Joyner v. Fleming et al

Filing 59

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/7/2018. (slt)

CL
ERK: OFFI t. . sT. UR'
GE 1S o1 K
AT ROANOK ,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT
N
TED
STRI

FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI GI A
CT
R NI
R O AN O K E D I SI N
VI O

#A ê3 2 1
t
28
J I ç.
UEA DUD , ERK

BY:

'

L K

K ENN ETH B W AN JO YN ER ,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

LESL I J.FL EM I G ,e al,
E
N
t .
Dee
f ndant .
s

Ci lA c i n N o.7: c 00486
vi t o
16- v-

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By:

H on. i hae F.U r
M c l
bans
ki

Chi fUhie St e Dit itJudge
e
t d at s s rc

Kenneh Bra J
t in oyne ,aVigi ai a epr e ng pr K ,c
r
r ni nm t oc edi
o
omm e d t sa to
nce hi c in

ptruantt 42U. C.j1 na hgnlmeoussafo t Vigi aDe me ofCor ci
zs
o
S. 983, mi z r tf f he r ni pe nt
re tons

(VDOC' a dt eW aln kig SaePrs n(C RS 'a d fnd n s Plitf alg st a hi
t
<
' n h le s d e tt io C P' s ee a t. anif le e h t s
)
W
)
a s gnm e t s c a housng and t co i c to ofhi pr pe t vi a e t Ei ht a
si
nt o pe i l
i
he nfs a i n
s o ry ol t d he g h nd

Foure nt Am e e t oft Unie St t sConsi i De e nt fl amoton f
te h
ndm n s he t d a e
tt on. f nda s ied
m
i or

sl r j g n , n Pli tf r s o e , kngt i matrrpef rds o iin. Aj
l
mmay ud me t a d anif e p nd d ma i hs te i o ip sto 1 ur
r vi wi t r c d,t c tgr n sDe e nt 'm oton a die t t m t fl a he mpto
e e ng he e or he our a t f nda s
i nd r c s he o ie not r i n

f rs mma yj d me ta de sn a dto l li .
o u r u g n d r sig d i na cams
i
1.
?
k.

Pl s n t VDOC Op rtngPr c d r (1 ' 8 .,çpe il u ig'a imaema
z ua t o
r
e ai o e u e ç ) 613 G ca Ho sn , n n t y
OP'
s
'
notbehed i pr - a i s gr ga i f l ngç t n t r ewordng da wiho af nna r vi w
l n e he rng e e ton or o r ha h e
l
ys t ut o l e e

b t el ttto a ClsiiainAu h rt (<CA' .OP 8 . as rq ie te1 t rviw te
y h nsi in l a sfc to t o i ç '
u
y 1 )
613 lo e u rs h CA o e e h
a opr a e s ofpr he rng s r ga i no l t rt n ffe da t r a t r OP 861. f rhe
ppr i t ne s
e- a i eg e ton
a e ha i ten ys he e f e .
3't r
u

1 aniffldamoint i o p rt pe iu l-i de hi t 3191 ( No 4 -)t hsrs o s i
Plitf ie
to o nc r oae rvo syfl x bi z G ECF . 52 o i ep n e n
e
s
oppostont Defndant'm oton.Thecour gr nt t m oi t t e e t e bisar us i s
ii o e
s
i
t a s he ton o he xtnt he xhi t e ed n uppor oft
t he

ag me t s e iial r ie i ters o s .S eUntdSae v Du k l9 7F.d9 5 95 (t Ci.1 91 (l dg s
ru ns p cfc l as d n h ep n e e i tts . n e, 2 2 5 , 6 7h r 9 ) &u e
y
e
c
aeno l epis h nigfrtute b re i bif.) C 'eSp caj dca s l i d wi whc adsrc c u t
r t i g , u tn o r f s uid n res'. sh s e ilu iil oi t e' t ih itit o r
k
l
' f
cu
h
s d viw ...pr . c plit doe notta f m t co tit anad t ' W ele v. e tofSoc.Se s,
houl e
o K om an s s
rnsor he ur n o
vocae.
'
lr D p'
rv v901

