Clark v. Commonwealth of Virginia

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/10/2017. (tvt)

CLERK' OFFI U, , SX M UA
S
CE 8 DI
A ROANOKE,
T
VA
ri Q')
:) i
-

J 12 2 1
AN
27
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
RO ANOK E DI SI
VI ON
V I CEN T CLA RK ,
N

Pe ii ,
ttoner
V.

COM M ONW EALTH OF VI NI
RGI A,
R espondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

UL

(
:

D

,

s

CASE NO. 1
7:7CV00011

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI

By: GlnE. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnie St t sDititJudge
e
td a e src

Vi e Cl k,a Vigi a i t pr e di pr K ,ha fld t s a ton,s e ng t
nc nt ar
r ni nma e oc e ng o
s ie hi c i
e ki o
a a a sa e c tor r t tde e hi m o i n f m odi to ofhi tr o co i m e ,
ppe l tt our de ha nid s to or
fcai n
s e m f nfne nt
The c ti tal doc e t s
our nii ly ketd he ubmison a ape ii f rawrtofha a c pus pur ua t
si s
tton o
i
be s or , s nt o

2 U. C. 22 4.Afe f rh rrv e o tepei o h we e,hec u t o cud sta i i n t
8 S. j 5
tr u te e iw f h t in, o v r t o r c n l e h t t s o
t
1

ah b a peiin a mu t esl rl ds se f rlc o j rs ito
a e s t o nd s b l
t
mmaiy imis d o a k f u idcin.
Clr s s isonsi c t t the fl d a m o i n i t Amhe s Co t Cic tCour
a k' ubm s i ndia e ha
ie
to n he
rt un y r ui
t
f rmodii a i oft s nt nc spr vi usy i
o
fc ton he e e e e o l mpos d on hi by t tc t t r n s h s nt nc
e
m
ha our, o u uc e e es

c n u r nl o t oh r s a j thsr la ed t. Th Co r d r e hi mo inb o d rd td
o c re ty r o tewie dus i ee s ae e u t el d s to y r e ae
i
Dec m be 20, 201 N ot ng i t r co d i c t s t t Cl r has not d a a al of t
e r
6.
hi n he e r ndi a e ha a k
e n ppe
he
Cour s or e .2
ts d r

I hi c r e s iso t t sc t Clr s ekst a a t Amhe s c tsor r
n s u r nt ubm s i n o hi our, a k e
o ppe l he
rt our' de ,

wh c h prs n sa a atc me tt hi peiin.( e ECFNo. - . Clr c ne st a h i
ih e e e t s n ta h n o s t o S e
t
1 1) ak o tnd h t e s

e tte t a pe rf rah mi gt ag ei fv ro asn e c a j sme tf rt ra o s ( )te
n i d o p a o e n o r u n a o f e tn e d u t n o wo e s n ' 1 h
l
.
1 Un e Rue4b o teRue Go rig j2 4 Cae ,te c u tma s mmai ds s a j2 4
d r l () f h ls venn
25 s s h o r y u rl imis
y
25
p t intifipany a p as9o tep tto a da yalc e e hbt ta tepeio e i no e tldt rle
eio & l t lil p e r m h eiin n n ta h d x iis h t h tin r s t nie o eif
t l
t
t
i t dititco '
n he src mt'
2 Thecom'notst taltga genealy hast ry da t not a a a fom aVigi ati com'
t e ha ii nt
rl
hit ys o e n ppe l r
r ni ral t

j d me t roh ra e lbl o d r Se , . ,S Ct Rul 5 6 a .
u g n o te pp aa e r e. e ea. up. . e A:( )

c u t h u da py alc lc u tûNUNC PRO TUNC)RULE'a d ()Clr alg d yme t te
o r s o l p l o a o r GI
I
' n 2 ak le e l es h
gove ors r quie nt f a s nt e m odik ai he rng bec us he ha s r d û e t
m ' e r me s or e enc
t ton a i
a e
s e ve l
mor han

e
nough' of t l hy, co e utve s nt nce i pos d o hi f nonvi e ofe es
'
he engt
ns c i e e s m e n m or
olnt f ns .
Ac r ngl Cl r as t sco tt s thi c e f a he r ng.
co di y, a k ks hi ur o e s as or
ai

