Boyd v. Virginia Department of Corrections et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/30/2017. (tvt)

cbeRK' olyl; u. ol
s z ke s. smcour
AT DANVI VA
LLE.
FI
LED

MA2 3û 2 1
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W EST ERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
RO AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
NA TH A N I BO Y D ,
EL
Pettoner,
ii
V.

VI NI DEPARTM ENT OF
RGI A
CO RR EC TI N S,etal,
O
,
R espondent
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J
UL

BY:

D L
EM

RK

*

D

C

K

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00086
vi ton
17- vM EM O R AN D UM O PI IO N
N
By:

H on.Jaclson L.K i
t
ser
Se orUnied St e Dit c Judge
ni
t
at s srit

N a ha elBoyd,a V i g ni i na e pr ee ng pr > ,t l d a pe ii f w rtofha a
t ni
r i a m t oc di
o q ie
tton or i
be s
-

c puspurua t 28U. C.j2254.Peii rc lenge t valdiyofhi c i me
or
s nt o
S.
ttone hal s he i t
s onfne nt

p rua t ot eFe r ay2 , 01 ,u me t ft Cic i Co r o Ch rot Co ny.Afe
u s n t h b u r 5 2 5 j dg n o he ru t u t f alte u t tr
r vi wi t pe ii n,Ifnd t ti s ul bedimi s d s
e e ng he tto
i ha t ho d
s s e umm a iy purua t Rul 4 oft
rl
s nt o e
he

Rul Goveni j2254Cas .
es
r ng
es1
A fde a co tma no gr taj225 ha speii unls t peii re use t
e r l ur y t an
4 bea tton e s he ttone xha td he
r m e e a ia e i t cou t oft sat i whi h pe ii ne w a convi t d. 28 U . C.
e di s va l bl n he r s he t e n
c tto r s
ce
S.

j2 4*) Prie v. d iu z 41 U.. 7 ( 9 3 ; a t nv. mi 40 U. 5 ( 9 )
25 ; esr Ro rg e , 1 S 4 5 1 7 ) Slv o S t 4 S. 3 1 71.
h,
Thee
xhausi r quie e i s ts id bys eki r vi w oft cli i t hi tsaecou t
ton e r m nt s a ife
e ng e e
he am n he ghes t t
r

wihj rs ito t c nsd rtecam.O' ulva v Bo rk l5 6U. 8 8( 9 ) l
t u id ci n o o i e h li
S l n . ec e, 2 S. 3 1 99 . n
i
V igi a, non- a h r c ctc e us sat r e e i one oft ee w a ,de ndi on
r ni a
de t ow onvi an xha t t e em di s n
hr
ys pe ng

t na ur oft c am sr ie Fis,t c c c n fl adie ta
he t e he l i as d. rt he onvit a ie r c ppea t t Vig ni Cour of
l o he r i a
t
Appe swih as e
al t ubs quenta a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi ai t Cour ofAppe sr es
ppe l o he
e
t
r ni f he
t
al ul

a i tt co c.VA.
gans he nvit
CODE j17. 411.Se nd,hec c ca atc t c ci
1co t onvit n ta k he onviton
c l t r l by flng a s a e ha a pe ii n wih t c r ui c twhe e t c
ola e aly
ii
t t be s tto t he ic t our
r he onvi twas
c

e ce a t na alnga adves de sont t SuprmeCour ofVigi a I j8. onvitd nd he ppe i n
re cii o he
e
t
r ni. d. 01
lA pettonma bedimis pu s antt Rul 4 i i i cl rfom t peii t tape ii ri not
ii
y
s s ed r u o e f t s ea r he tton ha
ttone s
e ild t r le .
ntte o eif

65 A)1 ; Sup.Ct R.5: a) Fi l t convitc ne us rmedi byflngasae
4( ( ) Va.
. 9( . naly,he
c a xha t e es ii tt
ha aspeii diecl wiht SuprmeCour ofVigi a.VA.
be tton r ty t he e
t r ni
CODEj8. - 4( ( )
0165 A)1.
W hi he rr e i t ke t c
c ve out s a n, he onvi tuli a el m us pr en t c a m s t t Supr m e Cour of
c tm t y
t es t he l i o he
e
t

Vigi a a r evear lng fom t tc tbe or af der ldititc tca c i rt
r ni nd ec i
u i r ha our f e e a src our n onsde he
c a m s A ha spe ii rha note us e sa e r m e esi t pe ii rhast r g unde
li .
bea ttone s
xha t d t t e di f he ttone
he i ht
r

sa el t r iet quesi pr e e by a a ia epr dur and f ist do s 28U . C.
t t aw o as he
ton es nt d
ny val bl oce e
al o
o.
S.

j2254()
c.
The pe ii n c ea l s st tPe ii rhasnotpr e e cl i st t Supr e Cour
tto l ry how ha ttone
es nt d a m o he
em
t
ofV igi a.2 I deed,Pe ii r s s a e ha aspe ii r m ai pe ng bef e t Cic tCour
r ni n
ttone ' t t be
tton e ns ndi
or he r ui
t
ofCha l t Count i Boyd v. rf , 1
r ote
y n
She if CL 5000286- 0. Pe ii r s f iur t exha ts a e
0
ttone ' a l e o
us t t

r di sma t s
eme e nda es umm a y dimi s loft pe ii .3 Based upon t fndi t tPe ii r
r s sa
he tton
he
ng ha ttone
hasnotma t r quiies t nta s
de he e st ubsa il howi ofde a ofaconsiutonalrghta r quie by
ng
ni l
tt i
i s e rd

28U. C.j2253( andSlckv.McDa e,5 U. 473,484(
S.
c)
a
nil 29 S.
2000) ac tfc t of
, eriiae
a al biiy i de e
ppe a lt s ni d.
ENT ER : Thi
s

-

-

da ofM a ch,201
y
r
7.

'

Se rUnie St t sDitltJ
ni
t d a e src udge

2 Peii a knowldgesi t pe ii t theha notpr s t t i t nthabe cl m st te Supr e
ttoner c
e
n he tton ha
s
e ened he nsa
as ai o h
em
Cour ofV igi a,et rvi asaeha ascor peii o ana alfom t Cour ofAppe sofVigi a.
t
r ni ihe a t t be
pus tton r ppe r he
t
al
r ni
3 Pe ii rm a rfl hi fder ha spetton i heuns ce s ul pr s nt t cli st t Supr m e
ttone y e ie s e al bea ii f
uc s f ly e e s he am o he
e

Co ro Vignitru ho eo tetrerue dsrbd.P tinria vsd h we e,hthst t tlsae
ut f ri a ho j n fh he ots ecie eio e s d ie , o vrta i i o 5e tt
t
me
a dfd r l a e sp tln i l td S e28U. C. 2 4 () VA. Ej80l6 4 A)2 ; . u Ct R.
n e ea h b a eio s s i e . e
t
mi
S. j 2 4d , COD . -5 ( () Va S p. .
*
59 a .
:( )
2