F.d38 3 1(t Ci. 9 ) seCla ic rv. De it5 5F.d3 4, 3 (t Ci. 0 )(e o ii apanif
2 7, 9 4h r 1 90; e o nn e Mc vt, 5 3 2 3 6 4h r20 9 rc r zng litf
cnn tu earso et amoinf rsmmayj d me toa n o c re thec mpan c aln e b temoin
a o s ep ns o to o u r u g n t me d r orc t o lit h le g d y h to
frs mmayj g n)
o u r ud me t.

r q ie t 1 t rv e t eimaesaj sme t ndb h vo e r nneyd y a d
e ur s he CA o e iw h n t ' du t n a e a ir vey i t a s n
rc
e omm e whehe t i t s d r m an i s gr ga i
nd
t r he nma e houl e i n e e ton.
On Nove r26,201 de e n Si o c r d Pl i ifwih G awd o Obs e Act
mbe
4, f nda t gm n ha ge àntf t d e
t
r c ne s
D i e t Tow a d ori t Pr s nce ofAno he ' f rm a t ba i i herpr s nc Pl i ifw a
r c ed
r
n he e e
t r' o
s ur tng n
e e e. a ntf s

ta f redt pr - rng s r to t ts m eda On De e be 2,201 whi wast ne
r ns e r o e hea i eg ega in ha n
y.
cm r
4, ch
he xt
busne sda t 1 r viwe Pli ifshousng sa a r omm e d he sa i pr hea i
i s y, he CA e e d antf
i t ms nd ec
nde
t y n e- rng
s r ga i .2
eg e ton

Si e da lt ron De mbe 18 201 aDHO de m e Pl i ifguly of( awd o
xten ys a e
ce r , 4,
e d antf it
Ge
t
r

Obs e Ac s' nd fne hi $1 00. TheI conve d t ts me da a ha Pli if
c ne t'a i d m 2. 3
CA
ne ha a
y nd d antf
a s g d t adm i s r tve s gr to
s i ne o
nit a i e ega i n.
The I r vi w e Pl i i fa i on Fe ua y 27,201 w hi h w a w ihi ni t da of
CA e e d a ntf ga n
br r
5, c
s t n ne y ys

t l s I he rng.The1 r commende t tPli ifga i s r ga i f al nge pe i d
he a t CA a i
CA e
d ha antf ty n eg e ton or o r ro

o sa l a j sme t
f tbe du t n .
TheI r conve d on J 3, 5, c wassx da pa tt ni t da pe i The
CA e
ne
une 201 whih
i ys s he ne y- y rod.
1 r omm e d t tPl i ifber l as d t a ge r lpopulton t ti s ewa a ia e
CA ec
nde ha antf
ee e o
ne a
a i mi f pac s va lbl .
Pl i ifm o d ou ofs gr t o on J m e 5,
a ntf ve t e ega i n
t
2015.
B.

Att tm ePli tf r eve t c r f G e orObs e Acs'heha bee a sgne
he i
a n if ec i d he ha ge or t wd
c ne t,'
d n si d

t W RSP' Gr ngStnda dVi aorHousngUni (d '.TheVHU' c r lng
o
S oomi a r olt
i
tt
VHU'
)
S ontoli
pr e te,OP 8 2, e r st ta VI U i aewho i f md guit ofatte orObs ne
oc dtr
64. r quie ha ny - nm t
I
s ot
ly
iawd
ce

2V DOC a W RSP sa fhada e ende Tha gi ng holda 9om Thur da ,N ove r27,untl
nd
tf
n xt d nks vi
i y
s y
mbe
i
M o y,Dec m ber1,201
nda
e
4.
3Deenda sW a de Flm i a Re onalOm buds Pont afim edt co c i ona al
f nt r n e ng nd gi
man
on fr
he nviton
ppe .

