Witcher v. Clarke

Filing 14

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 16-335. (slt)

eLERK' oFFl u. .pls cour
:
ce s s
.
AT DANVI E,
LL vA

FL :
IE

MA 13 2 1
Y
27
I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R T H E W ESTER N DISTR I OF V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A NO K E DI I O N
V SI

M ARTI
NEZ 0 . I
W TCHER,

JJ c D iL' r E
C
L
)h ; q
M

BY:

Epu'
l
v

E

CA SE N O .7:
16CV 00335

Pe ii r
tt one ,
V.

M EM O R AN DU M O PIN IO N

H AROLD W .CLARK E,

By:H on.Jac on L. i e
ks
K sr
Seni U nied St es D itri Judge
or
t
at
s ct

R es
pondent
.

M a tne 0 . W ic r a Vi gi a i a e pr ee ng pr m , ha s i t d a pl di
ri z
t he ,
r ni nm t oc di
o
s ubm te
ea ng

e ild C
ntte I EF FROM A J
RELI
UDGM ENT AND ORDER PURSUANT TO RULE 60B( ,'
4)'
s e ng t vac t a 2004 c ci n i t Pityl ni Count Cic tCour. Be us W ic r s
e ki o a e
onvi to n he ts va a
y r ui
t ca e t he '

algai a a whol s ug t voi t sae c tc i na j me unde whih he i
le tons s
e o ht o d he tt our rmi l udg nt
r c
s
c r nty i a c a e t co ' doc t d hi pladi a a peii f a m i ofha a c pus
ure l nc r er t d, he ul
t ke e s e ng s
tton or
t
be s or ,

purua t 28 U. C.j 2254. Two wee alrhi frtplAdi W ic ras s te ml
s nt o
S.
ks fe s is e ng, the lo ubmitd
acualj225 peiin. Re ponde fld amoto t dimis a W ic rr ponde ma ng
t
4 tto
s
nt ie
in o s s , nd the es
d, ki
t ma tr rpe f r d s ii
he te i o iposton. Afe r vi w of t r or 1g a t m oto t d s is t
tr e e
he ec d, r nt he
i n o im s he
m oton a peii n.
i nd tto
1
.

Bac
kgro
und

l 2004, W ic r was c ced of am e sam or bur a y,t co mt of r bbe y,
n
t he
onvi t
r d t t y gl r wo t s
o r

maiiusbo i ij r ,a dt rec u t o us o afr am i t c mmiso o afln Th
lco
dl nu y n h e o n s f e f ie r n he o sin f eo y. e
y
Pi tyl ni Coun y Cic t Co t s nt nc hi t f
ts va a
t
r ui
ur e e ed m o oMy- g - r -m pr s nm e . The
ei ht yea s i i o nt
V i g ni Co ' of Appe l a tr e hi c
r i a ul
t
a s fi m d s onvi to ,and t V i g ni Supr m e Coul r f e
c i ns
he r i a
e
' e us d
t
revi . A fer f lng t recei habeas r i i t s at court he f l a feder habeas petton
ew
t aii o
ve
elef n he t e
, ied
al
ii

whih J d e J me Tl k ds se i 2 0 wi u p eu ie f rf i r t c mpl wih te
c u g a s z imis d n 01 t t rj d c o al e o o y t h
r
ho
u
c n iin l ii o d r
o dto a fl r e .On J y 1 2 6 W ic e fld amoin u d rRu e6 ()4 s edn
ng
ul 4, 01 , th r ie
to n e l 0b ( ) e l g

t o e tl hsame sauo yb r lr c n ci na v i a djzidcin lyd fci eb c u e
o v rum i r d tt tr u g ay o vito s o d n l s ito al e e tv e a s
r
t ti l c t çfa le l snzk o t ç g tme' ee e of t i cm e ' wihout
he ra our lr udtl nty t c ut he ni hti
lm nt
he ndi t nt' t

a hoiy.Addii ly,W iche fldaj2254peii wihfvegr mds
ut rt
tonal t r ie
tton t i ot :

( )Th Rih r o ' ttme t we ei o sse t
1 e c ads ns sae ns r nc n itn .
( )Th tilc u to l sr c o tGn ter g ti ' a d d d n tr -rag W ic ro te
2 e ra o r ny tu k u l h l h t ' n i o e ari n the n h
i
i me
n e di cme .
m nde ndi t nt

( The o fc rha hi he iht on bec us i wa r ni atd no be us i wasdak
3)
fie d s adlg s
a e t s ai ng l t ca e t
r
out i .
sde

( )The d u l j o r y ca e wa viltd b t e j d e wh n t j dg alwe a
4
o b e e pad lus s oae y h u g
e he u e lo d n
mne
ndment t t he r i e hi e f whe t pr e i di no wa t as f an
ha
a s d ms l
n he os cuton d t nt o k or
a e
m ndm e .
nt

( )M r.Rihads saedi t Vitm I tRe tt ts ha nophysc lijzisbut
5 s c r on tt n he ci mpac por ha he d
ia nlre
a ti lt s ii d t ts r ce ved bnls s f o W ic rw hi h w a a f aud e s a e e .
t r a e tf e ha he e i
ie r m
t he
c
s r ul nt t t m nt
I
I.

