Cooper v. Duncan et al

Filing 28

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/6/2017. (tvt)

Download PDF
nl RKSOF I U. DI A I F ' FCE S. SXP W AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED n T 2sb 1 2 '7 I TH E UM TED STA TE S D I N STR I C O U R T CT FOR TH E W ESTER N DISTR I O F W R G I A CT NI R O A N O K E DI SI N VI O JULî . A BY; v D C I A EL M Y CO O PER , SR C as N o.7: 6CV 00578 e 1 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N NI M M EE DUNCAN C K , By:Ho GlnE. nr d n. e Co a U ni e St esD i t i tJudge t d at src Dee nts. fnda t) By opi on a or r e e e M a 23,201 t c tsl a iy dim is wiho i nd de nt r d y 7, he our lmm rl s s ed t ut p eu iePlitf Ire Ra Co p rscvlrg t a to un e 4 U. C.j 1 8 f rfil et rj d c an if sa l y o e ' ii ih s ci n d r 2 S. 9 3 o alr o z sae a cam . S e 2 U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) Co pe h smo e f rr c n ie ai n o t i tt li e 8 S. 91 A()1 . o r a v d o e o sd r to f hs dimis lo de . s sa r r Be a eCo p rsg e a d d tdh smo inwihn 2 d ysfo e ty o t j g n , c us o e in d n ae i to t i 8 a r m n r f he ud me t tec u tc nsr e i a aii t e Rul 5 ()o t Fe ea Rue o Cii Pr c dle I i h o r o tu s t s rsng md r e 9 e f he d r l ls f v l o e t . t s r wele tbih d ta G e o sd r to o aj g n a trise ty i a e ta r i ay r me y l sa ls e h t l c n ie ai n f ud me t fe t nr s n x ro d n r e d r wh c s udb us ds a igy. Pa .n . v. Na'FieI s Co.1 F.d3 6 4 3 (t ih ho l e e p rn l ' c l s Co. Am. t r n . , 48 3 9 , 0 4 h ' l Ci.1 9 )(n e a ctto sa dq o ain makso t d .A j d mè tma b n n e u d r r 9 8 itnzl iain n u tto r mit ) u g n y e me d d n e e Rul 5 ()i o yt recrlmsa c s ( )t a c mmo aea itr e i c a ei c nr li e 9 e n nl h e icl tn e : 1 o c o d t n n ev nng h ng n o tol ng lw;( )t a c t f rn w e ie en ta alb ea tilo ()t c re tace rer ro lw o a 2 , c omt o e vd nc o v ia l t ra; r 3 o or c la ro f a r o p e e tma fs ij tc . S e ea,Ga la ov. la c S a d r Liel . .5 7F.d 2 0 r v n nie t nusie e , .. gin Rein e tn a d f ns Co, 4 3 3 , 2 n. (t Ci. 0 ) 41 8 4h r 20 8 . The c tha c r f ly r vi we Coope ' ne s iso a fndst tt y do not our s a e ul e e d rs w ubm s i ns nd i ha he pr s nta cr tmsa wa tng t r quese r lef The e or ,t m o i n wilbe dele ee icl t nce nu i he e t d e i . r f e he to l zid. . Coo rfrtco pl nst tt a ton wa ne rs ve on t de e nt ,t the ne r pe is m ai ha he c i s ve er d he f nda s ha ve h dteo p rt t t r s ndt amoin f rs mmayj d me t a t tt ec u t i no a t a h p o tmiy o e po o to o u r u g n , nd ha h o r dd t c in ne a ey t dir s l clins Thes cic sa s a e e iel c it ntwih 28 U. C. r r dit l o sni s ;s ar . e r um t nce r ntr y onsse t S. j 1 5 b ( ) wh c a t o ie te c u t t d s s a cam o c mp an G s s o a 91 A( )1, ih u h rz s h o r o imis li r o lit G o n s a pr ci a e' trdoc tng i i doe notsaea c am u whi h r le m a be g a ed. a tc bl 'afe ke i f t s tt l i pon c e if y r nt Coope a s cli st tt c tdi notalo t tl arng oft f t'be or dimisng r lo am ha he our d l w ç ll ii f he ac s' f e s s i t c e On t c r y,t co tr viwe t f c s Coo rpr de i t c he as . he ontar he ur e e d he a t pe ovi d n he ompl i a ant nd f ound t m i ufk intt sa e a c tt i he ns t e o tt ny onsiutonalc am . M or ove ,be us t dimi s lwas li e r ca e he s s a wih u p eu ie Co p rrman fe t r fl h scamsi an w a ds p r t cvi a to t t t o t rj dc , o e e is r e o eie i li n e n e a ae i l cin ha m a saGf laii oft f ct'heofe si s ke ûul rng he a s' f r n uppo tofhi c am s r s li . Be us Coo rs s isons di not a lge s fc e f c s t sa e c tm tona ca e pe ' ubm s i d le ufi i nt a t o tt onsi i l vi a i r l td t t cai i t i ta compl i ,t co tde e Coope ' m oto t oltons e ae o he l ms n he nii l ant he ur nid rs in o ame t r s dif r nt a tonalcli s a de e nt . Thi moton di not c r t t nd o aie fe e , ddii am nd f nda s s i d orec he d fce ce o whc t e iiil cams wee d s s e t e j 1 5 b () s t e c u t eiin is n ih h nta li r imis d md r 91 A()1 , o h o r d s s e i a f tl. Mo e v r t ep o osd a nd d camsween tprpel j ie i te imis d t s ' i ue ro e , h r p e me e li r o o ry on d o h cli i t i talc a ms n he nii ompli . ant I s r,Coope doesno pr s nta ne 1w ore de e ori ntf a c e re r of n ho t r t e e ny w a vi nc de iy ny l a ror 1w o ij sie Th r f r,t c ur wi d n hi moi n t atro a ndj d me t An a r nu tc . e eo e he o t l e y s to o le r me u g n . l a o it or rwilis he e t ppr prae de l s ue r wih. The Cl r i diec ed t s nd a co oft sor rt t pl i if ek s r t o e py hi de o he a ntf . ENTER: Ths # dyo oco e, 0 7 i a f tb r2 1 . Unie St t Diti tJ t d aes src udge

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?