Mosley v. Kittrell

Filing 24

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/19/2017. (mlh)

ekR:K' A C;M,4 PIT GQlR
8 OFFI
. e . 2Y
TDANVI VA
I
AKI
FIED
L

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E D I SIO N
W
LAR R Y D O N N ELL M O SLEY ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
'

J 18 2 1
UL 1 û?
J
UL
BY;
D

u L

,c

E

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00538
vi t on
16- v-

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
A .0 .K I
TTR ELL,
D ef
endant
.

By:

H o Jac on L . i e
n. ks
K sr
Seni U nied St esD i t ctJudge
or
t
at
s ri

Lan' DonnelM ose aVigi ai aepr e ngpr K ,c
y
l
ly, r ni nm t oce di
o
omm e edt scvi rg s
nc hi i l i ht

a to pu s ntt 42U. C.j1 nn ngDee tvçA.0. trl oft Lync gPolc
cin rua o
S.
983, mi
tci
Kitel he
hbur ie
De rme a t s ede e nt Pl ntf al ge t tKitelsf l ewrte saeme c us d
pa t nt s he ol f nda . ai if le s ha tr l' a s itn t t nt a e
Pl ntf obec c e a i a ce a e i vi ai oft Eq lPr t to a Due Pr s
ai ift
onvit d nd nc r r t d n ol ton he ua o eci n nd
oce s

i o s s , o c antf
clus soft Fo te h Am e m e t1 Kitelil amoton t dimi s t whi h Pli if
a e
he ure nt
nd n . tr l ed
r po d, a ng t sm al rrpe f diposton.A fe r vi w i t c pl i ,1g a t
es nde m ki hi te i or s ii
t r e e ng he om a nt r nt he

moint ds s a d ds s t ec mplitwi o t rj dc .
to o imis n imis h o an t u p eu ie
h
1.

Plitf ag e t a Km r l' alg d yf lesae n wa t ed fee c b t e aj r
an if r u s h t els le e l as ttme t s h ifrn e ewe n u y
fndi Pli ifg ly ofs c de è mur rand fndi hi et ri e o guit ofa
i ng a ntf uit
e ond gr e de
i ng m ihe nnoc nt r ly
ls e i ude ofe e Pl i ifa lgest tt f lesa e e tdesr
e s r ncl d f ns . antf le
ha he a s tt m n
toyed a c e bl a tmpt
ny r di e te
f rhi t a gues l- f ns Pl i ife a r t :
o m o r
e fde e e. antf lbo aes

Se ea frtrs o d r h d n r e whl g an it a dt evci wee sil
v r l is e p n e s a ri d ie plitfl n h itm r tl
v
pr e i t a me . Ofi e Pa a a Ofi rRa r z we et fr ti
es nt n he pm nt fc r vi nd fce mie
r he is n
t a rm e . O o ce Rn i e t k phot of t s e be or m e c l
he pa t nt
r m r z oo
os
he c ne f e di a

p ro a (i)b g n mo i go atndngt t vci Th s p oosce ry
e s n l sc e a v n r te i o he itm. e e h t lal
de c w ha w a f r tobs r e by fr tr s
pi t t s i s
evd
is e ponde sa vi
r ni ng.
Eac fr t r s
h is e ponde ga t A .0 .K it e la s a e e of wha t y obs r
r ve o
tr l t t m nt
t he
e ved
1Pl ntf notst he,K itel a t vitm a ealblc m e a ague t tt pr e t cl si
ai if e hat
tr l5 nd he ci r l a k n nd r s ha he otced as s

çrmia s s cs' CfBel lCo p v Two y, 5 U.. 4 , 5 (0 7 ; i dS ae v. msrng 5 7
t i n l upe t. . lAt. r . . mbl 5 0 S 5 4 5 5 2 0 )Unt tts Ar to , 1
c
'
e
U.. 5 , 65(9 6 .
S 4 6 4 19 )

