Meyers v. Miles

Filing 52

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/29/2017. (tvt)

Download PDF
rl RKSOF C U,. STCOU -F ' FIE S DI . W A R fi-zJ ,A T OAN 7 V JKE :! t I TH E UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O A N O K E D I SI N W O ANTH ONY M EYERS, J 2g 2 1 UN 27 JUL C. U BY: CASE NO.7: 6CV00360 1 Pl ntff ai i , V. M EM OM NDUM OPI ON M D R .M I LES, By: G l n E.C onr e ad Chi fUni e St e D i t i tJudge e t d at s s r c De e f ndant . Ant hony M e r ,aVig ni i ae pr ee ng pr K ,fld t scvi rght a ton unde ye s r i a nm t oc di o ie hi i l i s c i r 4 U. C.j1 8 a an tDr M ie ,aph sca wh te td hm a a lc l al Th matri 2 S. 9 3 g is . ls y iin o r ae i t o a j i. e te s c re ty b f r t e c u to Dr M ie 'mo in f rs mmayj d me ta d M e es r s o s s u rn l eo e h o r n . ls to o u r u g n n y r' e p n e t r t Fi ng t t M e r 'n e d co pl ntand ot r s he e o. ndi ha ye s m nde m ai he ubmi so pr e no ge ne s i ns es nt nui is ofmaeilfc i ds e s ng a vibl cam unde j 1 t co twilgrnt sues tra a t n iput howi a e li r 983, he ur l a sl r u me t o Dr M ie . l mmayj dg n f r . ls Backaround M e r wa frtic r e ae a t rg o l alfcl y i Du fed Vigni,o M ac yes s is n a c rtd t he e ina ji a it n fil, r i a n rh i 7,201 t e mont be or Dr M iesbe n wo ki t r The c s ofteam e t r a tr 6, hr e hs f e . l ga r ng he e. our e r t nt he e fe p o i e t M e esa t ej i,a r fe td i Dr M ie 'afd vtCW f , ECF No 3 - )a d r v d d o y r t h al s elce n . ls fi a i f' ' . 51 n a tc e me ia r c r s(1 e .' No. 5 2 , su d s u e t h d dc l e o d < d, ECF 3 - ) i n ip td. a M ' M e s r quese a was g a ed a mediale m i ton o Aprl28 201 whe he yer e t d nd r nt c xa na i n i , 6, n rpo td difc t wih urnai a ea ai andr se apr tt e nain. A nure e re f uly t i ton nd j culton eque td osae xnmi to s . pr ttone ,Kr t lLa ge, dbr e a r c ale m o M e r a not a mid e a ge e of acii r ysa r pe m d e t xn n ye s nd ed l nlr m nt hi pr tt She or r l b wo k,di s osa e. de ed a r agnos hi wih pr t tts a m i r r t nton,a ed m t osa ii nd na y e e i nd pr c i d a a i o i f t n days She not d M e r ' s a e e t t he w a c ac i a es r be n ntbi t c or e . e ye s t t m nt ha s ont tng ' % lwye be us G one i i e e t d i me i up t t i r quie e s a m e c l sa f' a r ca e l no s ntr se n etng o her e r m nt s di a tf ' ( e . t1 . M d a 3) M e e sn x viie t ej i' me ia t to Ma 1 ,20 6 wh n he c mpli d o y r e t std h als dc l mi n y 6 1 , e o ane f trna y hest nc Dr M o e c li r ia y. . r no onduc e a physc l e m t t r ve e no a td i a xn ha e ald bnonnalte , iis alhough a M e r 'r ques,t docorde e r d c t t ye s e t he t f r e onduc i a ge t le m i ton. Dr M or no tng nia xa na i . e di gnos d M e r wih cuoni pr tttsa pr s rbe ar fl oft an i o i Bacrm f r30 a e ye s t l c osa ii nd e c i d e l he tbi tc ti o days Healopr s rbed Flm a t i o urna i s . s e ci o x o mpr ve i ton ympt s om . Dr M or no s w M e r a n on