Williams v. Warden

Filing 27

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/5/2017. (slt)

CL
ERTSOFFI U. , ST O URR
CE S DI .
AT ROANOKE, A
V
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

M ARSHALL DEW AYNE W I AM S, )
LLI
Pettone
ii r,
)
)
v.
)
)
W ARDEN
)
Re po nt
s nde .
)

JUL 25 2 1
27
J A C.
ULI DUD
BY:
W

,
CLERK

K

Ci lAci No.7: c 00548
vi ton
16-vM EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Hon. ihae F.Ur ki
M c l
bans
UniedSt e Dit itJudge
t ats src

M a s l DeW a W ila ,af de ali aepr e ng pr K ,fl d ape ii f a
rhal
yne li ms e r nm t oc edi
o
ie
tton or
.

wrtofha a c puspurua t 28U. C.j2241 Peiine aguest tt fdea Burauof
i
be s or
s nt o
S.
. tto r r
ha he e rl e
Prs nsi ho di hi il ga l be us heha ar a s r edhi f de a s e s Thepa tes
io s l ng m le ly ca e
s le dy e v
s e r l entnce .
ri

sldmo in frs mmayj g n , n t i ma tri rpef rds o i o .Afe rv e n te
e to s o u r ud me t a d h s te s i o ip st n tr e iwig h
i
rc r ,h c u t rn sRepo de tsmoinf rs mmayj d me ta de isPei o e '
e o d t e o r g a t s n n' to o u r u g n nd ne tt n rs
i
mo inf rsl r j d me t
to o l
mma y u g n .
Peii ne ha be n co c e ofmuli e s pa a ec i e by asa eco ta t
tto r s e nvi t d
tpl e r t rm s
t t ur nd wo
dif r ntf r lditi co t.Pe ii rbei ve t tt m os r ce tf r ls nt ncei
fe e ede a srct urs ttone le s ha he t e n ede a e e
mpos d
e

b teUntd Sae Ditit u to t W e tr Dit c o Te n s e (-e ne seFe ea
y h ie tt s src Co r fr he sen sl t f n e s e Qr n se d r l
i
t

Co l li l a u be a eo ho tec u t oet es ne ei t en n e j d me t : 6
uf' s mlwf l c us f w h o r wr t h e tnc n h me d d u g n :1
9
mo t st b s r e c n e ui et t et ic a g ds ne c s( f1 9y a s i c s n mb r
n h o e e v d o s c tv o h md sh r e e tn e o 0 e rq n a e u e
CR3 8 - 48G o to t ( le S ae DititCo r f rte No t m Ditito Te sa d
- 4 1 - u f he Uri d tt s src u t o h q rhe src f xa n
t
c entm be 85 2 outoft 86 h J i i DititCou t Roc l Cot y,TX .
as l r Che t ud cal src
r, kwa l mt
'
'

Pei o ritr rt t n 't me ni r'c n l dn ta t ec nu cinc e tdt
tt ne n ep es t d'o a d , o cu ig h t h o j n to rae wo
i
a
o'
pos i e s nt nc be l i da es Thus Pe ii ne be i ve t s nt nc i pos by t
sbl e e e gim ng t .
j tt o r le s he e e e m ed
he
Te w s ee Fe r lCour c d beg n upo c m pl t o o t 1 ye r s nt nce Q n c s num be
m s
de a
t oul
i
n o e i n f he 09- a e e
t ae
i
r

CR3 8 - 486 o to t ( tdS ae DititCo r f rte No tenDitito Te sl.
- 4 1 - u f he Uni tt s src u t o h j rh r src f xa p l
e
c
c enum be 85C- outoft 8 h J calDititCo q Roc l Cot y,TX . Pe ii r
as
r
2
he 6t udi i src ur
kwa l mt
' ttone
'

beleve t tt s nt e i
i s ha he e enc mpos d by t Te
ç
he nnes e Fe r lCou ti il ala voi be aus i
s e de a
r s leg nd d c e t
cn
nnotbe dee m i whe t c ec i s n e ea m a l begns
tr ned
n he ons utve e t nc c ly i .

Thec u t ee t Peiin rsilgc l ne eaino t ewo dl 1' t eus o l n '
o r rj cs tto e ' l ia itprtto f h r ç d' h e f ç d'
o
m' ;
a
i t ej d me ti ce ra t mbg o s F rh r r ,h c le g dj g n fo te
n h u g n s la nd ma iu u . u te mo e t e haln e ud me t r m h
Te s e Fe r lCour wase e ed i Nove be 201 a t s ntnc f ca entmbe 85Cpne s e de a
t
nt r n
m r 2, nd he e e e or s l r
2 o oft 86 h J c a D i ti tCour o R o kw al Cot t had a r dy bee di c r d o
ut he t udi i l s r c
tf c
l my
lea
n s ha ge n

Augus 11.
t ,2005,whie i f de a c t vi t sae' m a t r s r son c rik a e Eve
l n e r l usody a he t t s nda o y upe vii e tf t . n
.

i t ec u tr ae l nd' sme nigç r't ej dg n ce l sae t es n e c i c n e u ie
f h o r te td ç 'a a n ç , h u me t lv y tts h e tn e s o s c tv
a
o '
t Emd sh r e 's n e c s Co e u n l,h j d me th st r nc ns c t t t
o t ic a g d' e tn e . nsq e ty te u g n a o u o e ui o he
t
ve
undic r d 1 - ars ntnc fom t Unied St t Diti tCour f t Norhe n Diti tof
s ha ge 09 ye e e e r he t
aes src
t or he t r src
Te ,nott dic ge s nt nc fom t sa ec ut
xas
he s har d e e e r he tt ot '
.
Ac r ngl t s ntnc i pos d byt Te s e Fe r lCour wilnotc
co di y, he e e e m e
he nne s e de a
t l
omm e e
nc
untlt 1 ye rs t ncei
i he 09- a en e
mpos byt Te sFede a Co ti s tsi d.Ther c d c d
ed he xa
r l ur s aife
e or oul
no l d ar tona ti off c t fnd i Peii rsf vor a Pe ii ne ' a g e t thei
t ea a i l rer a t o i n ttone ' a , nd tto rs r um nt ha
s

e t ldt d fulj g n i fioo s c r ig y Repo e tsmoi nf rs mma y
ni e o ea tud me t s rv lu .Ac o dn l , s nd n ' to o u r
t
j d me ti g a td a dPeiin rsmoin frsl r u g n i d n e
u g n s rn e , n tto e ' to o l
mmayj d me t s e id.
ENTER: Thi
s

da ofJ y,201
y ul
7

,

w

.
.

ti
l
7

éL: y
p''
b'
ï
z
,'

ey2 m . .6
!
,

.

.
'

,

- ,.

v.
.-

U nie St t
td a

2

.

(. . -,z%..
.. '
. .
.

.
-

i t i tJ e
s rc udg

. :
t .