Adams v. Light et al

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2017. (tvt)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI rnlr
S
CE S. SI - l
AT RO/NOKE,
è
L
VA
; Tj
'l. o
.:
.
j

MAt 29 2 1
â?
I T H E U NI
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E DIV ISIO N

DOM I
NQUE HERM AN ADAM S,
Pl ntf
ai if,

R. GHT, K ,
LI
c
Deendant.
f
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J A n u' L
ULI
BY:
DE

CASE NO.7:
17CV00027
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

By: GlnE. nr d
e Co a
Chi Unie St e DititJudge
ef t d ats src

Domi que He n Ada s a Vig ri i a e pr e ng pr K ,sld t s cvi rght
ni
nna
m ,
r ila nm t oce di
o
e hi i l i s

a i ptrua t 42 U. C.j 1 algi t tprs ofkil a Red Onin Stt Prs
cton ls nt o
S.
983, le ng ha ion t as t
o ae ion

p a e hm i f t -o n r s it f reg tho r wi o tj si to o d e p o e s Up n
lc d i n oz p i t ekan s o i h u s t u u tt i n r u r c s . o
r
h
ka
r viw of t r or t co tfnds t t t a ton m us be s m m a iy dim is d t de 42
e e
he ec d, he ur i
ha he c i
t
u
rl s s e m r

U. C.j1 9 ea , c u e i i ce rfo t e fc o te c mp an ta Ad msdd n tfl a
S.
9 7 () be a s t s la r m h a e f h o lit h t n i o ie
gre ncebe or c
i va
f e omm e i tlsl ui.
ncng li aws t

Ad msi i c r eae a W alnsli g S aePrs n (W alnsRig ' . Healg st t
a s n ac rtd t l td e tt io G l
e
G e . e'
d l
l e ha
e
on Se e r 1 2015,û dnms wa i or
pt mbe 6,
W
s nf med by Li htt pa k hi pe s lpr pe t a tr he
g o c s r ona o ry fe
sopped ki ki hi c ldoor a t Ada sa s d Coli t tCore to Ofi e J.Dea ha
t
c ng s el
, fer m dvi e
lns ha
r c i ns fc r
n d
de e hi hi outi r c e to t n Coli s i t Ada t t ç ofi r don' 1e ''
nid m s sde e r a i n, he
lns a d o
ms ha my fce s
t i .'

( mpl Ata h.3 !1 ECF No.13) Th r atr o t r e c re Ad ms t a t e c l,
Co . tc
,
- . e e fe, fke s s o td a o noh r el
srppe hi t hi unde s rs pl c a c i lrki li ha ufs wa s c i a 1 io ,
ti d m o s
rho t, a ed han il ng ls ndc f , it han, nd eg r ns
a l f hi r t a ned i t t m a r f ne r y e ghtho z s La e t t da Coli br ug a
nd e t m esr i
n ha
nne or a l i
lr . t r ha y, lns o ht

di cplna y c geag ns Ada sf t mpe i wih s u iy e pm e o de c
s i i r har
ai t m or a rng t ec rt qui nt r vie.

Ad msfld t sj 1 8 a to i Jn r 2 7. Li eal c n tun hi c mplit h
a ie hi 9 3 cin n a uay 01
b rly o sr i g s o an, e
alege t thol ng hi i f urpoi r sr nt f rne ry eghthour wiho ahe rng vi a e
l s ha di
m n o - nt e tai s o a l i
s t ut a i
olt d

ERK

hi rght unde t Ei h a Fo te h Am e e s Coli vi ae due pr e s by
s i s
r he ght nd ure nt
ndm nt ; lns olt d
oc s
br ngi a f l e di c plna y c ge;a s r s r ofi i l a l
i ng a s s i i r har
nd upe vi o y t c a s lowed t s vi a i t oc ur
he e ol tons o c .

Asr le ,Ada ss e m o t r da
ei f
m e ks nea y mage .
s

Th Prs n Liiain Reo m Ac (
e io tg to
fr
tG
TLRA' p o ie , a n o h r ti s t t a
' r vd s mo g t e hng , ha
)
prs
ioner c r brng a cvi aci n c e ni prs c to untlhe ha frt e use
amot i
i l to onc r ng ion ondii ns i
s is xha t d

a ia ea nitai rmedis Nusl v.Pore,534U. 51 52 (
valbl dmi srtve e e . se
tr
S. 6, 4 2002) Thi e usi
. s xha ton
r quie nti C
e rme s ç
mandaor ' Ros v.Blke,1 S.Ct 1
t y.
' s
a 36
. 850,1 ( ) I a ist G l
856 2016 . t pple o G
al
i t s t , t rt y i vege a cr um sa sorpa tc a e s ,...whehe t y
nma e uis whe he he nvol
ner l ic tnce
ri ul r piodes
t r he
alege e e sve f r e o s m e ot rm 'np' a whehe ornott f m ofr le t i ae
l
xc s i o c r o
he o ' nd
t r
he or
e if he nm t