2

Ac s' ha geber m o d fom t VHU a pl edi s t ga i untls h tmehequaii d f
t'c r
e ve r he
nd ac n eg e ton i uc i
lfe or
a itnc i oge r populton orr ad itncei ot VHU.
dm ta e nt ne al
ai
e m ta
nt he
A fe Pl i ifw a t a f r e t pr he r ng s gr ga i s a fha t i nt y a pac
t r a ntf s r ns e r d o e a i e e ton, t f d o nve or nd k

Pl ntf' pe s lpr ry lf i t c l. Coli , ne ,a Si o we es ri Pli ifs
ai ifs r ona ope t e4 n he e l
lns Tur r nd gm n r o tng a ntf'
pr ry when t f md a t k t ta ar d t be ga r l t Si m on c icae t
ope t
hey ot rwor ha ppe e o
ng e aed. g
onfs td h:
a t r asc ta nd,a t a t k' diposton orl a i i lnknown.
rwo k
on r ba
nd he rwor s s ii
oc ton s l
Bef r bengho ed i s gr ga i Pli tf had o de e aholda f d pa kage kno
oe i
us n e e ton, a n if
r rd
i y oo c
, wn

asat c ePa ' Unfrunaeyf Pli if i a ve a trhewa ar a i s r gain,a a
s ur k.' o t tl or antf t ni d fe
se
s le dy n eg e to nd
Se ur Pak i notpe m it d i i p s gr a i ce l Be a e t co e soft Se tr Pa k
c e
s
r te ns de , e eg ton l. c us he nt nt
he c te r

we e de med pe iha e,saf i or d Pl i ift theha t ma a r ng m e swihi t ry
r e
rs bl t f nf me antf ha
d o ke ra e nt t n hit
da t m a li orha s e r tive i fom W RSP.Pli ifdi notac ompls et ro i n,
ys o i t
ve om one e re t '
r
a ntf d
c
ih ihe pto
a t Se ur PA wa c ic t d on J nua y 26,
nd he c e
s qnfs a e
a r
2015.
II.

Dee a t a g i t i moinf rsu r j d me t h t itrai,he aee tte t
fnd n s r ue n her to o tnma y u g n t a,n e la t y r nild o
qualfe i m uniy.4 A pa t i e tte t s mmayj dg n i t ep e d n s t d sl s d
ii d m
t
ry s nild o u . r u me t f h la i g ,he ico e

m a e i so fl a a a fda t s
t ral n ie, nd ny fi vis how t tt r i no ge ne d s east a ma e i lf t
ha he e s
nui iput
o ny t ra ac .

Fe R. v. 5 () t aeil a t'aet o efcsn c s ayt e tbiht ee n so a
d. Ci P. 6 a . û tra fcs' r h s a t e e s r o sa ls he lme t f
M

p ry' c u eo a to .And ro v. b ry Lo b e n .4 7U. 2 2, 48( 9 6 .A g n i
a t s a s f cin
es n Lie t b v l c, 7 S. 4 2 1 8 ) e une
diput ofm a e ilf c e ssi,i viwi t a s i ee de e a a lr as bl i e e s
s e
t ra a t xit f n e ng he dmi sbl vi nc nd 1 e ona e nf r nce

bD ee da salo a s r pas i ybha t y aeabs ut y i unefom da age f t i de sonsm a i
fn nt s s e t sngl t t he r
ol el mm
r
m s or her cii
de n
i tt tonaldici i r he ngsa a al. W he s e ng a olt i m uniy,agover e ofk i be sahea
nsiui
s plna y mi
nd ppe s
n e ki bs u e m
t
nm nt t al ar
vy

bur n ofde tai t tove rdi publcpolc c i r tonswara s h e ptonalpr e i De e nt
de
monsr tng ha ri ng i iy onsde ai
r nt uc xce i
otcton. f nda s

h v n t o es , n frhemoe t e d n t d rs Cla ia rv Sa n r 4 4U..1 3 2 60 (9 5, ihh l
a e o d n o a d ut r r,h y o o a des e vn e . x e, 7 S 9 , 0 -7 1 8 )whc ed
t tprs ofk i sivol i dicplnar de sonsa ee il t q lfe nota ol e,i uniy, orqua i
ha ion t al n ved n s i i y cii r ntted o uaiid,
bs ut mm t f
s-

j iil u cins Co e u nl,h c u t o sd r wh te d fn a t aee tte t q ai e , n n ta oue
udca fn to . nsq e ty te o r c n ies eh r ee d ns r nild o u lid a d o bs lt,
t
i m uniy.
m
t

dr wn t e r i alghtm os f vor bl t t nona her fom n i
t a a e o he
movi pary,ar a ona ef c -i rc d
ng t
e s bl a tfnde oul

