Meyers v. Young et al

Filing 18

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/7/2017. (tvt)

rlFRK' OFFI U .S.DIE P UA
.
S
CE
S A
A Ir.,: KE VA
T 7 3.t)
s.

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I OF VI G I A
CT
R NI
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
D AV I M E YER S,
D
Pe ii r
t t one ,

W ARDEN S. YOUNG, AL.
K.
c
,
R espondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

FEB 27 2 1
27
JULA
I
BY;

..

q

CA SE NO .7:
17CV 00017

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI

By: Ho GlnE. nr d
n. e Co a
ChifUnie St e DititJudge
e t d ats src

Da d M e r ,aVigni i t pr ee ng pr K , ie t spe ii f rawrtofha a
vi
ye s
r i a nma e oc di
o fld hi tton o
i
be s

co pus purua t 28 U. C.j2254. Healege t tt Vigi a De rme ofCore ons
r , s nt o
S.
l s ha he r ni pa t nt
rdi

(VDOC' h s no p o ry c luae hs tr o c n e n n rf s s t p o ie hn
ç
1
' a t r pel ac ltd i em f o sn me ta d e u e o r vd iA
)
pr e tve c t a m e a he t team e t Upon r viw oft r or t c tc l s
ot c i usody nd nt l alh r t n .
e e
he ec d, he our oncude

t a t ep tto mus b s mmaiyds se wi o t rj d c .
h t h eiin t e u rl imis d t u p eu ie
h

A cc di t t pe ii M e r i c i d i t c t oft VD OC unde t r yor ng o he tton, ye s s onf ne n he us ody
he
r hi t

yea prs t r i
r ion e m mpos d i 201 by t Cic t Cour f r t Ciy ofPe e s g on M e r
e n
4
he r ui
t o he t
t r bur
ye s
c ci nsf rr r a
onvito o obbe y, bduc i m a ii woundi a r lt d fr a m sofe e . He doe
ton, lcous
ng, nd ea e ie r
f ns s
s
no c le he e t va i t ofhi c c i orhi s n e as i
t ha lnge r he ldiy
s onvitons
s e t nce mpos Ra he ,M e r
ed. t r ye s
c am s among ot t ngs t tVDOC o fcal ha notg a e hi c e ta i thi s ntnce
li ,
her hi , ha
fi i s ve
r ntd m r di ga ns s e e

f rtme h s r e i j i i daey atrhsar s a d rn e e uin o a c u t r ee
o i e e v d n al mme itl fe i ret nd u ig x c to f o r- d r d
o
ps hiti e l i r ga di hi c
yc a rc vauaton e r ng s ompe e t san til M eye s a kst s c ' t or r
t ncy o t d ra .
r s hi oul o de
t
t pr pe c l ulton ofhi prorc t c edi.
he o r a c a i
s i usody r t
M eye s alo a l ges o he pr bl m s w ih hi c r ntc
r s le
t r o e
t s ur e onfne e . H e c a m s t tV D OC
m nt
l i ha
of i a s ha r f e t a s g hi t a pr s f iiy t t ca pr de hi w ih a o i t
fci l ve e us d o s i n m o
i on ac lt ha n ovi
m t ppr pra e

m e a heat tè t e a pr e tve c t y. He alo cai t t prs ofi a s ha
nt l lh r am nt nd ot c i usod
s l ms ha ion fcil ve

C

G ai i l 'br
i lcousy' ough muli e, f le di cplna y c r agans hi a ha r f e t
m
t
tpl as s i i r ha ges i t m nd ve e us d o
pr de am e a he t pr es i t c
ovi
nt l alh of sonal o ouns lhi a
e m boutt c r sa as iti hi de e e
he ha ge nd ss n s f ns .
Ther uli dicplna y c c i ha c e hi t i ura i r s i hi s cliy lve ,
es tng s i i r onvi tons ve aus d m o nc n nc ea e n s e trt e l
t s f ra de r a e i t n o o good c
o ufe
c e s n he m unt f
onduc tm ehe ca e r ,a t f cea lke i
ti
n a n nd o a
i lhood of
ta f rt a hi s cliy prs M e r a lgest tprs ofk i l br htt f s c r s
r ns e o
gh e trt ion. ye s le
ha ion t a s oug he ale ha ge
ag ns li i r t iton f ii r peaed r que t f m e a he t te t nt a pr t c i
ai t zm n eala i or ls e t e s s or nt l alh r a me nd o e tve
c t y. Fi ly,he al ge t ta i sr tve ofi il ha i ed hi r que t t add ce ti
usod
nal
le s ha dm nita i
fca s ve gnor
s e ss o
ran

imae t h s ç e p s p rt' l t He a k t e c u tt is e ijmcins dr ci p io
n ts o i G e e aae' i .
k
s
s s h o r o su nt to ie t rs n
ng
ofk il t r ve s t s a r e dec sons a
f a s o e r e he e dve s
ii
bouthi cas ii ai saus ,a pl c hi i
s l sfc ton t t es nd a e m n
pr e tvec t y wih a e st m e a heat team e .
ot c i usod t cc s o nt l lh r t nt
I.
I

