Tucker v. Cobbs
Filing
10
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/23/2016. (tvt)
CLERKY OPII L, Dl e, llT
' eE I3. 3T, o lk
J
A) Ct,,1 ' VA
- ->!OFE
c .
'
P!.(
ltD
.!
-
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
JA C O B TU CK ER ,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Pl ntf ,
ai if
T.COBBS,RNCA,
Dee
f ndant
.
N0V 23 2 1
05
J A N U
ULI .
BY:
CL
CASE NO.7:6CV00444
1
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M
By:Gln E. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnie Stt sDititJudge
e td a e src
J co Tuc r aVigi a i t a Gr e Roc Core tonalCe e ,fld t spr K cvi
a b
ke , r ni nma e t e n
k rci
nt r ie hi o
i l
rg sa tonptrua t 42U. C.j1 3agans anure T.Co .Tuc ralgest ti M a
iht ci ls nt o
S.
98 i t s ,
bbs
ke le ha n y
201 Cobbsope a a c mti Tuc rs na e wih a m e c ls y c
6,
ned n c ot n
ke ' m
t
di a uppl ompa f g hi
ny, or ed s
sgna e t or r a wal r f r hi wiho hi wrten co e or a docors o de ,a made
i mr o de
ke o m t ut s it
ns nt
t ' r r nd
Tuc r r s i e f a c pa e t of $57 62 t ar t cost of t devi e. Tucker seeks
ke e ponsbl or o ym n
ow d he
he
c 1
.
t pe i d mo eay a d ijmci er le .Afe r ve o t erc r ,hec u t o ld st t
ms cse n tr n n t tv eif tr e iw f h e o d t o r c ncu e ha
.
t ac i mus be sl a iy dimis d asfi ous
he ton
t tmm rl s s e
rvol .
Tuc rha no pr pai t $350. flng f e a $50. a nita i f no maly
ke s t e d he
00 ii e nd
00 dmi sr tve ee r l
r quied t fl t ski la ton. Rahe ,he hasappled t pr e wihoutpr pa ntunde 28
e r o ie hi vi c i
t r
i o oc ed t
e yme
r
U. C. 1 5b a dh ssg e ac n e tf r a ren t pa t f l f etr u h isal n s
S. j 91 () n a i n d o s n o m g e ig o y he ' l e h o g n tl t
u
me
t bewihhel fom hi i aet u tac ot whe ve f ndsbec
o
t d r
s nm t r s c mt ne r u
ome a ia e.Ass h,Tuc r
va lbl
uc
ke
1 Tuc r ata hes c e of numeous compl nt a gre es he fld a
ke tc
opis
r
ai s nd ivanc
ie bout ha ng t pa t
vi o y he
c yme c r c e ng t the di notwa t wal rbe us he hasaca I r pons t one oft e
opa nt hage, ontndi ha
d
nt he ke ca e
ne. n es e o
hes
c pli s Gi wr t t Tuc r
om ant, bbs o e o ke :
1me wih yo pe s nal o ora
t t u r o ly n
bout5.9.6.You wa e t dicus t lyours cilnee .''
1 1
ntd o s s ç
al
pe a ds'
Durng t t c r ai you br ht t my atnton t t t physc l t a s ha
i ha onve s ton,
oug o
te i ha he
ia herpit d
r omme
ec
ndedt tyour t n t usng awaker You satd,C ndwha aeyou goi t do a
ha
eur o i
l .
te W
tr
ng o
bout
i?' 1 e ane t t Iwo d t l wih Dr W a a t physc t a s a t t i t y
t'
xpli d ha
ul ak t . ng nd he
ial herpit nd ha f he
rc
e omme
nded a wal ,one woul be or r f you. Dr W a or ed you a wakerwih
ker
d
deed or
. ng der
l
t
wheeswihi a fw da . l wasor r s t tyou woul ha i whe you rt r d t t
l tn e
ys t
deed o ha
d ve t n
e une o he
physc t r pit ..,Oncet wake a rve you r us d i. Acc di t DOC Polcy 720.
ial he a s.
he l r ri d,
ef e t
or ng o
i
4,
t r i no r t a t w ake w a t nt pr ry fryout dee neisdiposto
he e s efmd, nd he l r s ake o ope t o
o tnni t s iin.