rt naveditfrt no mova .J= Themovi pa t ha t bur nofs ng- çha i,
eur
r c o he n- nt #.
ng ry s he de
howi s t s
t
poi tng outt t di ti tco t t tt r i a a e ofe de e t s
ni
o he s r c ur - ha he e s n bs nce vi nc o uppo tt nonm ovi
r he
ng

p ry sc s . Ceo e Co . Cart, 7 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 6 .l t emo a tstsisti
a t' a e' ltx p v. tet 4 7 S. 7 3 5 1 8 ) f h v n aife h s
'
bur n, he t non- o ntm us s tf t s c fc f t t tde ons r t t e s e ofa
de t n he
m va
t e orh pe ii ac s ha m t a e he xit nce

ge nediput offctf til d.t322- A c r mayno rs veds t f t,weght
nui s e a or ra.L=a
24. ou t
t e ol ipued acs i he
e de ,ormakede e m i tonsofc e biiy.Rus e lv.M ir
vi nce
t r na i
r di lt
sl
c odyneCor ,65F. 1
p.
3d 229,1
239

( t Ci. 9 5 ; o e e v Mu p v, 9 F.d 1 9 1 2( t Ci.1 8 ) nse d ac u t c e t a
4h r 1 9 ) S s b e . r h 7 7 2 7 , 8 4h r 9 6 .I ta , o r a c ps s
tuet e de eoft non- o ngpa t a r s l sa1i e na co lc sa i e e esi t
r he vi nc
he
m vi
ry nd e o ve l ntr l nfit nd nf r nc n he

n n mo n p ry sfvo .Ch r o n c sd Frnc v. mih 5 7F.d40 , 4 (t Ci. 9 9 .
o - vig a t' a r ab n a e e a e S t , 9 2 6 41 4h r 1 7 )
Ho v r (mlr t u p re s c lto . .sn te o g S d fa as mmayj d me t
we e ,t e e ms p o td pe u ain . i o n u h o e e t u r u g n
g
moin. En i v. tl sno Bus & Ed c Ra is n .5 F.d5 , 2(t Ci.1 9 )
to ' n s Na' As' f . u . do l c, 3 3 5 6 4h r 9 5 .
'
A gove n ntof ils di a i viua ca ciyvi j 1 ma i kequaiid
r me fca ue n n ndi d l pa t a 983 y nvo
lfe

i ni .Co p rv. h e a , 3 F.d 1 3 1 8(t Ci. 01 )(ii M ic el Fo s t 47
mmu t
y o e S e h n 7 5 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 3 ctng th l v. rvh, 2
U. 51 , 2 ( 9 5 ) S d crn o q aiidi ni taa c st i o tn itr sste
S. 1 5 6 1 8 ).' o ti e f u lfe mmu t b ln e wo mp ra t n ee t-h
The
y
nee t hol publcof a sa ountbl whe t y e r s powe ir ponsbl a t ne d t
do d
i fcil cc a e
n he xe cie
r res i y nd he e o
s e d ofi i s f o ha as m e ,di t a to a la lt w he t pe f m t i dutes
hi l t c al r m r s nt sr c i n, nd i biiy
n hey r or he r i

r a o a l ' S t v Rà , 1F.d9 ,1 0(t Ci. 1 )( u tn Pe ro v Calh n, 5
e s n by.' mih . y 78 3 5 0 4 h r 20 5 q oi g as n . la a 5 5
'
U. 223,231(
S.
2009).TheG ii i
)
t fed mmuniyanaysst c lyi vest i re :( )
qual
t l i ypial nvol wo nquiis 1
whehe t pl nifha e tbls dt vi ai ofac tt i lrght a ( whehe t t
t r he aitf s sa ihe he olton
onsiutona i , nd 2) t r ha
r ghtw a c e r y e t bls d a t tm e oft a l ed vi a i ' R a v.Ca pbe l 785 F.
i
s l a l s a ihe t he i
he leg
ol ton.
' ub
m
l,
3d

876,881( hCi. ) s eI r Ale 1 F. 58 593( hCi.1997 (GA) ofca ma
4t r 2015 ; e n e ln, 06 3d 2, 4t r
) çg n fiil y
cl i qualf e i m uniy a l a hi a tons a e no c e ry es a i he t be be nd t
am
ii d m
t s ong s s c i
y t l a l t bls d o
yo he
4

b u aiso h sd sr to r a t rt ' .A S olt ya d e st e et q e to si t o d r
o nd re f i ic einay uho i ' ç t ma d r s h s wo u sin n he r e
y.) c r
. . .

