Bethel v. Director
Filing
7
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/11/2017. (tvt)
r.FRK' OFFI U..DI X URT
l S
CE S ST.
AT ROALQKE,
I 9h
'
FI ED
L
YA 12 2 1
t
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI T O F W R G I I
C
N A
RO AN O K E DI SI N
VI O
JULA
I
BY:
TYLER DANI BETH EL,
EL
Pett oner,
ii
M EM O RA N D U M O PI I N
N O
D I E CTO R ,
R
R e ponde .
s
nt
By:
H on.M i hae F.U r
c l
bans
ki
U nied St es Di t ctJudge
t
at
s ri
TylrDa e Bet l aVigi ai aepr ee ng pr K ,fl d ape ii f awrtof
e ni l he , r ni nm t oc di
o
ie
tton or
i
h b a c r u p rua t o2 U. C. 2 5 t c aln et j d me t n e e b t eCic t
a e s o p s u s n t 8 S. j 2 4 o h le g he u g n e tr d y h rui
Cour ofPityl ni Co mt Thi m a tri be or t c tf rpr lmi
t
ts va a t y. s te s f e he our o ei nmy r vi pur ua t
e ew, s nt o
Rul 4oft Rul Goveni j225 Ca e .Afe rvi ngt r or t c t s sest
e
he es
r ng
4 s s tr e ewi he ec d,he our dimis he
petton astme bar d.
ii
i
re
1.
On J 2,
une 2009, heCic tCo tofPityl a Co y s nt nc d Peii ne t mor
t
r ui ur
ts vani unt e e e tto r o
e
t n t nt t yea s i é c r ton f dr g-a tr n m-e ae c i .Pe ii rsdie t
ha we y-wo r ' nc r e a i or u nd i e r r lt d rmes ttone ' r c
a al c l d a t Supr m eCour o Vigni on Nove be 1 201
ppe s onc ude t he
e
t f ri a
m r , 0.
On M a c 23,201 Peii
rh
2, ttonerfl d ape ii f am i ofha a c puswih t Cicui
ie
tton or
t
be s or
t he r t
Cour ofPityl ni Count whih de edt pe ii Peii ra ald t t Supr me
t
ts vn a
y, c ni he tton. ttone ppe e o he
e
Cour ofVigi a whi r f s d t a alon M a c 7 2016.
t
r ni, ch e u e he ppe
rh ,
Peiine fldteisa t tto o M ac 2 2 7.S eR. v. 2 4 Ca e 3 d
t o r ie h n tn peiin n rh , 01 e Go j 25 s s ( )
t
( s rbngt prs n- iboxr ll Thecou tc tonalyfldt peiin,a sd
de cii he io mal ue.
r ondii l ie he tto dvie
Pe ii ne t tt pe ii a a ed t be t tm e y fl a pr de hi t oppor l t t
tt o r ha he tton ppe r o m i l ied, nd ovi d m he
p niy o
E
CL RK
C i lA c i N o.7: : 00083
vi ton
17- v-
V.
L
e an why t c ts d c i ri tme ytl
xpli
he our houl onsde t i l ied.Pe ii rpr vi st daesofva i
ttone o de he t
rous
e nt butdoe nota guet tmelnes oft pe ii
ve s
s
r
he i i s he tton.
I.
I
Ha e speiinsfld'n e j2 4a es b e t oao - r peido lmiain 2
b a tto e u d r 25 r u j c t neye ro f i tto . 8
U .S. j2 4 d ()1 Thea i bl pe i f t i t ntpeii n be nt r n f o t da e
pplca e rod or he nsa
tto ga o a r m he t
C. 24 ()1 .
o whc t ej dg n o c n cinb c me5n 12 2 U. C. 2 4 ( )1( ; e Clyv
n ih h u me t f o vito e a
a. 8 S. j 2 4 d ( )A) s e a .
Untd S ae , 3 U. 5 2 5 4 ( 0 3 (oli ac nvdinb c me fna o c te
ie tt s 5 7 S. 2 , 2 2 0 ) h dng o i o e o s i l n e h
a albl yo dr c r ve i e h u td .Th o - e rfl peidi t l dwhl ac nvc '
v i it f ie t e iw s x a se ) e ney a i ro s ol ie o its
a i
ng
e
i opel fl d a ia i n f rSt t pos- o c i orot rc l tr lr e ' sû ndi ' 28
ç
pr ry ie pplc to o ae tc nvi ton
he olae a eviw'i t
pe ng.