D i cussi
s
on

a Rue6 M o in
. l 0*) to
No W ic e r le o Rue 6 ()o t eFe e a Ru e o Cii P o e u e a a t o i
w, th r eis n l 0b f h d r l ls f vl r c d r s u h rt
y
f ran o de f om t sco 't r ve s hi c c i i t Pityl ni Count Ci c tCo ut
o
r r r hi ul o e r e s onvi tons n he ts va a
t
y r ui t '
.

Lo rfd r lc u t,l t i o e d n tha ej rs ito t c n u ta elt rve
we e e a o rs i h s n , o o v u idcin o o d c pp lae e iw
ke

o a y saec u ts u me t Pl lrv. o r ,1 F.d 7 8 7 ( t Ci.1 9 ) J rs ito
f n tt o r' j dg n . ye M o e 29 3 2 , 31 4h r 9 7 . u idcin
f r a p lae rviw o sae c u tj d me t le e cusv l wih s p ro sae c u t a d
o p elt e e f tt o r u g ns is x l iey t u e ir tt o rs n ,
uli tl wih t Unie St esSupr me Cour. I ;28 U. C.j 1
tmaey, t he td at
e
t d.
S.
257;b s e Pl e ,1
ut e ylr 29

F.d a 7 2 (e o nii g lwe fd r lc u t'j rs ito t r ve fna j g n so sae
3 t 3 rc g zn o r e e a o rs u idcin o e iw i l ud me t f tt
c t i f rlha ascor )
ours n edea be
pus.

2

W ic e as ha n g o n f rdr c r l ffo asaec u tu g n u d rRu e6 ( )
th r lo s o r u d o ie t ei r m tt o rj d me t n e l 0 b .
e
TheFede a RulsofCi lPr e e by t i own t r ,o y çgo l t pr edur i a1cvi
rl e
vi oc dur , he r
e ms nl l ve' he oc e n l i l
n
a tonsa pr e ngsi t Unie St t diti tc t .... Fe R.Ci P.1 Ther f e
ci
nd oce di n he t d aes src ours
' d.
'
v. .
e or ,
t s nzes cn
he e l
nnotpr de a ve ce by whih a ltga ma s e r le fom a sa e c t
ovi
hi l
c
ii nt y e k ei f r
ny t t our

r i whas ve ,ci na orci l1 W ic rma onl us Rul 60( t atc E omedee ti
ulng toe r rmi l vi. the y y e e b) o ta k ç
s
fc n

te itg i o t f d r lh e spr c e n s' I .a 5 2 (mp a i a d d . Sic W ic e
h ne rt f he e e a ab a o e dig . d t 3 e h ss d e ) n e th r
y
'
atc hi t ryi saec tci na c cinsa nott 201 dimis lofhi j225
ta ks s mdel ng tt our rmi l onvito nd
he 0 s sa
s
4
pe ii hi c am f isunde t Fe a RulsofCi lPr dur
tton, s l i al
r he der l e
vi oce e.
Addii ly,W ic r al ge t tt c r ui c ur e r i de di whehe t srke
tona l
t he le s ha he ic t o t red n ci ng
t r o ti
l ng ge i a s a e c i i ls a ut . H i cl i i ba e e i e y upon a s a e c ' i e r tng a
a ua n t t rm na t t e
s a m s s d ntr l
t t oul nt p e i
t
s a e l ,w hi h i out i t r a m off de a ha as r vi w e e i cic s M c s s w i
t t aw
c s s de he e l
e r l be e e xc pt n r um t e ho ng