Un e 2 U.. j 2 5 49, a fd r l c u t c n t g a t a h b a p tto t e s
d r 8 SC. 2 4 1
e ea o r a no r n
a e s eiin mls
pe ii r has e use t r m e e ava lbl i t c t of t sa e i whih he wa
ttone
xha t d he e di s ia e n he ours
he tt n
c
s
c ced. Uli a ey,exha to r quiest pe ii ne t pr e hi c am st t hi tsae
onvi t
tm t l
usi n e r he tto r o es nt s l i o he ghes t t

c u twihjlidcin t c nsd rte a rc iea nlng Se O' u l a v. ec l 5
o r t t s ito o o ie h m nd e ev
r
l . e S li n Bo rke, 26
i
v
U. 8 ,8 5 (9 9 . I a j2 4 p t o e ha n tp e e td hi h be scamst t e sae
S. 38 4 1 9 ) f
25 ehin r s o r sn e s a a li o h tt

c u t a dc u dsi d s , f d rlc u t ho dds s h sp tto wih u p eu ie Slv o
o rs n o l tl o o a e ea o r s ul imis i ei n t o t rj d c . a t n
t
i
v.Smih,404U. 53,5 ( 71 .
t
S. 4 19 )
M e r i c t s on t f c ofhi pe ii t the hasnottl a pe ii f a wrtof
ye s ndia e
he a e
s tton ha
ied
tton or
i

ha a c pusi a saec ut rii hi c r cli .Hi camsf j i c t ce ta e
be s or n ny tt ot asng s urent ams s li or al usody rdi r
c
ogni a e i ha as c pus pr e ngs i V i g ni howeve . See Ca r l v.J
z bl n be or
oc edi
n r i a,
r
r ol
ohns 68
on, 5

S. 2d 647,652 ( 2009)( dng t tpeiine s e ng pro c t ce to a Vigi a
E.
Va.
holi ha tto r e ki ir usody rdi n
r ni
s ntnc c d s khabe c pusrle,be a eû n or r e e e i ( s f vor i eprtng a
e e e oul ee
as or eif c us G de, ntr d n hiq a ,ntr ei
a

2

c n cin o a sn e e E ud ,a a ma trof1w a d sa dng aè e dr cl i a tt
o vito r e tnc , wo ll s
te
a n tn i ln , ie ty mp c he
d to o E s c nsn me f). Hema fl aha e sc r u p tto i t ecr utc u t e e
main f hiq o e n
y ie b a o p s eiin n h ic i o r wh r
he was c c e wih a s e nta alt t Supr m e Cour ofVigi a o he m a fl
onvit d, t
ubs que ppe o he
e
t
r ni , r
y e

s c apei o drcl i teS p e Co l o Vigna S eVa Co eAn j 80 - 5 ( ( )
u h tt n ie ty n h u rme u' f r ii. e . d n. j .1 6 4 A)1,
i
t

1 .- 6B) Ac o d n l,M e es h s no y te a se a ia e sae c u trme is a
7 140 ( . c r i gy y r a t e xh u td valbl tt o r e de s
r q ie t e j2 5 *) a t e c u tmu tds s h scamsfrj i c t d ce i wi u
e urd md r 2 4 , nd h o r s imis i li o al uso y rdt t t
ho
p eu iet alw hm t p e e tte e camsfrtt t sae c u t. I M e e si d saife
rj d c o l i o r s n h s li is o he tt o rs f y r s is ts d
o
wiht eo to o h ssaec u t a e sp o e dn s h ma t e fl aj2 5 p tto i t i
t h u c me f i tt o r h b a r c e ig , e y h n ie
2 4 ei n n h s
i
court
.

