White v. Duffield Regional Jail

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/19/2016. (tvt)

CL 'OF I U. DIXCOU '
ERKS FCE S. S
1
AT ROANOKE,
,
VA
.j
.
uuo

2E2 1S 2 1
26
I THE UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI SION
VI
TO BY A LEX AN D ER W H I
TE,

JUL '. U
I %
BY:
W

r
C

CA SE N O .7:
16CV 00531

Pl ntf ,
ai i f
V.

M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N
M

DUFFI
ELD REGI
ONAL JM L,

By: Gl n E.Conra
e
d
C hi fU nie St e D i t c Judge
e
t d at s s ri t

D e endant
f
.

To y Alx nd rW ht,a Vignaj i imae p o e dn p o . ,fld ti cvlrg t
b e a e ie
r ii al n t r c e ig r K ie h s i i ih s
a to u d r4 U.. j 1 8 ,algng d nilo a s e ild e t alvae so c to bl.
cin n e 2 SC. 9 3 le i e a f p ca it o le it tma h r u e
'

Upon r viw oft r c d, heco tfndst tt a ton mus be sl a iy dim is
e e
he e or t
ur i ha he c i
t lmm rl s s ed.

W hie' algai i hi j198 compli a es re:
t s le tons n s
3
ant r pas

I rq e td a s ca de tgl b c u e (1 a h vgn q p o lms wi my
e u se
pe il it ray e a s 1 m a i g r b e
t
h
so c a d h ve b e d ng d a y me ia te t n . I n silha i )
t ma h n a e n e i ) n
e
dc l r ame t
m tl. vl
ng
so c p o lmsa d h v b e l d t b t saf I sae i t e ilrue
t ma h r b e n a e e n i o y he tf. t tt s n h lr g l)
e
book t ts ciltlq aeonl rceved frrlgi o me c pur e ,a
ha pe a rays r y e i o ei on r dial pos s nd
IG e b e d n e t a.
gv l e n e id h t
( mp .2,ECF No.1) W ht s e G dc la d fn n il'rle i ti a to a d to b
Co l
.
i e ks l ia n ia ca' eif n h s cin n é e
e
me
t
mo e t p io . (d.
v d o rs n' 1 )
'
The c t i r quie t dim is any a ton or cai fl d by a prs
our s e r d o s s
ci
l m ie
ioner a i t a
ga ns

gove m e ale iy orof e i t c tde e mi t a ton o c am i fi o ,malc ous
m nt ntt
fc r f he our t r nes he c i r l i s rvol us
ii ,

o fist saeacam o whihrle ma beg a td.28U.. j1 5 b ( ) A &rv lu '
r al o tt li n c eif y rn e
SC. 91 A( )1. l i oo s'
f
c am i onet tGlc a a gua ebasset ri lw o i f t' Net kev.W iln ,490 U.
li s
ha ta ks n r bl
i ihe n a r n ac .
' iz
li ms
S.

31 , 2 , 2 ( 9 9 (nep ei llvoo s'nf r rv rino 28U. C. 1 5 d )
9 3 5 3 7 1 8 ) itrr t ii l u 'i o me e so f
ng f
S. j 91 ( ).
Sec i 1 3 pe m is a a i ve pa t t fl a c vi a ton a ns a pe s n f ac i ns
ton 98 r t n ggr e d r y o i e i l c i gai t
r o or to

tke t rc orofsat lw t tvi a e hi c tm to lrght.Se Coo rv.She han,735
a n mde ol
t e a ha olt d s onsi i na i s e
pe
e

F. 153,158 (t Ci.201 ) Theonl e iy t tW hienn sa adef ntt hi j 1
3d
4h r 3 .
y ntt ha
t me s
enda o s 983

..

