Redd v. Berryhill

Filing 20

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/22/2018. (ck)

clERK' OFFI U. . ST.
- :
CE : DI COURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRJCT COURT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

J 22 2 1
Ay
24
JUI
M
BY:

.' DL . , CLE

;EP

EX
K

EA RL N . ED D ,
R

Ci lAci n No. 1
vi to
7: 7CV00089
Pli if
antf ,

m M ORXNDUM OPI ON
M
N ANCY A. UW HI Aci
BEI
LL, tng
Comm isone ofSoc a Se urt
si r
i l c iy,

By:
Hon.Gl n E.Conr d
e
a
Se o Unie Stt Diti tJ
ni r t d a es src udge

Dee
f ndant
.

Pl i ifha fl d t sa ton c lngi t fna de son oft Comm isone o Socil
antf s ie hi c i hale ng he i l cii
he
si r f
a
Se urt de ng pli tf s c am s f dia lt i tr nc be ft a s e e als c iy
c iy nyi
a n if l i or s biiy nsla e ne is nd upplm nt e urt

i c meb n ft l e t eSo ilSe t i Ac, sa nd d 4 U. C.j 41 ()a d 4 3 a 4
n o e eis md r h ca cl t t a me e , 2 S. j 6 i n 2 , nd 2
ry
U. C.j 1 1e s c.rs e tv l. J rs ito o ti c u t spzs a tt 4 U. C.j4 5 g
S.
38 t el e p ciey u id cin f h s o r i l u n o 2 S.
,
r
0 ()
a d 4 U. C.j 1 8 ()3 . Asrfe td b t me r n a a d agu n s b te b te
n 2 S.
3 3 c( )
elce y he mo a d n r me t u mitd y h
pa tes t is snow bef et c t r whehe t Com misone ' fna dec son i s
ri , he s ue
or he our a e
t r he
s i r s i l ii s uppore
td
by s t nta e de e,o whehe t r i ç
ubsa i l vi nc r t r he e s t
good ca e' one es iaer m a ng t c et t
us 't c st t e ndi he as o he

Co s in rf rf rhe c n ie ain. Se 4 U.. j4 5 g .
mmiso e o u t r o sd r to
e 2 SC. 0 ( )
Thepli itEalN. dd,wasbor o Fe uay 1 1 ,a e nmal c eedhi
antf r Re
n n br r 2, 968 nd ve ly omplt s
hi h s hool e a i
g c
duc ton. M r Redd pr vi usy wo ked as a c me cal ce r He sopped
.
e o l
r
om r i lane .
t
wordng co plt l i 201 On J y 23,201 andN o m be 20,201 r peci l M r Re
l
m e ey n 4.
ul
2
ve r
2, es tvey, . dd
tl d a i a i f di abiiy i ur nce be ft a s e e a s ur t i om e be is I
i e pplc tons or s lt ns a
ne s nd uppl m nt l ec iy nc
neft . n

flng hi c r ntc am s M r Re a lge t the be me dia e f a lf
ii
s ure l i , . dd le d ha
cn
s bl d or 1 onns o s t ntal
f ubsa i
ganf e oyme on Oc o r 1 2010,due t pa r a ii,bac pan,and su trng. Att
i ul mpl
nt
t be 8,
o nc e tts
k i
t te i
he
tme ofa a nita i he rng o Aug t26,201 pl i ifa e
i
n dmi sr tve n i n
us
5, antf m ndedli a ia i nss a t
ls pplc to o s o

rfe ta alg d ds blt o s td t o J n r 9 2 5 ( .6 ) M. Re dno manan
elc n le e ia ii n e ae f a uay , 01 . Tr 6 . 1 d w itis
y
*
.

t thehasr m aned dia ed t t pr s nttme. W ih r s c t hi a i a i f dia lt
ha
e i
s bl o he e e i
t e pe t o s pplc ton or s biiy
i ur nc be is t r or r ve st tM r Re me t i ur d sat r r m e soft Ac
ns a e neft, he ec d e al ha . dd t he ns e t us equie nt he t

