Haendel v. Reed et al

Filing 53

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 2/13/2018. (slt)

eL ( ogz a u & :I% ç/tkf
kRt: ft
' p
a
l'
t

A 7 N I ,A
T A VI V
ki
FI
LEp

I THEUNI S
N
TED TATESDITRI COURT
S CT

FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DW I ON
SI

F B 1 )1
E 3 q8

J
u
BY
:

ux cu
s w

.
DE

DAN H AENDEL,
Pl ntf
ai if,

Ci lAc i No.7: c 0011
vi ton
17-v9

V.

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O

A NN A REED ,e a .
t l,
D ef
endant .
s

By:

c

H o Jacks L.K i er
n.
on
s
Se or U ni e St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

Da Ha nde,who i m e roft Diti to Coll aBa butaVigi aprs r
n e l
s mbe
he src f tmbi r
r ni ione
pr ee ng pr x , fl ave ii c
oc di
o
ied rfed ompli puruantt 42 U. C.j1 3. Pl i ifnam esas
ant s
o
S. 98 1 antf
de e nt AnnaRe d,an As itntComm onwe lh' Atom e f t Ciy ofSt t on
f nda s:
e
ssa
at s t y or he t
amt

tEtt o ' Ra mo C. b rs n,h Co n at sAto n yf rS amtn; i W i o ,
t amt n); y nd Ro e to t e mmo we lh' tr e o tt o Jm l n
s
s
t ChifofPolc f rSt t on;BB Culy,apolc ofi e f rSt t o M a k R. qi t
he e
i e o amt
l
i e fc r o amt n; r He ng,he
Ator y Ge r lofVigi a;a Ha ol W .Clr ,t Die t roft Vigi aDe t e of
t ne
ne a
r ni nd r d
a ke he r c o
he r ni parm nt
Core tons Pl ntf a guest thei beng f s l i a ce a e i vi a i ofd pr es
r c i . ai if r
ha
s i aley nc r r t d n olton
ue oc s
be a ehi c ci f eecr cc mlni a i wih Ofi rCulyw e eus d unl wf ly
c us s onvi tons or l toni om l c tons t fce
l r e
a ul
durng li sa ec i lpr e ngs Def nda sfl m otonst dimi s Pli ifr s nde
i ls t t dm na oc edi . e nt ied
i o s s , a ntf e po d
a fl d am oton t n e a m os de e nt r ne e t rmotonst dim is Afe
nd ie
i o m nd, nd
t f nda s e w d hei
i o s s . tr
r viwi Pl i ifss
e e ng antf' ubmisons Ide e mi t tHe k v.
s i , t r ne ha c Humphr y,51 U . 477,478
e
2 S.

( 9 4 , r t ea to , sn n e , n d s s i wi o t rj d c a fi lu .
1 9 ) bas h cin a me d d a d imis t t u p eu ie s rvoo s
h

1Pli ifi lsedon t D.C.Ba ' we iea anSa i a tr y'i R
antf s it
he
rs bst s sctve to ne ' n good sa ng'des t hi fl
tndi ' pie s eony

cn ito s Se I ReKar aCa l ec e Co olLii.5 3F. u g.(61, 313 & M.4-5( D. .
o vcin. e n
ti naBrahs ns . tg, 3 S p 21 5 6 -3 1 1 E. La
n

20 8 (ol cigc ssidc t gta fd rl o rsma tk j dca n tc o g v mme tl b i s; il ms
0 ) c l tn ae n iai h t e ea c ut y a e u iil ole f o e na we st )W la
e
n
e
i
v. g 5 5F. u p. 6 9 68 - 8& n. (7 Md. 0 )(olcigc ssidc t gta potn so g v mme t
Lon , 8 S p 2d 7 , 6 8
4 1. 20 8 c letn ae n iai h t sig n o e n
n
we stsaeih rnl a t ni o sl-uh niaig .ld ci t e tndtel rl o tu to sa d dt a
b ie r n ee ty uhe tc r efa te tctn ) e l o xe h i a c nsr cin tn m. o n
ne
be
atre S eHan sv. re, 0 U. 5 9 5 (9 2 (bsrigta ac u's o l hodpr K c mpanst
ton y. e ie Ken r4 4 S. 1 , 21 1 7 ) o e vn h t o z h ud l o o lit o
t
çessrn e tsa d rsta f r l e dig da db lwy r' (mp a i a de )
ç s tig n tn ad h n oma pla n s rRe y a es' e h ss d d .
l
)