J 6,201 whe he not si hti ove e i . e a ye s gai une 6, n ed lg mpr m nt n urna y s pt s buta i r as i c tpa i a dirhe Ag n,aphysc le m r veaed i r ym om , n nc e e n onsi ton nd a r a. ai i a xn e l no a bnonnaltes butM e r de e r unde g ng a ge t e m . Dr M or no r fled t pro ii , ye s f red r oi nial xa . e e l he i r pr c i nsf 30m or da .Ac r ng t M e r , . or no di gnos d li wih apr t t es dpto or e ys co di o ye s Dr M e a e lm t osae i e to a ds i i ame tc ul tk fo 6mo t st ay a . ( . mpl2 ECFNo 2 . nfcin n ad te t n o d a e ' m r n h o e r' Am Co . , ' . 0) l ea J y,afe t Ba ti pr s rpton r n o ,M e r wr t a me c lgre nc n dy ul tr he c rm e c i i a ut ye s o e di a iva e, ç ' sa i : AM SUPPOSED TO TAKE BACTRUM FOR AT LEAST 4 M ONTH S. THE ttng 1 FLOW M AX HI LPS W I URI EJ TH NATI UNTI M Y P ON L ROSTATE I BACK TO NORM AL. S 1 jHASBEEN I T( NFECTED AND M ES EI UP FOR A LONG TI E SO ( REATMENT SE D M Tj M AY TAKE LONGER....A P osae itecin i a g rj aig a s mei sp if l' r tt nl jto s g g av tn nd o tme an u . ' ( p.a 2,ECFNo. ) Res , t 48. Dr M ie 'i ta c a twih M e r oc ure on J y 11 201 The doc o not d t t . l s niil ont c t ye s c r d ul , 6. t r e ha M e r w a a glm e t tve a i i t d t he ha a pr t t i e ton a waspl l i t f l a ye s s r l n a i nd ns s e hat d os a e nf c i nd a m ng o ie lws t The docors no esa s r po tM e r 'sa e e st the f l he wa pa ayze be ow a ui. t ' t lo e r ye s tt m nt ha et s rl d l t wait he c d nottrna eco r cl hedi notwa apr tt exa , a d hene de anot r he s, e d he oul li t r e ty, d nt osa e m 1 n 1 M e r de est the r us d t unde go a pr tt e na i o J y 11 201 s e CountrAf.2, ye s ni ha ef e o r osae xami ton n ul , 6, e e f ECF No. a c 42, nd ompli i va i s misonst tDr M ie neve peror d apr t ee na i o hi ans n rous ub s i ha . ls r f me osat xami ton n m. dos ofantbi i s Te tr uls s wed t tM e r 'urne wa ne tve f r i eci a t t e i otc . s es t ho ha ye s i s ga i o nf ton nd ha hi PSA wa nonna . Dr M ies ex ai d t M e r t t a to l a i otc we e no s s l . l pl ne o ye s ha ddiina ntbi is r t i c e b t s r uls az coul a ly be ha mfz.2 I ta , t docor r fle t ndiatd y he e es t ld d cma l r t l ns e d he t e ild he pr c i i n f rFl m r and o de e aurne c t e3 es rpto o o r rd i ulur . Dr M ie s w M e r a n o J y 1 whe t M e r c . ls a ye s gai n ul 8, n he ye s' ompli s we e r pore a ant r e td s f l : olows ( r M ilj Ic mz t h n le tis s ro l ,hes mpo a ere t r igt D). les a olj a d lq h lj eiusy t y tms r rq' nn he u mlq iain wa h l n i y u d n lql o h w t d a n s meIn e t s e e dc to s epig f o o ot t w o o ig o e n ed o e s e il t bllial f esl e 1g ta b llo n i my b t l e mlqbu g i p cai , a sc ly e l i s k o ag o n j ut i k y tt s j t rnngi i eo tb r sc nlq u iaeh rsi ce s i i etihslwe b c ull i nsd u u n a 't rn t u t n ra e nsd h g o r a k fesb us d isd l Ic b t e tsilsa dr c if ce p o ttso l e l r ie n ie . th ewe n e tce n e mm, n e td r sae