t twilbes f c lt t t f ra efi i n diposton ofe h c e. Esa eofAr tong v.
ha l t a iiae he ai nd fc e t s ii
ac as ' tt
'
msr

Vil o Pi h rt 81 F.d8 2 8 8(t Ci. 01 )(n en lq tto ma k o te ) A
l. f ne u s, 0 3 9 , 9 4h r 2 6 itr a uoain r s mitd .
plitf' cam E u vv ssz r j d me t h we e, ny i (h c u t a we ljb t
anifs li l r ie l
s
mmay u g n , o v r o l f te o rj ns rs oh
que to i t a fr tve. I
si ns n he fima i ' d.
'
111.

Plitf d saifcin wihtea j d c to o t ei siuin lc ag a dtetmes e t
anifs is tsa to t h du iain f h n ttto a h t e n h i p n
i s gr t o i plc t s t Due Pr s Cl us oft Fouree h A m e m e .5 The c r fnds
n e ega i n m i a e he
oce s a e he
t nt
nd nt
ou t i

t a De e d n saee tte t q ai di nt a ds mma yj d me tf rte ecams
h t fn a t r n ild o u lfe mmu i n u r u g n o h s li .
y
To sa ea d pr es c am ,a i t m us s
tt ue oc s l i n nma e
t how t thewa de i d ofG ie lbe t or
ha
s prve
G f , i ry,
l

P o ry'byg v r me tl cin.Be rt v S t , 20F.d5 0 5 2( t Ci.1 9 ) W he a
r pe t ' o e n na a to
veai . mi 1 ) 0 , * 4h r 9 7 . n
h
0
di c plna y pe ly doe notca e a i a e' or gi ls nt nc t be e nce pr t t d
s i i r na t
s
us n nm t s i na e e e o
nha d, o ec e
i e e t a e ge r l lm ie t f e dom f om r s r i tt ti pos a y c a s g fc nt
nt r s s r ne aly i t d o r e
r
e t a n ha m es t pi al nd i nii a

ha ds p on t i ae i r l to t t o di r i de sofprs lf Se Sa n v.Co me ,
r hi
he nm t n e ai n o he r na y nci nt
ion ie. e ndi
r r

51 U. 47 48 ( 9 5 ( ligt tds i iay s ge ai nddn t r s n tetp o
5 S. 2, 4 1 9 ) hodn ha icpl r e r g to i o p e e t h y e f
n
ay ia, infc n d p iaini wh c asaemih c e t al ryitr s) Un e st imae
tp c lsg iia t e rv to n ih tt g t r ae i t n ee t. ls he n t
be
pr sde i to ofapr e t d i e e t hehasno f de a rg t pa tc a pr e tons See
ove prvai n
ot c e ntr s,
e r l i ht o riulr ot c i .

Supei e nt Mas Cor.l t v.Hil41 U. 445,454( 985 (ubsantver quie ntf
rntnde s s. r ns. l, 2 S.
1 ) s t i e rme or

5Pl ntf r pe e y i
ai if e atdl nvokest lbe Sdelbe aei fe e ,'whihi atr ofa tr ltngt cam s
he a l s i r t ndifr nce ' c s e m
r eai o li
a ii unde t Eiht Am e m en ' pr hi to ofc ue a unus punihm en ofp ione s Se eg.Fmn rv.
rsng
r he g h
nd ts o biin r l nd
ual s
t rs r . e. . , ne

Brl n 5l U. 8 5 8 8( 9 4 .Th c u t e l e t c n tu t u hacam bae meeyo telb l'ei rt
ema , 1 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ) e o r d ci s o o src s c li sd rl n h a e l l ae
n
d be
i fe e e' ndi t a e ofa pe tne f c t co d bec i r d i s ppo o t tcam. Se ea.
ndifr nc 'a n he bs nce ny ri nt a t hat ul
onsde e n u rt f ha li
e. . ,

Be u et Civo Ha tn 7 5F.d1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci.1 8 )(e o nzn l ea c n tu to do sn t a
a d tv. t f mpo , 7 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 9 5 rc g iig i r l o srcin e o me n
b
c ut mu t oj r u q eto sne e s u rl p ee td .
o rs s c nu e p u sin v r q aey rsne )
5

prs n dicplnepr e ngsi iai t DuePr s Clus ) W of v. c nnel418U.
io s i i oce di mplc tng he
oces a e; lf M Do l,
S.