tr u h t ef u t q a tro 2 6 b tn tt ee fe . Se c n rlv 4 U. C.j 41 ()a
h o g h o rh u re f 01 , u o h r atr e e eal, 2 S. j 6 i nd
4 3 a . Co s q nl p an if i e tte t a p ro o d sb l y a d ds b l y i u a c
2 ()
n e ue ty, litf s n ild o e id f ia ii n ia ii ns r n e
t
t
be ft onl i he has e t bls d t the be n e di a e f a1 f r of s tntalg nl l
ne is y f
sa ihe ha
cm
s bld or 1 o ms
ubsa i ai
e oyme on orbe or De e be 31 201
mpl
nt
f e c m r , 6.
M r Redd' a ia i w e e de e upon i ta c i r ton a r c i r ton. He
,
s pplc tons r nid
niil onsde a i nd e onsde a i
t n r se a r ceved a de novo he rng and r viw be or a Ad i sr tve La J e.
he eque t d nd e i
ai
e e
f e n m nitai
w udg
I alo ni n da e Oc obe 6,201 t La J
n ! pi o t d t r
5,he w udgealode e mi d t tM r Re i no dia e
s t r ne ha . dd s t s bl d.
TheLaw J
udgef md t tM r Re s f r fom s ve als ve e i panne s i l ng Clmba
ot ha . dd ufe s r
e r e r m i nt , nc udi ç l r
l
sr i l ba pe i r la tr die e i t rghtuppe exte iy,and c oni obsnltve
ta n/um go, rphe a re y s as n he i
r rm t
hr c t c i

p l nayds a e( D)' ( . ) Ne e tee s t eLa J d ed tr ne ta M r Re d
umo r ie s COP . Tr 43 . v rh ls ,h w u g ee mi d h t . d
'
'

.

r t i t r sdualf nci na c pact t pe f nn almie r ngeoflg e ri laci t The
e ans he e i
u to l a iy o r o
i td a
i ht xe tona tviy.
La J
w udgeas e s d M r Re sr sdua f tona c pa t asf l :
sse
. dd' e i l unci l a ciy olows
Afe c r ulco i ai of t e ie r c d,t t r i d
tr a ef
nsder ton
he ntr e or he mde sgne
fnds t t t cai nt ha t r i ua f tonal ca iy t
i
ha he l ma
s he esd l unc i
pact o

p ro m l h wo k a d fn d i 2 C. R. 4 4 1 6 49 a d
ef r i t r s eie n 0 F. 0 .5 7 1 n
g
41 9 7 b e c p h c n o tlrt e p s r t h z r s o
6.6 4 ) x e t e n n t oeae x o u e o a ad r
c i ng l dde s r s ors fol . He c n oc sona l ha e,
lmbi a r , ope , ca f ds
a ca i ly ndl
snge ,a f lwih t rg u r e r m iy. He c n t e at
r nd ee t he i ht ppe xte t
a olr e
oc sona e
ca i l xpos et pul
m o mona yi tnt a c m i a s
r nia s nd he c l .

( . 4 . Gi n h sr sd a f cin lc pa iy a d a trc n iei g M r Re d' p irwok
Tr 4 ) ve i e iu l un to a a ct , n fe o sd rn
. d s ro r
e re e a t t tm o ofa voc tonalex l t La J ge de e m i t tM r Re i
xpe i nc nd he esi ny
ai
pet he w ud
t r ned ha . dd s
t bl t pe f r hi pa tr lva wo k as a c me ca cea r Howe r t La J
ma e o ro m s s ee nt r
om r il l ne .
ve , he w udge
f
ound t t M r Re r t i s fc e f tona c pa t t perbr ce t n lght w or r es
ha
. dd e a ns uf i i nt unc i l a ciy o l m rai i
k ol

e itn i sg iia tn e i ten to a e o o . ( .5 ) Ac o dn l, h La J d e
x si g n infc n umb r n h ain l c n my Tr 0 . c r i gy t e w u g
c l d t tM r Re i notd s bld,a t the i no e ild t be t t ret rf de a
oqc ude ha . dd s
i a e nd ha
s t ntte o neks mde ihe e r l

p o rm . S eg n r l 2 C. R.j 4 4.5 0 g a d 41 .2 () TheLa J d eso no
rga
e e e al 0 F. j 0 1 2 4) n 69 0 g .
v
w u g ' piin
wa a e a t fna de ii n oft Com misone by t SocalSe trt Admi sr to s
s dopt d s he i l c so
he
s i r he i
c liy
nitai n'
Appeas Cot l Ha ng e use a 1a ia e a nitai r me e ,54.Re ha now
l
mci. vi xha t d 1 va lbl dmi sr tve e di s 1 dd s
.
a
ppeaedt t sc
l o hi omt

s e o e ti o ms
mpl m nt he r il ac t
a
W hie pli if m a be diabld f r c ran f r of e oy e ,t c uca f tll
l antf
y
de e mi to i whehe pl i if i dia e f a1 f m s of s t ntalga nfl e oyme .
t r nai n s
t r antf s s bld or 1 or
ubsa i i l mpl
l
nt