1.
2.
(

Pli tf wasa r se on M a 13,2014,a ac eq nc ofhi c
a n if
retd
y
s ons ue e
s omm t c tonsofa
mi ai
s xualna u ewih Ofk e Culy,who ha pr t ndedt be am i r Pl i ifwa c r d wih
e
tr t l r l
d ee
o
no . antf s ha ge t

atmp i t tkeid c n l riswihamio , nvilto o Vigz aCo ej 1 .- 7 a d
te tng o a n e e t i t t
be e
n r i o ain f r ii d j 82 3 0 n
l
18. 26, ndwih usng a c
2- a
t i
omm lniato s t m t f ciia ea s xua ofe ewih am i ,i
l c i ns yse o a ltt e l fnc t
nor n

v oai no Vign aCo ej 1 .- 7 ..Plitf p e d dn c n et a do De e r3 ,
ilto f r ii d 82 3 43 an if la e o o ts, n n c mbe 0

2 4, ewa s n e c db teCic i Co r o S amtn ( ic t uf't al cietnn o
01 h s e tn e y h rut u t f tt o G ruiCo z l o ra tv e f
f
s ve ye r 'i r er ton.
e n a s nca c ai
Ne ry ayea lt ri Se e r201 Pl i iffld wih t Cic tCour aM oton f
al
r ae n pt mbe
5, antf ie t he r ui
t
i or
Rec i r ton a M oton t Suppr s Evi e
ons de a i nd
i o
e s d nce.Pli ifa gue t tt e e toni
a ntf r d ha he l cr c
.

c
omm uni to wih Ofi rCuly we eunl wf l i e ce ed a s d ha be n
cai ns t fce
l r
a uly nt r pt nd houl ve e

s e s The Cic tCour de ed M oton f Rec i r ton and M oton t Suppr s
uppr s edr
r ui
t ni
i or onsde a i
i o
es
Evi nc a Pli ifa al t ucc s uly t t Cour ofAppe l ofVigi a a t
de e, nd a ntf ppe ed ms es f l o he
t
as
r ni nd he
Supr m e Co tofV i g ni
e
ur
r i a.

I J nua y 201 Pl i ifcomm e e acvi aci i sa ecou tby tlng apr #
n a r
6, antf
nc d i l ton n tt
r
ii
o q
-

G o i n ofJ m e 'a i tRe Ofi e Culy,Stun on,t St t on Polc De rm e ,
G to
M
udg nt' ga ns ed, fc r l a t he amt
ie pa t nt
t Ofi oft Comm onwe lh' Ator y f rStt on, ndt Co monwe t ofVig ni
he fce he
at s t ne o amt a he m
a1h
r i a.

P an ifalg dta t s d fnd n sv oae Vign aCo ej1 . 6 j itya d sveal , n
litf l e h t he e e e a t i ltd r ii d 92- 9 on l n e rly a d
e
a e la ef dn age . I as e ntflng tted, t o i n f rJ m e - Am e d,'
r ibl or m s2 n ubs que ii il t to o udg nt
M
nde '
Pli tf a g d t tRee a Ofk e Culy vi aed t pr vii gove ni t us ald
a n if r ue ha
d nd t r l ol t he o sons
r ng he e l