Th c u t l as ds s wi o tp eu ieM e e s d p oc s camsc n e n t e
e o r wil lo imis t u rj dc y r ' ue r e s li o c mig h
h
r t as i d f hi t e r good co uc tm e i t f t e,be us t scli lc me i. A
ae sgne or m o a n
nd t i n he u ur ca e hi a m a ks rt
Vigi a i ae ha no c tmtonal pr e t d lbe t i e es i a pari ulrr t ofe i
r ni nm t s
onsi i ly ot c e i ry nt r t n ny tc a a e am ng

g o c n u ttme a an th ssn e c . Mil v.Home ,9 F.Su p.3 9 4,9 5 ( D.Va
o d o d c i g is i e tn e ls
l s 5
p d 2 3 E.
.
20 5 ( o dn t a Vign a imae ha e n prtce lb ry itrs i GCA e r n lv l
1 ) h l ig h t r ii n t s v o oe td i et n eet n
anig e e)
(iigW etv. meo ,1 5F.d 2 ( t Ci.9 )(n u ls e )(l mae h ven p oe td
ctn
s Ar lne 6 3 2 4h r1 98 u p b ih d G n ts a o r tce
s
lbe t i t r t i r m ani i or beng a sgne t a pa tc a good c
i ry n e es n e i ng n
i si d o
ri ulr
onduc alowa
t l nce

lv l . .) J me v.Ro is n 45 F.d 4 ( t Ci.9 4 ( u ls e ) (a ) Be a s
e e. .'; a s
'
bn o ,
3 26 4h r1 9 ) t b ih d sme . c u e
mp
M e st hasno c nsiu i na due pr es cli r a di hi GCA ea ni lve,hi cai s
yer hus
o tt to l
oc s am eg r ng s
r ng e l s l m
r ga di t s sa u c ngesdonotpr s nta gr
e r ng he e tt s ha
e e ny oundsf rf de alha sr le .
o e r bea ei f
1 1.
1

Th c u t l as d s s M e r' e iigcamswi o tp eudc , e a ete ae
e o r wi lo imis yes r mann li
l
t u rj ie b c us h y r
h
n ta p o raeyrie i a j2 5 p tto . Th fd r lh b a c russa ue ga tadsrc
o p r p itl as d n
2 4 eiin e e e a a e s o p tt ts rn itit
c u tu d cint e tranpei o frh be sc r usr le f rpes n whod mo srt t t
o rj ds ito o n e ti tt ns o a a op eif o ro s
i
e n tae ha

3

t y a e i c t i vi ai oft c tt i orl wsorte tes o t Unie Stt . 28
he r n usody n ol ton he onsiuton
a
r a i f he t d a es

U. C. j2 41c () 2 4( M ae v Co k 4 0U. 48 , 0( 9 9 .
S. j 2 ()3 , 25 $; lna . o , 9 S. 8 49 1 8 )
G ti we ls tl t tchal ngest t f torl ngt ofc i me a epr ry
t s l e ted ha
l
le
o he ac
e h
onfne nt r ope l
c i r d i t c ex ofha a c pus'whie c le est t condii of
onsde e n he ont t
be s or ' l ha lng o he
tons
o s c i m e a e pr ry br
ne' ontne nt r ope l ought as c vi rght a tons Se Pl e v.
i l i s c i . e ylr

M o r ,1 9 F.d 7 , 3 ( t Ci.1 9 )(iig P es rv Ro rg e ,41 U.
o e 2 3 28 7 3 4h r 9 7 ctn r ie . d iu z 1 S.
4 5 48 - 8( 9 3 ( o dn t tac aln et t elngho C cu lc nfn me t
7 , 7 8 1 7 ) h l ig ha h le g o h e t f l ta o ie n
a
i p io 'mus b b o g ta ah b a c r sa to l;To d v. s e vle 71
n rs n' t e r u h s a e s opu cin ) d Ba k r il, 2
F. 7 ,7 ( t Ci.1 8 ) (fa p tto c le g s t c ndto s o (h
2d 0 2 4h r 9 3 . I j ei n haln e he o iin f te
i
pei o rs c nfn me trt rt a te f c o lngh o h s c v ne n ,i
t ine 'j o i e n ahe h n h a t r e t f i o me t t
t
c nnotpr e a aha sc pusa ton.
n
oc ed s bea or
ci

Ro n o v Cra e No. 0 - 0 3 7, 0 9W L 1 7 6 2 a * ( D. . . r 21 2 0 )
bis n . e s y, 5:7 CV- 0 4 2 0
0 3 4 , t 8 S. W Va Ap . , 0 9 .

Ac o dn l c l n e t c ndto st whiht eimaei s b e tdli c n i me taen t
c r igy, hal g s o o i n o c h n t s u j c t ng o fne n r o
e
i
r
pr pe l br
o ry ought by w a of f de a ha as cor pr ee ngs M c n v. Ga t , No.
y
e r l be
pus oc di .
cai
ni y

