Adams v. Light et al
Filing
12
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2017. (tvt)
CLERK' OFFI U. DI rnlr
S
CE S. SI - l
AT RO/NOKE,
è
L
VA
; Tj
'l. o
.:
.
j
MAt 29 2 1
â?
I T H E U NI
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E DIV ISIO N
DOM I
NQUE HERM AN ADAM S,
Pl ntf
ai if,
R. GHT, K ,
LI
c
Deendant.
f
s
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
J A n u' L
ULI
BY:
DE
CASE NO.7:
17CV00027
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By: GlnE. nr d
e Co a
Chi Unie St e DititJudge
ef t d ats src
Domi que He n Ada s a Vig ri i a e pr e ng pr K ,sld t s cvi rght
ni
nna
m ,
r ila nm t oce di
o
e hi i l i s
a i ptrua t 42 U. C.j 1 algi t tprs ofkil a Red Onin Stt Prs
cton ls nt o
S.
983, le ng ha ion t as t
o ae ion
p a e hm i f t -o n r s it f reg tho r wi o tj si to o d e p o e s Up n
lc d i n oz p i t ekan s o i h u s t u u tt i n r u r c s . o
r
h
ka
r viw of t r or t co tfnds t t t a ton m us be s m m a iy dim is d t de 42
e e
he ec d, he ur i
ha he c i
t
u
rl s s e m r
U. C.j1 9 ea , c u e i i ce rfo t e fc o te c mp an ta Ad msdd n tfl a
S.
9 7 () be a s t s la r m h a e f h o lit h t n i o ie
gre ncebe or c
i va
f e omm e i tlsl ui.
ncng li aws t
Ad msi i c r eae a W alnsli g S aePrs n (W alnsRig ' . Healg st t
a s n ac rtd t l td e tt io G l
e
G e . e'
d l
l e ha
e
on Se e r 1 2015,û dnms wa i or
pt mbe 6,
W
s nf med by Li htt pa k hi pe s lpr pe t a tr he
g o c s r ona o ry fe
sopped ki ki hi c ldoor a t Ada sa s d Coli t tCore to Ofi e J.Dea ha
t
c ng s el
, fer m dvi e
lns ha
r c i ns fc r
n d
de e hi hi outi r c e to t n Coli s i t Ada t t ç ofi r don' 1e ''
nid m s sde e r a i n, he
lns a d o
ms ha my fce s
t i .'
( mpl Ata h.3 !1 ECF No.13) Th r atr o t r e c re Ad ms t a t e c l,
Co . tc
,
- . e e fe, fke s s o td a o noh r el
srppe hi t hi unde s rs pl c a c i lrki li ha ufs wa s c i a 1 io ,
ti d m o s
rho t, a ed han il ng ls ndc f , it han, nd eg r ns
a l f hi r t a ned i t t m a r f ne r y e ghtho z s La e t t da Coli br ug a
nd e t m esr i
n ha
nne or a l i
lr . t r ha y, lns o ht
di cplna y c geag ns Ada sf t mpe i wih s u iy e pm e o de c
s i i r har
ai t m or a rng t ec rt qui nt r vie.
Ad msfld t sj 1 8 a to i Jn r 2 7. Li eal c n tun hi c mplit h
a ie hi 9 3 cin n a uay 01
b rly o sr i g s o an, e
alege t thol ng hi i f urpoi r sr nt f rne ry eghthour wiho ahe rng vi a e
l s ha di
m n o - nt e tai s o a l i
s t ut a i
olt d
ERK
hi rght unde t Ei h a Fo te h Am e e s Coli vi ae due pr e s by
s i s
r he ght nd ure nt
ndm nt ; lns olt d
oc s
br ngi a f l e di c plna y c ge;a s r s r ofi i l a l
i ng a s s i i r har
nd upe vi o y t c a s lowed t s vi a i t oc ur
he e ol tons o c .
Asr le ,Ada ss e m o t r da
ei f
m e ks nea y mage .
s
Th Prs n Liiain Reo m Ac (
e io tg to
fr
tG
TLRA' p o ie , a n o h r ti s t t a
' r vd s mo g t e hng , ha
)
prs
ioner c r brng a cvi aci n c e ni prs c to untlhe ha frt e use
amot i
i l to onc r ng ion ondii ns i
s is xha t d
a ia ea nitai rmedis Nusl v.Pore,534U. 51 52 (
valbl dmi srtve e e . se
tr
S. 6, 4 2002) Thi e usi
. s xha ton
r quie nti C
e rme s ç
mandaor ' Ros v.Blke,1 S.Ct 1
t y.
