Bethel v. Director

Filing 7

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/11/2017. (tvt)

r.FRK' OFFI U..DI X URT
l S
CE S ST.
AT ROALQKE,
I 9h
'
FI ED
L

YA 12 2 1
t
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI T O F W R G I I
C
N A
RO AN O K E DI SI N
VI O

JULA
I
BY:

TYLER DANI BETH EL,
EL
Pett oner,
ii

M EM O RA N D U M O PI I N
N O

D I E CTO R ,
R
R e ponde .
s
nt

By:

H on.M i hae F.U r
c l
bans
ki
U nied St es Di t ctJudge
t
at
s ri

TylrDa e Bet l aVigi ai aepr ee ng pr K ,fl d ape ii f awrtof
e ni l he , r ni nm t oc di
o
ie
tton or
i

h b a c r u p rua t o2 U. C. 2 5 t c aln et j d me t n e e b t eCic t
a e s o p s u s n t 8 S. j 2 4 o h le g he u g n e tr d y h rui
Cour ofPityl ni Co mt Thi m a tri be or t c tf rpr lmi
t
ts va a t y. s te s f e he our o ei nmy r vi pur ua t
e ew, s nt o

Rul 4oft Rul Goveni j225 Ca e .Afe rvi ngt r or t c t s sest
e
he es
r ng
4 s s tr e ewi he ec d,he our dimis he
petton astme bar d.
ii
i
re
1.

On J 2,
une 2009, heCic tCo tofPityl a Co y s nt nc d Peii ne t mor
t
r ui ur
ts vani unt e e e tto r o
e
t n t nt t yea s i é c r ton f dr g-a tr n m-e ae c i .Pe ii rsdie t
ha we y-wo r ' nc r e a i or u nd i e r r lt d rmes ttone ' r c
a al c l d a t Supr m eCour o Vigni on Nove be 1 201
ppe s onc ude t he
e
t f ri a
m r , 0.
On M a c 23,201 Peii
rh
2, ttonerfl d ape ii f am i ofha a c puswih t Cicui
ie
tton or
t
be s or
t he r t
Cour ofPityl ni Count whih de edt pe ii Peii ra ald t t Supr me
t
ts vn a
y, c ni he tton. ttone ppe e o he
e
Cour ofVigi a whi r f s d t a alon M a c 7 2016.
t
r ni, ch e u e he ppe
rh ,

Peiine fldteisa t tto o M ac 2 2 7.S eR. v. 2 4 Ca e 3 d
t o r ie h n tn peiin n rh , 01 e Go j 25 s s ( )
t
( s rbngt prs n- iboxr ll Thecou tc tonalyfldt peiin,a sd
de cii he io mal ue.
r ondii l ie he tto dvie
Pe ii ne t tt pe ii a a ed t be t tm e y fl a pr de hi t oppor l t t
tt o r ha he tton ppe r o m i l ied, nd ovi d m he
p niy o

E

CL RK

C i lA c i N o.7: : 00083
vi ton
17- v-

V.

L

e an why t c ts d c i ri tme ytl
xpli
he our houl onsde t i l ied.Pe ii rpr vi st daesofva i
ttone o de he t
rous
e nt butdoe nota guet tmelnes oft pe ii
ve s
s
r
he i i s he tton.
I.
I

Ha e speiinsfld'n e j2 4a es b e t oao - r peido lmiain 2
b a tto e u d r 25 r u j c t neye ro f i tto . 8
U .S. j2 4 d ()1 Thea i bl pe i f t i t ntpeii n be nt r n f o t da e
pplca e rod or he nsa
tto ga o a r m he t
C. 24 ()1 .

o whc t ej dg n o c n cinb c me5n 12 2 U. C. 2 4 ( )1( ; e Clyv
n ih h u me t f o vito e a
a. 8 S. j 2 4 d ( )A) s e a .
Untd S ae , 3 U. 5 2 5 4 ( 0 3 (oli ac nvdinb c me fna o c te
ie tt s 5 7 S. 2 , 2 2 0 ) h dng o i o e o s i l n e h

a albl yo dr c r ve i e h u td .Th o - e rfl peidi t l dwhl ac nvc '
v i it f ie t e iw s x a se ) e ney a i ro s ol ie o its
a i
ng
e
i opel fl d a ia i n f rSt t pos- o c i orot rc l tr lr e ' sû ndi ' 28
ç
pr ry ie pplc to o ae tc nvi ton
he olae a eviw'i t
pe ng.
'