ny j g lqwo s a dc ntkemo t t c r . et re n a a nhs o u e ( e .a 1 . Thed co e mi e M e esa d fu noa n r lte .Hi u i c lu ewa M d t 0) o tr xn n d y r n o nd b o mai s s rne utr s i a i negai f i e ton. The docor r as tr M e r t t he di no ha a pr t t gan tve or nf c i t e sled ye s ha d t ve osa e i e ton a t ttm e. nf c i t ha i Dr M iesne s w M e r on Augus 1 201 . l xt a ye s t 7, 6.He no e t tM e r wa c t d ha ye s s ompli ng a ni of ce fui 9om hi r cum a a ic be we n hi r t m a t tc e ,as we las l ge lar l d s et nd n t h t e s ec u nd esi l s l ar ea uain . M e esi sse ta h h d l o l d o me ia is e p s il c n e ' a d j c lto s y r n itd h t e a G me dn f d c l su , o sby a c r' n s d ma e ada n i.( f a !9. Ba e o h ss mp o , . ie da n e M e e swih e nd d ig oss Af. t ) s d n i y t ms Dr M ls ig os d y r t po sb ec l i a d o iia l bo ls n r me(ç ' a d p e ci e Be t lt te tt I . sil oi s n /r n tbe we y d o GBS' n r srb d n y o r a he BS t I ) Thedoc o as or r af l up e m i t we ks t r lo de ed olow xa n wo e . 2 Acc di t M e r, Dr. iess i U ai wilnotpay f te t nt you c or ng o yes M l ad, l l or r ame , annottkea i otcsf t t a ntbi i or ha ln , o c n o sean ljoo it. ( Co . . o g y u a n t e eurlgss' Am. mpl3) ' 3 M e r fld a me ca greva aqe hi a nt di l i nce r s ppoi menton J y ll c ul , ompli ngt tt a i otc Dr ani ha he ntbi is . ye s ie M or pr ci s d ha be c i d f f t sx mont . A nure r ponde H s n t docor eno es rbed houl ve en ontnue or our o i hs s es d: You ee he t td y(uy l , 01 1 Hei od rngau i c tr whihy ug v asmpl frti AM i wil h w iyo ha e o a J l 1 2 6 . s rei rne ul e c o a e a e o hs u t ls o f u v b cei i yo ruie . . eBa ti h sb e dic n iu db cu ey u c mpee i (n lted co d e n t a tra n u rn . . Th crm a e n s o tn e e a s o o ltd t a d h o tr o s o wiht ro d ra tboisu ls y u uiec luec me b c po iv . ( s , t3 ECFNo 4 . s o e r e n iit nes o r rn utr o s a k st er Rep.a , c i ' . 8) 3 Att f l up a nt nton Se e r8,Dr M ie not M eye s r por t tt he olow ppoi me pt mbe . l s ed r ' e t ha he cla fui i hi sool ha dec e ed.Thedoct i r as t pr s rpton f Be ylal alo e r l d n s t s d r as or nc e ed he e c i i or nt ld s c tnue t Fl a on i d he om x. Dr M ie e . ls xami d M e r a i on Oc o r 1 201 a t M e r c ne ye s gan t be 0, 6, fer ye s ompl i of aned s li i hi pr t t a ditc t wih urna i Hi physc e we lng n s osa e nd fi uly t i ton. s ial xam wa no m a ,howe r s r l ve . D r M ies pr c d a co s oft a i otc Bac r m i a a t m ptt ale a e s e or al of . l es dbe ur e he ntbi i ti n n te o l vi t om 1 M eye s s pt s a co i r ' ym om nd ntnued t Fl u . he om Me r c ye s nme t s e Dr M ie agan on Oc obe 25. M e r t n i itd t tt t ee o e . ls i t r ye s he nsse ha he hr we k c s ofa i otc t doc orhad or r wa E ntes ' be a e l osa e i e tons e our e ntbi is he t de ed s G l s' c us t tt nf c i poi pr tk mo tst te t' IZ a ! 