Germann v. Berryhill

Filing 24

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 9/8/2018. (ck)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT
S
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE, A
V
FI
LED

I TH E UN I ED STATE S D I
N
T
STRICT COU RT
FO R T H E W E STERN D ISTRICT O F W RG I I
N A
RO AN O R D I SION
W

sEF 12 2 1
22
J
U
av,

M EI N I G.
A
E y

C. UDLEM CLERK

;.TCLERK
DPY c
E
6e
U

Pl ntf ,
ai if

Ci lActon N o.7:7cv001
vi
i
1
28
N AN CY A.BE RRYII LL ,
CI
Com m i i
ss onerofSoci Sec iy,
al urt

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

Chi fUnie S a e Di ti tJ
e
t d t t s src udge

D ef
endant
.

M E M O RAN D U M O PI ION
N

Thi s i ls urt diabiiy a
s oc a ec iy s lt ppea w a z e z t ta H onor bl Rober S. lou,
l s ef t ed o le
a e
t Ba l

UltdSae M aitaeJ d e p sa tt 2 U.. j6 6 $() ,fzp o e fndn
e tts gstt u g , r u n o 8 SC. 3 4 17) o r posd i igs
offc a d ar c
a t n e omme e ds i n. ma itaej d efldarpo ta
nd d iposdo The gsrt u g l
e e r nd
r c mme da , e o ndn t tpli ifsmoto f rsx r jd me tbed ne ,
e o n don r c mme ig ha antf' i n o l
mmay u g n
e id

teCommison rsmoto f sl t jd me b ga e a teCo si rshna
h
si e' in or l
mmay u g nt e rntd nd h mmisone' l
d cso beaftne Pli ifMea i G.tM ea ellha fldobetonst t rpo tt
eiin fi d. antf lne f lni' s i
v
f
e jci o he e r,he
Com m i sone hasr s
si r
e ponded,a t sm ate i now zpef t c tsconsde a
nd hi
tr s
i or he our '
i z don.
1
.

Mea er ie t r eag z nt o s mma yj g n a d ma st s met e
lni asd h e rtme s n u r ud me t n ke he a hz e
ag me t i he o e ton t t ma itaeJ g ' r po ta r c mme ai The
r u n s n r bjci s o he gst t ' es e r nd e o nd ton.
ud
pu pos ofma itaej g rviw i t c e v jdiil e o c s Unie S ae v.
r e
gsr t ud e e e s o onsr e u ca r s ur e . td tt s

1D ue t prva y conc m s t c ta st r c m e don oft Com mit e on Cou tAdm i sr
o i c
e , he our dopt he e om nda
he
te
r
nitadon a Cas
nd e

Ma a e n ofh ulil nfrnc ofh UrtdSae t u eo l tefs n mea dls iia o t c ma i
n g me t tel cca Co ee e te le tts o s ny h t t a n atnd l fhe bi ntn
i
i
r
s c a s c iy opi ons
o i l e uzt ni .

Mi et, 7 F.d6 6 6 ( hCi. 0 7. t te ,heo e d r qè e ntstf t
d te 4 8 3 1 , 21 4t r 2 0 )To ha nd t bjc on e ltme e orh
i
i Rue7 ofteFe ea Rue o CiiPr e u ei deine t fti qt atn nof
n l 2@) h d tl ls f vl oc d r s sg d o f ang he te éo
t
lot t citi tcouz a t c tofa
a h he lsrc
t nd he our
ppeasupon onl t ei s st tr an i diput
l
y hos s ue ha em i n s e

atrt ma itaej g ha ma f i sa r c mme ai . L. (ii Tho sv.
fe he gszt ud e s de i ng nd e o nd tons' t ctng ma
nd
'l
a
Ar 4 4U..1 , 4 - (9 5)Anobjci pat mu tdos T t s fiints e iiiy
n, 7 S 40 1 7 48 1 8 ).
etng ty s o f h u fce p cfct
wi
s a rao bl t aett dsrc c ur o t tu go frteo e to 'J a 6 .
o s es na y o lr he itit o t f he te r und o h bjcin. d. t 22
'
'
To concude ot r s woul def at t pur e of r quii
l
he wie
d
e he
pos
e rng

ob e é . ewo d bepev idn apat t a a a y is e
jc ons W
ul
tnt g ry o ppe l n su
t twa be o e t m a itae j g ,r g r ls o t n t r
ha s f r he gst t ud e e a de s f he a u e
a d s o ofob e tonsma e t t ma itaej g ' r po t
n c pe
jci
d o he gsr t ud es e r.
Eihe t diti tc tw oul t n ha t r vi w e r is
t r he src our
d he
ve o e e ve y s ue

i te ma itae j g ' p o e f i s a
n h
gstt ud es r posd i ng nd
nd
r om m e tons or cotrs of a a s woul be r quie t
ec
nda i
lt
ppe l
d
e rd o
r viw i s t tt dit c tne rconsde e I e t r
e e s ues ha he sdct our ve
i r d. n ihe

c s ,udca r s u c swoud b wa td a d t e d sdc c ur'
a e j iil e o r e
l e se n h it t o ts
e fci ne s b s d o h l fom ma itae j g swold be
fe t s a e n ep r
ve
gsr t ud e t
l
unde= i d.
ne
=
I
d

The citi c tm us de e nnne d no a y p do oft ema itaej g '
lsrct our
t t r i . vo n or n h
t
gsrt ud es
.

r po ta t c mme ai n t whih ap o ro e to ha be nma .f hedititc r
e r nd e o nd to o c z pe bjcin s e de T
l' stc ou t
ma a c ptr jc, rmo f t er c
y c e , ee to diy h e omme e diposd ; e ev f rh re i e c ; r
nd d s i on r c ie i t e vd n e o
l

r tr tematrt t maitaej g wihi tu t . Fe R. v P. 29 3; c o d
eun h te o he gstt ud e t nsr ci ' d. Ci. 7 $()a c r
ons'

2 U.. j6 6q 1.l, we r apat fma e g nea orc cus r o e do t tdo
8 SC. 3 $() fho ve, ry f k s e rl on l o y bjc ns ha
f
notdr c t c r t as e ii er ri t ma itaejd ' p o e fncng a
ie t he ou t o p cfc ro n he g sr t u ges r pos d l s nd
i
r omm e dons''X novor viw i notr rd.Di t e ov.Col n,N o.5:3-vec
nda ,'
ee s
equie
oj r
vi
1 c

0 08 - 0 8FDW DSC, 01 W L 1 6 06 a * ( D. C. r 2 , 1 )( u gHo r
2 4
6 98 , t 1 W. N. Ap . 8 20 4 q odn wad
Yelw Ca s I . Unie S ae ,9 7F. up 4 , 7 ( . . . 1 9 ).vhec r wi
lo b . nc v. td tt s 8 S p. 69 4 4 W D N C. 9 7) f
ou t l
l

2

not onàde t eo e do byt pli ft taemeeyc cu o yo atmptt obe t
c ' z hos bjc ns he anéf ha t rl on ls r r te o jc
i
t t e ie y oft Repor,wihoutf usng t c tsa t nton on s ii e r s
o he ntr t
he
t t
oc i he our' te i
pecfc r or

t ri 'Ca e v.
heen. m r Comm' o So . e .No. :8 v6 , 0 9WL 9 4 1 ,a * ( D. .
:
r f c S c, 40 c 9 2 0
0 4 11 t 2 . Va
E.