S e 4 U. C,j 4 3 d ( )a d 1 8 c a. Th r ae f u ee n so p o fwhc mu tb
e 2 S. j 2 ( )2 n 3 2 () ee r o r lme t f r o ih s e
co i r d i m n ng s h a a l i. The eee n saes mmaie a f lo : 1 o j cie
nsde e n ki uc n nayss
s lme t r u rz d s ol ws () b e tv
1

me ia f csa ci c lfn i g ;( )te o no a d c n lso o te tn p y iin ;()
dc l a t nd l a id n s 2 h piins n o cu ins f raig h sca s 3
ni
s b e tv e d n eo p y ia ma ietto so i ime t, sd srbe tr u h acama ts
u j cie vie c f h sc l nf sai n f mpar ns a e ci d h o g li n '
tsi n ; n ()t ecama tse uc to , o aina i so y r sd ls il, nda e Vie v.
e t y a d 4 h li n ' d ain v c to ll tr , e iua k ls a g . tk
mo
i
Fi h 4 8F.d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0 ( t Ci.1 71;Und r o v. bc f, 8F.d 8 0 8 ( t
nc , 3 2 1 7 1 96 4h r 9 )
ewo d Riio f 29 2 5 , 51 4h
Ci.1 6 )
r 9 2.
On a
ppea,M r Re r ie s ve a a g e s i udi t tt Law J
l . dd as s e r l r um nt, ncl ng ha he
udge i pr pe l
m o ry
a k s d t medi lo ni evi ncea dir ga ded t te tng physca nze i dee mi ng
s es e he
ca pi on de
nd s e r
he r a i
i in l n t r ni

h s r sd lf cin l c pa iy Thi pat ulr a gl n wa te s b e t o s p lme tl
i e iua un to a a ct . s ri a r l t s h u j c f u p e n a
c
me
bre i by t pa tes Afe r viwi t r c d a c i rng t pa i s mp l nt ,t
ifng
he ri . tr e e ng he e or nd onsde i he rte '
me s he
co tfndsGgood c us 't r m a t c et t Comm isone f f rhe de opme a
ur i d
a e' o e nd he as o he
s i r or ' t r vel
u
nt nd

c nsd rto . S e4 U. C. 40 ( )
o i eai n e 2 S. j 5g .
Unde t r ultonss ti f t t sa r f re l tngm ed c opi on e de e,
r he eg @ i
e tng orh he t nda ds o vauai
i al ni vi nc
t opi on ofateai physca i e ttedt S:ontoli we gh '...s l ast o ni n i
he ni
r tng
i in s n il o &c r lng i t
o ong he pi o s
ç l- u re by m e cal ac e a eclni a a l aor di nosi t hni
we ls ppo td
di ly c pt bl i c l nd abor t y ag tc ec quesa i not
nd s

i onsse wih t ohe s tnta e de e i (he cama 'qc e r or .'' Le sv.
nc itnt t he t r ubsa il vi nc n t li nts as ec dll' wi
Ber l,858 F. 858,86 ( h Ci.201 (leai i orgi l (uoi 20 C. R.jj
rvhil
3d
7 4t r 7) atrtons n i na) q tng
F.

4 4 1 2 ()2 a d 41 .2 ()2 ) s eas Br wn v. mm' So . c,8 F.d 2 , 8 6
0 .5 7 c4 ) n 69 7 c( ); e lo o
Co r c Se . 73 3 51 26 - 9
(t Ci. 01 ) W h n teLa J g d e no gvec n r ligweg t o ate tn p ysca s
4 h r 2 7 . e h w ud e o s t i o toln i h t r aig h iin'
o ni t La J
pi on, he w udge mus c i ra no xc usve ls off t st detr i wha wei t
t onsde
ne l i it acor o e m ne
t ght o
g vet opi o oft te i physcan a a1ot rm e c lopi onsi t r co d. J
i he nin he r atng
ii nd l he di a ni n he e r
ohns n v.
o

