Tucker v. Cobbs

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/23/2016. (tvt)

CLERKY OPII L, Dl e, llT
' eE I3. 3T, o lk
J
A) Ct,,1 ' VA
- ->!OFE
c .
'
P!.(
ltD
.!
-

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
JA C O B TU CK ER ,

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Pl ntf ,
ai if

T.COBBS,RNCA,
Dee
f ndant
.

N0V 23 2 1
05
J A N U
ULI .
BY:

CL

CASE NO.7:6CV00444
1

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M
By:Gln E. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnie Stt sDititJudge
e td a e src

J co Tuc r aVigi a i t a Gr e Roc Core tonalCe e ,fld t spr K cvi
a b
ke , r ni nma e t e n
k rci
nt r ie hi o
i l

rg sa tonptrua t 42U. C.j1 3agans anure T.Co .Tuc ralgest ti M a
iht ci ls nt o
S.
98 i t s ,
bbs
ke le ha n y
201 Cobbsope a a c mti Tuc rs na e wih a m e c ls y c
6,
ned n c ot n
ke ' m
t
di a uppl ompa f g hi
ny, or ed s
sgna e t or r a wal r f r hi wiho hi wrten co e or a docors o de ,a made
i mr o de
ke o m t ut s it
ns nt
t ' r r nd

Tuc r r s i e f a c pa e t of $57 62 t ar t cost of t devi e. Tucker seeks
ke e ponsbl or o ym n
ow d he
he
c 1
.

t pe i d mo eay a d ijmci er le .Afe r ve o t erc r ,hec u t o ld st t
ms cse n tr n n t tv eif tr e iw f h e o d t o r c ncu e ha
.

t ac i mus be sl a iy dimis d asfi ous
he ton
t tmm rl s s e
rvol .

Tuc rha no pr pai t $350. flng f e a $50. a nita i f no maly
ke s t e d he
00 ii e nd
00 dmi sr tve ee r l
r quied t fl t ski la ton. Rahe ,he hasappled t pr e wihoutpr pa ntunde 28
e r o ie hi vi c i
t r
i o oc ed t
e yme
r

U. C. 1 5b a dh ssg e ac n e tf r a ren t pa t f l f etr u h isal n s
S. j 91 () n a i n d o s n o m g e ig o y he ' l e h o g n tl t
u
me
t bewihhel fom hi i aet u tac ot whe ve f ndsbec
o
t d r
s nm t r s c mt ne r u
ome a ia e.Ass h,Tuc r
va lbl
uc
ke

1 Tuc r ata hes c e of numeous compl nt a gre es he fld a
ke tc
opis
r
ai s nd ivanc
ie bout ha ng t pa t
vi o y he
c yme c r c e ng t the di notwa t wal rbe us he hasaca I r pons t one oft e
opa nt hage, ontndi ha
d
nt he ke ca e
ne. n es e o
hes
c pli s Gi wr t t Tuc r
om ant, bbs o e o ke :
1me wih yo pe s nal o ora
t t u r o ly n
bout5.9.6.You wa e t dicus t lyours cilnee .''
1 1
ntd o s s ç
al
pe a ds'
Durng t t c r ai you br ht t my atnton t t t physc l t a s ha
i ha onve s ton,
oug o
te i ha he
ia herpit d
r omme
ec
ndedt tyour t n t usng awaker You satd,C ndwha aeyou goi t do a
ha
eur o i
l .
te W
tr
ng o
bout
i?' 1 e ane t t Iwo d t l wih Dr W a a t physc t a s a t t i t y
t'
xpli d ha
ul ak t . ng nd he
ial herpit nd ha f he
rc
e omme
nded a wal ,one woul be or r f you. Dr W a or ed you a wakerwih
ker
d
deed or
. ng der
l
t
wheeswihi a fw da . l wasor r s t tyou woul ha i whe you rt r d t t
l tn e
ys t
deed o ha
d ve t n
e une o he
physc t r pit ..,Oncet wake a rve you r us d i. Acc di t DOC Polcy 720.
ial he a s.
he l r ri d,
ef e t
or ng o
i
4,
t r i no r t a t w ake w a t nt pr ry fryout dee neisdiposto
he e s efmd, nd he l r s ake o ope t o
o tnni t s iin.