ç c mpeemic ni g o j sie' eW rc t Anc l n ,1 1F.d 1 ,1 8( t Ci.1 9 )
ç o lt s a a e f u tc .
a
'Se ih v. eo e 5 3 51 5 4h r 9 8 .
W ic r f l t de ons r t t t t s a e c ts a tons r s t d i a c pl t m i c ni of
t he ais o m t a e ha he t t our ' c i
e ule n om e e s a age

j sie h fist p o e hsa ta ino e c ;t eeo e hs cam i n tc g ia l i fd rl
u tc ; e al o r v i cu l n c n e h rf r , i li s o o nz be n e ea
coul .2
'
t

lA Rul 6 ()moini a e ta riayrme yta i C o asb ttt fratmey a dpo e a p a,
e 0b to s n xrodn r e d h t s l t u siue o i l n rp r p e l'
n
'
a dtu i a tn p r pit me h ns frdrcl c l n ig tev l i ofU saec n cin . Do l v.
n h s s n t a p o rae c a im o ie t hal gn h ai t
i
y e
dy
tt o vito s' wel
'
SaeF l Fie& Ca . t.Is Co.9 3F.d4 , (t Ci.1 9 ) Ole v An eo e 2 5WL 6 7 6 7 a
tt a' r
m
s Auo n . , 9 2 6 48 4h r 9 3 ; sn . c ln , 01
830,t
# - ( . VaNo 9 2 l )(1 l 6 () ma n t u e g id pe d nl . .oc aln o o etr afd rl
12 W D. . v. , 0 5 çRue 0bj y o be sdl n e n e t . t h le ge r v run e ea
(
y
o saeci n lc n ito ' . F rh r tea pl ain o Rul 6 ( )i srcl lmi do fd rlh be srve
r tt rmia o vcin.) u te, h p i to f e 0 b s tit i t n e ea a a e iw
'
c
y
e
be a s o tep tniloS ic mv n l AEDPA' rq ie nsta an w cam b ds se u ls irle o a
c u e f h oe ta t s ru e tj
c
S e urme t h t e li e imisd ne st eis n
ne rl o c n tuin la o ne yds o ee fcs' Go z lzv. ob 5 U, 5 4, 313 ( 0 )
w ue f o si to a 1w r wl ic v rd at. n ae Crs v. 45 S. 2 5 -2 20 5.
t
'
2 c lrbl cam ofama in cnc c nsrea at ae y'oscleteaj diaino a oh m ie
A ooa e li
c ln o e e a ev s t twa 't et h du c to f n te s
g
r
u rviwa eo d futdcam. S hu v Deo 51 U. 2 8 31 ( 9 5. ' epeiin rmu ts o ta ii
n e e bl r ea l li c lp . l, 3 S. 9 , 5 1 9 ) Th t o e s h w h t t s
e
t
mo el l ta no ta n r ao a ej rrwo l h v c n itdhi i telg to Eo )n w e ie c . I. t
r i y h n t h t o e s n bl u o ud a e o vce m n h ih f s me e vd n e' d a
ke
'
327. W ic rdoe nota s r acolr bl s
t he
s
set
o a e howi ofa t i
ng
cual nnoce e unde t Sc up sa r s a t ope t t
nc
r he hl tnda d o s o n ha
gae y t consdeaton ofhi de a td cams W ic doe notcie Sc up orM coui n v.Per ns 1 S.Ct
twa o
i ri
s f ule li . ther s
t hl
cci
ki , 33
.

l 2 (01 ) h d e no pe e ta yn w c mp lige ie c u a albl a til ro a pe la dh o l ma e
9 4 2 3 , e o s t rsn n e o eln vd n e n v i e t ra o n p a, n e ny k s
a
c n l o ysae nfrg r ig hsin c n e S ePe'' j2 4 P t 1 ,1 ( No 5 (ûj s rcnl fu d
o cusr ttme t e adn i n o e c . e trs 25 e. 5 7 ECF . ) < u t e e t o n
1
y

outaboutt s ero s i my c s and ho f ly,lwilbe alowed t m ove f wa d w ih my a in i t scou
he e r r n
ae
pe ul
l
l
o
or r t
cto n hi
rt
bec us lvebe n tyi f t ls 1 ye st pr my i enc t any cou tt twoul lsen t m e' Alo,
a e '
e r ng or he a t 0 ar o ove
nnoc e o
r ha
d it o .' s
t e ealow m et tl a W rtofH a asCor i t f de alco ts 1c n pr m y im oc et t c ta
ç as l
pl
o 5e
i
be
pus n he e r ur o a ove
r enc o he our nd

g h met myc i rnl) seas , r e v. eo ,2 8F.d 1 2 1 3n.0(t Ci. 0 0 (mdngta a
oo o
hl e ' ; e lo Bu k t Anc lne 0 3 7 , 8 1 4h r 2 0 ) f i h t s
d '
3

b J2 5 Peio
. 2 4 tt n
i
Re r es ofW ic rsRul 60( moton,hi j225 peii i tmebar Unde j
gadl s
the ' e b) i s
4 tton s i - red.
r