Ma 6 20 9; e Mi et, 78F.da 6 rf ci 6 6 $()do snotc ntna ea
y , 0 ) se d te 4 3 t 21 seton 3 9 1 e
ou e nc
fr of neaie obe éo t c ve alsue a drse b t ma itaej g ;t
om ge zl d jc n o o r 1is s d esd y he gsrt ud e i
z
c ntmplt st tapa t ob e tont ama itaej g ' r po'bes cûca d
o e aè ha rfs jci o
gsrt ud es e l pe i n
t
pa tculrz ast samt diecst diti c tt rviw onl zhoe rin oft
ri aied, he t e t t he srct our o e e
y t spotos he

rpo to j c;#pr posdû n so rc mme da nst whc d ;i/Jma en S h
e r rpef: o e ndig r e o n do o ih / ' ;' d.à. uc
'
// J
# b
,
g ne a o e t f a t smee f c a afi et obe t o a awav ro s h
e r l bjci T ve he a fe t s al o jc, r s ie f uc
ons h
ur
ob e to 'M o v. X Te h l is 7 2 F. up 2 8 7 8 ( . Va 2 1 ) s eas
jc in. on BW
'
c noo e , 4 S p. d 2 , 29 W D. . 0 0 9 e lo

Thoma, 7 U.. t1 4rflhesaut do sno rq iet j g t rve a is .
s 4 4 S a 5 rl tt e e t e ut he ud e o e iw n sued
q
no i no o e to a ef1d'.
vo f bjc ins r t '
e )

Re s i ag nt rie beo et ma itaej g d sno c mpl wiht
hahng rume s asd fr he gstt ud e oe t o y t he
.
r q' e nts tf rh i t Fe rlRue o Ci l oc d r t fl s chco e éo .
e lr me e o t n he dea ls f viPt e u e o ie pe i bjc ns
i

l e d, bjci st tsmpl tieaeag nt rie beoet ma itaejd ae
nd e o e ton ha i y etrt rume s asd f r he gsrt u ge r
c i r d t bege rlo e do t t e ieyoft er po ta r c
onsdee o
nea bjc ns o he nt t h e r nd e omme a n. e
r
nd éo S e
Ve v. tu ,5 9F. u 2d 8 , 4 - ( . Va 2 08 . t ec ur no e i V em-:
ne Asr e 3 S pp. 41 8 4 45 W D. . 0 ) As h o t t d n- . y
-l
A lowi a ltga t obt n de novo r viw ofhe e ie ca e
l ng ii nt o
ai
e e
r ntr s

b meeyr fr ti a erirbre a a o e d T kls
y rl eomat n al if s n bjc on f e)
ng
e
ma
t i ta r f r nce t t m a s r t us l s The f tons of
he nii l e e e
o he gi t a e e es .
unc i
t diti t cour a e e f c i l duplca e a bot t
he s rc
t r f e tvey
i td s
. he
h
m a s r t a t diti t cour pe f ' i ndc l t s .Thi
gita e nd he sl c
t r ot de a a ks
m
s

d l a n oft a e f r wa ts j ca r s ur e r t r
upi do
c
i nd fo t se udiil e o c s ahe
me
t
han s vi t , a nm s c r r t t put es of t
a ng hem nd
onta y o he
pos
he

M a itae Ac. Ho r ( S cyofHe lh & Hu a S r sl
gsr ts t' wa d v. e '
'
at
m n e v .,
9 2 F.d (05)g 5 ( t1Ci. 9 12
3 2 5 , 09 ( 1 r 1 9 ).
6

3

539 F.Supp.2d at846. pl i ifwho r ier eshe pr vi l r ie a gu e swilnotbe
A antf
e t ay r e ousy- as d r m nt l
gi f he s ond bieatt a e s s eks' i t a he r -ie bre wilbe te ed a a
ven f ec
t
t he ppl he e i ns e d, r e fl d i f t
'
r at s

g n rlo e t whc h st smeefc a wozdafi r t o e t l .
e ea bjci
on, ih a he a fe t s ll al e o bjc. d
u
M ea esobe to a e i lr epa t azieai oft ea g me ss er ie on
lni' jcins r, n a g r, etr t
on h t u nt h as d

sz r j g nta aenothetpeofs e ii obe to rq ie b Rue7 q
lmmay ud me nd z t y
p cfc jcins e urd y l 2 $.
Ho v r t c ur ha rve détn votos podo oftema itaejd 'rpo tt
we e,he o t s e iwe
o h e l ns h gsrt u ges e r o
whih Mea eob e td a fndst AT ' de iin i s ppo td b s bsa da e i nc .
c lni jce nd i he ,S cso s u re y u tn l vde e
J
lI
.

l i nott pr nce ofa f de a c tt m a admi sr tvedia lt decsons
ts
he ovi
e r l our o ke
nita i
s biiy ii .

Rahe ,ud ca r ve ofd sbit c s si l td t d tr nigwhehe s tnta
t r j iil e iw ia l y a e s i e o ee mi n
i
mi
t r ubsa il
e de s
vi nce uppor st Com m isone ' c l i t tt pli ff ie t m e hi bur n
t he
s i rs oncuson ha he nndf ald o et s de

ofp o i g ds b ly S eHa sv. u l n, 0 F. 1 5 ,1 6(t Ci. 9 0 ;s eas La
r v n ia ii . e
t
S li 9 7 2d 4 3 45 4 h r 1 9 ) e lo ws
va

v. lbrz e 36 F. 6 0, 4 (t Ci. 9 6.ns d ig t c t tma net r
Cee ez , 8 2d 4 6 2 4h r 1 6 ) I o on ,he oz y ihe
r
unde t kea dq novo r viw oft Commisonersde ii norr - i t e denceof
ra
.
ee
he
si ' cson
ewegh he vi
.