5 9 5 6( 9 4 (n a o tp o e u a r q rme t)
3 , 5 1 7 ) sme b u r c d r l e uie ns.
Neihe Pl i ifssa i s r to f ra pr m ael sx mont nort $1 00 fne
t r antf t y n eg egai n o p oxi t y i
hs
he 2. i
i ia esi e esspr e t d byt DuePr e sCl e.Pl i iff ist e tbls t tt fne
mplc t nt r t ot c e
he
oc s aus
antf al o sa ih ha he i
i
mpos d a aypi ala sgnii a ha ds p on hi i c
e n t c nd i fc nt r hi
m n ompa io t t or na y i i nt o
rs n o he di r ncde s f
pr s lf . Se .e. , e r o v. i c ni N o.7: 7- vi on i e e c. H nde s n V r i a,
0 c 266,
2008 U . D it LEX I 5230,a
S. s .
S
t

* 3 2 0 W L 20 48 , t* 0( . Va J n. 3 2 08 (idnga$1 fn ddn tp s a
3,08
4 0 a 1 W D. . a 2 , 0 ) fn i
2 ie i o o e n
a ypi a a s gnii a ha ds p on t pl i tf i c pa i o t t or na y i de sofpr s
t c l nd i f c nt r hi
he a n if n om r s n o he di r nci nt
i on

l e , f', 7 F. p' 2 4(t Ci. 0 ) seas W a h es v W i tn, 3 F.d 1 9 1 5
i ) afd 2 2 Ap x 6 4 h r 2 08 ; e lo s lfke . nso 2 4 3 7 , 8
f
(t Ci. 0 0 ( ic si gt elmie itts al n t h si at s a c u t.Lie s ,
4h r 2 0 ) ds u sn h i td n ee t ri mae a n nzt c o n) k wie
Pli iff ist des rbehow Vigi àc e t d apr t c e lbe t i e e tt a d s gr ga i a
antf a l o c i
r ni r a e
o e t d i ry ntr s o voi e e ton t
W R SP a how hi c as ii a i a s gr a i a W R SP wer a ypi alors gnii a .
nd
s l sf c ton nd e eg ton t
e t c
i f c nt

Se . ..S ndn 51 U. a 48 . e as F e ma v Rie u , 0 F.d 9 , 51( Ci.1 8 )
e eg, a i, 5 S. t 4, e lo r e n . d o t 8 8 2 49 9 2d r 9 6
s
( odngt a acam o af leds iln r c r ec n o s r ea t b ssf rac nsi to a
h li h t li f as icp iay hag a n t ev s he a i o o t u in l
t
cam) CAl mi srtv s g e aini t es r o c n e n t a imae s udra o a y
li . ç d nitaie e rg to s h o t f o fn me t h t n ts ho l e s n bl
l
a i i t r c vi a s e po nti t i i a c a i ' H e itv.Hel s 459 U . 460,468
ntc pa e e ei ng t om
i n he r nc r er ton.
' wt
m , . S.

( 983) Cha sEi aprs ne ' l ai vaito ofdal r i ,c nge i co tonsof
1 . nge ln io rs oc ton, rains iy outne ha s n ndii

c n i e n (n ldngé mi itaies g e ain , ndt ed n a o p i ie e grjmatr
o fn me t icu i d nsrtv e r g to ) a h e il f rvlg s aé tes
whih e r prs rc na i paelndwhihja ec e ae byhi orgi s ne et
c vey ione a ntci t a
c r ontmpltd
s i nal e tnc o

p io ' Ga tnv. v o , 4 F.d3 0 3 3( t Ci.1 91.
rs n. so Ta l r 9 6 2 4 , 4 4h r 9 )
'
;
I i notdi put t ts a fe e ded tm e i s tby OP 861 3 f va i c as ii a i
ts
s ed ha t f xc e
i lnes e
. or r ous l s f c ton
r vi w s H ow e r Pl i iff ist e t bls how t bre de ays e n i vi a i VD O C polc
e e .
ve , a ntf a l o s a i h
he i f l , ve f ol tng
i y,
i plc t f de a due pr e spr t c i . Se Ri i v.Ct ofFaif x, A . 907 F. 1 9,1
m iae e r l
oc s o e tons e cc o
y.
ra V ,
2d 45 469
6