( mp. tc me t, tl , No 2)
Co lAta h ns a 0 ECF . .
.
i pu s n hslws i t e t eL f nn p u e i sau e j 1 5 a di s b e t ot a sau es
s ruig i a ut md r h q o a a p rs ttt, 91 , n s u j c t h t ttt '
oh rp o so s S cin j 1 5 e( )B)i rq ie adsrc c u t od s s ac mpan fld
t e r vii n . e to 91 ()2 ( () e u rs itit o r t imis o lit ie
L f ma pa dsGa a tme i t c tdeemi t t
q or
upe tt ny i f he our tr nes ha
t a ton or a a .
he ci
ppe l
fi ousormalcius' Tii s c i lkeispr de es orsa u e,
rvol
i o . ls e ton, i t e c s t t t was
'
d sg d lr ey t ds o rg te fln o ,a d wat o j iila d p iae
e ine ag l o ic u a e h ig f n se f udca n rv t
r our s u
es ce pon,ba e e s l ws t t tpa ng ltga s ge r ly do no i tae
s l s a uis ha yi ii nt ne al
t nii t
bec us of t c t ofbrngi s t a be aus of t t z a of s nc i f r
a e
he oss
i ng ui nd c e
he h e t
a tons o
brngi ve touss t unde Fede a Rul ofCi lPr du e 11. To t se
i ng xa i
uis
r
rl e
vi oce r
hi nd,
t esaue a c r sj d e n to l t a t o i t ds s acam b s d o a
h tt t c o d u g s o ny he u h rt o imis li a e n n
y
i s a y me il s l lt or butas t t ualpowe t pi r e t vel
ndiputbl
rte s ega he y,
lo he mus
r o e c he i
of t c pli ts f t l al ga i a dim is t e c am s whos f cua
he om a n ' ac ua le tons nd s s hos l i
e at l
co e i a ecla l ba ees .
nt ntons r e ry s l s
Netk v W ila ,4 0 U. 31 ,3 7- ( 9 9 . G u t ma ...c n i e t r mi i s
iz e . l ms 9 S. 9 2 28 1 8 ) ç rs y
i
co
o sd r hed nmi
v l e o a cam a o fco i a li t fioiy t s o 2 U.. j 1 1 ()2 ( ()'
au f li s ne a t r n ppyng he rv lt e t f 8 SC. 9 5e ( )B)i.
'
Na vv F C Bu n r 3 6F.d2 2 2 7(t Ci. 0 4)
z .M
t e, 7 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 0 .
The c u tsn s wih u q e to ,t a Tu k rs j 1 8 c mpan ,fld t a o d o
o r d , t o t u si n h t c e ' 9 3 o lit ie o v i r
pr e tt polc r quied m e c lc pa e of$57.2,qualfe a a fi ousl ws tunde
ot s he iy-e r
di a o ym nt
6
ii s s rvol a ui
r
j1 1 ()2)B)i. Th s i wi b s mma y dimis d a s c . Ha a ra o be panif
9 5e ( ( () e ut l e u dl s se s u h
l
d e s na l li tf
be n f c t pr pa t $ 00 flng c tf t s lws t- a fna i outa ne l s ven
e or ed o e y he 400. ii os or hi a ui
ncal l y ary e
tmest a
i
he mountoft c lnge c ym e - t c ti s tsi d t the woul ha be n
he hale d opa nt - he our s a ife ha
d ve e
d tn'd fo fl s t Be a s te a to wilb d s se wi o tp eudc ,h we e ,
ee e rm i ui. c u e h cin l e imis d t u rj ie o v r
ng
h
Tuc r r m ans fe t purue hi cai i a ne and s pa a e c vi aci n,pr de t the
ke e i ' e o s
r
s lm n
w
e r t i l to
ovi d ha
pr pa t flng coss Nac 376F. a 257.
e ys he ii
t.
v,
3d t
ENTER:Thi Jx W dyo No e e, 201
s g a f v mbr 6.
ChifUn ed St t Diti tJ
e
aes src udge
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?