2Vi i aCo ej1 26 pemisacvl cinfrd ma e i crancrmnsa e a ans Sn p ro
r ni d 9.-9 r t iia to o a g s n eti ic tncs g i ti y esn
a
wh itre t, ico e o uss o po ursa yoh rp ro t itre tdsls o us E r,eeto co o ai
o nec ps dslss r e, r rc e n te esn o nec p ico e r e wie lcrni r rl
co
mmunia i '
c tons.
'

dicosleofe e toni c
sl t
r
l cr c onve s tonsbe a eOf e Culy pos d a a unde a mi rwihout
rai
c us fc r l
e s n
r ge no t
c uta ova . Pl ntf a s a g d t tO fi rCuly c d no ha ç nt r e e ' he
ot ' ppr l ai if l o r ue ha tce
l oul t ve ç e c pt d' t
i

ee r cc
lctoni onve s tonsbec us t ofi rwa apa t t t cq r ai n. The Cic tCour
rai
a e he fce s ry o he nve s to
r ui
t

uli a ey de e Pl i ifl a t 5l t t o i f J
tm t l ni d antf e ve o e he d ton or udgm e - Ame d'a dimis d t
M
nt
nde ' nd s s e he

c s wi p eu ieo J l 11 201 .Plitf a e ldu s c e sul t t eS p e Co r o
a e t rj d c n uy , 6 an if pp ae n u c sf ly o h u rme u t f
h
Vi g ni
r i a.
B.

Pl i ifc me e t sa ton no e le t n M a c 24,201 alegi i e a i
antf om nc d hi c i
ari r ha
rh
7, l ng, nt r la,
co tt i lduepr s vi a i nsby G r ri Ofi i sby f iur t f l w pl n l ngua of
nsiutona
oce s olto
l gila fcal
vi
a l e o olo ai a
ge
Vigi a Stm t a voi ghiii r ulngi flears a flei ionme . Li i t
r ni a e s d rto es t n as re t nd as mprs
l
i
nt' ke n he
'
.

çM oton f J
s i or udge e - Am e d, Pl i ifas e t t tRee a Ofi e Culy vi a e t
m nt
nde ' antf s rs ha
'
d nd fc r l olt d he
1 w by usngt i rm i tng eecr lcc mt c tonsi t c i lpr ee ngsa ns
a
i he nc i nai l tori om mi a i n he dm na oc di
gai t

Pl ntf. Pli ifm ant i t s de e nt 'acst nt dhi c i i c e a r nde hi pla
ai if antf i ans he e f nda s t ai e s rm nal as nd e r s e
a c c i i ld a voi gb i to.
nd onvitons nvai nd d nii 3
-

I r pons t t m otonst dim isfld by Robers Re d,a W iln s Pl ntf
n es e o he i o s s ie
ton, e nd li m , ai if

flda$ to t n nda dmoini o p sto t d fnd n ' Ei) to t d s s .4
ie $ i n o me n to n p o i n o ee a ts sc moi n o imis'
mo
i
'
Pl ntf e anst tt moton i t ca y a m it r tndi a
ai if xpl i ha he i s o ldf ny smde sa ngs boutt sa ton a t
hi c i nd o
m odiy pa t oft co pl i .
f rs he m ant
I taly, antf c a ii t the s def nda si bot t i i vi ua a ofi i l
nii l Pl i if l rfes ha
ues e nt n h her ndi d l nd fc a
ca cii s Nonehel s Pli ifnme t r le s
pa te .
t es , antf
nds he e if ough t o i G elefi t f of
t o m t : i n he onn
r

3Pl ntf acmowl
ai if l
edgest t d s t hsp irc aln e t teci n lu g n i saec u t, eh s
ha, epi i ro h le g s o h rmia j d me tn tt o rs h a
e
notyets
oughtawrtofha asco pusfom Vigi acours
i
be r r
r ni
t.
4I wa as c ptonedasa'veii compl n 'buti i clar9om t docume t ti i noti e
t s lo a i
l rfed
ait' t s e
he
nt ha t s ntndedt
o

rpa et oi ia c mplit Se Fe . Ci P. ()Cpla igsmutb c nsre s a t d usien.
e lc he lgn l o an . e d R. v. 8 e e dn
s e o tu d o s o oj tc .)

