Woolwine v. New River Valley Regional Jail

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/11/2017. (tvt)

O - S OFFI U.S. SX COUr
FRK'
CE
DI
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI ED
i
.

MA 12 2 1
t
07

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O

MI
CHAEL LANDON W OOLW I
NE,
Peii n r
tto e ,

NEW RI
VER VALLEY
REGI
ONAL JAI
L,
Res
ponde .
nt

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

JULI G. U

BK

- ,

L

C i lA c i N o.7: - vvi ton
17 c 00137
M E M O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

By:

H on.M ihae F.Ur
c l
bans
ki
U nie St e Di t i Judge
t d at s s r d

M i ha lLa n W ool ne,aVigi ai t pm c e ngpr K ,fl d ape ii f wrt
c e ndo
wi
r ni nma e
e di
o
ie
tton or i

o ha e sc r u p ru n t 28U. C. 2 4.Pei o rc alng st ev ldt o hi
f b a op s us a to
S. j 25
tt ne h le e h aiiy f s
i

c nfn me t u s a t ot De e e 1 , 01 ,ud me t ft Cic tCo r o F o dCo ny
o e n p ru n t he c mb r 3 2 6 j g n o he rui u t f l y u t .
Afe r viwi t pe ii t c t i t ti s d bedim is d s ma iy pur ua t
tr e e ng he tton,he our fnds ha t houl
s s e um rl
s nt o

Ru1 4oft Rul Goveni j2254Ca e .
e
he es
r ng
s sl

A f d rlc u t yn t rn aj2 5 h be sp tto t e st ep tto e e ha se t
e ea o r ma o g a t 2 4 a a ei n mls h eiin r x u td he
i
r m e esa l ei t c t oft saei whi h pe iine wa c ded.28U . C.
e di vaiabl n he ours he tt n
c tto r s onvi
S.

j2 5 ()P esrv. rc e , 1U. 4 5(9 3; a o v. mi 4ù U. 5 (9 )
2 4b; rie Rodiu z 41 S. 7 1 7 )Slytn S t 4 S. 3 1 71.
h,
Thee usi n r quie e i s ts i by s ki r vi w oft cai i t hi s sa ec t
xha to e r m nt s a ifed
ee ng e e
he l m n he ghe t t t our

wihj rs ito t c nsd rtecam .O'ulva v Bo rk l5 6U. 8 8( 9 9 .I
t u id ci n o o i e h li
S l n . ec e, 2 S. 3 1 9 ) n
i
Vig ni anon- a h r c c ca e us sa er m e e i oneoft e wa ,de ndi on
r i a,
de t ow onvi t n xha t tt e di s n
hr e ys pe ng
t na lr oft c am sr ie Fis,t c c c n fl adiec a a t t Vig ni Cotr of
he tze he l i as d. rt he onvit a ie r t ppe l o he r i a lt
Appeaswih a s e
l t ubs quenta a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi ai t Cot 'ofAppe snles
ppe l o he
e
t
r ni f he ut
al l

a i tt c c.VA.
gans he onvit
CODE j1 1- 1.Se nd,heco c c na t kt c ci
7. 41
co t nvit a tac he onviton
c l t r ly by flng a s a e ha a pe ii n wih t cic tc twher t c
ola e a l
i
t t be s tto t he r ui our
e he onvi tw a
c s

c ce a t na alnga a rede sont t SuprmeCour ofVigi a I j8. onvitd nd he ppe i n dves cii o he e
t r ni. d. 01
.

jA pettonm aybedim is ptrua t Rul 4 i i i cl r9om t peii t tapettone i not
ii
s sed ts nt o e f t s ea
he tton ha
ii r s

e il t r lel
ntted o elt

C

6 4 A)1 ; . u Ct R. 9a .Fial t ec n c c ne ha s rme isb fl gasae
5 ( ( ) Va S p. . 5:() n l h o vit a x u t e de y i tt
y,
n
h b a p tto dr cl wi t Su rmeCo r o Vign a VA. DE j80 - 5 A)1.
a e s eiin ie ty t he p e
h
u t f r ii. CO
.1 6 4( ()
W hihe rr ei tke t c c uli t l m us pr s ntt cli st t Supr p eCour of
c ve out s a n, he onvit tma ey
t e e he am o he
e
t

Vigi a a r eveanli fom t tco tbe or af de a dititc tca c i rt
r ni nd ec i
lng r ha ur f e e r l src our n onsde he
cai s A ha aspeii rha no e use sa er medi i t pe ii rhast rghtl d
lm .
be
ttone s t xha t d t t e
es f he ttone
he i m er
sa e1w t r iet que ton pr s nt by a a lbl pr dtr a f ist do s 28U . C.
t t a o as he si
e e ed
ny vaia e oce le nd al o
o.
S.

j2254()
c.
Thepeii cla l s w st tPeii ne ha no pr s nt d c am st t Supr m eCour
tton e ry ho ha tto r s t e e e l i o he
e
t
ofVigi a.2 Petto rsf iur t e us saer medisma t sl a y dimi s loft
r ni
ii ne ' al e o xha t t t e
e ndaes lmm r s s a
he
pe ii n.3 Based upon t indi t tPe ii rhasnotm a t r quiie s t tals wi
tto
he
ng ha ttone
de he e st ubsan i ho ng

O d n a o ac n tt to a rg ta rq ie b 2 U. C. 2 3 a dSlc v Mc ne, 2
f e il f o siui n l ih s e ur d y 8 S. j 25 /) n a k . Da il 5 9
U. 4 , 4 ( 0 ) ac rii eo a
S. 73 48 20 0 , e t
f
f
Ex'x R :Thi
l
s

lb l yi d ne .
a ii s e id
t

l)I dyoMa 2017.
ar y
,

/
J

-imu g
'
r

Gv#'

Unie Stt sDititJ W
t d a e src udge

2 Peii ralege i t peii t tcoms di notpurueadie ta alandhehasnotyetpr e e
r c ppe ,
ttone l s n he tton ha t el d
s
es ntd
t t tcl m t t Supr meCo tofVigi a.
he ha ai o he
e
ur
r ni
3Peii rma r iehi f r lha aspeii i heuns es f l p es st cai t t Supr
ttone y efl s ede a be tton f
ucc suly r ent he l ms o he
eme
Cour ofVigi at o oneoft t r r ut sdes i Peii i a s d,howeve ,t hi tmet fl sae
t
r ni hr ugh
he h ee o e crbed. ttoner s dvie
r hat s i o ie tt

a dfd rl a e speio si l td S e28U. C. 2 4 ( VA. E j80 - 5 ( ()Va Su CtR.
n e ea h b a tin s i e . e
t
mi
S. j 2 4 *; COD .16 4A)2 , . p. .
'
59a.
:()