Owlfeather-Gorbey v. Baker
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 2/14/2017. (slt)
CLERK' oFFl u. DI .couR:
cE s, ST
f
,
ATDANVILEI
L VA
FI ED
L
I THE UNI
N
TED S
TATESDI
STRI COURT
CT
ys jj z j
gy
FOR TH E W EST ERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROANOKEDI SI
VI ON
BJ CD LYCL K
Y
E R
:
DEPUR CLERK
MI
CHAEL S. LFEATHER GORBEY,)
OW
Pl ntf,
ai if
)
)
v.
)
)
BAKER,e al,
t .
)
Dee nt.
fnda s
)
Ci l to No 7:7 c 0 0 1
viAci n . 1 -v- 0 5
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Hon.Jac on L.Kier
ks
s
Se o Unie S a e Dit itJ e
nir t d t ts src udg
o
M i ha lS. w le t r Gor y1 a f de ali a e pr e ng pr r , c m e d t sc vi
c e O f a he - be , e r nm t oce di
om nce hi i l
a t o pur ua t Bi ns v.Si Unknow n N n ed A ge s o Fe Bur a ofN a co i , 3 U .
c i n s nt o ve
x
m
nt f d. e u
r tcs 40 S.
' ec ds t ppe r ai if s d
t
388 38 ( 71 , Fe uay9,201 2 Upo rviw ofcoul r or , i a a sPl ntf ha ha
, 9 19 ) by br r
7.
ne e
a l s t e non- bea c vi ac i nsora
t ea t hr e
ha s i l to
ppea s pr vi usy d s i s d a f i ous asm a i i ,
l e o l i m s e s rvol ,
lc ous
o f rf lngt sa ea ca m bef r flngt sa to Se Owleahe - be v.J c on.e al,
r o aii o t t li
o e ii hi c i n. e
f t r Gor y a ks
t .
No 2:6c 0 5 , l o a 4( D. . pt2 , 01 )( imisdf rf iigt saeacam)
. 1 -v- 0 51 si p. t E. Va Se . 2 2 6 d s se o aln o tt li ;
p
Go b yv. Stt o Vicnis ta.No. 1 -v 0 6 , lpo a 4( D. . a.1 , 1
r e The ae f r i a e 1, 2:1 c - 01 4 si p. t E. Va M r 7 201 )
( s se f rfiigt saeacaml Gobe v Uni dSae . ta.No. 0 -v 0 21 si o
dimis d o al o tt li ; r y . t tts e l, 2:8 c - 01 , l p.
n
e
p
a 3 4( D. . . uy7 2 0 ( imisdf rf ingt saeacaml s e eg, r e v Fe .
t - N. W Va J l , 01 ) d s se o al o tt li ; e . ..Go b v . d
i
Blr a ofAl hol Tobac o. r a m s & Exnl i s e a .N o.5: - v- 26,si op. t5- 0
ze u
co s
c Fie r .
osve s t 1,
11 c 001 lp a 1
( D. . . a . 4 20 2 ( ..Seb r)(it 25c s st a q lf a srke) s eas
N. W Va M r 1 , 1 ) M J, ie t l i
s ng a e h t uaiy s ti s; e lo
Coe nv. le s n 1 5 S Ct 1 5 , 76 ( 01 )( odnga(ti 'd s s a i c u td
lma To lfo , 3 . . 7 9 1 3 2 5 h li ç rke' imis l s o n e
s
rga de st t tmi ofas e nta al;M c nv.UniedStt ,566F. 391 399( h
e r ls o he i ng
ubs que ppe ) Lea
t aes
3d , 4t
Ci. 0 9 ( imis l wih u p eu ief rfio o n s s o l no b e e tdfo 28U. C.
r 2 0 ) d s sas to t rj dc o rv lus e s h u d t e x mp e r m
S.
j1 5( )
91 g).
1Pl ntf' ot rm oni ri M iha lStvenGor y.
ai ifs he
ke s c e e
be
2Thi daei whe t cour r ceve t c
s t s n he
t e i d he ompl n. Net rt c
ait ihe he ompl ntno isenveopebe sadaeor
ai r t
l
ar
t
pos m a k.