2 4 ( )1 , p tto e mu tfl h sfd r lh be sp tto wihn o e y a fo t elts o
2 4 d ( ) a ei n r s ie i e ea a a eiin t i n e r ' m h ae t f
i
r
wh n: 1 hi c n cinb c meûn lb t c n l in o die trv e o tee piain o t e
e ( ) s o vito e a
a y he o cuso f rc e iw r h x rto f h
tmef rs e ig s c rviw, 2 a yilga saece td i e i n t fl gwa rmo e , 3
i o e kn u h e e ( ) n le l tt rae mp dme t o ii
n s e v d ()
t Unie Stt s Supr m e Coul r og ze a ne r toa tve y a i d c tm tona rght or
he t d a e
e
' ec ni d
t
w, er c i l pple onsi i l i ,

( t fcua pr di t oft cli c d ha be n dic vee tlough d dii nc . 28
4) he a t l e cae he am oul ve e s o rd lr
ue lge e
U. C.j2244( ( )
S.
d)1.
A pe ii
ttoner c G ol' t f de a ha a s a ut of lm ia i i t o w a : s am o y
an ç l' he e r l be s t t e
t
i t ton n w
ys t t r
t lng and e t bl t lng. St ut y t lng occ s w he a pettone fl s a s a e ha a
oli
quia e oli
at or oli
ur
n
ii r ie
t t be s

pe ii wihi t f de a sa t eoflm iai n pe i The f der lha assa u e oflmia i i
tton t n he e r l t tl
t
i tto rod.
e a be t t t
i t ton s

t e t l d frte d rto o te saeha e sp o e dng
h n ol o h u ain f h tt b a r c e i .28U. C.j2 4 ( )2 . Eq tbl
e
S.
2 4 d ( ) ui e
a
t ligo c r o l i apeiine s o ( ( )t theh sbe np ru n h srg t dlg nl a d
oln c u s ny f t o r h ws : 1 ha
t
C
a e u s i g i ih s i e ty, n
i
( t t s me e ror nay crumsa sood i hi wa a pr ve e tmey flng.'
2) ha o
xta di r ic tnce t n s y' nd e ntd i l ii '

Holn v Flrd ,5 0U. 6 , 4 ( 1 )(uoi Pa ev Di g il , 4 , S. 0 , 8
l d . o ia 6 S. 31 6 9 20 0 q tng c . Gu lemo 5 4 U. 4 8 41
a
(
2005).
)
W ic r s die a ala sa e ha aspr ee ngs co l
the ' r ct ppe nd tt be
oc di
ncuded s ve alyea s ag He
e r
r o.

h sn ts ts dt er q ie n so a y o t e e to lcrl tnc su d rj2 4 * , i
a o aise h e urme t f n f he xc pina icl a e n e 2 4( he s
ms
n te tte t tli g3a d h ha no d mo sr td amic rig o j tc ta wo l e u e
o nild o o ln , n e s t e n tae
s ara e f usie h t ud xc s
hi untmei s The eo e hi j2254peii i tmebar
s i lnes. r fr , s
tton s i - red.
111
.

p tto e b asb r e t riec u e a d p eu ie o a ta in e c ,ac utn e n tc n ie ete i n t
eiin r e r u d n o as a s n rj dc r cu l n ocn e o r e d o o sd r ih r f o
asre b p tin r.
setd y eio e)
t
3tIg o a c o t 1w i n tab ssfre utbetlig. Uni dSae v So a 3 4F.d5 7, 1 (t
t jn rn e fhe a s o ai o q ia l ol ' t tts . s, 6 3 0 5 2 4h
E
n ' e
Ci. 0 4 .
r2 0 )
4

F rt ef rg ig ra o ,1g a tRe p n e tsmo int d s s , n ds s t 6 ()
o h o e on e s ns rn s o d n ' to o imis a d imis he 0b
motona t j2254peii f awrtofha a c pus Ba e upo myfndi t tW ic r
i nd he
tton or i
be s or . s d n
ng ha the
ha no m a t r quiie s t n i ls
s t de he e st ubsa ta howi ofade a ofa c tt i lrghta r quie by
ng
nil
onsiutona i s e r d

2 U. C. 2 3 c, c ri c t o a pe lblt i d nid.
8 S. 5 25 4) a e ts ae f p aa i y s e e
t
i

ENTER: i ï
Ths

d yo Ma , 01 .
a f y2 7
/
%

%

e orUnied St t sDiti J e
n
t
a e srd udg

5