'
U. C. 2 4 d () s eW alv Kh l, 6 U. 5 ,5 85 ( 01 )( ic sn p o e dn s
S. j 2 4()2 ; e l . o i5 2 S. 45 5 - 9 2 1 ds usig r c e ig
ta q aiya c ltrlrve .
h t u lf s ol ea e iw)
a
Pei o rsj2 5 peiini t i l t e j2 4 ( )1( .Peiin rsc n ito
t ine' 2 4 t o s mtmey md r 2 4 d ( )A) tto e ' o v ci n
t
t
bec m efnalon J nua y 31 2011 whe t tm eexpie f Pe ii rt no ea a a fom
a i
a r ,
, n he i
r d or ttone o t n ppe l r
t eSu r meCo r o Vign at t eUni dS ae S p e Co r.S eU. Su . . 1 4 )
h pe
u t f r ii o h
t tts u rme u t e S. p CtR. 3 1
e
(ttn a peln mus fl ap tto fram i o c rir r wi nnn t d y o tej d me t
saig p la t t ie ei n o
i
t f eto ai t iey a s f h u g n
hi
1Theoneye rlmia i pe i begi t nm o t lts off da e :
a i tton rod ns o
n he ae t our t s
( ted t o whihtej g n b cmefn l ytec n l ino drc rve o tee piain
A)h ae n c h ud me t e a ia b h o cuso f ie te iw r h x rto
oft tmef rs e ng s r viw;
he i o e ki uch e e
'
( ted t o whc tei dme tofl ga a piaincetdb Saea to i voaino t
B) h ae n ih h mpe i n t ii n p lcto rae y tt cin n ilto fhe
n
Consi i orlwsoft Unie Sttsi r
tmton a
he td ae s emoved,i t a i ntwa pr ve edfom flngby s h
f he pplca
s e nt r ii
uc
Stt a i
ae cton;
( ted t o whc tec nsiuin l ih asre wa iiil rc g ie b t S pe Co
C) h ae n ih h o ttt a rg t setd s ntal e o nz d y he u rme mt
o
y
i t rghthasbee newl r cogni dbyt Supr m eCour a m a r toaci l applca et
f he i
n
ye
ze
he
e
t nd de er tvey
i bl o
ca e oncola ealr e o
ss
lt r eviw; r
( ted t o whc tefc l rdiaeo tecam o camsp ee tdc ul h v b e
D)h ae n ih h a ma p e c t fh li r li rsne o d a e e n
dico r t o t e r ieofduedii nce.
s veed k ugh he xe cs
lge
2 U. C.j2 44d ()
8 S. 2 ()1.
2Peio e ddn tag etmeiest e s b eto s( tru (
tin r i o r u i l s md r u scin B) h o gh D)
t
n
.
2
benga pe ld .Peiine fldlssaeh b a peiini Ma c 2 2 mo et a 4 0d y
i p ae ) t o r ie t tt a e s tto n r h 01 , r h n 0 a s
t
i
atrhij d me tb c mefn l Be a et ef d rll tt nsp ro h dara ye pie b
fe s u g n e a ia . c us h e ea i ai e id a le d x rd y
mi o
t tmePe ii rfld hi saeha a peii n, oli t r28 U. C. j2 4 ( 2 d e no
he i
ttone e s tt be s tto t lng mde
S.
2 4 *4) o s t
a pl Se . . , n e v Be k 2 0F.d6 3 6 5(t Ci. 0 )(e og ii t tsae
p y. e ec.Mitr . c , 3 3 6 , 6 4h r 20 0 r c n zng ha tt
ha a p t insc n o r vv apei do lmiain t a h dar a y e pie ) Ac o dn l
be s ei o a n t e ie ro f i tto s h t a le d x r d . c r i gy,
t
Peiin rd dno fl teisa t t inwihno ey a o whe t ec i n l u g n be a
tto e i t ie h n tn pei o t i n e r f n h rmia j d me t c me
t
sna .
l
Equiabl t lng i a l eonl i ûhos r ei t nc swhe e- duet c r lmsanc s
t e oli s vaiabl y n ç e ar nsa e
t
r
o icl t e
e e na t t pa t so co uc - i wo d beunco ci bl t e o c t lm iai n pe i
xt r l o he ry' wn nd t t ul
ns ona e o nf r e he i t to rod
a ans t ep rya dg o sij tc wo l r s l. Ro s v. e 3 9F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci.