r c d. e v. ul n, 9 F. 31 3 (t Ci. 9 2 . de ei s bsa il e ,
e or Huntr S lva 9 3 2d , 4 4 h z 1 9 ) Evi nc s u tnta wh n
i
consde i t r cor a awhol i mi be dee e ade t t s
i rng he e d s
e, t ght
m d qua e o uppor a c uson by a
t oncl i

r a on bl r nd mc a ds v. r ls 40 U. 3 9 4 (9 ) o whe i woud b
e s a e ni , h r on Pe ae , 2 S. 8 , 01 1 71 , r n t l e
s fkintt r f s adz ce ve dc i ajl tilS nt v. tr 9 F.d 6 5 6 (t
u f e o e u e ie td r it n uy ta. n ih Chae , 9 3 3 , 38 4 h
Ci.1 6 . bsa l vi nc i notafageorc nsd rbl a untofe i e e'Pir e
r 99 ) Su tnda e de e s
fr
l
o i e a e mo
v d nc y e c
'

v. e wood 48 U.. 2, 6 (98 ) bu i mo et a ame esi iaa s wh t e s
Und r , 7 S 55 5 5 1 8, t s r h n r cntl nd ome a ls
l
t n a pr ponder nce Pe a e ,402 U . a 401 La s 368 F. a 6 I t
ha
e
a . r ls
S. t 9 w ,
2d t 42. f he

4

Com m isone ' decson i s
s i rs ii s uppor e by s t le de e, tm us beafi e 42 U . C.
td
ubsanda vi nc i
t
f= d.
S.

j40 () Peae , 0 U.. t40 .
5g ; rls 4 2 S a 1
1 1.
1 2

Mea i frtobjcst tema itaej g ' c cuso t tteAT pr el
lne ls et o h gsrt ud es on l in ha h J op ry
c i z d h zobeiya a c untd f rp an ifso st, z uig t a Tthe AT '
onsdee e st nd c o e o litf beiy ag n h t fj
g
J
,S
decson ga no w eghtt pli ifsobest i f ultng t r i lf nc
ii
ve
i o antf'
iy n o= a i he esdua ' dona ca ip'
u
l pact '

P1sObj ECF. 1 , t9 M ea ec ntndst the BM1of5 . i cshe
. .
'
,
No. 5 a . lni o e ha r
27 mpa t r
d g ne ai j ntds a eoft k e, c c us si r a e pnn a l ttont n
e e r t oi ie s he ne s whih a e nc e s d i nd i ai ha
ve
mi

e pe tdfom de e ea ejitdsaeao a wa un cou e f i t RFC. .
x ce r
g n rdv on ie s lne nd s a c ntd orn he
P1'
s
Ob .ECF. 1 , t8 . ep n st he phy iins no e t l eweg a h r
j,
No. 5 a -9 Sh oit o r sca ' t s o os iht nd e
tsi nya utstig a sa i , nd ag st a t AT fi d t c i rt a h r
et
mo bo itn nd tndng a r ue h t he , al o onsde h t e
J e

e r weg i r ae he pana dft . . Obj ECF. 1 , t1 -1 .
xta ihtnce ss r i n akue P1s .
'
,
No. 5 a 0 1
Ho ve , st ma ita ej g a l n e ,V e ei no r q rm e i t
we r a he g st t ud e pt ots f r s e uie nt n he
y
r g ltonst tt AT i l ealn t yorpr cs a ay i g o st)i t oprin.
e uai ha he J ncud e g h
e ie n lss of be iy n he il '
o '

Re & Re omm.ECF No 21 a 5 (ii mc r sv. t e No. :1 v 0 7 2 2W L
p. c
,
. , t ctng ha d Asx , 61 c 00 1 , 01
5 5 9 , t* ( D. . ul 5 2 1 ). r q ie b S il c 'yRui 0 -1 t
46 4 9 a 6 W. Val y , 0 2) As e u r d y oca Se utt l 2 p,he
i
ng
AT e la e Mea esob st a se 2t r ug 5oft s q n ile aua n pr e s
J vau td lni' e iy t tps h o h
he e ue ta v l do oc s.
TheAT f undobeiyt beasve ei im e t( 22 3 , n s cûc l no e
Jo
st o
e r mpar n RA -2 ) a d pe i al td
y
M eani ' t tm ony t tfhe a tvii ofdal l ng we elm ied by he obest . ..
l es esi
ha T r c i tes
iy i
vi
z i t
r
iy. '
'

2 ) Ther sd lf nci a c pa iya ay i r pe tdya drs e M ea esobe i a is
4.
e iua u ton l a ct n lss e a e l d e s d lni' st nd t
y
e f cso he k ei ime t TheAT notd t tt me ia e i e c f rhe k e
fe t n r ne mpnr n .
J e ha he dc l v d n e o r ne
2Detied f ct aboutM e aze' i pa r nt a m e l la pr e la hit y c be f z iztz r por a
al a s
l ri s m ime s nd ci nd oc dtr l sor an outd r le e t nd
ca

rc mme d d na i tea miita v ta cit( No . , 1. sc te wi no b rpetdh r.
eo n a o nd n h d nsrd e rnszp ECF s 8 2 )As u h,h y l t e e ae ee
l

i st n a ob st mosl pos- ae t ls i s e d t ofMa c 31 20 9 ( 2 )
mp ime t nd e iy ty td td he a t n urd a e
r h , 0 . RA 4 .
H enot d M ea e sr pot sofi s swih a t m pt t l eweghti he m e c lr or i
e
lni' e t
s ue t te s o os i n r dia ec ds n

J y 2 0 , nd t ts r po td al sof11po si De e z2 0 b si h d
ul 0 4 a ha he e re os
und n c mbe 0 4 ut tl a
l
oc ai na pop i gi he kn ef l wi p o o e a t iy ( 2 ) S ha k e
c so l p n n r e ol ng r l ng d ci t.RA 5 . he d ne
o
v
r plc e s ge yi lt 2005, hi 1 d t a s resofr por sofi pz m enti o
e a em nt ur r n a e
w ch e o e i
e t
m ove
nt

Se e r2 0 .( 25. A1Jnotd fafe t d t ls i u e , hecnma t
ptmbe 0 9 RA ) The , e , f qtr he ae a t ns z d t li n
g
c ntn d t h vefw c mpli sr ltd t he k e , tas r mane ob s . ( A 25.
o iue o a e o ant ea e o r ne s bu lo e i d e e' I )
?k