( hCi.1 )( l ngacam t prs ofi asha notf l dt rown i pe n
4t r 990 hodi
li hat ion fcil ve olowe hei
nde nde t
polcisorpr ed e as doe notsaeaconsiutonalcam) c I ma v.Stri 7 lF.
ie
oc ur s lo s tt
tt i
li ; f nol a ilnc, 9 3d
51 5 ( h Ci. 5)( di at nt rco i me ti sgr toni i t albe t
7, 20 4t r 201 hol ng we pyea nfne n n e egai mplcaed i ry
itr t.
nees)
Pl i ifsal ga i t tprs n ofi i si e i ly orneglge l de i d hi ofhi
4ntf ' le tpns ha io fcal ntntona l
i nty prve m
s
pr pe t i c r ve i ofpolc o c t do notsa eat c tt i c am i am e ni f l
o ry n onta nton
iy r usom
tt l onsiutonal l i f
y
n ng u

po td p iainrme y i a ia l f rt el s Hud o v. l r 4 U. 51 , 3 ( 9 4 ;
s- e rv to e d s valbe o h os. s n Pame, 68 S. 7 5 3 1 8 )
Par tv. y o , 51U.. 2 , 3 - 9( 9 ) o er ldL ir lv n p r kyDa esv. i ims
rat Ta lr 4
S 5 7 5 8 3 1 81, v rue q ree a t a t
nil W l n ,
l
47 U.. 2 , 3 - ( 98 ) Plitf a ap td prv to rme yt e Vignalw,h
4 S 3 7 3 0 31 1 6 . an ifh s os- e iain e d md r r i i a t e
VignaTo t amsAc (VTCA' .Se Va Co ej801 1 5. ç e to 1 8 wa itn e t
r i i r Cli
t$
&
' e . d . - 9 3. ç cin 9 3 s n e d d o
)
s
pr t c onl f r lr ght gua a e by f de all w ,a nott t a m s f whi h t r a e
o e t y ede a i s r nt ed
e r a nd
or cl i or c he e r

a e u t rme isu e saelw. W rg t Col , 6 F.d8 , 4 (t Ci. 98 )
d q ae e d e nd r tt a ' ih v. li 7 6 2 41 8 9 4h r 1 5 .
'
ns
Thee o e Pli ifcamotpr valwihaco tt ina cli t rj1 3agans VDOC
rf r , antf r
e i t
nsiuto l am mde 98 i t
ofii l bas d on t alege pr ry l si t sc s .
fc as e
he l d ope t os n hi a e
Pli iff ulsman de e nt f t i pa tc pai i orr pons st ad i sr tve
antf a t
y f nda s or her rii ton n es e o m nitai

r medi orf al da t o o s i byt i s di ts Ho ve,la lt unde j 1
e es or lege cs r misons her ubor nae . we r ibiiy r 983
ma notbepr i a e on t t o y ofr s ndea s ro .M onel v. p' ofSoc Sews,
y
ed c t d
he he r
e po
t upe i r
l De t
. l .436

U. 6 , 6 n., 919 ( 9 ) Ba n r v M ao e 26 F.d2 8 2 5( t Ci. 0 )
S. 58 6 3 7 6 - 4 1 78 ; y ad . ln , 8 3 2 , 3 4h r 2 01.
Fur he
t nnor ,Pl i ifdoesnotha a c tt i
e a ntf
ve ons iutonalrghtt a ce sad i s r tve r m e es
i o c s m ni t a i e di .