1 ) Dr M ie o d rd 1b wo k a d a f lo u e a i t a e nh o ra. J t 2. . ls r ee a r n olw p x m n wo ' . we ks Two dayslt r on Oc obe 27,M e r waspl e o s cde wa c l i Nove be 2, e . ae, t r ye s ac d n ui i t h mtl m r 201 6. A ntr e pr cii ne exa i d M e r o Nove be 1 201 She not d hi r pors of ls a tto r m ne ye s n m r 6, 6. e se t ongoi pr e w ih trna i a hi c ng obl ms t li ton nd s ompl i sofpan i hi t tc e a cea fui fom ant i n s esil s nd l r l d r t r ct . A r t exn r ve e a enlr d pr tt ,a t di gnoss wa pr t tts he e um ecal m e ald n a ge osa e nd he a i s osa ii. M e r r c i d apr c i i n f t o a i otc --onet t ke f rt eem ont a onet t ke ye s e e ve es rpto or w ntbi i s o a o br hs nd o a f f l we ks or otr e . M e r fl d hi n e ye s ie s m nded compl nt agans Dr M ie i e ry Novembe 201 4 ai i t . ls n al r 6. Li r ly co t i hi al ga i a s iso ,he cli s t t Dr M e r vi a e hi be a l nsnzng s le tons nd ubm s i ns am ha . ye s olt d s c tt ona rght by: ( ) ds ntnui t a i oi ( fii t snd M e r t a onsimi l i s 1 ico i ng he ntbitc; 2) alng o e ye s o 4 M e r i tals bm isonale d asf l : R J y 11Dr ( ls sae t met'eJii n tg ig yes' nii u s i lge olows On ul . Mi ) ttd o e 'h als o on l t pa f yo keament' Iwa tki medi ton a he dic i d my mediai Physc har Fal e t o y or ur t . s a ng cai nd s ontnue c ton. ial m, iur o po ieme ia te t n ' ( mpl4 ECFNo 1) Thec u'noiidMe esta te ealg t nsddn tsae rvd dc lrame t' Co . , .. o l tfe y r h t h s l ai i o tt t e o s fiin fcsfra ato a ecam u d rj 1 8 a an tted co a d ga tdhi a o potnt t tl a utce t at o n cin bl li n e 9 3 g is h o tr n rne m n p ru i o ie n y amende c d ompli ,whih he di Si e t n,M e r ha as con i ant c d. nc he ye s s lo tnued t s tlte sand exhi t t t o ubmi etr bis hat he co thasc i r d i s ur onsde e n uppor oft cl msr s i t a t he ai aied n he mende c d ompli . ant 4 l eu r l gs' o oh r s e ils;a d () rf sng t da n s o te tM e es t o lm. i llo o it' r te p cait n 3 e u i o ig o e r r a y r ' ç be ' n pr ' ( Co l 34, No. . Me e sa mista Dr Mie h sc n iu dt eFlma t t a Am. mp . - ECF 20) y r d t h t . ls a o tn e h o x ha h s heped wih hi urna i di c tes He c l t s i ton o uli . ompl nst tt doc o û d notdignos orc c ai ha he t r G di a e he k (ilp osae' n rp ae l me to dt a M e e swa o y28y a sod ( eECF No 31) hs r tt 'a d e e t dy nine h t y r s nl e r l. Se . . He pr e s medialr c ds r l c i t tDr M ie e mi d hi i J n 201 f rt s me es nt c e or efe tng ha . ls xn ne m n a 7 o he n pr e sa sildi notpe f m apr t e e m . M e r co e t tbe a e ofDr M ies oblm nd tl d ror osat xn ye s nt nds ha c us . l ' te t n d cso , i û r b e ' re e a dhel s 3 pomd .( Co l 3. Hes e rame t e iins hs G o lm'wo s n d n p o t 5 t s Am. mp . ) e ks mo eayd ma e a dij n tv r le o d rngt a heb d a n s da dte td n tr n g s n nu cie eif r ei h t e ig o e n r ae . D i si scus on A c r s o l g a ts mmayj d me tçfte mo a ts wsta t eei no g n i ou t h ud r n u r u g n G h v n ho h t h r s e une i d s u ea t a ymaeilfc a t mo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatro lm ' Fe . ip t s o n tra a t nd he v n s n i d o u g n s l te f a ' d R. v. 5 () G t maeil y . .gq l d s u e o e fcst tmih a fc t o to Ci P. 6a . 