Gorbey v. Felps et al

Filing 33

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/30/2017. (tvt)

JLERZ: oFFl u.8. sm cour
cE
a
.
ATDM ML VA
LEV
FIED
L

I TH E UN I D STATE S D I
N
TE
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O

MI
CHAEL S.GO RBEY,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

MA2 3&r 27
21
.
JL . t c
uw
A v

s
y:

c

E UTY CLERK

Ci lA c i N o.7: 6- vvi t on
1 c 00551
M EM O M ND U M O PINIO N

FELPS,e a .
t I,
Dee
f ndant .
s

By:

H on.Jac on L . i e
ks
K sr
Se orUnie St e Dit itJudge
ni
t d at s s rc

o
M ihae S.Go be 1 af de a i a e pr ee ng pr K ,c
c l
r y , e r l nm t oc di
omm e edtlscvi aci n
nc li i l to
.

puruan t Bi nsv.Si Unkno Na
s t o ve
x
wn medAce sofFed.Bur a ofNa co i s 403U . 388,
nt
eu
r tc ,
S.

3 9( 9 ) b No mb r1 , 01 .Plitf ddn t yt efl f eu o c mme cn t
8 1 71, y ve e 8 2 6 an if i o pa h ii e p n o n ig he
ng
a tona s htla t pr e i fr pa rspu s n t 28U. C.j1 5.
ci nd oug e ve o oce d n o ma upei rua t o
S.
91
1pr vi usy dee mi t tPli ifhada l s t eenon- bea cvi a i nsor
e o l tr ned ha antf
t ea t hr
ha s i l cto
a al pr vi l dim is d asfi ous asm ai i ,orf f ii t sae acli be or
ppe s e ousy s s e
rvol ,
lcous or a lng o t t
am f e
flng t sac i n.2 Ia1 o had de e m i t ta s a e e i t c pl i ti plca ed t
ii hi to
s
t r ned ha t t m nt n he om a n m i t he

e e to t t tr esrk sp o ii nf ri n n d n e o as ro p ysc lij r
xc pi n o he h e -tie r v so o mmie t a g r f eius h ia nu y.
Co s q e ty Irf re t ama itaej d epe 2 U. C. 6 6 b ()B)t eq e to o
n e u n l, e erd o gsrt u g r 8 S. j 3 ( )1( h u sin f
wh t rPlitf wa t e i n n d ng ro s ro sph ia ij r a t tmeo fln te
ehe an if s md r mmi e t a e f e iu ysc l nu y t he i f iig h
c pl ntf bei f c t e ebeow fe zi tm pe a ur si hi c l whiewe i onl
om ai or ng or ed o ndur l r e ng e r t e n s e l l arng y
a pa rs r a pa r s r sf f z days
pe hi t nd pe ho t or olr
.

1Pli if' ot rmoni ri M iha Owleahe .
antf s he
ke s c el f t r
2Se Ow leahe - be v. Jc sn, t l No 2:6c -0 51 si o . t4( D. . p. 2 2 6
e
f t rGor v a k o e a. . 1 -v0 5 , l p a E. Va Se t2 , 01 )
,
p

( imisdfrfin t saeacam) Gob vv Th Saeo Vh na e a.No. 1 -v0 6 , lpo . t4( D.
ds se o al g o tt li ; r e . e tt f xii.t l 2:1c -01 4 si p a E.
i
,
Va Ma.1 , 0 1 (imisdfrfiigt saeacam)Gob yv. ie Sae . t 1 No. 08c -01 , l
. r 7 2 1 ) ds se o al o tt li ; r e Untd tts e a. 2: -v0 21 si
n
,
p
o a 34( D. . .uy7 201 )s e ec, r e v F d Bue uo Alo lTo ac . rams&
p. t - N. W Va J l , 0; e . ..Gob y . e . ra f c ho- b c o Fier .
Ex o ie. ta.No 5:lc -01 6 si o . t5 l ( D. Va Ma. 4 20l)( J, eb l)(itn 2 c ss
plsv s e l . 1 -v0 2 , l p a -0 N. W. . r 1 , 2 M..S ie' lsig 5 a e
,
p
t
ta q aiya srk s; e as Coe nv Tolfo ,1 5S. .1 5 ,1 6 ( 5 (odn aStie' imisli
h t u l s tie )s e lo lma . les n 3 Ct 7 9 7 3 201 ) h lig ç rk 'ds sa s
f
s
c u tdrg r ls t t tmigo as b e u nt p a) Mc a v. i dS ae, 6 F.d39 ,3 9(t Ci.
o ne e ades o he i n f u sq e a pe l; Le n Unt tts 5 6 3 1 9 4h r
e
2 09 ( imisl wi o t rj dc frgioo n s s o l n t e e tdfo 2 U. C. 1 1 ().
0 ) ds sas t u p eu ie o v luse s h ud o be x mpe rm 8 S. j 9 5g)
h

.

