Mullins v. Unknown

Filing 5

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/19/2017. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI k,:r SKJ URT
:
CE l DI X
AT ROANQKK,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TI E W ESTER N D I
I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O

AP2 19 2 1
27
J
BY

c.

; W

R EEC E G EN E M U LLI S,
N
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

Ci lA ç i N o. 7: cvvi ton
17- 00108..- '

Ex cLunx

w cL ax
s

M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

UNKNOW N,
D ee
f ndant
,

By: M i
chaelF.U rbanski
U nied St e Di t i tJudge
t
at s s r c

Re ceGe M uli , oc edi pr K ,fl acvi rg sco pl nt ptr ua t 42
e
ne
lns pr e ng o
ied i l i ht m ai , ts nt o

U. C. 1 3.By Or e e tr dM a c 2 20 7,h c u t ie tdp an ift s b twi i
S. j 98
d r n ee rh 2, 1 t e o r drce litf o u mi t n
h
20 da fo t dae oft Or ra c
ys r m he t
he de ompl i pendi t s ts a ton oft r quie nt t t
ant
ng he a if c i
he e r me s ha
we e si aedwihi t to de a wel asa sae e o as e s a i t ac ountf r ,a a
r tpul t
t n ha r r s l
tt m nt f s t , n nma e c
o m nd
c rii d c ofpl ntf tus f a co mtsa e ntf t sx- on h pe i i e a ey
e tfe opy
ai ips r t und c t t t me or he i m t rod mm dit l
pr c di t flng oft compl nt obt i fom t a o i t prs ofi i la e chpds n
e e ng he ii
he
ai , aned r he ppr prae ion fc a t a
o

a whi pl ntf i o w a confne f t tsxt ch ai if s r s
i d or ha i mont pe i a l sl an e u edve iid
h rod nd a ty
xec t
rfe
J

sa e ntf
t t me onn.Pl ntf wasad s d t taf itr t c
ai if
vie ha a lle o ompl woul r ul i dim is oft s
y
d es t n s s al hi

a to wi u p eudc .
cin t t rj ie
ho
M or t n 20 da ha ea e a pl i ifha f ie t co pl wih t de c i d
e ha
ys ve lps d, nd antf s a ld o m y t he s rbe

c n iins Ac o dngy t c u t imis st a to wi o t rj d c a srk stec s
o dto . c r i l,he o r d s se he cin t u p eu ie nd tie h a e
h
fom t a tvedoc toft co t antf ma r fl t cam si as pa aeac i onc
r he c i
ke
he ur.Pl i if y e ie he li n e r t ton e
pli ifi pr pa edt c
antf s e r o ompl wih t notd co to .
y t he e ndiins
The Cl r i di e t d t s nd a co oft sM e or nd Opi on a a co pa ng
ek s r ce o e
py hi
m a um
ni nd c m nyi
or rt pl nts.
de o ai i

E E Ti /9
NTR: hs

dyoApi21.
a f r,07
l

.

+/ r,-. i
. '$.. e#
,

- *
.
'

.

Unie sttsbitit dge
td ae szc
. .
v v

. .