TheAI c tn dt the BMIwa 5 a of a ay2 0 a t ts c mpli dof
J oniue ha t
s 2 s J nu r 01 , nd ha he o ane
lc i af lr n ofmo n i he k ebe i nigi Au s 20 0 ( A 25 6 .
a kng ul a ge
do n t ne g n n n gu t 1 . . -2 )
R
W ih r s c t M ea ' r sd a f n to a c pa iy t AT d t t ne t a
t e pe t o lies ei u l' ci n l a ct, he J ee mi d h t
.
u
M ea e' fbone onlni s f
- boneos e rhtdsi t rghtkneeand s e ntt a knee
t oa t i n he i
ubs que ot l

r plc me t aogwi hro et s ppo tal t t t l ht r i vov n no k ei ,
e a e n , ln t e bs u r i ai o i wo k n li g ne l no
h
j,
mi on g
ng
c a i a no cl bi ofldde s r s or s afol ,a onl occ i lpe f m ance
r wlng, nd
i ng a r , ope , c f ds nd y asona r or
m

ofot rposur l c v te . ( 26 (mph ssa de l. AT e p il ga weg t
he t a a d iis' RA e a i d d ) The J x Ect ve iht o
'
y
M ea le' obe iyi f m ultng t r i lf tona c pa iy. ddii ly,t m e c l
lri s st n or a i he esdua unc i l a c t A tonal he dia

r c r o wh c t e AT r le i e l l Mea esa it t wo k rg al r fe t
e o ds n ih h , eid n vauai
J
ng lni' b ly o r e ulry elc
i
M ea e' heght we ght and body m a si x and not he obe iy
lni s i , i ,
s nde
e z st .
l a ton t r viwi t r or a awhol ,t c ts ii l r viw e e ch
n ddii o e e ng he ec d s
e he our pecfcal e e d a
y

pa ectdi M ea eso jci r g r i he ne d t l s weg orh rd fiulysGng
g ie n lni' b e ton e a dng r e o o e iht e ifc t i ,
s a ng,a m a nt i ng a sa pos ur t a c rai whe he t se dence s d ha
t ndi nd i ani
t dc t e o s e t n
t r hi vi
houl ve

s g e td t t ATJt a pli fc ul n pe f r l two kwih l i do . er c r
u g se o he , h t anéf o d ot ro m i
gh r t i t ns Th e o d
. m a
c t i i l M e a est s i ony t ts s fsbet n sandi sti and l ng
iatons nc ude l ni' e tm
ha he bit
wee t ng, itng,
yi

6

do d t dso o ta ofe tke b e k .1A 4 -5 ) S eas n e cfiuly
wn ue o ic mfr nd yn a s ra s (t 8 0. h lo otd lfc t
i
puti on he s ksa s
tng
r oc nd hoesduet he obe iy a t s e re e pnn i he
o r st , nd hat he xpe i nc d i n z

k e .IA 5 ) Theme ia r c r r fr nc dhe o st, r aDe e r1 , 0 4
ne s I 0 .
k
dc l e o ds e ee e r be iy whe e c mbe 3 2 0
vii f t oseoa t ii i he rghtkne att Roa
st or he t rhrts n r i
e he
noke O rhopae c Cent rnot an 11t
di
e
ed

pound weghtl s contnue poppi and c c ng i he knee oc sona e y f i biiy
i os ,
i d
ng
at hi n z
, ca i l as atga lt ,
a ar omm e
nd ec
ndadon t ts fc i wih he e r ie a weghtl sr gl e .'
ha he fontnue t r xe cs nd i os e ' nt'
m

7 5 . un 3 2 4 Na yS Hm e , S FNP ca nos dMea ewih o st ,
7 ) Onl e , 00 , nc .
y M Nl g e lni t be iy
i
pr ded he wih i oz a i a
ovi
r t nf m ton boutwe g m ana m e t ate ptgr dua weghtl s
i ht
ge nt o tm
a l i os ,

a r c mme e asr curd weg l spr r m.IA 8 ) OnJ ne6 2 0 Br ntM.
nd e o nd d tu t e iht os og a ( 48 . u , 0 3, e
I
J ns n, . t c mme dweg tr d t a e c urg dhe t c nd e* t1 r
oh o M D. e o nde ih e uci nd n o a e r o o nu . he
on
1

rcntweg l so zopo nds I 78 )
e e ihtos f - u .RA 4 .
TheAL c nsd r d t si o ma on, i ig o st t beasve ei ime t
J o i e e hi nf r é fndn be iy o
e r mpnt n ,
r f r ncng M ea e' a t m pt t l ew eght and nodng he dal l ng a dvi we e
ee e i
lni s te s o os i ,
r iy i
vi c ées r

l t db he ob st. 1A 2 ) Thectdpa e oft eme c l e o dpr v d p sig
i e y r e iy (l 5 .
mi
ie g s h dia r c r o i e a sn
r f r nc t he obest r he t n e de e off i llm ia i .li iv. s e N o.
e e e es o r
iy at r ha vi nc
unctona i t tons tcc A % ,

51 CV0 0 , 1 W L 3 3 9 a * ( D. .a 3 , 01 )rl ta ofprvi nga y
:1 0 81 20 3
9 33 , t 2 W. VaJ n. 1 2 3 fnse d
o di n
e denceofaf
vi
uncéona lm ia pos d by obest t r or e de e c t by t
l i t éon e
iy, he éc d vi nc ied he

ma itaej g c nsssamos e l i l ofpa sn r fr nc st o st . .? . s
gst t ud e o it l t xcus y
ve
si g ee e e o be iy . .) The e
'
r f r nc do notsand i iolton,a a egene al r lct d i t m e c la s s m ent
e e e es
t
n s ai
nd r
r ly efe e n he dia s e s

ao wihamy id ofot rhe lh is s TheAT as e pl il no e s m eoft s
l ng t
ra
he at sue .
J lo x i t t d o
cy
he e
r fz n e i t eme ia r c d, uc a M ea esl - un weg l s ( 2 ) I s m ,
e ee c s n h dc l e or s h s lni' l po d iht os. RA 5 . n u

7

t AT r pe tdyc nsdee Mea i' o st a ise fc so he k e i ime i
he , e ae l o i r d ln es be iy nd t fe t n r n e mpar nt n
J

fslo ngtersd lun to l a ct. lni' o e to i o rue
alini h eiua f cina c paiy Mea es bjcin s verld.
I .
V