se i a ia l tlo g e ha sin o a miitaie rme is d. ctng80 t v Ch me ,
e ks s valbe l u h x u to f d n sr t e de .1 (ii
r
v
0h . u r
5 2 U. 7 1 7 ( 0 ). To c mpy wi j1 9 e a,a imae mu tp o ry f lo e c
3 S. 3 , 41 2 01)
o l t 9 7 () n n t s r pel o lw a h
h
se oft esa ihe a nita i pr ed e t tt sa epr vi t prs r a me a 1
tp he t bls d dmi sr tve oc ur ha he t t o des o ione s nd et l

d a l swi nt t o e t eb fr tl g hsj1 3 a to Se W o d o dv. o 5 U.
e di
ne t ha pr c dl eo e ii i 98 cin. e o f r Ng , 48 S.
hi
r
n
8 ,9 - 4 ( 0 6 . E c u'ma s a s n ed s s a c mp an whe t alg d f csi t e
1 0 9 2 0 ) 1 o l y u po t imis o lit n he le e a t n h
A
t
co pl nt t ke a tu pr ve t tt i ae f l d t e us hi ad i sr tve r medis.
m ai , a n s r e, o ha he nm t aie o xha t s m nitai e
e '
'

Cusi v. vi, 51F.d35 , 6 ( t Ci. 01 )
ts Da s 8 3 8 3 1 4h r 2 7 .

The c u ttk s j iilnoie o t e fc ta Vigni De rme t o Co r cins
o r a e udca tc f h a t h t r i a pa t n f re to
(VDOC' Op rtngPr c d r (4 ' 8 61 i t ewrte a mi srtv r me isp oc dle
G
1
' eai o e u e : ) 6 . s h itn d nitaie e de r è t
)
OP'
r
t tVDOC i ts s h a Ada ,mus f l t c ywih j199 ()1 U nderOP 866 1
ha
nmae , uc s ms t olow o ompl t
7ea .
,
.

an i ae wih a g iva e a ut s m e e n or is mus fr tm a a g
nm t t
re nc bo o
ve t s ue
t is ke ood f ih efor t
at f t o
r ol hi c
es ve s once ns i o ly i medit l a tr'he i de ,nonnaly by flng a i onna
r nf nna l m
a ey fe t nci nt
l
ii n nf
l
1 See OP 866. 1 Ofe de Gre nc Pr c du e he :, f n r iva e o e r , /
/

(a tvii dM a 9, 7 .
ls st
e y 201 )

. d . r i ag v a ou o e r s
va ocvigni.o / b Fpr c du e

c
ompl i f m . Prs n sa fs dpr de t i ae wih awrte r s e on t botom of
ant or
io t f houl ovi he nm t t
itn e pons
he t
t i o ma c
he nf r l ompl i f a r t n i t hi wihi ffe n days Thei a ec n t n i tae
ant onn nd eur t o m t n ite
.
nm t a he nii t
t ne s e unde OP 866. - a r gul rgre
he xt t p
r
1
e a i vanc w ih t i or a c pl i a t he
e, t he nf m l om a nt tac d.

A r ulr gre nc mus be fl d wihi 30 da of t occzr nce a ut whih i
eg a i va e
t
ie
tn
ys
he
tre
bo
c t

c
ompli . Afe i si aton oft gre nce t wa de orhi de i
ans tr nve tg i
he i va , he r n
s sgneewils nd t i ae
l e he nm t
a Le l 1 r s
ve e pons . I t r pondi ofi i l dde m i t gr e nce t be t ounde ' f r
e f he es
ng fc a
r nes he i va
o
l
unf
d,' o

f l e usi n of a l e r m e e ,t i e. t a a t t hol ng t Le l 1, t
ul xha to
vaiabl e di s he nmat mus ppe l ha
di o ve 1 he
r gi la i sr t , i s m eca e , o Le l11
e ona dm nitaor and n o
s s t ve 1 .
On t f ce of hi c pl nt A da s s a e t the di nott l a gr e nce r ga di
he a
s om ai , m t t s ha
d
i e ny i va s e r ng

tecamsr ie i hsj 1 8 c mp an . Heh sas s b te c p e o ohe r me yf r
h li as d n i 9 3 o lit
a lo u mitd o is f t r e d o ms
he fl pu poredl i a e f tt e us. M or t n a ye ra trt i de a is ,Adnms
ied, r t y n n for o xha t
e ha
a fe he nci nt t s ue
frt sl d a i or c
is e n nf mal ompl i f m ,dae Oc o r 16,201 c
ant or
td t be
6, ompli ng t t ofi e s ha
a ni ha fc r d

