Graves v. Clark

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/6/2016. (kab)

qk
KRp. ot l u . w e l l
z o:
p
t ddke

A pFIEDiV
T A vl ,A
N lk
L

'

.

I TI E UNI
N I
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O
GREG ORY DARNELL GR AVES,
Pe ii r
tt one ,

HAROLD CLARK ,
R espondent
.

BEC -6 2 1
26
JUL
BY:

. Lsy CLERK
D

C E K

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00466
vi t on
16- v-

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
By:

H on. ks n L.Ki e
Jac o
sr
Se or U ni e St t D i t i tJudge
ni
t d a es s r c

Gr gor Dn nelGr ve ,aVigi ai a:pr e di pt K ,fl ape ii f rawrtof
e y r l a s
r ni nm t oc e ng o
ied
tton o
i

ha a c pusptrua t 28U. C.j2
be s or
ls nt o
S. 254.Thec tc tonal fldt peii ad s d
our ondii ly ie he tton, vie
Pe ii rt tt pe ii n a a e t bet i ey fld,a g a t Pe ii rt opporuniy
ttone ha he tto ppe r d o mtm l ie nd r n ed ttone he
t t
t e an whyt peii n wastmey fl Pe ii rhasr ponde a t sm a tri rpef r
o xpl i
he tto
i l ied. ttonp
es
d, nd hi te s i o

p ei n r r ve pls a tt Ru e4o teRulsGo e ln j2 5 Ca e .Afe rv e n
r l ay e iw t u n o l f h
mi
r
e v n ig 2 4 ss tr e iwig
t r co d,Ide Pe ii ne ' moton t a n c ms la dimist peii astmeba r d.
he e r
ny sto rs i o ppoit ot e nd s s he tton i
re
1.

TheCic tCour oft Ciy ofDmw il s n e e Pe ii ne on M a 4,2000, o f t
r ui
t he t
le e t nt d tto r
y
t ory
yea s'i i o nta trPeii rplade guit t sam or bur a y,a tmpt d s
r mprs nme fe ttone e d ly o tt y gl r te e odomy,a
nd
a tm pt d r pe.Pe ii rdi notfl a a a t t Cour ofAppe l ofVigi a.
te e a
ttone d
ie n ppe l o he
t
as
r ni

OhFe rzr 2 , 01 'Pei o rfldap tto f ram i o h be sc r u wi t
à t y 7 2 4 t ine ie eiin o
a
, t
t f a a o p s t he
h
#uprmecour ofvigi a whihdimis t peii a untmeyonAprl20,201
e
t r ni, c s sed he tton s i l
i
4.

Pei o e fldt ei tn f d rl t inn e rir h nAu u t2 , 01 S eR. v. 2 5
tt n r ie h nsa t e ea pei o o ale t a g s 4 2 6. e Go j 2 4
i
t
Ca e 3()( s rbi t prs mal nze.
s s d de ci ng he ion- ibox ll
I.
l
A.
A ha spe ii ne doe notha a co tt i lr ghtt c
bea tto r s
ve
ns iutona i o ouns l Se Pe vl a v.
e . e nns vnni

Fi y,481U. 551 $55( 987)(û'erghtt a ntdc ms le e t t frta a of
le
S. ,
1
if i o ppoi e ot e xtnds o he is ppe l
-h

rg ta dn f rh r' .Th c u t ya pon c t e t aha e sp tto e i t c u t
ih, n o u te .l e o r ma p i t omsl o b a eiin r f he o r
'

d eemi sta t itrsso j tc s rq ie . . 1 U. C. 3 0 A()2 ( .
l tr ne h t he n ee t f usie o e ur . .' 8 S. j 0 6 a ()B)
d
'
Pe ii ne a guest thene dsc ms lbe a ehe al ge y r c ve i feci
tto r r
ha
e ot e c us
le dl e ei d ne f tve
a ssa ofco e a nee hep i si a i hi cli . Ho ve ,not ng i t r or
s it nce
uns l nd ds l nve tg tng s am
we r hi n he ec d
pr s nty i c t st tPeii ne i t bl t pr ee pr K o t tt m at ri s dit tt
e e l ndi a e ha tto r s ma e o oc d o r ha he te s o fkul o

rq ietea pon me to c u s l Ac o dn l ,h itr sso j tc d no rq iet e
e ur h p it n f o n e. c r ig y t e n ee t f usie o t e ur h
a nt ntofc
ppoi me
ouns la t stme,a t m o i t appoi c ms i de e
e t hi i
nd he ton o
nt ot el s nid.
B.

