Boatright v. Kiser et al

Filing 65

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/1/2017. (tvt)

eLERK' ognce u s ol ccoun'
:
s'
r

A - IL ,A
r gi v

,

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

FL
IED

FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A

J g jg j
UN
gy

R O AN O K E DI SI N
W O

BJuLw c ouDL cL nx
Y
Ek j
. .

EARL MAW HEW BOATRI ,
GHT

: oEptr
:yk rycLER

Pl ntf ,
ai if

Ci lA ct on N o.7: cvvi
i
16- 00433

M EM OM NDUM O PI O N
NI
J.K I
SER ,e aI,
t .
Dte
f ndant .
s

H on. ls L.K i e
Jack on
sr
Se orUnie St t sDit c Judge
ni
t d a e s rit

By Or re e e M ay 2,201 1die e Pl ntf o pa t outt ndi flngf eort
de nt r d
7, r ctd ai ift y he sa ng ii e
o
ot r ie r s
he w s e pond due t hi r l a e f om i a c r ton, nd Ial o diec ed hi t r s
o s e e s r nc r e a i a
s r t
m o e pond t
o

de e nt 'dipostvem otons Pl i ifwa advie t taf llet r pond wihi f t n
f nda s s ii
i . antf s
s d ha aitr o es
t n ouree

d yswo l r s l i t ed s s a o t a to wi o t eu ie Plitf h sn t e p n e t
a
u d eut n h imis l f he cin t u prj d c . an if a o r s o d d o
h
t eOr e, n a c r i gy Id j s t ec mpli t t u p eudc a dd n a mo t ny
h d r a d c od n l, imis h o an wi t rj ie n e y s o a
ho
pe ng m o i duet Pli ifsf l et pr e ut . Se Bala d v.Ca lon,88 F. 93,96
ndi
ton
o a ntf aiur o os c e e lr
rs
2 2d

(t Ci. 9 9 (ttngt a p os l ia t a el u jc t t etmer q ie n sa drs e tfr
4 h r 1 8 ) sai h t r e i g n s r i be t o h i e ur me t n e p c o
t
s
c u t r e swih u whc efci j dca a mi srto wo l b i sil' M c n l v
o r od r t o t ih fe tve u iil d nitain ud e mpo sb e); Do ad .
He dCrmia Ct S p l s rOfie, 5 F.d1 ,1 4 ( dCi. 98 )(sW l iep os
a i n l . u ewio fc r 8 0 2 21 2 2 r 1 8 G h l r e
g
ltga sm a i ge r de ewem or l nintteam e t n t er pr s nt d by co e ,a1
ii nt y n ne al s l
e e e r t nt ha hos e e e e
uns l l

.

r
c

:
n

ltga s i l ng pr s s ha a o i t o t c pl w ih c ' or r . W he t y foutt t
ii nt , nc udi
o e , ve n blga i n o om y t oul de s
t
n he l ha

oblgaint y,lkealltga s mus s frt co eq nc oft i acins'
i to he i l ii nt, t ufe he ns ue es her to .
).
EN TER : Thi
s

ï

dyo
a f

,

201
7.
f

Se rU nie St t D i ti tJ
ni
t d a es s r c udge

/'