n sy cu
u
sv
;
,

'

.

BRI FARABEE,
AN
Pl ntf,
ai if
v.

.

HAROLD CLARKE,e aI,
t .
Dee
fndant.
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

D

LERK

Ci lAcin No.7: c 00325
vi to
16-vM EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

By: Hon. i lF.Ur ki
M chae
bans
UniedSt e Dit itJudge
t ats src

Bran Fa a ,aVigi ai aepr e di pr K ,c
i
r bee
r ni nm t oc e ng o
omm e edt sa ton pur ua t
nc hi c i
s nt o

42U. C.j 1 De e nt ha r s nde t t s onda nde c antwih amoton
S.
983. f nda s ve epo d o he ec me d ompli t
i

f rs mma yj d me ts p re b a fd vt.Plitf ag e ta d fnd ns whoa e
o u r u g n u po td y fi a is an if r u s h t ee a t,
r
a s cae wiht eVignaDe a t n o Co rcin (VDOC', e e hm a e u t
s o itd t h r i i p rme t f re to s ç
E
' d nid i d q ae
)
t e t e ,f ci y a i s e e m e c t o unl w f l r t a ned a i pr s ne hi , e
r a m nt or bl dm nit r d di a i n, a uly esr i
nd m i o d m deni d

hi t fee
m he r dom t a s a e a dic i i t agans hi on a o mtofa dia lt Pr s nty
o s ocit , nd s rm nae i t m
cc t
s biiy. e e l

.

,
f

'

)'
!'
t
'

beor t cour i Plitf' motonf apr i nayij ncin.
f e he ts anifs i or elmi r n u to
*.
.
'

Pl i i fha be n f
a ntf d e ound notg ly by r a o ofi a t a c vil c m it d t t
uit
e s n ns niy nd i ly om te o he
Com m i s one oft V igi a D e rm e o Be vi r H e 1h a D e opm e a Se vi e
s i r he r ni pa t nt f ha o al a t nd vel
nt l r c s

(co sine' f rte t n , u heh ssn eb e ta ser dit t ec t d o t eVDOC
d mmiso r) o r ame tb t a ic e n r n fre n o h uso y f h
s
'
duet t r voc ton ofa s pe
o he e a i
us nded s nt nc i N o mbe 201 Pl i ifdoe notbe ivet t
e e e n ve r 5. antf
s
le ha
hi pr e c i m e i t V DO C i c
s es nt onfne nt n he
s onduc ve t hi physca ,e otona , nd ps hol c
i o s
i l m i la
yc ogi al

he lh,a he a kst s r hi s ntnc i t c t y oft Commi so ri t d.
at nd
s o e ve s e e e n he us od
hè
s i ne nsea

A p ei n r ij n to i a e ta r ia ya dd atcrme y W itrv. tr l s
rlmiay n u cin s n x ro dn r n rsi e d . n e Naua Re .
Def Councl l .555U. 7, ( ) A mova mus esa ihf ee nt beor a
.
i.nc,
S. 24 2008 .
nt t tbls our lme s f e

p ei n r ij n to ma is e ( )h i lk l t s c e do t emeis ( ) i lk l t
r l a y nu cin y su : 1 e s iey o u c e n h rt; 2 he s i ey o
mi

!

.

s frirpa a eham i t a e eofprlmi r rle '()t balnceofe testpsi hi
ufe re r bl r n he bsnc
ei nay eif 3 he a
,
quii i n s

f v r a d( )a ijmcin i i tep bl itr s.I . t2
a o ; n 4 n nt to s n h u i ne et d a 0.
c
A ferw e ghi t s co i r tons t c tfndst tPl i ifi note il d t a
t
i ng he e ns de a i , he our i
ha a ntf s
ntte o

p ei n r ij n to Plitf d e no d mo taet el l o o i daea
r l a y nu cin. anif o s t e nsrt h i i d f mme it nd
mi
ke ho
irp r beham b f r rs lto o temoinf rsl r j d me t a dPlitf d e n t
re a a l r e o e e ou in f h to o l
mmay u g n, n an if o s o
e t bls t the i lke y t s c e o t m e isofhi c a m s Fore m pl Pl i ifa s r s
s a i h ha
s i l o uc e d n he rt
s li .
xn e, a ntf s e t
r ght a f ded de ai esunde t Fouree h Am e m e , he a knowl dge he i a pr s ne
i s f or
t ne
r he
t nt
nd nt but c
e s s io r

s b e t oteEih hAme d n ' cu la du us l u ih nsca s .W h l Plitf ud
u jc t h g t
n me ts r e n n ua p n s me t lu e
ie anifwo l
pr f rt r c i co elngi t a ofm e c tons aprs ne ' diag e m e wih me c l
e e o e e ve uns i nse d
dia i , i o r s s r e nt t di a

pes love t c ureofte t ntdoe notsaeaj1983cli W rch v. lns 766F.
ronne r he o s rame
s tt
am. i t Coli ,
2d

8 , 4 ( t Ci.1 8 ) Ru s lv. h fe , 28F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 )( rc ra .
41 8 9 4h r 9 5 ; s el S efr 5 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 pe u im)
M o e r de e nt e a n t tPl i iff ie t e us a i sr tve r e e be or
r ove , f nda s xpl i ha a ntf a l d o xha t dm ni ta i em di s f e

c
omme ngt sa to a r quie by42U. C.j 1 ()
nci hi cin s e rd
S.
997ea .
Thebaanc ofe te pr s nty tpsi de e n s f vorbe us t y a em o ea e
l e quii s e e l i n f nda t ' a
ca e he r r bl
t Pl i ifort c tt pr s nty de i how t a l a e r s c t m oniora tea
han a ntf
he our o e e l c de
o loc t e our es o
t nd r t

Pli if sphysc ,e o i ,a m e alne ds nvol ng af de a co ti t da t day
antf'
ial m tonal nd nt e .l vi
e r l ur n he y-o-

a miitain o ap io i ac u s t j d cayg n rlyd sp r v so tl g.S e ec,
d nsrto f rs n s o re he u iir e eal ia p o e f adn e . ..
Bel W o fs , 41U. 5 0, 4 n.3 5 n.9( 9 9 (x lii t a man anigs c rt
l v. lih 4
S. 2 5 0 2 , 48 2 1 7 ) e p anng h t iti n e u i
y
a o dera ope a i i tm ton i m a gea e f s on a e co i r tonspe ula l w ihi
nd r
nd r tng ns i i n na bl a hi r ns de a i
c i ry t n

t pr ncea pr esi e rieofc r cinsofcas.Thepublc' i eeti betr
he ovi nd of sonal xpe ts
ore to fiil)
i s ntrs s te
s r ed by no pr s nty i e f rng w ih pe la i s r ton,es ci ly i a c s ,lke he e
ev
t e e l nt r e i
t na dm ni ta i
pe a l n a e i
r,
i vi t m e a he lh te m e a phys c ls f t ofa i a e who r pe t dl har s
nvol ng he nt l a t r at nt nd
i a a ey
n nm t
e ae y m

hms l.Ac o dn l, anifsmoinf rap ei n r ij n to i d n e
i ef c r igy Plitf' to o r l ay n u cin s e id.
mi

E T RTi / dyfpi21. V
N E :hs Y aoAr,07
l

l+ - .2.. #. &-, '
1 / , cT
1
)
à
'
c
ég:ï
;.'
)
'l

U nie St t s Di t i udge
t d a e s rc