U. C. 2 4 d () s eW alv Kh l, 6 U. 5 ,5 85 ( 01 )( ic sn p o e dn s
S. j 2 4()2 ; e l . o i5 2 S. 45 5 - 9 2 1 ds usig r c e ig
ta q aiya c ltrlrve .
h t u lf s ol ea e iw)
a
Pei o rsj2 5 peiini t i l t e j2 4 ( )1( .Peiin rsc n ito
t ine' 2 4 t o s mtmey md r 2 4 d ( )A) tto e ' o v ci n
t
t
bec m efnalon J nua y 31 2011 whe t tm eexpie f Pe ii rt no ea a a fom
a i
a r ,
, n he i
r d or ttone o t n ppe l r

t eSu r meCo r o Vign at t eUni dS ae S p e Co r.S eU. Su . . 1 4 )
h pe
u t f r ii o h
t tts u rme u t e S. p CtR. 3 1
e

(ttn a peln mus fl ap tto fram i o c rir r wi nnn t d y o tej d me t
saig p la t t ie ei n o
i
t f eto ai t iey a s f h u g n
hi

1Theoneye rlmia i pe i begi t nm o t lts off da e :
a i tton rod ns o
n he ae t our t s

( ted t o whihtej g n b cmefn l ytec n l ino drc rve o tee piain
A)h ae n c h ud me t e a ia b h o cuso f ie te iw r h x rto
oft tmef rs e ng s r viw;
he i o e ki uch e e

'

( ted t o whc tei dme tofl ga a piaincetdb Saea to i voaino t
B) h ae n ih h mpe i n t ii n p lcto rae y tt cin n ilto fhe
n
Consi i orlwsoft Unie Sttsi r
tmton a
he td ae s emoved,i t a i ntwa pr ve edfom flngby s h
f he pplca
s e nt r ii
uc
Stt a i
ae cton;

( ted t o whc tec nsiuin l ih asre wa iiil rc g ie b t S pe Co
C) h ae n ih h o ttt a rg t setd s ntal e o nz d y he u rme mt
o
y
i t rghthasbee newl r cogni dbyt Supr m eCour a m a r toaci l applca et
f he i
n
ye
ze
he
e
t nd de er tvey
i bl o
ca e oncola ealr e o
ss
lt r eviw; r

( ted t o whc tefc l rdiaeo tecam o camsp ee tdc ul h v b e
D)h ae n ih h a ma p e c t fh li r li rsne o d a e e n
dico r t o t e r ieofduedii nce.
s veed k ugh he xe cs
lge

2 U. C.j2 44d ()
8 S. 2 ()1.
2Peio e ddn tag etmeiest e s b eto s( tru (
tin r i o r u i l s md r u scin B) h o gh D)
t
n
.

2

benga pe ld .Peiine fldlssaeh b a peiini Ma c 2 2 mo et a 4 0d y
i p ae ) t o r ie t tt a e s tto n r h 01 , r h n 0 a s
t
i

atrhij d me tb c mefn l Be a et ef d rll tt nsp ro h dara ye pie b
fe s u g n e a ia . c us h e ea i ai e id a le d x rd y
mi o
t tmePe ii rfld hi saeha a peii n, oli t r28 U. C. j2 4 ( 2 d e no
he i
ttone e s tt be s tto t lng mde
S.
2 4 *4) o s t

a pl Se . . , n e v Be k 2 0F.d6 3 6 5(t Ci. 0 )(e og ii t tsae
p y. e ec.Mitr . c , 3 3 6 , 6 4h r 20 0 r c n zng ha tt
ha a p t insc n o r vv apei do lmiain t a h dar a y e pie ) Ac o dn l
be s ei o a n t e ie ro f i tto s h t a le d x r d . c r i gy,
t