camsi tej i is l.Th ji, o ve, sn taE e s n's b e tt s i u d rj 1 8 .M c y
li s h altef e alh we r i o s r o ' u j c o ut n e 9 3 co
p
v.Ch sp a e Co r Ce tr 7 8 F.S p .8 0.8 3 9 ( D.Va 1 9 )( dngj i i me
e a e k r. n e, 8
u p 9 , 9 - 4 E.
. 9 2 fn i al mmt
fo s i a dn tap ro f r r o e o j 1 8 ) Se as As r f v.q l 5 6U. 6 2 6 6
r m ut n o es n o pu p s s f 9 3 . e lo hco t Iba, 5 S. 6 , 7
( 0 9 ( ( p an ifmu tp e dt a e c Go en n - f a d fn a t t r u ht eo fca'
2 0 ) :A1 litf s la h t a h v r me tot l ee d n , h o g h fiils
1
ki
own i vi a tons ha vi ae t Consiuin.). Bec us ' hie fis t sae f t
ndi dual ci , s oltd he
tt to '
a e W t al o tt acs

rg r n a to s t ta y pa t ua j i o lca u d ro k i voain o l s c nsi in l
e adig cin ha n ri lr al fiil n eto n ilt f a o tmt a
c
o
i
o
rg t, ht' c mp an prs n sn lg l rf cu l a i f racam a to beu e j1 8 .
ih s W ies o lit e e t o e a o a ta b ss o li cina l nd r 9 3

Fo t e sae ra o t e c t' wils
r h ttd e s n, h out l ummaiy ds s ti a to wi u p eu ie
rl imis h s cin t t rj dc ,
ho
l e hi
pls a t oj 1 5 b () a fi lu . A na p o raeorderwilent rt sday
t u n t 91 A()1 , s rvoo s1
r
p r p it

.

The Clr i die t d t s nd c es of t s me or ndum o ni a a c pa ng
ek s rce o e
opi
hi m a
pi on nd c om nyi
or rt pli tf .
de o a n if

E E T l Na ooee e,06
NT R: us h y r cmbr21.
Chif nie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

1 I a y e e t W ht' c re talg to sd n tsaea yc n ttt na cam ato a l t e 51 3
n n v n, i s urn l ain o o tt n o siui l li cin be mdr 98
e
e
o
agans a
i t nyone. He doe notsae fct s ng a s rousmedi lnee f rteame ori c tng a hi mor
s
tt a s howi
ei
ca d o r t nt ndiai nyt ng
e

ta hsdsge me twi tej i' me ia safa o t eh ras e ilde i n c sayo a p o raetet n
h n i ia re n t h als dc l tf b u wh te p ca it s e esr r p rp it rame t
h
t alvaehsalge so c df ute . Se Esel v Ga l,4 U. 9 ,1 2 (9 6 (odn ta o y a
o le it i l d tma h isc lis e tle . mbe 29 S. 7 0 1 7 ) h lig h t nl
e
p io ot a' d l eae idifrn et imaessro sme ia ned voae teEihhAme d n) Th
rsn fkils ei rt n fee c o n t' eiu dc l e s ilts h g t
b
n me t. e
deieaeidfee e sa d r isno stsid b .,.meeds ge me tc n enn tqu sin o me c l
l rt n ifrnc tn ad t t aife y
b
i
r ia re n o cr ig lleto s f dia
j d me t' Geman v S e rn 5 F. p' 3 2 3 5(t Ci. 01 )(n u ls e )(u t Rusel Sh fe,
u g n,' r i - h ai, 31 Ap x 9 , 9 4h r 2 3 u p bih d q oi
'
.
ng s lv. efr
5 8F.d31 , 9(t Ci.1 759 S eas Bo i v Go wi 5 1F.d4 , (t Ci.1 7 )(idn ta i
2 2 8 31 4h r 9 2. e lo wrnc . d n, 5 2 4 48 4h r 9 7 tn ig h t n
c tt ina cam r ga di prs me c c r ,tt e s nta ts i o ofme c nec st a notsmpl t t
onsiuto l li e r ng ion dial a e the s e il e t s ne
dial esiy nd
i y ha

whihma b c n iee meeyd srbe'.
c y e o sd rd rl eia l'
)
2