30 CV4 5 2 0 W L 3 3 2 3 ( D.Va J l 1 , 0 )(i dn a cam rltngt me ia
:2 3 , 0 2
2 6 0 2 E.
. uy 6 20 2 fn ig li eai o dc l
c r wa i r p ry a v nc d u e 28 U. C.j 2 41 . Si lry i a imae s c u t
ae s mp o el d a e nd r
S.
2 ) mia l, f n n t ' o r
s ison s e E omehi ot r t n i e a e or m o e s dy r l s - t ta to l
ubm s i e ks s t ng he ha mm dit
s
r pee eea e he r dii na
PUr os of ha s c pus' t n G be c pus i not a a o i t or a ia e f de a
P e
bea or ,' he t as or
ha
s
n ppr pr a e
va l bl e r l

r med ' Pr ie , 1U. a 49
e y. e s r 41 S. t 4.
'
M e r 'r m ani cli do nots k hi i me ae ors
ye s e i ng a ms
ee s m di t
oonerr l as fom c t y a
ee e r
usod nd
a e,t r f e,no pr ry pr s nt d t t c t i t s ha a a ton. The e cli s r he e or
t ope l e e e o he our n hi be s c i
s am
c
onceni hi s c iy c a sfc ton a ke p s pa ae ls,hi me a he lh team e or
r ng s e urt l s ii a i nd e e r t it s nt l at r t nt
a l ged l k t e ,hi a l ge ne f pr ec i c t
le
ac her of s le d ed or ot tve us ody,of i e s alege r t la i a i t
f c r ' l d e a i ton ga ns
hi f flng gde nc - co e a c le t t c t o he ha e re e d i hi
m or ii
va es
nc m
ha l nge o he ondii ns
s xpe i nc d ur na s

c
onfne e ,r t rt n a c le oft f c orlngt ofhi co i m e . M or ve ,ast
m nt ahe ha
hal nge he a t e h
s nfne nt
eo r
o

e c o t s cams M e esi s e ig ij n tverle
a h f he e li , y r s e kn nu ci eif

o d r dr cig p io o fcast
r es ie tn rs n fiil o

pr de c ran housng c
ovi e ti
i hange ora omm oda i - r t rt n s e ng habe c pusr i f
s cc
tons
ahe ha e ki
as or
ele

4

t tme ey fndst f c orl h ofhi c i me t be unl wf . Acc di y,t c t
ha r l i
he a t engt
s onfne nt o
a ul
or ngl he our

c n ld s t a M e es rmanng cams ae no c g ia l t e j 2 4 a d mu t b
o cu e h t y r' e ii li r t o n z b e md r 25 n
s e
sl a iydim is d wihoutpr l di e.'
lmm rl s s e t
eu c
-

Fo t r as sa e t co tdimis a lt c am s i M eye s s petton wiho
r he e ons t t d, he ur s s es l he l i n
r'
ii
t ut

p eudc . An a p o raeo d rwile trti d y.Th Clr i drce t s n c pe o t i
rj ie
p r p it r e l ne l s a
l
e ek s ie td o e d o is f hs
memor ndlm o ri n a a co pa ng o de t peii r
a l pilo nd c m nyi r r o ttone .

ENTER:Ths S
i

d yo Fe r ay 2 7
a f b u r, 01 .
Chi fU ied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge

1 The cour declnest cons nl M eyer nont i o
t e
s'
habeas cor cli s i t ss i i as a ci l
pus am n hi ubm sson
vi

rg s a to u r42 U. C.j 1 3. Th c re t s s in d e no icud t e ne e s r fc u l
iht ci n nde
S.
98
e u rn ubmiso o s t n l e h c sa y a t a
s po tf r s h cams und r j 1 8 Se BelAt.Co .v.Two v,5 U. 5 4,5 ( 07
up r o uc li
e 9 3. e l l p
mbl 50 S. 4 55 20 )
( dng t tsaig acam E e uie mor t n lbesa c cuson ' a t a c mplitmu tsae
holi ha ttn li l q r s e ha a l nd on l i s' nd h t o an s tt
r
s t e tdm a t a alg to ...o rie arg tt r le a vet s e ultve lve' . M oro r t
ufkin d cu l le ains t a s i h o eif bo he p c ai e l)
'
e ve , o

p ru hscamsu d rj1 8 , y r mu t o sn t p (te$ 5 fl gfefrs c a a to ;nti
u se i li n e 9 3 Me es s c n e to a h 3 0 ii e o u h n cin i hs
n

c s ,he h s o y i iae hi wilng s t t $ 00 flng f ea ia et a ha a c r usa ton.
ae
a nl ndc t d s ll ne s o he 5. il e pplc bl o
be s o p ci

Fo t e e ra o ,t c u twilno c nsr e a fl M e r 'j225 peiin a a j 1 3 c mpan
r h s e s ns he o r l t o tu nd ie ye s
4 tto s
98 o lit
i t a I hewihe t p s j 1 cams hema do s b fln ane a s p rt c mpaitt t
nse d. f
s s o urue 983 li ,
y o y iig w nd e a ae o l n ha
meet t pl ng r r m ent f s an acton.
s he eadi equie
s or uch
i