Peiin rd dno fl teisa t t inwihno ey a o whe t ec i n l u g n be a
tto e i t ie h n tn pei o t i n e r f n h rmia j d me t c me
t
sna .
l
Equiabl t lng i a l eonl i ûhos r ei t nc swhe e- duet c r lmsanc s
t e oli s vaiabl y n ç e ar nsa e
t
r
o icl t e
e e na t t pa t so co uc - i wo d beunco ci bl t e o c t lm iai n pe i
xt r l o he ry' wn nd t t ul
ns ona e o nf r e he i t to rod

a ans t ep rya dg o sij tc wo l r s l. Ro s v. e 3 9F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci.
g i t h a t n r s nusie ud e ut' u e Le , 3 3 38 2 6 4h r
'
20 3 (nba c (ne a q o ain makso te )(i n Harsv Hu c i o 20 F.d3 5
0 ) e n ) itm l u tto r mitd ct g ri . thns n, 9 3 2 ,
i
3 0(t Ci. 0 0
3 4 h r 2 0 :.Th , peiin rmu th v G e np runghi rg sdlg n l, n . .
us a t o e s a e G e u s i s iht iie ty a d .
t
b
s m ee r or na y cr um sa esood i hi wa ' o pr ve tm ey flng. Hola v. orda
o
xta di r ic tnc t
n s y't e nt i l ii
lnd Fl i ,

5 0U. 6 , 4 ( 01 )
6 S. 31 6 9 2 0 .
Pe ii r sl c ofknowl
ttone ' a k
edgea
boutl ga pr e so t sa tt y dea i f f de a
e l oc s r he ttzor
dlne or e r l
ha asr i doe no s
be elef s t uppor gr ntng s h e r or na yr le . Ha rs 209 F. a 330.
t a i uc xta di r ei f ri,
3d t
Furhe
t nnor t c tdoesnotfnd a e r or na y cr um sa si t sr or t t
e, he our
i ny xta di r ic t nce n hi ec d ha
pr ve e Peii rfo flng atmel pe ii n. Se se. ,Unie Stt sv.Sos 36 F. 507,
e nt d ttone r m ii
i y tto
e g. t d a e
a, 4 3d

5J (t Ci. 0 ) ( tn ta p o. sa'sa din rnc o telw d e n t u t ye utb e
2 4h r 20 4 noig h t r K tt n g o a e f h a o s o j si q ia l
u
f
t lig ; m e v J h s n,1 7F.d3 0 3 2( t Ci.1 9 )( oi t t n n l rt wi t e
oln ) Tu r . o n o 7 3 9 , 9 5h r 9 9 n tng ha u fmii i t h
a y h
lw d et i iea yo p oK sau d e n t ol i tto speid .Ac o dn l, t in r
a u o l trc r r t' s o s o yl lmiain ro ) c r igy Peio e
l
t
t
fldhi fd r l a e spei o mo et no ey a a trt ej g n b c mefn lPei o ri
ie s e ea h b a t in r ha n e r fe h ud me t e a i a, tt ne s
t
i
3

note ild t e t bl t lng,a t pe ii mus be dimis d.Se Hilv. a o 277
ntte o quia e oli nd he tton
t
s se
e l Br xt n,

F.d7 , 0 ( t Ci. 0 2 (e o nii adsrc c u t y sl rl d s s aj2 4
3 01 7 7 4h r 2 0 ) r c g zng itit o r ma l
mmaiy imis 25
pe ii i apeii
tton f ttonerf ist maket r q st s
al o
he e uiie howi o tmelnes a trt c t tfe
ng f i i s fe he our no i s
pe ii rt tt pe ii a a suntmel a alowsa opporuniy t pr vi a a gume
ttone ha he tton ppe r
i y nd l
n
t t o o de ny r
nt

ml e ie c )
d vd n e .
11
1.

Fort f e ngr a ons t co tdimis st pe ii f awrtofha sco usa
he or goi e s , he ur s s e he tton or
i
bea p
s
tm eba r d. Ba e u t c tsfndi t tPe ii rhasnotm a t r uiies tntal
i
re
s d pon he our' i ng ha ttone
de he eq st ubsa i

s ngofadeni ofaconsiui lrghtasr uie by28U. C.j22534)a Sl kv.
howi
al
tttona i
eq rd
S.
c nd ac

M c n e, 29U. 4 3 48 ( 0 0 , c riiaeo a pe lblt i d r d Peiin rsmoin
Da il 5
S. 7 , 4 2 0 ) a e t c t f p aa ii s et d. tto e ' to
f
y
i
f rr la epe dngr ve
o ee s n i e iw

moin t sa e o c me t ft saej g nt r d n e
to o ty nf re n o he tt ud me a e e id.

ENTER: i // dyo Ma, 0 7
Ths
a r y2 1.

/ f- - r4 /. W &=r '
+ '
4
#.
Unie St t sDiti tJ ge
t d a e src u

4