Meaz ne tobe t t t ema itaej d esc ncuso t a t e AT p o zy
lre x jcs o h gsrt u g ' o l i n h t h , ê pe l
i
J

e l tdh ra lyt mananasai wo kpos ea h rne dt tk bra s P1sOb.
vauae e bit o iti tt z mr nd e e o a e ek . . j,
i
c
'
ECF No 2 a 2 . lni agu st a t ATJdd no ma deald f to b . 2, t -3 Mea e z e h t he , i t ke ti , uncin- y
e

f to f i sa rq tdbyS R 9 -p, acov. vn, 8 F.d6 2 (t Ci. 01 )
uncin i ng s e uie
nd
S 68 M si Coli 7 0 3 3 4h r2 5,
a d Mo oev. vi 8 6F.d 1 6( t Ci. 01 ) Thec ur c nc swih t ma itae
n nr Col n, 2 3 7 4. r 2 6.
h
o t o ur t he gsr t
j g ,a ho d t a s tnéa e i e c s ppo t t AI ' de ii i t srgad.
ud e nd l s h t ubsa l v d n e u rs he ,s cson n hi e r
J
SS 96 8 a r se t RFC a s sme , nd t q ie t eAL t fd n yt e
X. - p dd e s s he
se s nt a e ur s h J o f e df h
i
i vi lsf éona lm ia
ndi dua' unc
l i t donsorz ti éonsa a s s hi orhe wor r lt a lte
esrc
nd s e s s
r
k- ea ed biiis

on af ncin- y f tonba i,n ldigt f nc nsgse eswh r i t
u to b -unci ss icu n he u do l t d le e e n he
i

r g léo jpS R 9 - p,1 9 WL 3 2 07 a * guy2 1 6 .Th AT i i tu td t
e u a ns. S 6 8 9 6
'
6 2 , t 1 l , 99 )3 e J s nsr ce o
i l a na r
ncude r advedic son a ct s ii m edia f ct and nonm edi le dence
s us i nd ie pecfc
cl a s
ca vi
s
uppor i hi concuson,dic st i l dua' a lt t pe f . s t ned wor a éviis
tng s
l i
s us he nci
vi ls biiy o r ot usni
m
k c te
i a orlna yw or s ti on ar gultand c i zng ba i ,des rbe t m a m um a ount
n n ci r
k e tng
e a
ontnli
ss
c i he xi
m
ofe ch wot r l t d a i t t i vi lca pe f m ,a e ai how a m at ra
a
k- e a e ctviy he ndi dua n r or nd xpl n
ny
e il
i
nconssenc e ora bi i i t e de ewe e c i r a r s ve I a *7;s e
it i s m gaées n he vi nc r onsde ed nd e ol d. d. t
e

as M o loe 8 F.d a 1 9(mph szn t ta AT ne d t p o i ea e pl i
lo rr , 26 3 t 8 e a iig ha n J e s o z v d n x i t
c
e p a do l igm e ia e de el t di t de ii t hi u t t fndng )
x lna n i n d c l vi nc i e n he cson o s li e i i s.
nk
s
ma

3Exa pl ofls e physc lfmc i i l a c mantsf biiy t perot c r qn physc lde a ofwo k a dviy,
m es it d
i a i tons nc ude bi ' f lt o f . e ti
a
m
i a m nds
r c t

sc a stig sa dn , lig lt g crpn , u hn , ll g o ohe ph scl n t n ( cu igma iua v o
u h s i n ,tn ig waln ,i i , ar'g p s ig pli , r t z yia Alci s i ldn np ld e r
t
r fn
ln
o n
po trl lc o s sc a rahn , a dig so pn o co c ig. .'2 C. R. 4 69 5 .
sua hn d n ,u h s ec ig h n l , to ig z ru bn ) . . 0 F. j 1 .4 $)
n
'
'
8

f r he ATJSfi et c u taf to b -unci n a lssd sno ne e s rl
fj
r
,' al o ond c uncin- y f to nay i oe t c s n i
ur
y
r s ti a om aécr a ' H um hresv.Col n,N o.3: - 188,2015N w9942619,a
e ul n ut
em nd.
:
i
vi
15 CVW
t

* ( D. . c 3 , 01 ) t o ta r c mme dain a o t d 20 6WL 35 0 6 ( D.
4 E. Va De . 1 2 5, e r nd e o n to d e , 1
6 8 E.
Va l n. , 1 ) l Ma co t c ur rjc e aT rs r er q tngrma whe t
. a 28 20 6 . n si , he o t ee td f e ul e uii e nd n he
pe
AT doe no pe f z a e pii f nci - -u éo a lss' fn l g t tTg e nd
J s t ro m n x lct u t by f nc n nay i, i c n ha fr ma
on
' i
fq
ma bea r pra e. . r a AT fi t a s s acama ' c p ct t pe f r t lv n
y pp o it . whe e n , al o se s li nt a a iy o ro m ee a t
J s
s
f éons des t c r di t ye denc i t r cor orwhe e ot ri de c e i t
unc
, pie onta c or vi
e n he e d,
r he na qua i s n he

AT ' a lssfu taeme nng u r ve ' 78 F.d a (iig Cihoc i Asnz, 29F.d
Js nay i r sr t a i f l e im ' 0 3 t ctn c k v. t e 7 3
:
1 2 1 7 (d Ci. 01 )9 i Nes v. r li, 71 - 5 3 20 7WL 78 9 8 a +
7 , 7 2 r 2 3). lon Be nl No. :5 CV- 7 , 1
q
l
2 3 ,t 1

( D. . b. 8 2 7 (eomme ngrma wheefheAT ' o tin ( f)t c t
W. Va Fe 2 , 01 ) rc
ndi e nd r f
t
J
,S pi o l t he ou t
l e
t g e sa ho her a he l sc ncuso rg r i Nes sR-C'
o u s t w e c d l o l i ns e a dng lon' F I.
i
l apr vousc s be o et sc utwheet epli ifagt d t ta <AT i
n e i a e f r hi ot , r h antf r z ha n K J s
e
r i e t m a s i fndi a
equ r d o ke pechc i ngs boutwhe he hi lm ia i woul ca ehi t le down
t r s i t tons
d us m o i

durng t da t feque l change postonst t poi he c nnotm ant i wor ac t ,
i he y, o r nty
ii
o he nt a
i an
k éviy
a t ha difc t conc r
nd o ve fi uly
entaéng a f usng due t pan,'t c ztuphe d t de ii
nd oc i
o i ' he olr
l he c son

whe et AT s fce l e pli dwh t pli ifstsi ywa ds r d tda d
r he J ufiint x ane y he antf' e t
y
mon s ic e ie n
c aned s c f a l i t tal
onti
pe ik nayss ha lowed f m e ni ulr viw.Se G odf e v.Be hil N o.
or a ngf e e
e
r
r l,

71
:6CV5 0 2 8W L 1 7 08 ,a * ( D. . r 26 2 8. he c tsi t Fo r.
8 , 01
4 4 7 t 4 W. Va Ma . , 01 ) Ot r ou t n he u t
h
Cic th veu l de ii whe eT heAT ' n ra eper isme r n f l e iw be a s
r ui a phed csons r f
t
, S ar dv rnt al g u r v e c u e
J
i
ghem a ea i ii fndigofPli ifsc pa iyt sa a waka e pli d h w
q
d n mpl t i n
c
antf a ct o tnd nd l nd x ane o
gher a he t a c l i 'Tut rv. r li, 11 CV1 0 2 1 R 1 11 3 , t
j e c d h t oncuson. ne Be nl No. :6 2 2, 0 8
'
l
3 59a