1 o trai . o ny ip ts v r a t ha g t fe t he u c me As t o t e s i t e te g venn 1w wilp o el prcu e t e ty o s mmay j g n ' f h ut md r h o r ig a l r p ry e l d he nr f u r ud me t' An es n v. b rv Lo y I . 4 7 U. 2 2, 48 ( 9 6 . A ds t a o tamae lfc i d ro Li e t bb e nc, 7 S. 4 2 1 8 ) ipue b u tda a t s g n n çft ee i e c i s h ta ar a o bej r c udr tr av r itf rten n vn e uie t h v d n e s uc h t e s na l u y o l et n ed c o h o mo ig i l pa t ' I Fi l i r vi wi t e de e,t c tmus dr w a lr a ona e i e e e i ry.' d. naly, n e e ng he vi nc he our t a l e s bl nf r nc s n f vor of t nonmovi pa t a m a not m a c edi lt de e mi to or we gh t a he ng ry nd y ke r biiy t r nai ns i he e d n e' W il msv. tpls l c, 7 F.d6 2 6 7 (t Ci. 0 4 . vie c . li ' n Sa e e n -3 2 3 6 , 6 4 h r 2 0 ) Se ton 1 pe misa a c i 983 r t n ggde d pa t t fl a cvi a ton agans ape s f a tons ve ry o ie i l c i i t r on or c i t ke unde c orofs a e l w t tvi a e hi c ns iu i ldght . Se Coo rv.She han,735 a n r ol t t a ha ol t d s o tt tona s e pe e F. 1 1 (t Ci.201 . The Ei h Ame nt whih a i t t sae unde t 3d 53, 58 4h r 3) ght ndme , c pples o he tts r he Due Pr es Clus oft Foure nt Am e oc s a e he te h ndme ,gu r nt esfe m fom c ue a unus nt a a e r edo r r l nd ual pl s e .To pr i o a cai of co tt tonaly i qua e medialc r ,pli if mus nihm nt eval n l m nsiu i l nade t c a e antf t e tbls a s or omisons ha mf e sa ih ct si r ul nough t c tt e de i r t i f e e e t s rous o onsiut lbe a e ndif r nc o e i me c l e ds Esel v Gn l, 2 U. 9 1 6( 9 6 . dia n e . tl . mb e 4 9 S. 7, 0 1 7 ) e F rt t e p io e mu ts o ta t e d p i ai n s fee o t e ij r ifitd wa , is, h rs n r s h w h t h e rv to u fr d r h n u y n lce s G b e tv l ,Gu t e ty sro s' Fa me v Brl n 51 U. 8 5 8 4 ( 9 4 (iains l j ciey s fkin l ei u .' r r . ema , 1 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ) ctto o ' omitd) A s rousme c lnee ûsonet thasbe n dignos d by aphysca a ma tng te . ei dia d t i ha e a e iin s ndai team e or o t ti s obvi t te a 1 pe s wo d e iy r cognie t ne es iy r t nt ne ha s o ous ha ven ay r on ul asl e z he c st f ra d co ' atn in' 1 o v.S rve 5 F.d 2 5 2 4 h Ci.2 0 )(i to o te ) o o trs te to - k ' h e , 35 3 2 , 41(t r 0 8 ct in mitd . a Fo pur e oft sopi o t c twilpr um et tM e r 's r pos s hi ni n, he our l es ha ye s ympt spr s nt a s ro om e e ed e i us medialne a t tm eofhi i e a tonswih Dr M iesbe wee J y a Nove be 201 t c ed t he i s ntr c i t . l t n ul nd m r 6, he pe i a is i t slw s t rod t s ue n hi a ui. Toprvai onhi j 1 3 cam agans Dr M ie ,howe r Meyesmus as s w t t e l s 98 li i t . ls ve, r t lo ho ha t doc ora t d wih delber t i fer nc t hi s dous media ne d. Spe fcal hem us he