u o nrv l Boh ( an i la dvitm we eprs n a te arve A.
p n ria . t Plitf n ci r e e t s h y ri d. 0.
f
Kitela v d a tr( anif a d vci h db e r mo d A.0. Kitel
trl ni e fe Plitfj n itm a e n e ve .
t l
r
ne r s t vi tm i t a rm e t The fr t r s nde s saeme s
ve aw he ci n he pa t n .
is e po r ' t t nt
obvi l m ac whatt phot s
ousy th
he
os how.
I s t of t frt r s
n pie
he is e ponde s sa e e s a t phot , A.0. Kitel
r ' tt m nt nd he
os
tr l
pr ee d t s ult as t wha mus ha occ r d, co r ditng fr t
oc de o pec a e
o
t
t ve
ure
nta c i is
rs
e ponde s a phot e de e D e ec i A .0 .K i tel w a t fr tt s y,
r nd
o vi nc . t tve
tr l s he is o a
tfhe vitm was f md by fr t r ponde s l ng on s a cove e by t
i'
ci
ot
s es
r yi
of ,
rd
he
br
own blnke ' Alo s yi Grhe vitm ha t be cove e by t bl nke
n t' s a ng, l
ci
d o
rd
he a t

wh n h wa s o ' Thi ao ed sr y dt Plitm ' sl- ee s cam.
e e s h i' s ln e to e he an i s efd fn e li
Th jly c ul n tpo sb efn s l d fn ei t e beiv d ta te vci
e t o d o sil id ef ee s f h y l e h t h itm
r
e
wa hepls l l ng down wr pped i abl rke .
s l e sy yi
a
n al t
The pr ec i r le upon t s t s i ony a e de ,pl t tof Roy C.
os uton e i d
hi e tm
nd vi nce us ha

Da s t s c egqmur rçon ci
vi,o e ur a de viton.
Pli tf e anst tt Kite lsal ge f le sae e wasi p o aed i o t
a n if xpl i ha he tr l' le d a s tt m nt
nco r t nt he
ofii li si tver or t twa us t s tr t c ci Pl i ifal gest tt f le
fc a nve tgai ec d ha s ed o ecle he onviton. antf le ha he as
sa e e twa no hi m or t n Kitel' s c ai n.Pl i ifa ksa r i ft t1o de t
t t m n s t ng
e ha tr ls pe ulto
antf s s ele ha r r ç
a
r ta ton oft sa e nt' nd a r ç m pe a in ...f rc t' nd punii da
erci
he t t me 'a wa d ç
co ns to
o os'a
tve mage .
s
Stt co tr cor r ve lt tt Cic tCo tofLy hbtr e e e Pl ntf c i nal
a e ur e ds e a ha he r ui ur
nc lg nt r d ai ifs rmi

j d me t o mt d ro S p e e 7 201 ,nCo n at v. r l, 5 0 2 - 0
u g n f r l e n e tmb r , 6 i mmo we 1 DomelCR1 0 0 010 .
r
h
TheCour ofAppeasofVigi a de ed a a
t
l
r ni ni n ppea on M a 1 201 i Donnelv.
l
y 2, 7, n
l

Co n at , . 5 9 1 - , n Plitf smo inf rtrej d ep ne rmansp n i
mmo we 1h No CR1 3 - 6 3 a d an if to o h e -u g a l e i e dng
wi t a 'o t 1 ; e Va S p CtR. A: 5a .
t h tc m' d.s e . u . . 5 1 ()
h
.
I.
I

Kite la gu t ttzsa ton i ba r dbyHec v.Hlm p le 51 U. 477, - 7
tr l r es ha l c i s r e
i
k
l ir y, 2 S.
486 8

( 994) whihhedt tapl ntf ma notr c rdn gesvi j 1 fra al dl
1 , c l ha ai if y
e ove ma
a 983 o n lege y
unco tt tonalc
ns iu i
onvi to w ihouttr tha ng obt ne G a a e t r i ton. Fa a e
ci n t
i s vi
ai d E vor bl e m na i ' vor bl
f
'
t r na i oc ur whe t he co c i ors nt nc ha be n r ve s d on di e ta a ,
e mi ton c s
nG
t
nvi ton e e e s e e r e
r c ppe l

2

e mge by e c i or r de l r d i ldby asa eti m a a horz t makes h
xpt d
xe utve de , c a e nvai
t t rbt l ut ied o
uc
de e mi ton, ca ld i o que to by a f de alc tsis nceofawrto ha a
tr na i or le nt
si n
e r our' s ua
i f be s
c pus ...' 1 a 487.
or . ' d. t