* -8( D. C. r 1 , 01 ) s eas Ar ton v. li , .11
6 M. N. Ma . 3 2 8 ; e lo msr
Cov n No :4CV3 , 01 W L
46 2 5

9

6 38 2 , t* -6( . N. No 4, 01 )(i i s tnda e i nc s po td ATJS
7 7 3 a 3 M D. C. v. 2 5 fndng ubsa l vde e up re ,'
deii rg r ngk ei ime ' efc o wo kpef ma ewheepli ifo jce
cson e adi ne mpnt nt fe t n r ror nc
s
r ant be td
f
t lc off nci n- y f c n a lssbutAT pr vi d d tie na r t ofme ia
o a k u to b -un éo nay i
J o de eald r ai
ve
dc l
e de ea d e pli e r aoni f rc e iii d tr nn t l Ha rs v. l n,
vi nc n x an d e s ng o r db ly ee ni ai ; rion Covi No.
t
on

11 -CV-1 , 01 W L 1 61 6 a * ( . N. Apz 1 , 0 3 (f yfnl g. tMs
:0
82 3
6 09 , t 2 M D. C. . 7 2 1 ) <Bl ici t
g
n ha .
Ha rs wa c pa eo pe f l ngE two k t eAL i l iy f un t ts ewa
rion s a bl f rorni gh r h J mp i t o d ha h s
cl
c pa l ofsa i o wak n f a pr i t l sxho si a eg - urwo kda .)
a b e tndng r li g or p oxmaey i ur n n ihtho
r y' .
'

Hee t ma itaej g ct dt r q ie nt o S R 9 - 1, nd d srbe ho
r ,he gsr t ud e ie he e u rme s f S 6 83 a e ci d w

t AT stsidt er ql e nt wh na ay igMea i'ph ia l tdons
he , aife hos e lrme s e n lzn lnes ysc li a :
J
i
mi
I hi o i i t AT r c nz d M ea ilst si y a t
n s p non, he , e og ie
J
ln e' e tmon t he
hea i r ga di he c i
rng e r ng r ontnued pan f l ng he knee s ge y
i olowi
r
ur r

a d h rl td a iiyt sa R. 4. we r t AT n e
n e i e b l o tnd. 2 Ho ve , he , otd
mi
t
J
t m e c l e de e s
he
dia vi nc howi t t s ha a not a gat
ng ha he d
m l i,
wihout t us of a a ss i de ce f l ng he knee
t
he e
n s itve vi , olowi
r
t plce ent s ge y, and r por e f te t no pan i he
e a m
ur r
e t d ttl o
i n r

k t' R.25 .A r c d fo M ea e' otho ds no e
ne .
'
-26 e or r m
lniqs - pe it t s
f
t t sx w e ks f l ng he kne s ger s i w aki wih
ha , i
e olowi
r e ut y, he s l ng t
no as idve de c a com pli ng of fnnni a pqn' e ept
ss
vie nd
ani
f i m l i ' xc

atr t e a y.R.76 At M eal ls f lo u a i m e s
fe h r p
3.
lre' o lw p ppont nt
i
one yea a t ee ye r pos s ge y,s r pored ltl or no
r nd hr
a s t ur r he e t ite

pan a d ha no ma g i. R. 7 8 7 6 Li e s , t e AT
i n d r l at
5 , 4 . k wie l
a J
e phasze t t fno t e dng or e nlri s uce s
m
i d ha f r a
xa itng ot
uggesed
t
dia lt dtrng t r lva pe i ' J . Th AT wr e
s biiy li
he e e nt rod.' .
d e J ot,
.

TM ea i' g ne al n ma gata o he wienomnl sc l
f lnes e r l or l i nd t r s
r
j
y
a phy ia
e r na
xa ni éons i cae t t s was c pa e of t sa ng,
ndi t ha he
a bl
he t ndi

wakn ,a ltn rq zdfrl hte ed j . .=l s
lig nd i ig e uie o i x r on obs'1 n um,
f
g
'.
d
t e AT ' d cson i l e t nar t dic son r q ie b
h ,S e ii ncud s he rai s usi e u r d y
J
ve
SSR 96 8 a
- p, nd c ans s fcent i o= ai t .al
ont i
ufi i
nf
ton o low

m e nigf rv e Un ie t AI i M a co,t e AT i t i
a n ul e iw. lk he J n s i h , n hs
J
c s di not f i t c i z confi
ae d
al o onsde
lcdng m e c l e dence.
dia vi

Futh z t c ur i T t lf t g s a ut ho t AT
t e , he o t s f e t o ue s bo
no
w he J
arve a l sc ncusons'be a et ATJsfndng i l e a
ri d t l o l i ' c us he ,' i i s ncud
i
d t i d s rt r of M ea e' me ia r c r , M ea iqs
eal u r y
e
ma
lniqs dc l e o ds
lne'
h ai tsi o y a t AI ' c l i .
e rng e t n nd he ,s oncusons
m
J

10

Re & Re omm.ECF No. , t8 . AT ' de iin isl a notonyt ema it e
p. c
,
21 a -9 The .s cso ter nd
J
l h gsz
ut
j g ' de ii ,ncude t enaz t ds usi r q r dbyS R 9 - p, nd c nti
ud es cson i l s h rai ic son e uie
ve
S 6 8 a o ans
s fce ti o mai t alw me nig u r v e oft RFC.( A 2 -2 )
ufiin nf z ton o l
o
a n f l e iw he
1 3 6.
l
TheAT dd no fit c sde c nfc i me ia e i e e l ei M a co, ndci
J
, i t al o on i r o l t
i ng dc l v d nc ,i n s i a l
k
d
notpos hy hetc lquesi t t voc i le r t te l d s e ofM ea es
e pot i a
tons o he atona xpe t ha xcude om
li '

fz to l i iai ns l ei M on oe TheAT no e M ea i' sae nt a uthe ne d
t ina l tto ,i n
nc
m
k
r .
J t d lnes tt me s bo r e
t wak orledown afersti a hezwoz sa i butuli a ey f
o l
i
t itng t
k t ton,
tm t l ound t y lcke
he a d

c edi lt i pa tbec us no te i physc a ore m i ng s ces
r biiy n r
a e
r atng
ii n
xa ni our uggesed dia lt
t
s biiy

dzigt rlva peid.RA 2 - , -5 )TheAL as ak dt vocdo le pet
trn he ee nt zo ( 4 26 48 0.
J lo se he a na x r
a
boutslfi be wee st a sa lng;a t
litng t n idng nd tnci lhough M ea econt ndst tt hy hedca
lni
e
ha he pot
l
wasf ed on t pr r s 't s c d r m an i plcer t t n l ve herwor sa i
f
bas
he e nie' hat he oul e i n a a her ha ea
k t ton

t wak a r s, h AT di not c e h rt si ya f l c e i ea t r f r dd no
o l nd e t t e , d a c pt e e tmon s ul r dbl nd hee o e i t
J
y
4

n e t a r s h rc ntn d p e e c a t wo k sai I 48 0 5 ) .f Coo v.
e d o dd e s e o iue r s n e t he r tton.RA -5 , 6 9 -. k
g