mo eayd ma e 'a da ijmcint t u dc mp l s e de r la efo i c r eain.
n tr n g s' n n nt to ha wo l o e a p e ir ee s ' m n ac rto s
r
Pl i tf s e onl de l r t y r le t tr og z s:
a n if e ks y c a a or e i f ha ec ni e

Vigni c t' lc ju s ito a v i fo te i e to o t e l t g'
r i a out a k tid ci n s o d r m h nc p in f h t i '
s
sn
ope a i n a c r r t t pl i a s ii lngua oft Vigi a sa ut s
r to s onta y o he an nd pecfc a
ge he r ni tt e
i vi ato ofc vi rght t rt Vigni a U . Consiui ns Thes
n ol i n
i l i s mde he r i a nd S.
tt to .
e
ofi i s f r aed t dsi 'o r ton knowi orha ng r as t lnow
fcal o mult he dtng' pe a i
ng
vi e on o c

telmiain o VA Co e()1 2-2( ()e e to frt ein ec p in'
h i tto s f
d j 9. 6 B)2 x mp in o h ç tre to '
i
by a pa t t t commt ia i t t s h c muni ai , e n i
ry o he
m c ton ha uc om
c tons ve f
G r isbl ,' a e no ç dm isbl' i Vig ni l l pr ee ngs a e
t m s i e' r
pe
t ç s i e' n r i a ega oc di , bs nt
a

j d ca a t rz to p i rl be a eteVignasame i c n rs t te
u iil uho iain rmaiy c us h r i i tt ,n o ta t o h
f r lsa e m a si a f l ny vi a i t us a ordicos t c t nt
ede a t mt , ke t e o
olton o e nd/ s l e he on e s
ofa i e ce i i t pe s s doi lno orhm r as t kno t tt
n ntr pton f he r on o ng c ws
s e on o w ha he
co e s a e fom a i e c ptwihoutr quiî as doe t f r sa ut ,
nt nt r r
n nt r e
t
e rng,
s he ede al tt e
t tt i e ce bei vi a i oft sa e.
ha he nt r pt n olton he t mt

Fidngi a pr p it t d s i a c r a c wi Fe e a Rul o Ci l o e u e1 a
n i t p o rae o o o n c o d n e t d r l e f viPr c b r 5 nd
h
Fo nv. v s 3 U. 1 , 8 ( 9 2 ,h moint n n i g a tdt t ee tn i
ma Da i, 71 S. 78 1 2 1 6 ) t e to o me d s ' n e o h x e t t
r
c a ii st ve ii d c
l rfe he rfe ompli asi e
a nt nt nded,a t r le i lmiedt de a a or r le .Cf
nd he e if s i t o clr t y e if .

Ke tc v. a a 47 U. 1 9, 6 n.8( 9 5 (o igasaesi ni c nb o e c me
n u ky Gr h m, 3 S. 5 1 7 1 1 8 ) n tn tt ' mmu t a e v r o
y
b n migsaeo fcasa d fnd nsi o fca-a ct a to f rijmcieo d caao y
y n n tt fiil s ee a t n fiilc pa iy cins o nt tv r e lrtr
r le ) Supr m eCour ofVigi av.
e if ; e
t
r ni Cons r Uni n ofU . SI , U . 71 736ume s o
S. nc.446 S. 9, 38

( 9 0 ( icamiga s lt i mi a ad fns t a to f rd ca ao yr l g.
1 8 ) ds li n b ou e mmt t s ee e o cins o e lr tr ei
y
e
I.
I

He kv. l h e , 2U. 4 7 4 6 8 ( 9 4 , a sti a to . Se W ili on v
c Hl r y 51 S. 7 , 8 - 7 1 9 ) b r h s cin6 e lcns
mp

.