plc d hm i ç mb ao yr srit'freg th u so Se tmb i1 ,2 6. ( S.a 3 ECF
a e i n t ultr e tan s' o ih o r n pe e 6 01 V. , t ,
a
No. ) Thers n e d td Oco e 21 201 ,sae t a a c r igt r c r s no a u ao y
2.
epo s , ae t b r , 6 ttd h t c o dn o e o d , mb ltr
r sr i s ha be n a i d t Ada s o Se e be 16,201 Ada s fl a s ond i onnal
e tant d e pple o
m n pt m r
6.
m ied ec
nf
c
ompl i ,da e Ocober24,2016,m adng t s
ant t d t
l
he ame c
ompl i ,butsai t c r c da e of
ant
ttng he ore t t
t n
he mbult r r sr nt i i nt a Se e r 1 2015. The m i tn r pons , daed
a o y e tai s nc de s pt mbe 6,
te es e t
,

Nove be 11 201 i c t d t tAdn s had wat d mor t 30 da t fl a i or al
m r , 6, ndia e ha
m '
ie
e han
ys o ie n nf m
c
ompli a
ant bouta Se e r201 i de . Bas d on t sr s
pt mbe
5 nci nt
e
hi e pons ,Ada s a gue t theha
e
m r s ha
d
7

no ava l bl a i sr tve r m e es i Oc obe 201 a t t any a t pt t fl a r gul r
ia e dm ni t a i e di n t r
6 nd ha
tem
o ie e a
g i vanc or f r he a
re
e
u t r ppea s w as f ie. H e a gues t tt s a l ge f tlt i 201 e us hi
l
m l
r
ha hi le d ' iiy n
u
6 xc ed m

fo tee h usinrq ie n u d rj1 7ea .Hei mitk n
r m h x a to e ur me t n e 99 ()
s sa e .

Ada doe not sa e a f c s s
ms
s
tt ny a t ugge tng t t t g i va pr e e a W a lns
si ha he re nce oc dur s t le
Ri we e una ia e t hi i a r pec i Se e
dge r
val bl o m n ny es t n pt mber a Oc obe 201 or t t t
nd t r
5,
ha he
pr ed le di notofe a r le . Ros ,1 S.Ct a 1859. Ra he ,Adams a l to ,tke
oc tr s d
f r ny e if
s 36
.t
t r
' legai ns a n
a tue s w t the f ie t a tmpt e usi of s h gre nc pr e le i e a ey
s r , ho ha
a ld o te
xha ton
uc iva e oc dtr s mm di t l
f l ng t Se e r 201 i i nt a i t a wat d mor t n a ye r t fl hi frt
olowi he pt mbe
5 ncde nd, nse d, ie
e ha
a o ie s is

i or a c
nf m l ompl i f r sa
ant o m bouti. Onc t d t the had fl d out i t 30- y de dlne f a
t
e ol ha
ie
sde he da a i or
r l r gre nc he s o d a t m ptng e us i Thus i i c ea f om t f c of Adn s'
egu a i va e, t ppe te i xha ton.
, t s l r r he a e
m

c
ompli ta a t hme st the di notc m plt t a ia e se i t VDOC gre nce
a n nd tac nt ha
d
o e e he va lbl tps n he
i va
pr edu e: he di not fl a tm e y i or a c
oc r
d
ie i l nf m l ompl i or r ulr g iva e i t 30 da
ant
eg a re nc n he
ys
f l ng t i de a a a cons que e,f ie t pur ue t a i sr tve r m e es a
olowi he nci nt nd, s
e nc a ld o s he dm nita i e di nd
a
ppeas t n a ia e t hi unde OP 866. . The c tc l
l he val bl o m
r
1
our oncudes t t s cla f l e t
hat hi e r aiur o

c mpl wih 4 U. C. j1 9 ea b fr fl g hi j1 3 c mpan b r t s lws i.
o y t 2 S.
9 7 () e o e ii s 98 o lit a s hi a ut
n
Ac o dngy t c u twi sl
c r i l, he o r l l
l mmmiy d s s t e a to wi u p eudc . An a p o rae
l imis h cin t t rj ie
ho
p r p it
or rw ili s t sda
de l s ue hi y.

The Clr i die t d t s c es o t s me or ndum o ni a a co pa ng
e k s r c e o end opi f hi m a
pi on nd c m nyi
or rt pl ntf.
de o ai if

ENTER:Ths 9 d yo Ma , 01
i
a f y 2 7.
Chif nie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

4