Meyers v. Large et al

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/8/2017. (tvt)

O mn soF I u. as
J x' FcE s mcouW '
A q A o ,h
T oNl v
'
Fu
l Eo

I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F V I G I A
C
R NI
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

FEB 22 2 1
27
J A 'D D
ULI ,
BY:

,

g
,

ANTH ONY M EYERS,

CASE NO . 1
7: 7CV00024

Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

M E M O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

KRYSTAL LARGE, AL.
c
,

By: G l E.C onrad
en
C hi U nied Stat D i t ctJudge
ef t
es s ri

De e
f ndants.
t)
Ant
hony M e s a Vigi ai t pr e ng pr K ,fl d t s cvi rgh saci n unde
yer , r ni nma e oc edi
o
ie hi i l i t to
r
.

4 U. C.j 1 8 ,algn t a a n ls p a t ine a te j i wh r h i c n ie i n t
2 S.
9 3 l ig h t t e r ci o r t h al ee e s o fn d s o
e
r
t
pr di hi a qua e m edi alc r . The c e ha no ye be s r d on t def nda s and
ovi ng m de t
c ae
as s t t en e ve
he e nt ,

by s pa a e or r t co twildiec M e r t fl a a e d c
e r t de , he ur l r t ye s o ie n m nde ompl i m n ng a c e ra
ant ki
l a nd

pa tc a i e sa e e toft cai shewihest ptr ue a i tea h de e nt On Fe ' r
riulrz d t t m n
he l m
s
o ls ga ns c f nda .
bl y
ua
7,201 howe r t cour r c ve a lte i whi h M e r c m pl i t the i i g ea pan
7,
ve , he
t e ei d e tr n
c
ye s o ans ha
sn r t i

a d s e i dae c u ta ssa c ( No 1 ) Th c u tc nsr e ti s b sin a a
n e ks mme it o r sitn e ECF . 1. e o r o tu s h s u miso s

mo inf ritro u o yij nci rle t tmu tb d n e
to o n elc t r nu t eif ha s e e id.
ve
M e r saes t the ha bee s f rng E ie a e m e c is s'snc he wa frt
ye s t t ha
s n ufe i t s r bl
m
dial s ue ' i e
s is

ic r eae a t e < ufi l J i'i M ac 7,2 6 1 ( te 1 ECF No 1 . l hs
n a c rtd t h & fed al n rh
D
'
01 . Letr ,
. 1) n i
s isons hei c e t tove t l tm e snc hi a va ,hehass n doc or a anur e
ubm s i , ndiats ha
r weve i s i e s ni l
ee
t s nd
s
pr c ii r he ha be n pr de a i o i ,a he ha unde gone t ss buthi çis i sil
a ttone ,
s e ovi d ntbi tcs nd
s
r
e t,
s Gs ue s tl

pr e sng a getngwore. Pan i a 1 1 /G '. (d. He saest thi motonsas ngt
ogrsi nd ti
s
i s - 0t10' I )
tt ha s i
ki o

s e a o ti e d co o s e il th v b e u u c sf la d ta tej i' me ia safi
e n u sd o tr r p cai a e e n ns c e su n h t h als d c l tf s
s
1 I a copy ofa J
n
anuar 23, 201 j i r q s f n, ye ssae t t ha wa G lc d o a
y
7,al e uet on Me r tts ha he s s E a e n
p

pr tt te t n l lnli No 201 by KRYSTAL LARGE NP, b ha no be n b c t s e he
osae r ame t pa n v. 6
' ut s t e a k o e r
'
snc t n.( No. ) I r s ons ,aj i c p ansae : C wilne d t s a wih me iala t
i e he ECF 9. n e p e al a t i tt s G
You l e o pe k t dc bou
yo st ain s i ma be pr pe l a drs e ' (#- M e r do no sae wheh r h t r a tr
ur iu to o t y
o ry d e s d. J ,
' ) ye s es t tt
t e e hee fe
f lwe a prpraejipo e rst se dfee tme ia c r.
olo d p o it al rc due o ek ifrn dc l ae

a r t thsl e lh i veymu h i j L q a d (n h s is ei g tigwo s a af s rt .
wae ha i G at s r c n eo p r y a d iq su s et
h
n re t a t ae'
'
(d) M e e ssae : G ud t c u tp e s a ss me i g ti i dae a d a p o rae
I . y r tts û l he o r la e sit n et mme it n p r p it
co
ng
me ia atn ina s o a po sbl?'(d 2)
dc l te to s o n s si e ' I . .