Bo k rv. . De to Con, 5 F.d5 3 5 ( t Ci. 1 ) Ada v Rie 4 F.d7 7
o e SC. p' f t' 8 5 3 3 , 41 4h r 20 7 ; ms . c , 0 3 2, 4
.
(t Ci.1 9 ) Mo e ve,s )s p ro ' atrt -a td na o agiv nc Errs n et a
4 h r 9 4 . ro r Ga u e irs fe-hefc e il f re a e o epo s o
g
lte)f l frs to esa ihi j1 la lt ' pa av.Ra No. 1 v001 201
etr als a hor f tbls ng 983 ibiiy.'De ol
y, 7:2c 39, 3

U. DitLEXI 1 71 2, t* 3 2 3W L 4 1 6 a * ( . Va J l 2 , 01 )( r e t
S. s.
S 1 8 a 2 , 01
45 23 , t 8 W D. . uy 2 2 3 Sag n ,
7

M .. (iigBr o sv. ad 1 7F. p' 9 , 25(r Ci. 0 6 ) Ac o dngy Dee d n s
J) ctn o k Be r , 6 Ap x 23 9 3d r 2 0 ). c r i l, fn a t
aee t ldt q aiidi
r ni e o u lfe mmunt a ds mmayj g n f rt e ecams
t
i n u r ud me t o h s li .
y
IV .

Two t num e a e c am sa a i t t r m e 'a tc e t t n nde c
me
r t d l i ppe r n he t pl nt' ta hm nt o he me d ompli
a
ant
t Def nda sha notye a e s Pl i ifct st Fouree h Ame
hat e nt ve
t ddr s ed. antf ie he
t nt
ndme ' Equa
nts
l
Pr t c i Cl us a a g st thewa te t d dif r nty t n ot i a e i t VHU .
o e ton a e nd r ue ha
s r a e fe e l ha her nm t s n he
Spe ii aly,Pl i ifal gest tt o he i m a e ,o ofwhom wasguit alo guit oft wd
c fc l antf le ha he t r n t s ne
ly s
ly te
orObs neAc s'ha bee s e t d i pr he rng de e i a trPl i ifbutwasr l a ed
ce
ty' d n egr ga e n e a i
t nton fe antf
ee s
e rirand diecl ba k i o t VHU , r sPl i ifwa dea ne l ra r e ed i o
a le
r ty c nt he
whe ea antf s ti d onge nd elas nt
a i sr tve s r ga i Pl n ife anst tt sal d dipa a ete t ntr s t dbe a e
dm nita i eg e ton. aitf xpli ha hi lege s r t r a me e ule c us

ç o o y rle h gjbe nc mpli ige c pt Pli tfls gtfqwl s g igt rla e
c b d es j ad e o ann x e ( anif, o sa t a j on o ee s
n

P litflls. Thec u ti r lyc n tu st i s c n alg to a artlai ncam pls a t
anit at'
'
o r l al o sr e h s e o d le aln s eaito li t u n
be
r
t Bo k rv. o t Cao iaDe a t n o Cor cin , 5 F.d5 3 5 ( t Ci. 01 )
o o e S u h r ln p rme t f re to s 8 5 3 3 , 41 4h r 2 7 .
Pt s a tt S a dn Or e 2 3 6 Dee d n ss al ieamoinf rs mmayj dg n
l u n o tn ig d r 01 - , fn a t h lfl
r
to o u r u me t
s p re b afd v ts a d e sn t s t rmann cams
u po td y fi a it) d r sig hee wo e iig li .
V.
Fort f e ng r a ons t co tg a t i pa tPl i if sm oton t i or r t e bis
he or goi e s , he ur r n s n r a ntf
i o nc po a e xhi t ,

g a t De e d n s moinf rs mmayj d me t a dd rcsDee a t t fl amoi nfr
rn s f n a t' to o u r u g n , n ie t fnd ns o ie
to o
s mmayj d me t u p re b afd vi s ta a d e s st ee ua p o e to a rtlain
u r u g n s p o td y fia t ) h t d r se h q l r tcin nd eaito
t
cl m s.
ai

s h y
y
EN TER : Thi 7t da of M a , 2018.

1

@

@'
+

.

*
'
'kw.# -A
i z,
l
'*

&
1r.t .'4 -'.
' i: .
.
. l 1 4' '
t

ç

'

-' ! ' .''
1 '
.
.'

Chi fUnied St t i ti tJ
e
t
a eeD sr c udge
8

. *4 '<9
.
.i C '
J