Pli ifcn
antf nnotpr vef vor bl tr na i bec us hei silc nvit d a i a c aed
o a a e e mi ton a e s tl o c e nd nc r er t
f t crm ef whih he s ksm one a y r le ,a s e swo d i y t i i t ofhi
or he i or c
ee
t r ei f nd ucc s ul mpl he nvaldiy
s
c ci n.Pl i ifa g st thewoul no ha be n co c e o s ond- r mtr rhad
onvi to
antf r ue ha
d t ve e nvit d f ec deg ee lde
i notbe n s i a l f Kitelsalege y f s sae e .Furhe mor Pl i if
t
e pecsc ly or tr l' l dl ale t tm nt
t r e, antf
a kno l dgest twha he s e ç ilr pr e a f i c le t t Pl ntf a ha ng a f i
c w e
ha
t e ks ç l e es nt a r ha l nge o he ai i f t vi
w
ar

ti li t Stt Cotf't alege f le sae e G f t be ftoft pr ec t ';a
ra n he ae u ; he l d a s tt m nt t
was or he ne i he os u or' nd

%Ki r l'jsae n ma i d e h veb e u e i asaeci na c s a dac n ci nwa
f t els ttme t y n e d a e n s d n tt rmi l a e n o vito s
l l
ga ne ' M or ove ,ane tilwoul ber quie i t al ge y f s sa e e wo d ha
i d.
'
e r
w ra
d e r d f he le dl ale t t m nt ul ve

a fce t ej d me to tej r i a yr a o a l l l o .S e eg, ci v. ie Sae ,
fe td h u g n f h u y n n e s n b e i i d e . ..Gilo Untd tts
ke ho
4 5U. 1 0 1 4( 9 2 .Ac o dngy t ec mpan i b re byHe k.
0 S. 5 , 5 1 7 ) c r i l,h o lit s ar d
c
11
1.

Pl ntf a s s e a o de t r t a tK ite ls s a e e wher ve i m ay be f m d.
ai i f l o e ks n r r o e r c tr l ' t t m nt
e rt
ot

W hie Pl i ifa guest tr taci n i Gno f t pur e o i ldai t c nvito 'he
l antf r
ha er to s i t or he pos f nvai tng he o c in,
'
ac
knowldgest ha i wilr pr e af rc lng t t Pl i ifa ha ng af i ti li t
e
ç t t l e es nt ai hale e o he antf t vi
t
ar ra n he
St t Cour .
ae
t'
'

Tot ee tn Plitf r q ssa u iilo d r os c r hi r la efo c t d h ss l
h xe t an if e uet j dca r e t e u e s ee s r m uso y, i oe
rme i fdealco ti apr ryfldha aspeii Se e. , U. C.j2254;Edwads
e dy n e r m' s opel ie be tton. e, R.28 S.
r

v. ls k 5 0U. 6 , 45 4 ( 9 7 ; r ie v. d iu z 41 U. 4 5 5 0( 9 3 .
Baio , 2 S. 41 6 - 7 1 9 ) P es r Ro rc e , 1 S. 7 , 0 1 7 )
Theeor Pli ifma nots e a or rfom afdealc t aj1 3t twoul s clehi
rf e, antf y
e k n de r
e r our vi 98 ha
d e tr s
r e e f om c t qui ke t n wha hi s nt nc c r nty r quies Alo,1do notha t
el as r
us ody c r ha
t s e e e ur e l e r . s
ve he
3

a to iyt j a tma d musrle a an tsaeo fcaso saea e ce .Se - ..Gu lyv.
uh rt o rn n a eif g is tt fiil r tt g n is e eg, re
S p r Ct o M e k e bl:Cny.41 F.d5 6 5 7(t Ci. 9 9 .Ac o dn l Ic n o
u e . . f c ln t
r t , 1 2 8 , 8 4h r 1 6 ) c r igy, n n t
pr s n l g q t e t bl r le Pl i ifs ks
e e ty r nt he quia e e if antf ee .
I .
V

Fort f eg ng r as ,Igr ntKite lsm oto t dimi sa dim ist c
he or oi e ons
a
tr l'
i n o s s nd s s he ompl i
ant

wih u p eu ie
t o t rj dc .
ExTF, : s I
R Thi

wdyo Jl 2017.
a fuy
,

%

e ' Unied St t Dlt tJ
or t
aes sdc udge

4