Do s n, 4 U. 7 8 - 2 ( 0 5 (e og ii j1 8 damsf rd ca ao yr l faebard
to 5 4 S. 4, 1 8 2 0 ) r c n zng 9 3 i o e lrt r ei r re
e
5Ide i t c t et a i a s ' ng ha r leff rs ve a r as . Pli ifi,i xplca y,sil
clne o onsru he cton s ee
ki beas ei o e r l e ons antf s ne i bl tl

alcn e atr yi g o sa dngwihteD. Ba, o o h b a r l ta dh sn t e s u h h be srl f
ie s d tone n o d tn i t h C. ru ws f a e s ei n a o y t o g t a a ei
e
e
M or notbl ho ve,i t f c Pl ntf ex i ty dicamss ki ha asr lefi t sacin. Se e. ,Ca to
e a e, we r s he a t ai if plcil s li ee ng be ei n hi to
e. 2. sr

v UntdSae . 40U. 3 5 3 6(0 3 (ou a v rays se i d sg e aomdtep e s ta t pat s
. ie tts 5 S. 7 , 8 2 0 ) R r d esr y tm s ein d r t h rmie h the ri
e
know w ha i be tf t m ,a a er po i ef adva ng t f t a a gum e se ilngt t r le .
t s s or he nd r es nsbl or
nci he acs nd r
nt ntti hem o eif
Re har trzai i unlke çi alco tuciny i t ti r r sac tdei r tl t ove det D oK
c ace i ton s i lber nsr to ' n ha t equie our lbe aey o ni he r

l ia tsc oc o prc d l e il frhscam.)(c la J, o c ni g .
ig n ' h ie f o e ma v hce o i ll ' S ai, .c n u n )
t
' '

6'hepa te fl dipostvemotonsr ii va i c le
1
* ris ied s ii
i asng rous halngest t co ai ,asn e d. 1fndi
o he mpl nt m nde
i t

4

t de Hec i s es oft ca m swoul nec s rl de o tae t i ldiy oft
m r k f ucc s he li
d es a iy m nsr t he nva i t
he

p io rsc n e n wi o tfv rb etnnnai n .Plitf e ae l c aln e t
rs ne' o fn me t t u a o a l e i to ) an ifrpe tdy h le g s he
h
lg l yo t eivetg to a dci na j g n f rwhihi p e e tyi c r eae Theei
e ai f h n si ai n n rmi lud me t o c s r sn l n a c rtd. r s
t
no a nuet bot is t r que t d de a a i ye noti pugn t l lt ofPli ifs
ve
o h s ue he e s e clr ton t
m
he egaiy
a ntf

c c i a i a c r to Pli ifwoul bet a u l i a c r t i,a uendo,Vigi a
onvitons nd nc r e a i n. antf
d mlwf ly nc r e aed f m
r ni

c u t lc e j d cin.Alo t ec a ta s rp -teo ys ct e ie ee tbihnghi
o rs a k d uds ito
s ,h h tr n cit h nl pe i vd nc sa ls i s
k
guit- w o d ha be n s e s d ha t pr ec o sa polc vi aed d pr es a
l
ul ve e uppr s e d he os ut r nd ie ol t ue oc s nd

c
omm itd f l est s c ehi c c i .Pl ntf a gu st tli co c i wo d notbe
te e oni o e ur s onvitons ai if r e ha ls nvitons ul
i
mpug d by is ng t deca ai be a ehi Alor pl a ço he e de e' hepolc
ne
s ui he lr ton c us s f d ea nd tt r vi nc 't
ie

