Henderson v. Rice et al

Filing 31

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/6/2017. (tvt)

cO nrsoF l u. Dlm rnu*
FcE s, s ATRO;):KE,
'') VA
hI
F1. 1
-( L
Z3

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W EST ER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
RO ANOK E DI SI
W ON

FEB 25 2 1
97
JULA -,-1. '
I . *'- X
;Jk
)

BY:

U

N'
NEK A H ENDERSON,

cL
E

CASE NO .7:
16CV00398

Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

PAUL RI c & ,
CE,

By: G l n E.C onrad
e
Chi Unied St e D i t i Judge
ef t
at s s r ct

Dee da ts.
f n n t)
N' ka He r on, a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fl d t s cvi rght a i n
ne
nde s
r ni nm t oce di
o
ie hi i l i s cto

p ru n t 4 U.. j 1 8 .Th d fnd n sfld M oinst Dimiso De e e 2 2 6
u s a t o 2 SC. 9 3 e ee a t ie to o s s n c mb r 2, 01 .
On De e r2 , 6 i ec u t ie an tc a viig M s He d ro t a t ec u t ul
c mbe 3 201 , h o r mald o ie d sn
. n es n h t h o r wo d
gi he 21 days t s
ve r
o ubmi a f rhe co mt rafi vis or ot r lva e de
t ny u t r t e - fda t
her ee nt vi nce
co r ditng,e ai ng,ora di t de e nt 'e de e be or r i on t i motons
nta c i
xpl ni
voi ng he f nda s vi nc f e ulng
her
i .
The notc wa ne M s He r o
i e r d . nde s n:

I Plitf d e n trs o d t Dee d n l' p e dng ,te Co r wila s me
f an if o s o e p n o fn a ts) la i s h u t l su
t tPl i ifha l ti er s i t c s ,and ort tPl i ifa ee w ih wha t
ha antf s os nt e t n he a e
/ ha antf gr s t
t he

Dee a ts sae q i t i r s o sv p e dig s. I Plitf wihe t
fnd n g) ttl n her e p n ie la n t) f an if s s o
contnue wih t ca e i i ne es a y t t Pli if r s nd i a a oprae
i
t he s , t s c s r ha antf e po n n ppr i t
f hi Pl i ifm a wih t r s nd wih c mt ra fda t orot ra tonal
as on. antf y s o e po
t ot e - fi vis
he ddii
evi nce a o lned a
de
s uti
bove. Howe r i Pl ntf doe not fl s
ve . f ai if s
ie ome r s e
e pons

whhi t t nt o ( )da pe i t Co tm a dimist c e f f iur
n he we y- ne 21 y rodp he ur y s s he as or al e
t pr
o osecut
e.

( ie ECFNo. 0 (mp a i i o i ia.
Nbtc ,
3 ) e h ss n rgn l
)
Si e m a lng t no i e t M s He r on, t c t has r c ve no f rhe
nc
ii he tc o
. nde s
he our
e ei d
't r
u
c
ommunia i fom he abou t s c s ,a t de dlne f he r pons t t def nda s
c ton '
r
r
t hi a e nd he a i or r es e o he e nt '

motonshaspa s Ac or ngy,t c tc l st t purua t Rul 41b)oft Fe r l
i
sed. c di l he our oncude ha, s nt o e (
he de a
Rul ofCi lPr ed e M s He r on ha f l t pr ec e t sa ton. Se ae Bal r v.
es
vi oc ur , . nde s
s aied o os ut hi c i
e n. la d

Calo ,8 2F.d9 (t Ci.1 8 )
rs n 8 2 3 4 h r 9 9 .

'

!

The c ut ha ng dul no ii d t pa te t tM s He r o sf iur t r pond t t
ot', vi
y tfe he ri s ha
. nde s n' al e o es
o he
def nda s dipostvem otonswoul be i e pr td asf iu et pr e ut a woul be c us
e nt ' s ii
i
d
ntr ee
al r o os c e nd
d
a e
,

I

frds sa o t ea to wih u p eu ie c n ld st thea to mus bed s se wih u
o imis l f h ci n t o t rj dc , o cu e ha t cin t imis d t o t

p eu ie A s p rt o d rwil n e t sd y
rj d c . e aae r e le tr hi a .

I

M s He r on i ad s d t ti s i e t pr e wih t saci n,s mus peii
. nde s s vie ha f he nt nds o oce d t hi to he
t tton

j

)

t co twihi 30 oft e r oft s o de f a r i tt m e oft saci n. Any m o i n f
he ur t n
he nty hi r r or ensa e nt hi to
to or
r i tt m e s ul pr vi s cfc e ana i f M s He r on' f l e t r pond i a
ensa e nt ho d o de pe i xpl ton or . nde s s aiur o es
n

I
.

1

.

tm ey f hi n t de e nt 'dipostvem o i .
i l as o o f nda s s ii
tons

l

Th Clr i drce t snd cpiso t sme rn u o i o a d a c mpa yng
e ek s ietd o e o e f hi moa d m pnin n co n i

i
I

;

odropani a dt cu sl feodfrh dfn at.
re t litf n o o ne o rcr o te ee dns
f
ENTER:Th s V
i

d y o Fe r ay 2 7
a f b u r , 01 .

Chi U ie St t Diti tJ
ef t d aes src udge

2

1

;