' s
a 36
. 850,1 ( ) I a ist G l
856 2016 . t pple o G
al
i t s t , t rt y i vege a cr um sa sorpa tc a e s ,...whehe t y
nma e uis whe he he nvol
ner l ic tnce
ri ul r piodes
t r he
alege e e sve f r e o s m e ot rm 'np' a whehe ornott f m ofr le t i ae
l
xc s i o c r o
he o ' nd
t r
he or
e if he nm t
se i a ia l tlo g e ha sin o a miitaie rme is d. ctng80 t v Ch me ,
e ks s valbe l u h x u to f d n sr t e de .1 (ii
r
v
0h . u r
5 2 U. 7 1 7 ( 0 ). To c mpy wi j1 9 e a,a imae mu tp o ry f lo e c
3 S. 3 , 41 2 01)
o l t 9 7 () n n t s r pel o lw a h
h
se oft esa ihe a nita i pr ed e t tt sa epr vi t prs r a me a 1
tp he t bls d dmi sr tve oc ur ha he t t o des o ione s nd et l
d a l swi nt t o e t eb fr tl g hsj1 3 a to Se W o d o dv. o 5 U.
e di
ne t ha pr c dl eo e ii i 98 cin. e o f r Ng , 48 S.
hi
r
n
8 ,9 - 4 ( 0 6 . E c u'ma s a s n ed s s a c mp an whe t alg d f csi t e
1 0 9 2 0 ) 1 o l y u po t imis o lit n he le e a t n h
A
t
co pl nt t ke a tu pr ve t tt i ae f l d t e us hi ad i sr tve r medis.
m ai , a n s r e, o ha he nm t aie o xha t s m nitai e
e '
'
Cusi v. vi, 51F.d35 , 6 ( t Ci. 01 )
ts Da s 8 3 8 3 1 4h r 2 7 .
The c u ttk s j iilnoie o t e fc ta Vigni De rme t o Co r cins
o r a e udca tc f h a t h t r i a pa t n f re to
(VDOC' Op rtngPr c d r (4 ' 8 61 i t ewrte a mi srtv r me isp oc dle
G
1
' eai o e u e : ) 6 . s h itn d nitaie e de r è t
)
OP'
r
t tVDOC i ts s h a Ada ,mus f l t c ywih j199 ()1 U nderOP 866 1
ha
nmae , uc s ms t olow o ompl t
7ea .
,
.
an i ae wih a g iva e a ut s m e e n or is mus fr tm a a g
nm t t
re nc bo o
ve t s ue
t is ke ood f ih efor t
at f t o
r ol hi c
es ve s once ns i o ly i medit l a tr'he i de ,nonnaly by flng a i onna
r nf nna l m
a ey fe t nci nt
l
ii n nf
l
1 See OP 866. 1 Ofe de Gre nc Pr c du e he :, f n r iva e o e r , /
/
(a tvii dM a 9, 7 .
ls st
e y 201 )
. d . r i ag v a ou o e r s
va ocvigni.o / b Fpr c du e
c
ompl i f m . Prs n sa fs dpr de t i ae wih awrte r s e on t botom of
ant or
io t f houl ovi he nm t t
itn e pons
he t
t i o ma c
he nf r l ompl i f a r t n i t hi wihi ffe n days Thei a ec n t n i tae
ant onn nd eur t o m t n ite
.
nm t a he nii t
t ne s e unde OP 866. - a r gul rgre
he xt t p
r
1
e a i vanc w ih t i or a c pl i a t he
e, t he nf m l om a nt tac d.
A r ulr gre nc mus be fl d wihi 30 da of t occzr nce a ut whih i
eg a i va e
t
ie
tn
ys
he
tre
bo
c t
c
ompli . Afe i si aton oft gre nce t wa de orhi de i
ans tr nve tg i
he i va , he r n
s sgneewils nd t i ae
l e he nm t
a Le l 1 r s
ve e pons . I t r pondi ofi i l dde m i t gr e nce t be t ounde ' f r
e f he es
ng fc a
r nes he i va
o
l
unf
d,' o
f l e usi n of a l e r m e e ,t i e. t a a t t hol ng t Le l 1, t
ul xha to
vaiabl e di s he nmat mus ppe l ha
di o ve 1 he
r gi la i sr t , i s m eca e , o Le l11
e ona dm nitaor and n o
s s t ve 1 .