Ha e sp tto fldu d rj2 4a es b e t oao' - a peido lmiai n 2
b a eiins ie n e 25 r u j c t neye r ro f i tto . 8
a l h s ro e i s o u r m h ae n ih h u g n
U. C. 2 4 d ()l Gener ly, ti peidb gn t r nfo ted t o wh c tej d me t
S. j 2 4() 1.

o c n ito be o stna. 28u .. . 2 4 ()1 ( .A c n ito b c me fn l n et e
f o v ci n c me s l
2
s c j 2 4 d ()A) o vcin e o s i a o c h
a albit o dr c r ve i e h u t d UntdS ae v. a , 3 U. 5 2 5 4('0 ) The
v i l y f ie t e iw s x a se . ie tts Cly 5 7 S. 2 , 2 20 3 .
a i
one- a flng pe i i t l whiea c nvitsç ope l fld a i ai f rSt t
ye r ii
rod s oled l o c ' l
pr ry ie pplc ton o ae

p s-o vito o ohe c laea r ve 'àl e dng' 2 U.. j2 4 ( )2 ;s eW al
o tc n cin r t r o ltrl e iw'i s n i . 8 SC. 2 4 d ( ) e lv.
p
'
Kh l, 6 U. 5 , 5 ( 1 ( ic si p o e dng t t u l ya c lâea rviw) X
oi à 2 S. 45 5 2 201 ) ds u sng r c e i s ha q ai s oltr l e e .
f
d sdc c t t ysl rl d s s aj2 5 p tt n i ap tto e fist ma ter q st
it t ol ma l
r
mmai imis 2 4 eii f ei n r al o ke h e uiie
y
o
i
1Theone-y a peido l tto frtln ah be sp t inu d rj2 5 b gn t nm o telts o
e r ro f i ain o iig a a eio n e 2 4 e is o
mi
t
n h aet f
f urdae :
o
ts

( ted t o whihtej d me t e a fn l ytec ncu ino drc rve o t e prto ofh
A)h ae n c h u g n b c me ia b h o lso f ie te iw r he x iain te
tmef s e ng s h r e
l or e ki uc eviw;

( ted t o whc t i e i n t fln a a pl aincetdb Saea to i voaino te
B) h ae n ih he mp dme t o iig n p i to rae y tt cin n ilto f h
c
Consi i orlwsoft Unie Stt i r
tt on a
m
he td aes s emove i t applc ntwa pr ve t d 9om flngby s h
d, f he ia
s e ne
ii
uc
Stt a ton;
ae c i

( ted t o whc t c n t uin l ih asre wa i tal rc g z db teS p e Co r ite
C) h ae n ih he o si to a rg t setd s ni ly eo nie y h u rme ut fh
t
i
rghtha bee ne y r ogni dby t Supr meCour a ma r toa i y a iabl t ca e o
i
s n wl ec ze
he
e
t nd de er ctvel pplc e o s s n
colaer r e ;o
lt al eviw r

( t d t ol c tefcu l rdc t o t cam o camsp ee tdc udh v bendso ee
D)he ae iwhih h a ta pe iae fhe li r li rsne o l a e e ic v rd
t ough t e r ieofduedii e.
hr
he xe cs
lgenc

28U.. . 2 4 ()1.
SC j 2 4d ()
2Peio e ddn t r u tmeie su d rs b eto s( tr u h(
tin r i o ag e i l s n e u scin B)h o g D)
t
n
.

s
howi oftme i sa trt c t ii st pe ii rt tt pe ii n a a st i e yand
ng i lnes fe he our notfe he ttone ha he tto ppe r mtm l
a l a o runiy t pr vi a a gtme a e de e.Hilv. axt 277 F. 701 707
lows n ppo t t o o de ny r t nt nd vi nc
l Br on,
3d ,

( h Ci.2002)
4t r
.

Peiin rsj2 4p tto i t i l u de j2 4 ( )1( .Peiin rsc n ito
tto e ' 25 eiin s mtmey n r 2 4 d ( )A) tto e ' o v cin
bec m efna i Jme 2000 whe t tm ee r d f rPe ii rt no ea a a fon t Cic t
n i ln t
n he i xpie o ttonç o t n ppe l ' l he r ui
r

Co r o teCi o Da v let t Co r o Ap aso Vigni.S eVa S p. . 5 6 a
u t f h t f n il o he u t f pe l f r i a e ' u Ct R. A:()
y
.
(ttn a a p a 9o t etilc u tot eCo r o Ap e l i al we o l i t ea peln
saig n p e l m h ra o r t h u t f p as s lo d ny f h p l t
a

flsanoieo a p a wihnt ryd yso t fn l u g n ) Pdiine fldli saeha e s
ie
tc f p e l t i hit a f he â a j d me t. to r ie zs tt b a
pe ii m o et n t e ye r lt ri Febr r 201 Be a et one- a f r lsa t eof
tton r ha hr e a s a e n
ua y 4. c us he
ye r ede a t tz
t
lmia i ha az dy e r d by t tm ePeii rfld hi sa eha a pe ii saut r
i ttons d lea xpie
he i
ttone ie s tt be s tton, t t o y

