Gorbey v. Waters, et al

Filing 7

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 1/3/2017. (tvt)

GL- :o sc usDs ou r
F F n lmc R
I
'ùt A n
. k, T
. .

VêiV
l :A
L

Flnn
u

.

I TH E U M TED STA TES DI
N
STRI T C O UR T
C

FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O

J 23 2 1
AN
27
r JUL c. a c Rx
'
DuDl

BK f
kï

MI
CHAEL S.
GORBEY,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

W A TER S,eta .
I,
De e
f ndant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

ci l to xo g:6 c t p r u
viAci n . l -v-msw u yc s
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Hon.Jacls L.Kier
ton
s
Se o Unie St tsDit itJ e
nir td a e src udg

o
M ihae S. be 1 af de a i aepr e ngpr K , c
c l Gor y , e r l nm t oce di
omm e edt scvi aci n
nc hi i l to
ptr ua t Bi nsv.Si U nknown N a e A ge sofFe Bur a ofN a c i s 403 U . 388
ls nt o ve
x
m d
nt
d. e u
r otc ,
S. ,

38 (9 ) b De e e 8 2 6 At h o s t ft ea to ,hec u t r te Plitf t
9 1 71, y c mb r , 01 . t e n e o h cin t o r pemi d an if o
l
a yt pr e L fr pa rsbutad s dPli ift s hpe s i woul ber cnde
ppl o oce d q oma upei
vie antf hat uc nnison
d esi d
i Pl i ifha ha tle pro c s sdim is d a fi o ,m ai i ,orf f ilr t sae a
f antf s d lr e i r a e s s e s rvol us lcous
or a lze o tt

cam, u s n t 28U. C. 1 5 g .
li p rua t o
S. j 91 ( )
Upon r vi w ofc tr c ds i a a sPl i ifha hâ a l a tt e non- be scvi
e e
our e or , t ppe r antf s d t e s hr e
ha a i l
aci nsora a spr vi l dimi s d a fi ous a m ai i us orf f lngt sa eac am
to
ppe l e ousy s s e s rvol , s lc o , or aii o t t l i
bef r flng t saci n. Se Owle t rGo be v.J c om e a .N o.2:6- vo e i hi to
e
f a he - r y a ks
t l,
1 c 00551 si op.a
, lp
t

4 ( D. . e t 2 , 01 )( imisdf rfii t saeacam) Gobe v. S aeo
E. Va S p . 2 2 6 ds se o al o tt li ; r y The tt f
ng
Vicna e a.No 2: 1c - 01 4 si o a 4( D. . a.1 , 01 )( imis dfrf i n t
r i i. t l . 1 -v 0 6 , l p. t E. Va M r 7 2 1 d s se o al g o
,
p
i
saeacaml Gobe v Uni dS ae . ta.No. 0 -v 0 21 si o a 3 4( D. . .
tt li ; r y . t tts e 1, 2:8 c - 01 , lp p. t - N. W Va
e
J l 7 201 )(imis df rfii t saeacaml s e eg, r e v. d Bu e uo Alo o .
u y , 0 d s se o al o tt li ; e . ..Go b v Fe . r a f c h l
ng
To a c . rn ms & Ex l sv s e a.No 5 1 -v 0 2 , lp o a 5 1 ( D. . . a.
b c o Fie r . p o i e , t 1 . : 1c - 01 6 si p. t - 0 N. W Va M r
,
1 201 )( ..Seb r)(itn 2 c s st t u lf a srke) s eas Coe nv Tolfo ,
4, 2 M J, ie t lsig 5 a e ha q aiy s ti s; e lo lma . les n
1 5S. .1 5 ,1 6 ( 01 )( ligaGtie' imisli c u t dr g r ls t t etmi o a
3 Ct 7 9 7 3 2 5 hodn ç rk 'ds sa s o n e e ad e s o h i ng f
s