Fr t s al ga i ,t c tc ude t tCl r ha fld hi peii i t m '
om he e le tons he our oncl s ha a k s ie s tton n he ong

c u ts tm . Lo r fd r l c u t,lk t i o e d n th ve j idcin t rv e te
o r yse
we e e a o rs ie hs n , o o a urs ito o e iw h

j d me t o saec u t o a e l Pllrv.M o r ,1 9 F.d 7 ,7 ( t Ci.1 9 ) S e
u g ns f tt o rs n pp a. ve
oe 2 3 28 31 4h r 9 7 . e
as Ditito Cou i Ct Ap v.Fed n,4 0 U. 4 2 4 2 8 ( 9 3 ;Ro ke v.Fi
lo src f lmba . p. l ma 6 S. 6 , 8 - 6 1 8 ) o r d.
Tr s Cm,2 3 U. 41 ,41 - 6 ( 9 ) J rs cin f r a p lae r ve o sae c u t
ut
6 S. 3 5 1 1 23 . u idito o p elt e iw f tt o r
j d me t le e cu iey wi s p ro saec ursa dt e , tn ily wi t eUni dS ae
u g ns is x lsv l t u ei r tt o t n h n poe tal, t h
h
h
t tts
e
Supr me Cour. Pl e ,1 F. a 731;28U. C.j 1
e
t ylr 29 3d t
S.
257. The eor,t t e e t tClr
r f e o he xtnt ha ak
s ksdie ta lae r vi w by t sc toft Amhe s Cot y Cic tCour' o de de ng
ee
r c ppel t e e
hi our
he
r t mt r ui
ts r r nyi
hi m o i f a s nt nc modi a i t s a ton m us be s
s ton or e e e
sc ton, hi c i
t
umm a iy dim is d wihout
rl s s e
t

p eu ie a t sc u th snoj rs ito t c n u tt er ve Clr s e s An a p o rae
rj d c , s hi o r a
u id cin o o d c h e iw ak e k .
p r p it
or rwile e t sda
de l ntr hi y.

Th sc u t o sh vej rs ito t r ve tef c o ln t o a imaesc nfn me t
i o r d e a u idcin o e iw h a t r e gh f n n t ' o i e n
u d rasaec u tu g n tr u hh b a c r usrviw pzs n t 2 U. C. 2 5 .Pllr
n e tt o rj d me t h o g a e s op e e l ua t o 8 S. j 2 4 ve ,
r
1 9 F.d a 7 2. To warn rle t e j 2 5 ,h we e ,Clr mu td mo srt t a h i
2 3 t3
ra t eif md r 2 4 o v r ak s e n tae h t e s
c n ie i v oain o te Co ttto o lwso t Untd S ae , e j2 4( a dt a h
o fn d n i lto f h nsiui n r a f he ie tts s e 25 $, n h t e
ha e use saec trme e a t hi habe cams s e j2254(9. Clr fist sae
s xha td tt our e dis s o s
as li , e
1
ak al o tt
f c si s tsaci n ofet roft s r quie nt . Ac or ngl t c tde lne t addr s
a t n aif to
ihe
he e e r me s
c di y, he our c i s o
es

hi cure tpeiin a one s l ha sc pusr i unde j2254 a dimis si wiho
s r n tto s
eedng bea or elef r
nd s s e t t ut

p eudc . S e Sa n v.S t ,4 4 U. 5 ,5 ( 9 )(idig t tj 2 4 h b a peiin
rj ie e lgo
mih 0 S. 3 4 1 71 fn n ha 25 a e s tt
o
2

mu tb ds s e wih u p eu iei p tto rha n tp e e tdt ecamst tea p o rae
s e imis d t o t rj d c f ei ne s o rs n e h li o h p r p it
i
saec u ta d c u dsild s ) Dimis lo t ea to wi o tp eu iela sClr fe t
tt o r n o l tl o o . s s a f h cin t u rj dc e ve ak re o
h
fl ane a spaaej2254peii prvi dt thestsi t not r quieme s
ie w nd e rt
tton, o de ha aifes he ed e r nt.
The Cl r i die t d t s nd c e o t s m e a um o ni n a a c
e k s r c e o e opi s f hi mor nd
pi o nd c ompa ng
nyi
or rt pe ii r
de o ttone .

ENTER:Th s l d y o J n ay 2 7
i D a f a u r , 01 .

Ch'fUnie Stt Diti tJ
t d aes src udge