Th ma itaej d eh sis e arp r, e o n igd n igPlitf la et
e g sr t u g a su d e o trc mme dn e yn an if e v o
pr ee L f r p u e i.Th ma itaej d ed tr ne ,n e ai, h t anifwa n t
oc d q o ma a p rs e g srt u g eemi d itr la t a Plitf s o
.

u d ra i n n d n e o s ro sp y ia ij r a t etmehefldtec mp an .P an if
n e n mmie t a g r f ei u h sc l nu y t h i
ie h o lit litf
fldamoint s b e aa d amoi nf r ei n r ij n to , ndheh so j ce t te
e
to o u po n n
to o prlmia y nu cin a
a b e td o h
r po ta r comme ton. 1ha r e
e r nd e
nda i
ve eviwedt r por a r c me to t ta c o
he e t nd e om ndai n, he r ns dpt f

t h ai sb fr t ma itaej d e a Plitf so j cins Fo t ef l wigra o ,
he e rng e o e he gsrt u g , nd an if b e to . r h ol n e s ns 1
o
o e zeteo j cins a o tterpo t ndr c mme d to , e yPlitf moins a
v m l h b e to , d p h e r a e o n ain d n an ifs to , nd
d s s t ec mplitwi u p eu ie
imis h o an t t rj d c .
ho
A d src j d emus rviw arpo t n rc mme d to t whc ap ryo j cs a d
itit u g
t e e e r a d e o n ain o ih a t b e t, n
t ed src j d emus p o d isid p n e t e s n n wh n ap ryr ie n w e d n eo a
h itit u g
t r vie t n e e d n r ao i g e a t as s e vie c r

n w a g me ti a o j cin.28U. C. 6 6b ()C) Or in v J h s n 6 7F.d4 , 7
e r u n n n b e to
S. j 3 ()1 ( ; p a o . o n o , 8 2 4 4
( hCi.1 2) Theras ni ne dnotbeea aeorlngt b i mus pr deas cfc
4t r 98 .
e o ng e
lbort e hy, ut t t ovi pe ii
r i l t tpe m is m e ngf la la e r vi w . Se e. ,Unie St t v.Ca t r 5 F.
atona e ha r t ani u ppe l t e e
ee c.
t d a es
r e , 64 3d

3 5 3 0(t Ci. 0 ) Ho v r X no r ve i n t e urdwh n o j cinsc n en
2 , 3 4 h r 20 9 . we e , vo e iw s o r q ie e be to o c r
l lis sa notf t lis s Se se. ,Opino,687F. a 47.Si lry, novorviw
ega sue nd acua sue . e :. a
2d t
mial X
e e

i n t e uie S e ap rymac sg nea o c n l o yo j cinst a d n tdrc tec u t
s o r q rd ç n a t l e rl r o cus r be to h t o o ie t h o r
wh
e
t as e i er ri t ema itaej g ' p o sdfndn sa drc mme d to s' 1 .A
o p cfc ro n h gsrt ud es r po e i ig n e o n ai n . d
'
dsrc c u'i as n trq ie t rv e a yis wh n n pa t ha o j ce S e eg,
itit o l s lo o e ur d o e iw n sue e o ry s b e td. e s ..
t
Th ma v. n 4 4U. 1 0 1 9( 9 5 ; mb v. vi, 1 F.d 1 8 20 (t Ci. 98 )
o s Ar , 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) Cn y Da s 7 8 2 9 , 0 4 h r 1 3 .
Plitf o j csf rsv r l e s n , o o wh c aec n icn .Plitf ag me t
anif b e t o e e a r a o s n ne f ih r o vn ig an ifs r u n
ta t ma itaej d e sç is'e u rsh rrc a a dane he rn wi a t e ma itae
h t he g sr t u g ' t a 'rq ie e e us l n
b
w a ig t noh r gsrt
h
j d ei ba ee sa dfi oo s u l fio o si Plitf' o j cin, n r ltdmoint
u g s s ls n rv lu .Eq al rk l u s an ifs b e to a d eae to o
y
s poe t r qui e a doc ort t s iy on Pl ntf ' be l . Pl ntf a it d durng t fr t
ub na, o e r
t o e tf
ai if s ha f ai i f dm t e
i he i s

he rng t thedi no ha t f ndst pa f rava i s
a i ha
d t ve he u
o y,o
ld ubpoe ,a hi ofe t fl a docors
na nd s f r o ie
t '
a ûda tw oul notbe ad i s bl e de e. The c t ilneihe i s no e or e a
f vi
d
m s i e vi nc
our w l t r s ue r nf c