t r
Afe r viwi Pl ntf ss
tr e e ng ai if ubmi sonsi tzscvi a ton,ti c e rt tPl i ifdo not
s i n li i l c i i s l a ha antf es
alegeml f c si cai t thei c r nty unde a i i ntt ea ofany s rousphysc l
l
y a t ndi tng ha
s ure l
r ny mm ne hr t
ei
ia
ij r wihnt me nn o 28U.. j 1 5 g .Se . ..Ch s v. M a1y 46 F. p'
n u y t i he a ig f
SC. 91 () e eg, a e O' 1 , 6 Ap x
e
1 5 1 6 (t Ci. 01 )( oi t ep io e mu tb s e i r le fo a dd mo sr t a
8 , 8 4h r 2 2 n t h rs n r s e e kng eif r m n e n tae
ng
da rt ti inmi n a t tmeofflngt c ait.
nge ha s r ne t t he i
ii he ompl n)
Pl ntf sr pe t d r la eon t phr s tmm i ntda 'i a i a i n ofa lbe
ai if e a e e inc
he a e s ne
i
nger' s n nvoc to
a l
a c l i n t ti note ild t a a s
nd oncuso ha s
ntte o n s umpto o t t BelAt.Cor v.Two bl 550
i n f nzh. l l
p.
m y,
U. 544,555(
S.
2007) anifma notr yonva s c ai orc l or aleg i t
.Plitf y el
gue, pe ultve, oncus y l atons o
i
nvoketi i ntda r' bu i t a hemus m a Ss ct f c a lgatonsofongoi
dmm ne
nge , t nse d,
'
t ke Epe ik a t le i
ng
sro sp sc lij r , ro apal t o mic nd t v d n i gt elk l o o i n n
e iu hy ia nu y o f te' f s o uc e i e cn h iei od f mmie t
n
h
sro sp ysc lij r . J h s nv. nn r 2 0F. p' 2 , 7 (t Ci. 0 6 .
e iu h ia nu y' o n o W r e, 0 Ap x 70 2 2 4 h r 2 0 )
'
Furhe m o e Pli ifr pe t dl dic s spa tha mst ta eno l nge çm med a e'
t r r , antf e a e y s us e s r ha r
o rç
i
it'
pr e s Fore mpl ,Pli ifal ge t tde e ntOfi e Br nne - r tt e tne hi
oblm .
xa e a ntf le s ha f nda
fc r e rBa nne hr a e d m
a ke hi a kea1 ni on J nua y29,
nd pt m wa
l ght a r
2016;sa fti d t ha Pl ntf kil d ora s ule
t f re o ve ai if le
s a td
i J y andAugus 2016;sa for r d Pli ifbac i o anGt a e'c
n ul
t
t f de e antf k nt
çms f ' ompound o ge r l
r ne a
popul i s ti i Aug ta Se e be 201 saf m a hi we rpa rcl hesi aco d
aton e tng n
us nd pt m r 6; t f de m a pe ot n
l
c li Nove be 2016;sa fdi no gi hi s swhiehi celfoode f o a ove fowi
el n
m r
t f d t ve m hoe
l s l l d r m n rl ng
t lti Augus 201 a sa fa
oie n
t 6; nd t f nnounce hi pr t c i c t sa sa dif r nttm e i 201
d s o e tve usody tm t fe e i s n 6.
Pl ntf' beleft tt a
ai ifs i ha he nnounc m e st ul c us ' m t bea s ule Gye r down t r d'
e nt s d a e'hi o
co
s a td t as
he oa '
doesno de
t monsr t an i ne t e .M or ove , salegai nsesa ih t ther f s d t
ta e nuni nt hr at
e r hi l to
t bls ha
eue o
r t r t t C a e c po 'orS ne a po a i n' a i hous d i pr ec i c t
e ' n o he é f om und' s r l pul to ' nd s
u
uns
ge
e n ot tve us ody.
Ac di y, dimist a inwiho prj cef Pli ifsfitr t pa t flng
cor ngl I s s he cto t ut eudi or antf' alle o y he ii
f a t tmeofflngt c ant See e. ,Dup e v. l r 28 F. 1 1 ( t
ee t he i
ii he ompli . . g. r e Pame , 4 3d 234, 237 11h
Ci. 0 2 (e s n n t a t efl gf ei d eu o fl gacvla to wh nt f r p u ei
r 2 0 ) ra o i g h t h ii e s u p n ii
n
n ii cin e q o ma a p rs
pr so do notappl t pli ifa t tt c ti notr quie t pe mi pl ntf a
ovii ns
y o antf nd ha he our s
e r d o r t ai if n
opporu t t pa t flngf eafe r ognii pli ifi i lgi et pr e j fnna
tniy o y he ii e tr ec zng antf s nei bl o oce d . o
q
p u rs.
a pei)
Ex'ER:T i î 1 dyo Fb zr, 0 7
r hs L1% a f enay 2 1 .
.
M
I
e
ni Unied St t sD i ti tJ
t
a e sr c udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?