Hungate v. Harts et al

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/20/2017. (tvt)

CLERK' A KAu .sos c u
S oFyl N K l o f
T cE O' > m
.
E,

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI GI A
CT
R NI
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

FIE
LD

MA2 2 2 2 1
27
J I c. u
A
BY:

STEV EN E.H UN GA TE ,
Pl ntff
ai i ,

C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi
i
17- 00056

V.

M E M O M N D UM O PIN IO N

H ARTS,e al
t ,

By:

nl
ppzY
'
<'
L
.

De e a t)
f nd nts.

c

M i hae F.Urbans
c l
ki
Unie St t Dit i tJudge
t d a es s r c

S e e E. n ae p o e dn p oK ,ie acvl ih sc mplitpu s n t 42U. C.
tv n Hu g t, r c e ig r fld iirg t o an , rua t o
S. j
1
983, hie i a ce a e By is Or re e e Fe a y 1 201 t c ta s d pl i ift ta
w l nc r r t d.
t de nt r d bnz r 4, 7, he our dvi e a ntf ha

f l et upda eam a lng add e safe ata f rorr l a efom i a ce a i wilr s ti dim is l
aiur o
t
ii
r s tr r ns e
e e s r nc r r ton l e ul n s s a
oft saci n.
hi to

Th c u tsmalop an ifh sb e rt r e ( No 1 )a u ei rb e a dp anif s
e o r' i t litf a e n eu n d ECF . 0 s nd l a l, n litf ha
ve
notc a t d t c tsnc Fe a y 22,201
ont c e he our i e bnzr
7. Pli iff ld t c
a ntf aie o ompl wih t c tsOr r
y t he our' de
r quii pl n ift mai ai a a ur t maii a e s The e or t c u'fndst tpli iff ie
e rng aitf o nt n n cc a e lng ddr s . r f e, he ot t s ha antf a ld

t pr e ut t saci plrua tt Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e41b) bynotc mpl ngwiht
o os c e hi ton, zs n o dea e
vi oc dur ( ,
o yi t he

c u tsFe nzr 2 201 , d r c r igy Id s s t ea to wi u p eu iea d n al
o r' b a y 2, 7 Or e .Ac o dn l, imis h cin t t rj d c nd e y 1
ho
p n i gmoinsa mo t Se Balr v. rs n, 8 F.d9 , 6( t Ci.1 8 )(ttn p oK
e d n to s o . e l d Ca lo 8 2 2 3 9 4h r 9 9 sai g r
a
ltg nsaes be t otmerq ie n sa drs e tfrc u t r e sa d s s a i a a p o rae
ii a t r u j c t i e ur me t n e p c o o r o d r nd imis l s n p r p it
s n to f rn n c mpin e ; n el v. o n - a v leS lsCo , 7 F.d 3 9 3 - (dCi.
a cin p o -o la c ) Do n l J h sM n il ae m.6 7 2 3 , 4041 3 r
y
1 2 (e o nzn ad src c u t ys as o t ds s a a to pls a t oFe . Ci P. ( ).
98 ) r c g iig itit o r ma u p n e imis n cin t u n t d R. v. 41b)
r
TheClr i die t d t s ndcopisoft sM e o a l Opi o andt ac ompa ng Or r
ek s rce o e
e
hi m r ndtm
ni n
he c
nyi
de
t t partes.
o he
i

ENTER : s
Thi

day ofM a c 201
r h, 7.

/+/
!
w
A.
ë
e

-- . AF
- ë

-c1 )' 1
,2m.
' y
.

'.

':
'1

$
1
1

U nie St t sD i t i tJ ge
t d a e sr c u

/ r .
-- i.