t c e t i ae ndif e e o s e cl e ci ly, t sa e f c s i c tng t tDr M ie kne ofa dir ga de a e e sve rs t hi he lh or t t a t ndi a i ha . l s w nd s e r d n xc s i ik o s at s f t Se Fn me ,511 U. a 8 a ey. e r r S. t 37. The de e ntmus G t be a r off c s fom whih f nda tç h bo wa e a t r c t i e e ecoul be dr wn t ta s t talrs ofs roushn e s s a hemus a s dr w he nf r nc d a ha ubsan i ik e i nn xit, nd t lo a t ile e e. 1 The de e nti notla e i he ûc w t unde l ng f t butbei ve he zf r nc ' d. ' f nda s ibl f Gne he l ryi ac s le d (letu s t l)t a t rs t whih tef csg v rs wa is b tn ilo no e itn , o ab i n omdy h t he ik o c h a t a e ie s n u sa ta r n x se t' r ' i he r po d r as bl t t trs I a 844. t'o esa ih t ta he lh c r pr de ' f es nde e ona y o ha ik. d. t ç- tbls ha l a t a e ovi r s a tons c tt e de i r t i fe e e t a s ro m e ca ne t te t nt mus be s ci onsim lbe ae ndif r nc o e i us di l ed, he r a me t o gr sy i os l ncompe e ,i quat,ore s i ast s k t c ce e ort be i ol a e t t nt nade e xce sve o hoc he ons inc o nt er bl o fmd me tlf in s . M ite v Be r ,8 6F.d 8 ,8 (t Ci.1 9 )(ver ld o o h r t a n a ar e s' l r . o n 9 2 48 51 4h r 9 0 o rue n t e ' i g o byFame) r unds r r. Afe c r f r vi w of t pa te ' s iso ,pa tc a l t undiput m e ca tr a e ul e e he ri s ubm s i ns riul ry he s ed di l r co ds pr vi d,t cour co l e r o de he t ncudes t t M e r c ha ye s annotpr de i r t i fe e e he e. ove lbe a e ndif r nc r The evi nc esa ihes t a no tme di Dr M ie i e M e r 'c to or r f s t de e tbls hat t i d . ls gnor ye s ondii n eue o e xami ,di nos orte thi . W he M e sc m pl i d t Dr M ie a ne ag e, r a m n yer o ane o . l s bouthi s s ympt ,t oms he d co wa r s o sv t t s c mpans i lg to h se mi ain o M e e sa o j cie o t r s e p n ie o ho e o lit, n ih f i xn n to f y r nd b e tv t si Att i fr tmeei i J y 201 Dr M ie di no bele M e r ha a pr t t e tng. her is tng n ul 6, . l s d t ive ye s d osae ifcin a d ma e a me ia j d me tt o d rt e t ie c lu e a d e au t isr s t a d n e to n d dc l u g n o r e h z n u tr n v lae t e ul n r s ltr de opme s r t rt n r or rng a i o i t tha notpr vi l r s ved M eye s ae vel nt , ahe ha e de i ntbi tcs ha d e ousy e ol r' i s . At t Augu t e m ,t doc or bei ve M e s r ce hit r s s ues he s xa he t le d yer ' e nt so y, ympt s a t t om , nd es r ulsm i i c t c ii or1 a di gnos d a te t d hi te t nta c di y. Ata es t ght ndia e olts BS nd a e nd ' a e m r a me c or ngl r f lw u e a i e rySe tmb r Dr M ie a j tdM e e s me iain, a e o t rpo t ol p x m n al pe e , . ls duse y r ' dc to b s d n he e rs o ofhi s s ympt sa t ttme. W he M e r c om t ha i n ye s ompl i a uta s l n pr tt i Ocobe , he aned bo wole os ae n t r t doc ort n pr s rbe a i otc . t he e c i d ntbi is M e r alo c ye s s ompli t t Dr M ies s d ha r f n-d M e r t a s c ait a ns ha . l houl ve e e e ye s o pe i ls. Be us t physca e ms Dr M ie pe f r e on M e r we e nor ala M