1Pli ifsot rm oni ri M ihae Stve Owleahe - o be .
antf ' he
ke s c l e n
f t rG r y

s b e u n a p a) M c a v. ie S ae , 6 F.d3 , 9 (t Ci. 0 )( imis l
u s q e t p e l; Le n Untd tts 5 6 3 91 3 9 4 h r 20 9 d s sas

wih u p eu iefrfio o n s s ul n t ee e tdfo 28U.. j 1 5 g )
t o t rj dc o rv lus e s ho d o b x mp e r m
SC. 91 ( ).
Afe r vi ng Pli if ss bmisonsi t sci la ton,i i cea t tPli ifdoesnot
tr e ewi
antf u s i n hi vi ci t s l r ha antf
ale a f c si c tng t the i c e l unde a i mi ntt e tofa s rousphysc
l ge ny a t ndia i ha
s un-nty
r ny m ne hr a
ny e i
ial

ij r winnteme nigo 2 U. C. 1 5g .S e ec, a ev. M aly 4 6F. p'
nu y ti h a n f 8 S. j 91 () e . ..Ch s O' le , 6 Ap x
l

1 5 1 6(t Ci. 1 )( tn tep io rmu t es e igrle fo a dd mo srt a
8 , 8 4h r 20 2 noig h rs ne s b e kn eif r m n e n tae
d n e t a i i n n a t t o fln tec mp an) Pet v. o c nha , 5 F.d29 ,
a g r h t s mmi e t the i f iig h o lit; t
me
us M r e t u 5 4 3 3
2 6( dCi. 0 9 ( o igtec mp an mu trv a an x b t e t i n n d n e i
9 2 r 2 0 ) n tn h o lit s e e l e us ewe n he mmie t a g r t
alg sa dt camsia s rst q lf f ri n n -a e e c pi n .Plitf sc mp an
le e n he li t se t o uaiy o mmie td ng r x e to ) an if o lit
a i tt d e nt c e nst a l ged de i ton ofa r lgi usm e la t r t i ton he
ga ns he ef nda s onc r he le
pr va i
ei o
a nd he e ala i
s f r d f om c pl i ng a tr r Pl i if sr pe t d r la on t phr s ç m m i n
uf e e '
r
om a ni fe wa d. a ntf ' e a e e i nce he a e t
i ne t

da r'i a i a i ofal be a c l i t ti no e ild t a a s
nge ' s n nvoc ton
a l nd onc uson ha s t ntte o n s umpton oftut
i
r h.

BelAt.Cor v.
l l p. Twombl 550U. 5 555( 07) Furhe e Pl ntf ma notr l on
y,
S. 44, 20 . t nnor, ai if y
ey
va
gue,s ultve,o c l o y alegai nst i
pec a i r oncus r l to o nvokeGm mi ntda r'buti t d,hemus
c
i ne
nge y' nsea
t

ma eG p cfcfc alg to so o g igs ro sp y ia ij r o o apatl o mic n u t
k t e ii a t le ain f n on eiu h sc l nu y, r f te' f s o d c
s
n
e i e cn t elk lh o o i ne t eiusp y ia ij r . J l o v. nn r 2 0F. p'
v d n ig h ieio d f mmi n s ro h sc lnu y' oms n W r e, 0 Ap x
'
2 0 2 2( t Ci. 0 6 .
7 , 7 4h r 2 0 )

Ac od n l, d s s t a to wi u prj d c f rPli tf sf i r t p yt fln
c r à gy 1 imis he cin t t eu ie o anif al e o a he iig
ho
u
f a t tm eofflngt co pl nta dim isalpendi motonsa moot Se ,e. ,Dupr e
ee t he i
ii he m ai nd s s 1
ng
i
s
. e c.
e

v. l r 28 F.d 1 3 ,1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 (e s nigta t fln fei d u o fln a
Pame, 4 3 2 4 2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) r a o n h the iig e s ue p n ii g
ci la tonwhe L f mapa rspr sonsdono a yt pli ifa t tt c ti not
vi ci
n q or
upei ovii
t ppl o antf nd ha he our s

2

r quie t pe mi pli tf a o runiyt pa t flng f eafe r c zi pl i ifi
e r d o r t a n if n ppo t t o y he ii e tr e ogni ng antf s

i ii et pr e t f mapa rs.
nelgbl o oc ed q or
upei)

ENTER

vl
a.
:Ths 3 / d yo 3ae 'aOl
i a f
, 7
.
(
N

'

.

h
.

;
Y

Se orU nie St t s D it i tJ e
t d a e s rc udg

3