g i t h a t n r s nusie ud e ut' u e Le , 3 3 38 2 6 4h r
'
20 3 (nba c (ne a q o ain makso te )(i n Harsv Hu c i o 20 F.d3 5
0 ) e n ) itm l u tto r mitd ct g ri . thns n, 9 3 2 ,
i
3 0(t Ci. 0 0
3 4 h r 2 0 :.Th , peiin rmu th v G e np runghi rg sdlg n l, n . .
us a t o e s a e G e u s i s iht iie ty a d .
t
b
s m ee r or na y cr um sa esood i hi wa ' o pr ve tm ey flng. Hola v. orda
o
xta di r ic tnc t
n s y't e nt i l ii
lnd Fl i ,
5 0U. 6 , 4 ( 01 )
6 S. 31 6 9 2 0 .
Pe ii r sl c ofknowl
ttone ' a k
edgea
boutl ga pr e so t sa tt y dea i f f de a
e l oc s r he ttzor
dlne or e r l
ha asr i doe no s
be elef s t uppor gr ntng s h e r or na yr le . Ha rs 209 F. a 330.
t a i uc xta di r ei f ri,
3d t
Furhe
t nnor t c tdoesnotfnd a e r or na y cr um sa si t sr or t t
e, he our
i ny xta di r ic t nce n hi ec d ha
pr ve e Peii rfo flng atmel pe ii n. Se se. ,Unie Stt sv.Sos 36 F. 507,
e nt d ttone r m ii
i y tto
e g. t d a e
a, 4 3d
5J (t Ci. 0 ) ( tn ta p o. sa'sa din rnc o telw d e n t u t ye utb e
2 4h r 20 4 noig h t r K tt n g o a e f h a o s o j si q ia l
u
f
t lig ; m e v J h s n,1 7F.d3 0 3 2( t Ci.1 9 )( oi t t n n l rt wi t e
oln ) Tu r . o n o 7 3 9 , 9 5h r 9 9 n tng ha u fmii i t h
a y h
lw d et i iea yo p oK sau d e n t ol i tto speid .Ac o dn l, t in r
a u o l trc r r t' s o s o yl lmiain ro ) c r igy Peio e
l
t
t
fldhi fd r l a e spei o mo et no ey a a trt ej g n b c mefn lPei o ri
ie s e ea h b a t in r ha n e r fe h ud me t e a i a, tt ne s
t
i
3
note ild t e t bl t lng,a t pe ii mus be dimis d.Se Hilv. a o 277
ntte o quia e oli nd he tton
t
s se
e l Br xt n,
F.d7 , 0 ( t Ci. 0 2 (e o nii adsrc c u t y sl rl d s s aj2 4
3 01 7 7 4h r 2 0 ) r c g zng itit o r ma l
mmaiy imis 25
pe ii i apeii
tton f ttonerf ist maket r q st s
al o
he e uiie howi o tmelnes a trt c t tfe
ng f i i s fe he our no i s
pe ii rt tt pe ii a a suntmel a alowsa opporuniy t pr vi a a gume
ttone ha he tton ppe r
i y nd l
n
t t o o de ny r
nt
ml e ie c )
d vd n e .
11
1.
Fort f e ngr a ons t co tdimis st pe ii f awrtofha sco usa
he or goi e s , he ur s s e he tton or
i
bea p
s
tm eba r d. Ba e u t c tsfndi t tPe ii rhasnotm a t r uiies tntal
i
re
s d pon he our' i ng ha ttone
de he eq st ubsa i
s ngofadeni ofaconsiui lrghtasr uie by28U. C.j22534)a Sl kv.
howi
al
tttona i
eq rd
S.
c nd ac
M c n e, 29U. 4 3 48 ( 0 0 , c riiaeo a pe lblt i d r d Peiin rsmoin
Da il 5
S. 7 , 4 2 0 ) a e t c t f p aa ii s et d. tto e ' to
f
y
i
f rr la epe dngr ve
o ee s n i e iw
moin t sa e o c me t ft saej g nt r d n e
to o ty nf re n o he tt ud me a e e id.
ENTER: i // dyo Ma, 0 7
Ths
a r y2 1.
/ f- - r4 /. W &=r '
+ '
4
#.
Unie St t sDiti tJ ge
t d a e src u
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?