Boyd v. Virginia Department of Corrections et al
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/30/2017. (tvt)
cbeRK' olyl; u. ol
s z ke s. smcour
AT DANVI VA
LLE.
FI
LED
MA2 3รป 2 1
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W EST ERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
RO AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
NA TH A N I BO Y D ,
EL
Pettoner,
ii
V.
VI NI DEPARTM ENT OF
RGI A
CO RR EC TI N S,etal,
O
,
R espondent
s.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
J
UL
BY:
D L
EM
RK
*
D
C
K
Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00086
vi ton
17- vM EM O R AN D UM O PI IO N
N
By:
H on.Jaclson L.K i
t
ser
Se orUnied St e Dit c Judge
ni
t
at s srit
N a ha elBoyd,a V i g ni i na e pr ee ng pr > ,t l d a pe ii f w rtofha a
t ni
r i a m t oc di
o q ie
tton or i
be s
-
c puspurua t 28U. C.j2254.Peii rc lenge t valdiyofhi c i me
or
s nt o
S.
ttone hal s he i t
s onfne nt
p rua t ot eFe r ay2 , 01 ,u me t ft Cic i Co r o Ch rot Co ny.Afe
u s n t h b u r 5 2 5 j dg n o he ru t u t f alte u t tr
r vi wi t pe ii n,Ifnd t ti s ul bedimi s d s
e e ng he tto
i ha t ho d
s s e umm a iy purua t Rul 4 oft
rl
s nt o e
he
Rul Goveni j2254Cas .
es
r ng
es1
A fde a co tma no gr taj225 ha speii unls t peii re use t
e r l ur y t an
4 bea tton e s he ttone xha td he
r m e e a ia e i t cou t oft sat i whi h pe ii ne w a convi t d. 28 U . C.
e di s va l bl n he r s he t e n
c tto r s
ce
S.
j2 4*) Prie v. d iu z 41 U.. 7 ( 9 3 ; a t nv. mi 40 U. 5 ( 9 )
25 ; esr Ro rg e , 1 S 4 5 1 7 ) Slv o S t 4 S. 3 1 71.
h,
Thee
xhausi r quie e i s ts id bys eki r vi w oft cli i t hi tsaecou t
ton e r m nt s a ife
e ng e e
he am n he ghes t t
r
wihj rs ito t c nsd rtecam.O' ulva v Bo rk l5 6U. 8 8( 9 ) l
t u id ci n o o i e h li
S l n . ec e, 2 S. 3 1 99 . n
i
V igi a, non- a h r c ctc e us sat r e e i one oft ee w a ,de ndi on
r ni a
de t ow onvi an xha t t e em di s n
hr
ys pe ng
t na ur oft c am sr ie Fis,t c c c n fl adie ta
he t e he l i as d. rt he onvit a ie r c ppea t t Vig ni Cour of
l o he r i a
t
Appe swih as e
al t ubs quenta a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi ai t Cour ofAppe sr es
ppe l o he
e
t
r ni f he
t
al ul
a i tt co c.VA.
gans he nvit
CODE j17. 411.Se nd,hec c ca atc t c ci
1co t onvit n ta k he onviton
c l t r l by flng a s a e ha a pe ii n wih t c r ui c twhe e t c
ola e aly
ii
t t be s tto t he ic t our
r he onvi twas
c
e ce a t na alnga adves de sont t SuprmeCour ofVigi a I j8. onvitd nd he ppe i n
re cii o he
e
t
r ni. d. 01
lA pettonma bedimis pu s antt Rul 4 i i i cl rfom t peii t tape ii ri not
ii
y
s s ed r u o e f t s ea r he tton ha
ttone s
e ild t r le .
ntte o eif
65 A)1 ; Sup.Ct R.5: a) Fi l t convitc ne us rmedi byflngasae
4( ( ) Va.
. 9( . naly,he
c a xha t e es ii tt
ha aspeii diecl wiht SuprmeCour ofVigi a.VA.
be tton r ty t he e
t r ni
CODEj8. - 4( ( )
0165 A)1.
W hi he rr e i t ke t c
c ve out s a n, he onvi tuli a el m us pr en t c a m s t t Supr m e Cour of
c tm t y
t es t he l i o he
e
t
Vigi a a r evear lng fom t tc tbe or af der ldititc tca c i rt
r ni nd ec i
u i r ha our f e e a src our n onsde he
c a m s A ha spe ii rha note us e sa e r m e esi t pe ii rhast r g unde
li .
bea ttone s
xha t d t t e di f he ttone
he i ht
r
sa el t r iet quesi pr e e by a a ia epr dur and f ist do s 28U . C.
t t aw o as he
ton es nt d
ny val bl oce e
al o
o.
S.
j2254()
c.
The pe ii n c ea l s st tPe ii rhasnotpr e e cl i st t Supr e Cour
tto l ry how ha ttone
es nt d a m o he
em
t
ofV igi a.2 I deed,Pe ii r s s a e ha aspe ii r m ai pe ng bef e t Cic tCour
r ni n
ttone ' t t be
tton e ns ndi
or he r ui
t
ofCha l t Count i Boyd v. rf , 1
r ote
y n
She if CL 5000286- 0. Pe ii r s f iur t exha ts a e
0
ttone ' a l e o
us t t
r di sma t s
eme e nda es umm a y dimi s loft pe ii .3 Based upon t fndi t tPe ii r
r s sa
he tton
he
ng ha ttone
hasnotma t r quiies t nta s
de he e st ubsa il howi ofde a ofaconsiutonalrghta r quie by
ng
ni l
tt i
i s e rd
28U. C.j2253( andSlckv.McDa e,5 U. 473,484(
S.
c)
a
nil 29 S.
2000) ac tfc t of
, eriiae
a al biiy i de e
ppe a lt s ni d.
ENT ER : Thi
s
-
-
da ofM a ch,201
y
r
7.
'
Se rUnie St t sDitltJ
ni
t d a e src udge
2 Peii a knowldgesi t pe ii t theha notpr s t t i t nthabe cl m st te Supr e
ttoner c
e
n he tton ha
s
e ened he nsa
as ai o h
em
Cour ofV igi a,et rvi asaeha ascor peii o ana alfom t Cour ofAppe sofVigi a.
t
r ni ihe a t t be
pus tton r ppe r he
t
al
r ni
3 Pe ii rm a rfl hi fder ha spetton i heuns ce s ul pr s nt t cli st t Supr m e
ttone y e ie s e al bea ii f
uc s f ly e e s he am o he
e
Co ro Vignitru ho eo tetrerue dsrbd.P tinria vsd h we e,hthst t tlsae
ut f ri a ho j n fh he ots ecie eio e s d ie , o vrta i i o 5e tt
t
me
a dfd r l a e sp tln i l td S e28U. C. 2 4 () VA. Ej80l6 4 A)2 ; . u Ct R.
n e ea h b a eio s s i e . e
t
mi
S. j 2 4d , COD . -5 ( () Va S p. .
*
59 a .
:( )
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?