Bnn a t4 4 F.d 6 0 6 4 (t Ci. 0 5 ;s eas 2 C. R.j 40 1 27c a d 41 .2 /)
r h r, 3 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 0 ) e lo 0 F. j 4.5 () n 69 7
(it t efco st bec n ie e ) Th La J d emu tas p o i eS o d r ao i gi)
l i h a t r o o sd r d . e w u g s lo r v d t o e s ns n h s
s ng
g
n tc o d tr n to o d cso f rt e weg t( qgv ljEh )te tn s u c ' me ia
oie f ee miain r e iin o h ih he ies t e r ai g o r es dc l
o il n. 2 C. R. j4 4 1 2 ( 2 a d41 .2 ()2 ; e as S 9 -p,1 9 SS LEXI
p ro ' 0 F. j 0 .5 7X4 ) n 69 7 c () s e lo SR 6 8 9 6 R
i '
S
5(uy2 1 9 )(1 t e(e iua fncin l a a iy a s sme tc nlcswiha o ii nfo a
J 1 , 9 6 çf h r sd lu to a c p ct) se s n o tit t n pn o r m
ç
me ia s t c ,he g w J g qmu te p an wh t o n o wa no a o td.) Une st e
d c l ol e t La ud e s x li y he piin s t d p e ' . ls h
r
'
La J
w udget xplc tyi c t st we g gi n t a1o t r l va e de ,' r vi wi c ur
G iil ndia e he i ht ve o 1 f he e e nt vi nce'a e e ng o t
e
ca t de e m i whe he t La J
nno t r ne
t r he w udge' sndi a e s ppore by s t nta e de .
s
ngs r u
td
ubsa i l vi nce

Go d nv. h i r7 F. 2 , 3 ( t Ci. 9 4 ; e as M oto v, li 8 F.d1 6
r o Sc weke, 25 2d 31 2 5 4h r 1 8 ) s e lo r e Covn, 26 3 7 ,
r
1 9 ( t Ci.2 6 (W e h v h l t t $a n c sa y p e iae t e a i i s bsa ta
8 4h r 01 ) $
ç a e ed ha gq e e s r rd c t o ng gng n u tnil
e de r vi w i a r c d o t ba i f rt ALJ Sr i 'i udi ç dic son ofwhi h
vi nce e e s e or f he ss o he
' ulng, ncl ng a s us i
c
e de
vi nce t ALJ f t c e bl a why, a s c fc a i a i of t pe tne lgal
he
o md r di e nd
nd pe ii pplc ton
he ri nt e

r q ie nst t erc r e i e c .' (uoi Ra f r v. li 7 4 F.d28 , 9 (t Ci.
e urme t o h e o d v d n e'' q tng do d Covn, 3 3 8 2 5 4 h r
)
2 3)
01 ).
I t sc e t r or r ve st tM r Re be t e re pan a numbne si hi
n hi as , he ec d e al ha . dd gan o xpe ince i nd
s n s
rg wrs a a m i J nua y of2013,whe he washos t i d f t ee da a di gnos d
i ht it nd r n a r
n
pialze or hr
ys nd a
e

wi d e v i tr mbo i o te u pe e rmiy ( .5 2 3 ) Th ts me y a,Mr Re d
t e p en h o ss f h p r xte t . Tr 3 - 3 . a n e r . d
h
ijle hsba k wh l u l dn at c a wo k. ( .6 3 . M1 Re d s b e u n l s ug t
nt d i c ie noa ig nzk t r Tr 6 ) . d u s q e ty o h
r
.
te t e f ba k pai a pan a numbne si hi rghtuppe e r m iyon muli eoc sons
r am nt or c
n nd i nd
s n si
r xte t
tpl ca i .