e r 'ti ca e he i l xa . ls rom d ye s r m nd ye s u ne c lte a d PSA tsswe eas n r l h we e , . ie ma ea G dc l u me tt ta utl s n r et r lo o ma, o v r Dr M ls d ç ia j dg n ha me r fra t as e ils wa no me i d' ( f! 1 ) e erl o p cait s t rt . Af. 5. e ' M e r cla l dia ee wih Dr M ies te t nt de ii . He be ives he s d ye s e ry s gr s t . l ' r a me c sons le houl ha r eve a i otc f s ve a mont a Dr M or no a lge y pr dit d w o d be ve ec i d ntbi i s or e r l hs s . e le dl e c e ul ne s ar or r ce ved e l ton of hi s m pt s by a s c a i t The G lbe a e i f er nc ce s y e i va ua i s y om pe i ls . i i r t ndif e e de sa r i nots tsi d by ...me e diag e me E t e painta docor co e ng tnda d s aite r s r e nt bewe n te nd t l nc mi Gq u sin o me ia j g n 'Ge manv.S e rn 5 F.Ap x 3 2 3 5 (t Ci.2 3 (l e to s f d c l ud me t'' r i h ai , 31 p' 9 , 9 4h r 01 ) ( n u ls d (uoi Ru s lv. hefr 5 F. 31 , 9 (t Ci. 9 $; rg t Coln , u p bihe ) q tng sel S fe, 28 2d 8 31 4h r 1 75 W ih v. lis 7 6F.d8 , 4 ( t Ci.9 5 (n ) 6 2 41 8 9 4h r1 8 ) sme . Att mos,s h dia ee nt r fe tM e s a us to t tDr M ie m idi nos he t uc s gr me s e l c yer ' cc ai n ha . l s s ag ed hi c ton fo J y t ough Se e be a m itke y deaye pr di hi wih s ondii r m ul hr ptm r nd sa nl l d ovi ng m t a i oi or a s caits e l to ofhi c ton. Eg n i dve tntfitr t pr de ntbitcs pe ils' vauain s ondii GAl na re alle o ovi a uae medial ca e' does not a o t de i r t i fe e e a r r d t pr deq t c r' m unt o lbe a e ndif r nc s equie o ove a c tt i lde i ton. Esel,429U. a 1 Thus t rj1 a doco ma notbe onsiutona prvai tle S. t 05. ,mde 983, tr y hedla ef al dl ne i ntdi nosso te t nt d.a 1 (l c maprciedoes l ibl or lege y glge ag i r rame .I t 07 GMedial l a tc notbe comeac tt ona vi ai meeybe a et vitm i aprs n' s ealoJ hns onsimi l olton rl c us he ci s ione l; e s o on v Oun n s 1 F.d 1 4 1 8 6 (t Ci.1 9 )( rni g sl r j g n wheed co . io e , 45 3 6 , 6 - 9 4h r 9 8 g a tn l mmay ud me t r o tr pr de dignoss a te t e , but di not dignos o te t piuia y gl nd t m or t t ovi d a i nd r a m nt d a e r ra t tr a u ha . ul maey bid d te p io e plitf) Fid n n g n n is e o mae ilf c i d s u e t tl l e h rs n r an it. n i g o e uie su f tra a t n ip t i n s howi t Dr M ie kne M e r ha a s rousm e ca ne f rdif r ntte t ntt the ng hat . ls w ye s d e i di l ed o fe e r a me ha waspr de ort the co cousy i no e s h a nee t c tc l ovi d ha ns i l g r d uc d, he our oncudest tDr M ie i ha . ls s e t ldt sl r u g n a amatro lw.Ana p o raeo d rwil e tr dt i d y. ni e o l t mma yj d me t s te f a p r p it r e lbe n ee ls a z The Cl r i die t t s nd co e oft s m e a e k s r ced o e pi s hi mox ndum o ni n a a o pa ng pi o nd cc m nyi o de t pl i ifa t c ms lofr c d f t de e nt r r o antf nd o ot e e or or he f nda . ENTER:Ths JQ d yo Jme 2 1 . i . a ft ,07 Chi U nie St t s D it i tJ ef t d a e s rc udge 8

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?