t u p e 'u a c mpa idb t erq ii fe , n tema itae u g ddn t r hbi
i b o na' n c o n e y h e u st e s a d h gsrt j d e i o p o i t
s
e
Pli iffom madnghi own a r nge e st s
antf r
l
s
ra m nt o ubpoe a doc o .M o e r Pl i ifr f ed
na ny t r
r ove , antf e us
durngt fr the rngt a k Dr A s r t prs docor t tsiy on hi be fon a oun of
i he is a i o s . he , he ion t , o e tf
s hal
cc t
Pl n ipsr pea e S apr tc ' c
aitf e t d û l aci e' ompl i sagans t tdoc or Al of i ousa ePl i ifs
m
ant
i t ha
t . s rvol
r antf
as e tonst tt t he rngswe e%a ol ey unf i'a Gc
s ri ha he wo a i
r lbs ut l
a r' nd lomplt y ones de ' nd t t28
eel
i d'a ha

U. C.j1 5()i unc tt i l See e. ,Polncov.
S.
91 g s onsiutona. s g. a
Hopki ,51 F. 1 1 ( Ci.
ns 0 3d 52, 56 2d r
2007 .
)

1a r ewihtema itaej d eslg l ndf cu l e iin f rter a o sds u sd i
g e t h g sr t u g ' e a a a ta d cso s o h e s n ic se n
t r po ta r co m e ton a not bl ase de edby t he rngta c i s Se
he e r nd e m nda i nd, a y, vi nc
he a i r ns rpt . e
-

W i rv. o , 7 F.d68 7 ( t Ci.1 8 )( tn ad src j d emu te rien nmme Co k 7 4 2 , 6 4h r 9 5 noig itit u g s xecs o
d ega e a t iy i pe f nni a denovo r vi by consde i t a ualt tmony a not
el bl u hort n r o ng
e ew
i rng he ct esi
nd

meeyrv e n tema itée srpo t n r c mme d to s.Th p io sarha de
r l e iwig h g sr t' e r a d e o n ain ) e rs n' i n lr
diti e t s me c tone arofa oxi t l 68de ee e ly a ongprs r 'a
srbut d he n
ondii d i
ppr ma ey
gr s qua l m
ione s nd
sa fsz
t f ' oned ar asdurng t hea i s s Pl ntf a l ge t r w asa s lc pl i a o
e
i he tng ea on. ai if le d he e
ii one ug n ne

i h by t e i h hol i hi celswi
nc
hr e nc
e n s l' ndow,a heac
nd
knowl dt tt pl wo d l k whe
edge ha he ug ul ea
n

h ç g lgq't Ev ni o ti eng ti 1w tmp rtr sweea lw a 30d g e s ta
e l ged 'i. e f u sd ih t o e eau e r s o s e r e ,h t
wi
me
t mpe aur wastm por r a i i r as d t da i hihsofup t 73 de ee .Eve i hi
e rt e
e
a y s t nc e e o ytme g
o
gr s
n f s
wi
ndow l ke a ra l a 30 deg ee t
ea d i s ow s
r s hough a s al pl ed hol d i ni tm e hour f
m l ugg
e ur ng ghti
s or

f u c n e ui d y , an iff i t e tbiht th tmpeau ei hi c l s b e tdhm t
o z o s c tve a s Plitf al o sa ls ha te e rtr n s el u j ce i o
s
i m i ntda e ofs i phys c ha' .
m ne
ng r erous
i al l
m

3

Ac o dn l Id n Plitf moint s b o n , v mzePlitf so jcins a o t
c r igy, e y anifs to o u p e a o e l an if be t , d p
o
t rpor a r c
he e t nd e omme ton, ndde Pli ifsmotonf l vet pr e L f
ndai a
ny antf
i or ea o oc ed q onna

n u e i.Co e ue ty, ds s t ec mpan wi u p eu ied t Plitf' f i r t
a p rs nsq nl I imis h o lit t t rj d c ue o anifs al e o
ho
u
pa t slng f e a t tmeofslngt c
y he i e t he i
i he ompli . Se e. ,
ant e. g.Dupr v.Pam e ?28 F. 1 4,
ee
l r 4 3d 23

1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 (e s n n t a t efl gf ei d eu o fln acv l cinwh nL
2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) ra o i g h t h ii e s u p n iig ii a to e q
n
f ma pa rspr sonsdono a yt pli tf andt tt co ti notr quie t pe mi
or
upe i ovi i
t ppl o a n if
ha he ur s
e rd o r t
pl i ifa opporuniy t pa t flng f e a trr ogni ngpli tf i i lgi et pr ee
antf n
t t o y he i e fe ec zi a n if s ne i bl o oc d

L f r p u rs.ld n Plitf' moinf rap ei n r ij n to a mo t
q oma a pei) e y an ifs to o r l ay nu cin s o .
mi
ENTER : s
Thi

da ofM a c 201
y
r h, 7.
,

.

.
a

'
'

%

S ni Unie St t sDititJ e
or t d a e src udg