( . 7 , 31 7 3 7 8 8 3, 6 , 6 , 7 8 6 91 , 28 9 9 9 2 . On o Mr Re d' te tn
Tr 5 5 6 , 4 , 5 , 3 8 0 8 8 8 7, 8 , 5 9 , 5 , 8 )
e f . d s raig
4

physc a was Andr w M .W at r ,M . ,a physc a a Ca ii Clni Fn iy M e cne ii ns
e
le s D.
ii n t rlon i c m l
di i

Roa
noke sae , r M r Reddwa te t f di nos so c oni l rbac pan a c oni
/ lm whe e .
s r aed or ag e f l c owe
k i nd k c
rghtm i tpai On J y 23, 5, . at r co pl t al a s s m e ofM r Redd' physca
i
s n.
ul
201 Dr W le s m eed z s e s nt
.
s
i l
c pa lte . Dr W at r o nedt tM r Re c sa o wak f t ho sa atm ea f ra
a biii s
. le s pi ha . dd an tnd r l or wo ur t i nd o

t a offveholr i an eghthourwor y; ha hec n stf t e holr a atm ea f at t l
ot l i
zs n
i kda t t a i or hr e zs t i nd or o a
of fve hour i a e ghthotr wo kda a t the ca fe nty lf up t t n pounds a
l
s n n i - l r y; nd ha
n r que l it
o e
nd

o c so al l tu t ffe n p t s ( .8 9 . Dr W atr frh r o n d t a M r Re d
c a in ly i p o ite omd . Tr 1 ) . les u te pie h t . d
f
c nnot us hi rght hand f smpl gr s ng or fne m n pul to ld t t he çr quies
n
e s i
or i e a pi
i
ni ai n,az ha
Ee r
o
pporunii be
t tes yondno mal kbr a du i a 8hourda t 1edown t r to bei tvef
r wor e ks rng n
yoi
o es r naci or

ac ranpeida h fn sn c say. ( . 9 .
e ti ro s e i d e e sr ' Tr 81 )
'
I de e ni M 1 Re sr sdua fl tona c pa iy,t La J
n t nni ng . dd' e i l l i l a c t he w udge di no d s us o
nc
d t ic s r
a sg weghtt a1 ofDr W ale s opi ons I t d,afe r c mtng Dr W at r 'a s s e ,
sin i o 1
. t r ' ni . nsea tr e ot i
. le s s es m nt

t e La J d e sl rl sae a ol ws E e t esg e a c r s s me weg tt ( .
h w ug l
mmaiy ttd sf lo : Th md rin d c o d o
ih o Dr
W atr ' opi on t t e e t ti r ogni st cama ' ca ct f a r nge oflgh
le sq ni o he xtnt ha t ec ze he li nts pa iy or a
i t

e e t n lwo k a tvt . ( . ) No a l, h La J g ddno a r s, c ls p o d
x ri a r ciiy' Tr 48 . tby t e w ud e i t dd e s mu h e s r vie
o
'

S o d ra o s'f rrj cig Dr W atr 'o i o rg r i p an ipsia iiyt u ehi rg
G o e s n ' o ee tn , . l s pnin e adng litf n b l o s s iht
g
e
t

ha dfrgapigo tnema iuain o Dr' l r'o i o ta teplitf wo l rq r
n o rs n r i
np lto , r .Wat s pnin h t h anif ud e uie
e
e tab e k t led wno r s dliga eg tho rwo kd y 20C. R. j4 4.5 7 ()a d
x r ra s o i o r e t t n n ih - u r a .
r
F. j 0 1 2 /)2 n
41 .27c ( ) Be a ete eo no sweeic n itn wi t eLa J d esd tr n to o
69 ()2 . c us h s piin r n o sse t t h w u g ' eemi ain f
h
pl i i sr i ua f nc i
antY esd l u tonalc pa t t La J
a ciy, he w udge wasr uie t e an why t o ni
eq r d o xpl i
he pi ons

ween ta o td. Se S R 9 - p 1 9 SS LEM S 5(uy 2 1 9 ) I t a e c o s h
r o d pe
e S 68, 9 6 R
J 1 , 9 6 . n he bs n e f uc
e a ton,t c ti una et de e mi whehe t La J
xplna i he our s bl o t r ne
t r he w udge' de ii i s
s c son s uppore by
td

s b tn il vie c . S eM o r e 8 F.da 1 ( b evn ta net rtea pelt c u t r
u sa ta e d n e e n o , 26 3 t 91 o sr ig h t i h p lae o r no
he
t ditit c r c n unde tke a mea ng u s tntale de e r viw lnl s a La J
he src ou t a
ra
ni f l ubsa i - vi nc e e l es
w udge

