Entsminger v. Griffith

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 8/16/2016. (tvt)

CV RK' OFFI u.S. sm colr
S
GE
Dl
l
A DANVI E.
T
LL VA
FI
LED

ALs 15 2 1
' 26
I TI E UNI
N I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
RO ANOK E DI SI
W ON
R ON AI, D.
D ENTSM I GER,. .
N
J ,
R
Pettoner,
ii
V.

JUDGE H I W GRI TH,
LM
FFI
R e pondent
s
.

JUL
BY:

D LEM G RK

.

RP

C

K

Ci lAc i N o.7: 6- v- 35
vi t on
1 c 00 2

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI

By:

Hon.Jac o L.K ie
ks n
sr
Se or U nie St e Di t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

Rona dD . s i r J . aVigi ai t pr e di pr m , ie apeii n f ra wrt
l Entm nge , r, r ni nma e oc e ng o fld
tto o
i

ofha a copuspurua t Z8' S. j2 .Peii rco ansa tt Reponde ,
be s r
s nt o U. C. 241 ttone mpli bou he s
nta

saec u tu e s ne i h m t sx- nhs i rs n n f rf ingt p yc l s p o t
tt o r j dg , e tnchg i o i mo t 'mp io me t o al o a hi u p r.
i
d
W h t rp o e dngva28U. C.j2 41o j2 3 , h be speiin ri u t x a s a alb e
ehe r c e i i
S.
2 r 2 4 a a a t o e n s e h u t v ia l
t
sa ec t e edisbe o es e ngf r lha asr if Se e. ,Br n v. h J ca
t t our r m e f r e ki ede a be ele . e. c. ade 30t udi il

Cic tCo r, 0U. 48 , 9 - ( 9 3 ; o r v. Yo n , 5F.d4 7 4 2 4 ( dCi.
rui u t41 S. 4 4 0 91 1 7 ) M o e De u g 51 2 3 , 4 - 3 3 r
1 7 ) Peiine h sn v rp s dha e sr l f asaec u t.Co e ue t Pei o e h s
9 5 . t o r a e e urue b a ei vi tt o rs ns q nl tt n r a
t
e
y, i
sa ecou'r m e esa ia et hi ,no e r or na y cicl sa ese s i t sc e a l
tt t t e di va lbl o m
xta di r r tm t nc xit n hi as , nd

ds s t ep tto wi o t rj d c p ru n t Ruls1b a d4o t Ru e Go enng
imis h eiin t u p eu ie u s a t o e ( ) n f he ls v r i
h
Se to 2 5 Ca e .S eLe nadv Ha n 8 4F.d8 8 8 3( t Ci.1 8 )( dn
cin 2 4 s s e o r . mmo d, 0 2 3 , 4 4h r 9 6 sn ig
ha a peii ne sc le i cvi co i me f notpayi c l s
be s tto r ha lngng i l nfne nt or
ng hid uppo tmus srte us
r
t s xha t

saec u t e de b f r fln fd r l a a p tto ) Ba e u n myfndn t a Peiin r
tt o r r me is e o e iig e e a h be s eiin . s d po
i ig h t tto e

h sn t d terq iiesà tnilho n o ad na o ac nttto a rg ta zq ie b
a o ma e h e ust u sa ta s wig f e il f o si in lih s e urd y
u
28U. C. 2 5 ()a S a kv. c n e, 2 U. 47 , 4 ( 0 ) ac ri aeo
S. j 2 3 c nd lc M Da il 5 9 S. 3 48 20 0 , e t t f
fc
a
ppea abiiy i de e
l lt s ni d.

k
t 6
s r u: hs 1' da ofaugus 201
xr T ipf y
s
z
.

.
.

r

*
'

S ni r Unie St t s D i ti tJ ge
o
t d a e s rc ud