S
s pos es 'co d agan r ul i hi a r s a i a c r ton.Howe r ane pl he dng,
may s s' ul
i es t n s re t nd nc r e a i
ve , w ea a
t pr ton ofunknown t he e de e, r - e t a r i a c r to alpr s ppos t t
he oduc i
G r vi nc ' e r s, nd e-nc r e ai n 1 e u
ot
'
e ha

t ec re tud me ti ivai a dta t ci na p o e sb g n a e
h u r n j g n s n ld n h t he rmi l r c s e i s n w.
Pli ifcn us j1983t obt nde aaor r i t tne sa yde
antf nnot e
o ai clrt y elef ha ce sdl monsrtst
tae he
iva i t ofii c
n ldiy ls onlne e t a hec nno pr f vor bl tr nai n be a ehei sil
m n , nd
a t ove a a e e mi to c us
s tl

c c e a i r e aed f t c i e f whi h he s ksde lz t r r le Ac or ngl t
onvit d nd nca c r t or he rm s or c
ee
c a a o y ei f c di y, he
a ton i dimi s wihoutprl di easfi ous7
c i s s s ed t
eu c
'
rvol .

unnec s r t a es t eot rar
es a y o ddr s hos he gume si lghtoft br d a ia i ofHec
nt n i
he oa pplc ton
k.
1Pli ipspurui oft sa ton de pieanobvi l k offvo a etr nato c tmtst fi ous
antf
s t hi ci
st
ous ac
a r bl e mi in onsi e he rvol

p ruto a i ip tbl meieslg lh oy.Se . ..Netk v Wil ms49 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9 'e as
u s i f n nds ua y rt s e a t e r e ec, i e . li . 0 S. 9 3 7 1 8 ) se lo
l
z
a
,
Ru slv. i odCt. ncnaiv 5 9F. p' 6 , 5(t Ci. 5 (e c rn (mdigHe kb re a
sel Gul r v Mu ii l , 9 Ap x 5 6 4h r201 ) p r uim) f n c ard
f
t
j1 3c mplit ndu h dn ds sa a gioo spts n t 28U. C. 1 1 A()1) Wis nv. heif
98 o an a p olig imisl s v lu t ua to
r
S. j 9 5 b( ); lo S rf
De tNo. :0 c - 0 6 , 01 U.. s.
p'
. 71 -v 0 3 3 2 0 S DitLEXI 8 1 3 a * 201 WL 3 2 4, t* ( . Va Au .l , 01 )
S 5 9 , t 5, 0
29 65 a 2 W D. . g 9 2 0
(imisn wi o t rj dc a gioo su d r c (ii Oma v. a a o 31 F. p' 1 8 1 9(t Ci.
ds sig t u p eu ie s v lu n e He k ct
h
ng r Ch sn w, 8 Ap x 8 , 8 4h r
2 0 )( dfi dsrc c u tsds sa wi p eu ieu d rHe kt rfeth t imislswi o t rj dc t
0 9 mo iyng itit o r' imis l t rj dc n e c o elc ta ds sa i t u p eu ie o
h
h
pan if ein u o fv rbetr n to o c n ito )(e c iml)
litf rfl g p n a oa l emiain f o vcin p r ura l.
i

11
1.

Fo t f e ngr a ons Igr ntPl i ifsm oton t nme g a De e nt 'm o i ns
r he or goi e s , a
antf
i o
nd; r nt f nda s to

t ds s a t t a p iain o He kv Hu h e 51 U.. 7 , 7 ( 9 4 , ndd n te
o imis s o he p lc to f c . mp ry, 2 S 4 7 4 8 1 9 ) a e y h m
i pat smo ta t o h ra g me t; n d s s t ea to wih u p eu iea fi l u .
n r m o s o t e r u n s a d imis h cin t o t rj dc s rvoo s
Be us i a ar t D . Ba ha no ye be n i or e ofPli ifsc c i , heCl r
ca e t ppe s he C. r s t t e nf m d
antf' onvitons t
ek
s l f wa d ace tfed c oft sM e or ndum Opi on a a c pa ng Or t t
hal or r
rii opy hi m a
ni nd c om nyi
der o he
Ofke ofDici i r Co ms f t DititofCol bi Cou tofAppe l .
f
s plna y t el or he src
um a
r
as

E E T i -- a o Fb z y2 1.
NT R: hs -dy f ena ,08
l
r
Se orUnie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge

6