a e u tl e p an hi ra o f rt d feig weg t a sg e t me ia o no ) s eas
d q aey x lis s e s ns o he ifrn ih s si n d o dc l piins; e lo
Boge v. ry il No 1 - 81 2 7 U. Ap LEXI 2 4 , t* (t Ci. c 1 , 01 )
ly Ber h l, . 623 , 01 S. p.
S 51 4 a 3 4 h r De . 3 2 7
( o ldng ta i wa E o po sb e ... o c nd tme n n f la pelt rv e o t ALJS
c ncu i h t t s û t sil
n
t o uc a i g u p lae e iw f he '

d cso 'sn eSheALJd dn t ic so a sg weg t oa1 ft o i in o (h cama ts
e iiny ic ç
'
t
i o d sus r sin ih t 1o he p no s f t e li n 'j
te tngphyscin ...a t s o zi weei nsse wiht ALJSdeemi to ofghe
rai
ia
nd he e pilons r nco itnt t he ' tr nain t

cama ts r sd a Smcina c p ct ' Ac o d n l, e n i a p o rael
li n 'q e i u l to l a a iy). c r i gy rma d s p r p it.
For t r as
he e ons sa e t c t fnds E
tt d, he our
ç
good ca e' t r nd t c s t t
us ' o ema
he a e o he
Co misone f r f rhe de opme a c i r to .2 I t Comm iso r i una e t
m s i r o u t r vel
nt nd onsde ai n f he
s i ne s bl o
decde t s c e i pl ntY s f voron t ba i of t e si r c d,t Comm iso rwil
i hi as n ai i
a
he ss he xitng e or he
s i ne l
co uc a s pplm e ala i sr tve he dng a whih bot sdes wilbe alo
nd t u e nt dm nita i
a
t c
h i
l
l wed t pr e
o es nt

a to le de a a gu e . An a opra eor rofr m a wilbee e ed t sda
ddii na vi nce nd r m nt
ppr i t de
e nd l
nt r hi y.
TheClr i die t d t s nd c riid co e oft sm e a lm o ni t a1 c
e k s r c e o e e tfe pi s hi mor nd l pi on o l ouns lof
e
r or
ec d.

Lh t d y ofJanuar 2018.
z a
. y,

DATED : s
Thi

l

1
k

Se o Urie St t Diti tJ
ni r ltd aes src udge

1The c tde i t Commisone s i tton t r viw t r d deno t dicoverevi e
our clnes he
s i r' nvia i o e e he ecor
vo o s
denc
t s
hat upporst La J
t he w udge' decson t dicountDr W aler opi ons TheUnie St e Cour ofAppe s
s ii o s
. t s' ni .
td ats
t
al

f rt Fo t Cic tha ma ce rt a i i $ o rh rve n c ufs prvic ...t e g g i
o he urh rui s de la h t t s 6 t te e iwig o l ) o n e
n
o nae n
Ea tfndn )e r ie i t frtisa c . Ra f r 73 F. a 29 s eas Fo v Covn, 3 F. p'
fc-i ig xecs s n he is n tn e' d od, 4 3d t 6; e lo x . li 6 2 Ap x
'
7 , (t Ci. 1 )(< rcrut e e n ma e ce rta i i no Eh c u ts r l t s c lt a t h w
50 75 4 h r 20 5 $ ic iprc de t k s la h tt s t t e o r') oe o pe uae s o o
Ou
teALJa pidtelw t i fndng o t h oheieteALJS u ttc to sta wo l p r psfnds p r
h
p le h a o t i i s r o yp t sz h
s
'j si ain h t ud eha i up o t
i
i te rc r .) lse d t a p o it c u s i t Se n t t a e y fra iina iv siain o
n h e o d'. n ta , he p r prae o re s o d ma d o he g nc o ddto l n e tg to r
'
r
e pln to 'wh nt c u ti un bet dvauagjt bui frt ALJSd cso ' Ra f r ,7 4 F. a
x a ain' e he o r s a l o s l te he s o he ' e iin. d o d 3 3d t
e
'
2 ,se as M a co v.Covn 7 0 F.d 6 2,6 (t Ci.2 1 )( ol ng ta t lc ofe lnai fr
95. e lo s i
li, 8 3 3 40 4h r 0 5 h di h t he a k xpa ton o
ds rdin acama ' sae nsrq r drma d .
ic e t g li nts ttme t e uie e n )
i
'
2 I lghtoft cour' decii t r
ni
he
ts
son o emand t c et t Comm isoner t c tdeclne t addr s
he as o he
s i , he our
i so
es
M r Re sr ni cl msoferor
. dd' emai ng ai
r .

6