Coli No. 1 -c -3 5 , 01 K 4 08 0 a * 7( D. . .a 30 2 5 rrl AT
vn, 2:3 v 01 5 2 5
3 8 , t 1 S. W VaJ n. , 01 ) Tlhe J
ne d not o me o e r pic ofe d nc i t tc r .
e
c m nt n ve y e e vie e n he e o d'
).

Thec ut dia r e ,he e o e wihMea i' ag me tt tt A1 f i d t b l a
o t sg e s t t f r , t lnes z u n ha he , al o ui
J e
d
l ca brdgebet n t e de e a hi concuson t tM ea esphysc llm iaéons
ogi l i
wee he vi nc nd s
l i ha
lni'
ia i t

l the t sa i / l n a t6hot sa d st nga t6ho si a 8 ho wo kd y
i
mi r o tndng wakig bou
l n id bou
r
ur n n - ut r a .

( A 2 ) To t e tntt A1Jc n befut df rn e a i gi t d ti d, t ton by
1 3 . he x e he , a
l
a le o ot ng gn n he eal fmci - e
f i a l i M elni desr s t c tdoe nothnd r m a nec s r .Ast Fot h
uncton nayss a e ie , he our
s
e nd es a y
he ut
Cicztm a c e ri M a co a M onr ,t f iur t c
r ti de l a n s i nd
oe he al e o onducta f ton- f ton
unc i by-unc i

a l i doe notr quier a i e r ca e.I t ad,r m a i t a opra er m e
nayss s
e t em nd n ve y s nse
e nd s he ppr i t e dy

wheet AT fi dt ass tlva fnci orwheef h ri de uais'nt
r he - al o se s ee nt u tons
J e
r f e na q ce'i he
ot
opni Trztaeme n n f lrv e ' si ,7 0F.da 6 6 (iig Cihoc i7 F.d.t
i on K t r t a i g u e im'Ma co 8 3 t 3 ctn c k, 29 3 a
fs
1 ) s eas Mon oe 8 6F.d a 1 8.Net e oft s stzto i p e e he e TheAI
77 ; e lo
r ,2 3 t 8
ih r he e it ins s r snt r .
a
J
,
dic s d, n det i,M eani sr lva physca f dons s m a i d t pe éne m edi l
s us e i
al l e' ee nt
i l unc
, um rze he r nt
ca

z cor ,a pr de at oug e a éon f how hew eghe t m e c lopi ons
e ds nd ovi d hor h xpl na
or
i d he dia ni .

Ass c ,hemaitaej g wa c rc t fndt tt AT pr rya lz d
uht
gsrt ud e s ore t o i ha he , opel nay e
J
Mea i' p sc li ttonsa t a s tnta e i e c s ppo td t ATJSc ncusons
ln es hy ia l ai nd h t ubsa il v d n e u re he ,' o l i .
mi
Hil n-o sv. li , 3:4 CV- 8 , 01 W L 8 5 4 ,a * ( D. C. c 1 ,
cdi l ne Cov n No. 1 - 5 4 2 5
9 85 2 t 6 W. N. De . 5
2 5 (i digr ma un c s aywhe et AIJsnar t pr vde V mpl i i h i o
01 ) fn n e nd ne e s r z he ,' rai o i d f e nsg t nt
ve
a
hi d cson l r e s); ua hre v. vi No. :5 CV- 8 , 1 R 9 4 61 , t*
s e ii a p oc s' Hta is Col n, 31 - 1 8 20 5
92 9a 4
( D. . c 3 , 01 ) r o ta z c mme a la o td 20 6WL 3 6 8 ( D. .
E. Va Dè . 1 2 5, e r nd e o nd doi d e , 1
5 0 6 E. Va
J n. 8 2 6 (i n r ma d u c sa ywhe et AT a r s e f ee ntwo k rltd
a 2 , 01 ) f g e n nne e sr
ndi
r he J dd e s d f lva
r
r -eae
f ncins' ndpr v d daf ufiint sst rv e l sc cu i s'n t eRFC a lss.
u to 'a
o i e f fce ba i o e iw n on lson 'i h
s
i
nay i)

Ac o dn l, lni' obetonst teAI ' fz do b -un éo a lssaeo rue .
c r igy Mea es jci o h Js t n-y f c n nayi r ver ld
nc
V.

Fial, lr eob e t g ne al t t ma ita ejdg ' dee mia n t a t
n l Meaz jcs ç r l o he g s/ t u es t r n éo h t he
y
i
y
AI ' c e i it fndngi s ppo t db s bsa il v d nc . llepont t c ran
J
,s r d bl y i i s u re y u tnta e i e e Mea
i
i s o e ti
m e c le de e t s a gue dem ons t t he i biiy t pe f m t w or lve s a e
dia vi nc hat he r s
ta es r na lt o roz he
k e l ttd

i t eAT ' de ii S notst a t AT a d t ma itaejdg 'g r d t ee i nc
n l ,s cson. he e h t he J n he gsrt u e f no e h vde e
a J
i
a t rpli ifskneer plce e s ge y t ough t da el s i ur doclm e
fe antf'
e a m nt ur r ht
he t a t ns ed
x néng

p an fsc ntn d c mpli so p i i he k e a d lwe lg a t o e d
liéf' o iue o ant f an n t ne s n o r e s nd he bjc ve

m e ca e denceofr cor doc entng oseoa t i i bot kne a l rlgsa
di l vi
e d um i
t r hrés n h es nd owe e nd

c ntn d t ht s a o d t epael. P1' Ob.ECF No 2 a 4
o iue i ne s r un h tl ' . j
g
a' s ,
. 2, t .
I rv e n Mea escnm zg r n t AL ' c e i l yd t r na , hec ur
n e iwi g lni' li e a dig he JS r dbit ee mi don t o t
i
n e a t o te t tbe a et e AI f dt op mnt t obsr et ede a ra d
ots t he u s t ha c us h J f he por i o e v h me no n
ha
y

t deen etece blyoftecnma ,heAT ' o ev do c nc r n t s
o trùn h rdiii h li ntt ,s bsr a ns o enig hee
t
J
q e tonsaet begve g e t ih . Slv l v. c lt 7 F.d 9 7 98 (t Ci.1 $.
u si r o i n r a weg t' l e He ke , 39 2 8 , 9 4 h r 98
' i
Crdiii deemi t aee
e blt tr nai r mphaial t epr v n eo t AT , t ec r, nd
y
ons
tc l h o i c f he J not h ou t a
y
c t nor al s d noti e f r wih t s de e nlna i .See e.. Chafn v.Shaaa,
ours m ly houl
nt r e e t he e t r i tons
,
i
ll