Th pat s e i ap ei n r ij n to mus ma eace rs o n Gh thei l ey
e ry e kng r l a y nu cin t k la h wig s a s i l
mi
t
k
t s c ed on t m e is he i lke y t s f r ir pa a e ha m i t abs nc ofpr lm i r
o uc e
he rt ; s i l o ufe re r bl r n he e e
ei na y

rle;t a t ebaa eo e uiistp i h sfvo ;a a ij n to i i tepu l itrs.
eif h t h lnc f q te is n i a r nd n n u cin s n h bi n ee t'
c
'
W itrv Nau a Re . f Co n i.I . 5 5U..7 20( 0 ) S c itro u oy ij n tv
n e . t rl s De . u cl nc, 5 S , 2 08 . u h ne lc tr n u cie
r le i Ga e r r na y r med t t m a onl be a r d u n a c e r s
ei f s tn xtao di r e y ha
y y
wa de po
l a howi t t t
ng ha he
pli ifi e il t s h r le . I a 22.
a ntf s ntted o uc e if' d. t
'
Onl delbe ae i fe e e t al i ae' s rous medialne d vi at t Ei h
y i r t ndif r nc o t nm t s e i
c
e ol es he ght

Ame d n . Se Esel v. mbe 4 9U.. 7 1 2( 9 6 .A n reprci o ro oh rj i
n me t e tle Ga l, 2 S 9 , 0 1 7 ) u s a tt ne r te al
i
saf p ro i G eie aey id fee t' i s e ç o o a d d se ad ( r rs n s
tf es n s i l rtl n ifrn ' f h û ws f n ir g r s o epo d
d b
kn
l e s bl t a e si rs t i t he lh ors ft ' Fn me v.Brnnan,511U. 825,
mr a ona y o1 n xce sve ik o nmae at aey. r r e
'
S.

8 7 ( 9 4 . The d lb rt id fee e sa d r ûs n ts tsid b ...mee d s g e me t
3 1 9)
eieae n ifrnc tn a d G o aife y
i
r ia re n

c n enig Gqueto so me ia j g n ,'Ge man v S e rn 5 F. p' 39 3 5 (t
o c r n g l sin f d c l ud me t'' r i . h a i, 31 Ap x 2, 9 4 h
Ci. 3 (uoi Rusel S ef r 5 8F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 $, rme en g ie ei
r 201 ) q tng s l v. h fe, 2 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 o r e lg nc n
dignossorte t e .Esele, U . a 1 06.
a
i r am nt t l 429 S. t 05M e r ,i hi m o i n s ki i e l ut y r i ft o a n m e c c r ,f is t sa e
ye s n s to ee ng nt roc or ele o bt i
dial a e a l o t t
f c sm e tng one oft f urr quied ee e s i t W i e c e. I i c e rt tM e r ha
a t ei
he o e r lm nt n he nt r as t s l a ha
ye s s
naton
or
be npr vi d e e i me c lc r durnghi c i me a t j l exam i i by doct s
e o de xtnsve dia ae i s onfne nt t he ai:

a t nur e pr c ii ne ,m e ca t s s a m edi a i H e be i vest tt c r pr de w a
nd he s a tto r di l e t , nd
c ton.
le
ha he a e ovi d s

not c r t o wm i ufi i nt t a lvit hi uns ii d c ton o s
orec r s ns fc e o le ae s pecfe ondii r ympt . Suc
oms
h
alegai ns of ne i nt di gnos s or m e ca c r do no mee t r quied dei r t
l to
glge
a
e
di l a e
t
t he e r
lbe a e

i fe e e sa r t sa e a c tmtona ca m a i ta ne Si lry,M e s be if
ndif r nc t nda d o tt
onsi i l li gans nyo . mia l
yer ' le
t thi c r ntco ton wa r nt r f ra t as cils i m e el adi a e m e wih t nur e
ha s ure
ndii
ra s e e r l o pe a it s r y s gr e nt t he s

p a tto rs me ia j d me ta u t p o e c u s o te t n f r li n e s S c
r ciine' dc l u g n bo t he r p r o re f r ame t o l e d . u h
s
dia e m e sdo nots
s gr e nt
uppo ta sndi ofdei r t i fe e e. Ac r ngl M e r 'c r nt
r
ng
lbe a e ndif r nc
co di y, ye s ure
al ga i do not s
le tons
how a lkelhood t the wils c d on t m e is of hi c tt tona
i i
ha
l uc ee
he rt
s onsiu i l
cai a ns t nure pr c iine ,one of t s wi he m us ma unde W i e t be
l ms gai t he s a tto r
he ho ngs
t ke
r nt r o

e t ldt itro uo yij n tv r l f
ni e o n el c t r n u cie ei .
t
e
Be aus M e r t c
c e ye s hus nnno m a t ne es a y,f -a t s
t ke he c s r ourf c or howi t thi sm ai
ng ha s i ton
wa r nt i e l ut r r le ,t cou twilde hi m oton. An a opra eor rwilis tls
ra s ntroc o y ei f he r l ny s i
ppr i t de l s ue li
da
y.

The Clr i d r c e t s nd c es of t s me or ndum opi on a a compa ng
e k s ie t d o e
opi
hi m a
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pli if
de o antf .

ENTER:Thi Q
s

d yo Fe nlr, 01
a f b ay 2 7.

ChifUni d St t sDititJ
e
a e src udge