( mp. tc me t, tl , No 2)
Co lAta h ns a 0 ECF . .

.

i pu s n hslws i t e t eL f nn p u e i sau e j 1 5 a di s b e t ot a sau es
s ruig i a ut md r h q o a a p rs ttt, 91 , n s u j c t h t ttt '
oh rp o so s S cin j 1 5 e( )B)i rq ie adsrc c u t od s s ac mpan fld
t e r vii n . e to 91 ()2 ( () e u rs itit o r t imis o lit ie
L f ma pa dsGa a tme i t c tdeemi t t
q or
upe tt ny i f he our tr nes ha

t a ton or a a .
he ci
ppe l

fi ousormalcius' Tii s c i lkeispr de es orsa u e,
rvol
i o . ls e ton, i t e c s t t t was
'

d sg d lr ey t ds o rg te fln o ,a d wat o j iila d p iae
e ine ag l o ic u a e h ig f n se f udca n rv t
r our s u
es ce pon,ba e e s l ws t t tpa ng ltga s ge r ly do no i tae
s l s a uis ha yi ii nt ne al
t nii t
bec us of t c t ofbrngi s t a be aus of t t z a of s nc i f r
a e
he oss
i ng ui nd c e
he h e t
a tons o
brngi ve touss t unde Fede a Rul ofCi lPr du e 11. To t se
i ng xa i
uis
r
rl e
vi oce r
hi nd,

t esaue a c r sj d e n to l t a t o i t ds s acam b s d o a
h tt t c o d u g s o ny he u h rt o imis li a e n n
y
i s a y me il s l lt or butas t t ualpowe t pi r e t vel
ndiputbl
rte s ega he y,
lo he mus
r o e c he i
of t c pli ts f t l al ga i a dim is t e c am s whos f cua
he om a n ' ac ua le tons nd s s hos l i
e at l
co e i a ecla l ba ees .
nt ntons r e ry s l s

Netk v W ila ,4 0 U. 31 ,3 7- ( 9 9 . G u t ma ...c n i e t r mi i s
iz e . l ms 9 S. 9 2 28 1 8 ) ç rs y
i
co
o sd r hed nmi
v l e o a cam a o fco i a li t fioiy t s o 2 U.. j 1 1 ()2 ( ()'
au f li s ne a t r n ppyng he rv lt e t f 8 SC. 9 5e ( )B)i.
'
Na vv F C Bu n r 3 6F.d2 2 2 7(t Ci. 0 4)
z .M
t e, 7 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 0 .
The c u tsn s wih u q e to ,t a Tu k rs j 1 8 c mpan ,fld t a o d o
o r d , t o t u si n h t c e ' 9 3 o lit ie o v i r
pr e tt polc r quied m e c lc pa e of$57.2,qualfe a a fi ousl ws tunde
ot s he iy-e r
di a o ym nt
6
ii s s rvol a ui
r

j1 1 ()2)B)i. Th s i wi b s mma y dimis d a s c . Ha a ra o be panif
9 5e ( ( () e ut l e u dl s se s u h
l
d e s na l li tf
be n f c t pr pa t $ 00 flng c tf t s lws t- a fna i outa ne l s ven
e or ed o e y he 400. ii os or hi a ui
ncal l y ary e
tmest a
i
he mountoft c lnge c ym e - t c ti s tsi d t the woul ha be n
he hale d opa nt - he our s a ife ha
d ve e

d tn'd fo fl s t Be a s te a to wilb d s se wi o tp eudc ,h we e ,
ee e rm i ui. c u e h cin l e imis d t u rj ie o v r
ng
h
Tuc r r m ans fe t purue hi cai i a ne and s pa a e c vi aci n,pr de t the
ke e i ' e o s
r
s lm n
w
e r t i l to
ovi d ha
pr pa t flng coss Nac 376F. a 257.
e ys he ii
t.
v,
3d t

ENTER:Thi Jx W dyo No e e, 201
s g a f v mbr 6.

ChifUn ed St t Diti tJ
e
aes src udge

2