t l n i h t e mitd S e ea, itrv Be k 23 F.d6 3 6 5( t Ci. 0 0
ol g s o p r te . e s ..M n e . c , 0 3 6 , 6 4h r 2 0 )
i
(e o nzn t tsaeha e sp tto sc n o rvieapeido lmiainta h dara y
r c g iig ha tt b a eiin a n t e v
ro f i tto h t a le d
e r )
xpied .
Equia et lngi a ia e o y i t hos r r i t nce whe e- duet cr lm sa es
t bl oli s val bl nl n t e a e nsa s r
t
o icz t nc
e e a t t pa t sown c
xtm l o he ry'
onduc - i woul beunc cona et e or et lmia i pe i
t t
d
ons i bl o nf c he i tton rod

a ans t ep rya d g o sij siewo l r s t'Ro ev. e 3 9F.d2 , 4 (t Ci.
g i t h a t n r s n u tc u d eul. us Le , 3 3 38 2 6 4h r
'

20 3 (qb n )(n en lq oainmakso te )(iigHarsv. thns n, 9F.d3 5
0 ) q a c itr a u tto r mitd ctn ri Hu c i o 20 3 2 ,
3 ( hCi. 00 :.Th s ap tto e mu t a ei e npt s i hsrg t dlg n l, r . .
30 4t r 2 0
u , ei n r s h v ç e z ung i ih s iie ty al .
i
b
r
d
s ee r or na y cr umsanc joo i hi wa 't pr ve tm e y flng. Hola v. orda
om xta di r ic t e t d n s y' o e nt i l ii
lnd Fl i ,

560U. 631 649 ( ) Peii rsl k ofkno e a l lpr es ort saut y
S. , 2010 . ttone ' ac
wldge bout ega oc s he tt or
dea i f f der lha asr i doe no s
dlne or e a be elef s t uppo tgr ntng s h e r or na y r le . H a s 209
r a i uc xt a di r e i f
ni ,

F.da 3 0 F rh nno e ld n tfn a ye ta r ia ycrl tnc si t sr c r ta
3 t 3 . u te r , o o i d n x ro dn r icz a e n hl e o d h t
ms
3

pr ve e Peii rfom slng atme ypeii n. See e. ,Unied St t sv.Sos ,364 F. 507,
e nt d ttone r
i
i l tto
. g. t
ae
a
3d

51 ( t Ci. 0 4 ( oi gt a p o. sau a di n r n eo t elw d e n tusiye utb e
2 4h r 2 0 ) n tn h t r K tt s n g o a c f h a o s o j tf q ia l
t lng ; r e v. o ns n, 7 F.d3 0 3 2(t Ci. 9 9 ( tn ta u fmiirt wihte
ol ) Tu n r J h o 1 7 3 9 , 9 5h r 1 9 ) noig h t n h laiy t h
i
lw d t il ea yo p oK sau d e no tl l tto p ro ) M o e v r Pei o rd e
a ue o ltr c r r tt s o g t o li ains ei d . r o e, tt ne o s
i
mi
i
note t bls aba i t e us hi t e yea de a i pur ui r le afe c e alege y f ie
sa ih s s o xc e s hr e r l y n s ng e if tr ouns l l dl a ld
t i ta ea a a t t Cour ofAppe sofVigni Ac r ngl Pe ii rfld hi f r l
o niit n ppe l o he
t
al
t i a. co di y, ttone ie s ede a
ha aspe ii n mor t n oneye rafe t c ci nsbec m efna ,Peii ri no e il t
be
tto
e ha
a tr he onvito
a
l ttone s t ntted o
eq tbl t lng,a t pe ii mus bedim is d.
uia e oli nd he tton
t
s se
111
.

Fort f eg ng r as ,Idimist peii f awrtofha asco pusa tm eba r d
he or oi e ons s s he tton or
i
be
r
si
re

purua t Rul 4oft RulsGoveni j225 Ca e .Ba e upo myfndi t tPeiine
s nt o e
he e
r ng
4 ss sd n
i ng ha tto r
ha no madet r quiie s t ntals wi ofa de alofac tt i lrg asr uie by
s t
he e st ubsa i ho ng
ni
önsi ona iht eq r d
m

2 U. C. 2 5 ( )a d Sa kv M c nil 5 9U. 4 3 48 ( 0 0 , c riiaeo
8 S. 5 2 3 c n lc . Da e, 2 S. 7 , 4 2 0 ) a etfc t f
a albiiy i de e
ppe a lt s nid.
ENTER:Thi
s

= da ofDe e r 201
y
c mbe , 6.

N.

'

t

S ni rUrie S a e DititJ
o lt d t t s src udg

4