On t f ce of hi c pl nt A da s s a e t the di nott l a gr e nce r ga di
he a
s om ai , m t t s ha
d
i e ny i va s e r ng
tecamsr ie i hsj 1 8 c mp an . Heh sas s b te c p e o ohe r me yf r
h li as d n i 9 3 o lit
a lo u mitd o is f t r e d o ms
he fl pu poredl i a e f tt e us. M or t n a ye ra trt i de a is ,Adnms
ied, r t y n n for o xha t
e ha
a fe he nci nt t s ue
frt sl d a i or c
is e n nf mal ompl i f m ,dae Oc o r 16,201 c
ant or
td t be
6, ompli ng t t ofi e s ha
a ni ha fc r d
plc d hm i ç mb ao yr srit'freg th u so Se tmb i1 ,2 6. ( S.a 3 ECF
a e i n t ultr e tan s' o ih o r n pe e 6 01 V. , t ,
a
No. ) Thers n e d td Oco e 21 201 ,sae t a a c r igt r c r s no a u ao y
2.
epo s , ae t b r , 6 ttd h t c o dn o e o d , mb ltr
r sr i s ha be n a i d t Ada s o Se e be 16,201 Ada s fl a s ond i onnal
e tant d e pple o
m n pt m r
6.
m ied ec
nf
c
ompl i ,da e Ocober24,2016,m adng t s
ant t d t
l
he ame c
ompl i ,butsai t c r c da e of
ant
ttng he ore t t
t n
he mbult r r sr nt i i nt a Se e r 1 2015. The m i tn r pons , daed
a o y e tai s nc de s pt mbe 6,
te es e t
,
Nove be 11 201 i c t d t tAdn s had wat d mor t 30 da t fl a i or al
m r , 6, ndia e ha
m '
ie
e han
ys o ie n nf m
c
ompli a
ant bouta Se e r201 i de . Bas d on t sr s
pt mbe
5 nci nt
e
hi e pons ,Ada s a gue t theha
e
m r s ha
d
7
no ava l bl a i sr tve r m e es i Oc obe 201 a t t any a t pt t fl a r gul r
ia e dm ni t a i e di n t r
6 nd ha
tem
o ie e a
g i vanc or f r he a
re
e
u t r ppea s w as f ie. H e a gues t tt s a l ge f tlt i 201 e us hi
l
m l
r
ha hi le d ' iiy n
u
6 xc ed m
fo tee h usinrq ie n u d rj1 7ea .Hei mitk n
r m h x a to e ur me t n e 99 ()
s sa e .
Ada doe not sa e a f c s s
ms
s
tt ny a t ugge tng t t t g i va pr e e a W a lns
si ha he re nce oc dur s t le
Ri we e una ia e t hi i a r pec i Se e
dge r
val bl o m n ny es t n pt mber a Oc obe 201 or t t t
nd t r
5,
ha he
pr ed le di notofe a r le . Ros ,1 S.Ct a 1859. Ra he ,Adams a l to ,tke
oc tr s d
f r ny e if
s 36
.t
t r
' legai ns a n
a tue s w t the f ie t a tmpt e usi of s h gre nc pr e le i e a ey
s r , ho ha
a ld o te
xha ton
uc iva e oc dtr s mm di t l
f l ng t Se e r 201 i i nt a i t a wat d mor t n a ye r t fl hi frt
olowi he pt mbe
5 ncde nd, nse d, ie
e ha
a o ie s is
i or a c
nf m l ompl i f r sa
ant o m bouti. Onc t d t the had fl d out i t 30- y de dlne f a
t
e ol ha
ie
sde he da a i or
r l r gre nc he s o d a t m ptng e us i Thus i i c ea f om t f c of Adn s'
egu a i va e, t ppe te i xha ton.
, t s l r r he a e
m
c
ompli ta a t hme st the di notc m plt t a ia e se i t VDOC gre nce
a n nd tac nt ha
d
o e e he va lbl tps n he
i va
pr edu e: he di not fl a tm e y i or a c
oc r
d
ie i l nf m l ompl i or r ulr g iva e i t 30 da
ant
eg a re nc n he
ys
f l ng t i de a a a cons que e,f ie t pur ue t a i sr tve r m e es a
olowi he nci nt nd, s
e nc a ld o s he dm nita i e di nd
a
ppeas t n a ia e t hi unde OP 866. . The c tc l
l he val bl o m
r
1
our oncudes t t s cla f l e t
hat hi e r aiur o
c mpl wih 4 U. C. j1 9 ea b fr fl g hi j1 3 c mpan b r t s lws i.
o y t 2 S.
9 7 () e o e ii s 98 o lit a s hi a ut
n
Ac o dngy t c u twi sl
c r i l, he o r l l
l mmmiy d s s t e a to wi u p eudc . An a p o rae
l imis h cin t t rj ie
ho
p r p it
or rw ili s t sda
de l s ue hi y.
The Clr i die t d t s c es o t s me or ndum o ni a a co pa ng
e k s r c e o end opi f hi m a
pi on nd c m nyi
or rt pl ntf.
de o ai if
ENTER:Ths 9 d yo Ma , 01
i
a f y 2 7.
Chif nie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?