No 9 -1 4 ,1 9 WL 3 9 8 , t* (t Ci. g. 1 1 9 )@e cuim)(i ngHa sv.
.2 87 93
2 9 0 a 2 4 h r Au 3 , 9 3 r t a cd
S lva ,9 7F.d 1 3 1 5 (t Ci.1 9 )a Tho a v. lb e z , 1F. 5 ,5
ul n 0 2 45 , 4 6 4 h r 9 0 nd m s Cee r z e 33 2d 41 43
i

(t Ci. 9 4)M evnv. tu , :6CV 0 0 2 20 7WL 1 6 0 , t* ( . VaJ l 5
4h r 1 6 ); li Aste 60
03, 0
9 06 0 a 1 W D. .uy ,
20 7 (ii Hac rv. c ofHe 1h & Hu n Se v .8 F.d 2 , 3 (t Ci. 9 9)
0 ) ctng the Se '
at
ma r s, 98 2 1 2 4 h r 1 8 ).
He e t e AI e ha t l c nsd r dt me ia e i e c i hi d cson a wela
r , h , x usi y o i e e he dc l v d n e n s e ii , s l s
J
ve
M ea esalg éonsa t he f nci l a a ip TheALJr ve dM ea este % e
lni' le a
s o r u t c p ct
ona
e iwe lni' r a nt
r c r ,ncudngt s f lo n he l e2 05k er plc me , nd f undt tt e ewa
e o ds i l i ho e ol wi g r un 0 ne e a e nt a o
ha h r s
lm ie e de e prort M e ate' da e ls i ut d r ga ci f dona lm ia
i t d vi nc i o l ri s t a t ns e e rlng unc
l i t éonsc us d
a e

b he k e i ime a ob st It 24- )TheAT a drse ho M ea erpo td
y r n e mpar nt nd eip IA 25.
J
, d e sd w lni e re
nnni a pan a nea l a f lt ngeofm oton a f w we ksa t rt s ge y; e t no
i m l i nd ry ul a
i
e
e fe he ur r r pored

panwih a ldo a d ha f le tnson u n e a nain i une2 6 a cnme
i t mbu a n n d ul x e i po x mi to nl
00 9 nd li d
oc sona tght sa ound he pa el durng a no= a physc le nana b n i Se em be
ca i l i nes t
t t la i
l
i a xa i t n pt
t

2 8 a r xmaey sve mon hspro t h rdaels i t d.RA 2 ) Th AT
00 , pp o i tl e n
t i r o e t a tnsue ( 5 . e ,
J
uli at y concude t tM elni ' algatonswe e notf l c e bl ba ed on he l k of
tm el
l d hâ
a es le i
r
uly r di e s
z ac

nee f an a ss de c f a bul i t t ofltl t no pan i he knee he
d oz s idve vie ot m aton, epozs ite o
i n r
, t

n ma g i, ndhe c rngf he g a o p irt he daels i u e .I 2 )TheAT
or l at a r ai or r rnds n ro o r t a t ns r d RA 6 .
J
as f
lo ound pe s sve t tno tea i ore mi ng s z c s
r ua i ha
r tng
xa ni olr e ugges e dia lt durng t
t d s biiy i he

r lva pei d.RA 2 )
ee nt ro ( 6 .

Th ALJc nd tdapr pe ce i lya ayi i t sc s. tst ATJsr l t
e
o uce
o r rdbit n lss n hi a e I i he ,' oe o
i
r ol i
es ve nconssencisbe we acli a ' al ge i pai
it e t en l m nts le d m t
vnent a hi a lt t wor The
s nd s biiy o
k.
c tsr ei t det rni whe he t r i s t néa e de e t s
our' ol s o e r ne
t r he e s ubs a l vi nc o uppor t f caa
t he a tzl

fndn soft AT a whehe t yweerahe t o ht c rc lg lsa ad.-i ig he , nd t r he r e c d hr ug he oret e a tnd r .Z
J
CQ
v. tr 7 F.d5 5 5 9(t Ci. 9 6. r,heAT ddno ric aa trz t
Chae, 6 3 8 , 8 4. r 1 9 )Hee t
h
J i t nsh rceie he
e de or f lt buid al c lbrdgebet en t e de e a li concusonsr ga di
vi nce ai o l ogi a i
we he vi nc nd zs
l i
e r ng

M ea esc e bl y Thec ur fnd no ez ri t ema itaej dg ' c l i t tt
lni' r diii .
t
o t i s ro n h gsrt u es oncuson ha he
ATJSc e iii a s sme wa p o ra s pore b s bsa il v d n e
,' r dbl y se s nt s r pe nd up t d y u tnt e i e c .
t
a
W .

Thec ur ha r ve d t ma itaej g ' r po t t objc onst t r po t
o t s e iwe he g sr t ud es e r, he e d o he e r,
a t a ni sr
nd he dr nitaéver cor a i s doi ma a2:novo dee nnna oft e
e d nd,n o ng, de
tr i éon hos

po t oft er p tt whih Mea epr pe l ob e t d Thec r fn t tt
ri
ons h e or o c lni o ry jce .
ou t i ds ha he

ma itaej g wa c re ti c ldigt tt r i s tnta e de ei terc r t
gstt ud e s o rc n oncu n ha hee s ubsa il vi nc n h e o d o
s ppo tt e AI ' d cso Ass h, h ma itaej g ' r po ta r c
u r h , s e ii n. uc t e g stt ud es e r nd e omme ai wi
J
nd t
on l
l
be a
dopt d i ise ie p
e n t ntr t

An appr i t O r rwilbe e e ed t t tefe .
opra e de l
nt r o ha f ct

E te: a # oa ao/
ne d
r
Y
*

:.
*

M iha lF.Ur s
c e
b ki

... -

ClifUnie Sa e Ditit u ge
ze ' t d tts src l d

. . . . -- .
. - .