Gorbey v. Kiser et al
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/14/2017. (tvt)
/
cœ e s OFFIE U. DI GG W
C S. SX
ATRO,NOKS,
A
VA
SI
LED
APR 1i 2 1
2?
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
MI
CHAEL S.OW LFEATHERGORBEY, )
)
Pl ntf,
ai if
)
v.
)
)
JUDGE J
ACKSON L. SER, AL.
KI
c
, )
)
De e da .
f n nt
)
J A C aDk c ,
ULI
' .
BY;
D
E
CA SE N O .7: 7C V0015
1
2
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
By: Gln E.Conrad
e
Chi f Unied St e Di t i tJudge
e
t
at s s r c
M ihae S.OwleaherGor
c l
f t - bey,a f r i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld t s cvi rght
ede al nma e oc di
o
ie hi i l i s
a to t e Bie v.Sx Un no F d Nac tc Ag n s 4 3U. 3 8 (9 ) Go b y s s
cin md r v ns i k wn e . r ois e t, 0 S. 8 1 71 . r e ue
tr ef d r l u g s ap o e uo , n n me o fd r lp io o scas algngta t e h ve
h e e ea j d e , r s c tr a d u rus e e a rs n f il, le i h t h y a
co pie t pl e a ke p li i s r t housng a t Unied St t Pe tnta y i Lee
ns r d o ac nd e lm n eg egaed
i t he t
aes nie ir n
Co ny (US Le ' a t h v hi patcvi a to sd s se ,n ng oh rt n s Gob y
u t G P e' nd o a e s s i l ci n ilis d mo t e hig . r e
C
)
ha a i t pr ee L fr pa rs
s ppled o oc d q o ma upei.Uponrviw oft rco d,hec tfndst tGobe
e e
he e r t our i ha r y
d e no q aiyt pr c e j f r n u rsu e 28U. C. 1 5 g a ta t i c s mu t
o s t u l o o e d . o ma a pei nd r
f
q
S. j 91 () nd h t h s a e s
be sl a iy dimis d ac or ngl
lmm rl s s e c di y.
ThePrs Lii ton Reor Ac of1 s tntaly n ndedt L f mapa rs
ion tgai
f m t 995 ubsa i l me
he q or
upei
saue 28 U. C.j1 1 . Th p r s o t Ac wa t r q r a1p io e ltg n ss n
tt t,
S.
9 5 e u po e f he t s o e uie 1 rs n r i a t uig
i
gove n e e ii or ofk il t pa c tflng f es i 1 1,e t r t o
r m nt nttes
t a s o y our ii e n 1 ihe hr ugh pr pa e or
e ym nt
tr u h i tlme t wi hed fo t l ia ts i t t s a c u t j1 5 b . Se to
l o g nsal n s t l r m he i g n ' nmae nzt c o n . 91 ( ) cin
l
h
t
1 5g d nist i tl n pa me tmeh d t p io e swh h v Gh e srk s' t o e
91 ( ) e e he nsal t y n to o rs n r o a e l r e tie '- h s
me
t
prs r who ha ha t eepr vi c s sora
ione s
ve d hr
e ous a e
ppeasdim is d a fi ous malci ,orf
l s s e s rvol , i ous
or
f iur t sae a cam , unl s t t ee srke i a e s w s çm mi nt da r of s rous
al e o tt
li
e s he hr -ti r nm t ho G
i ne
nge
ei
p y ia ij r . j1 5 g .
h sc lnu y' 91 ( )
'
Go be ha br
r y s ought s h a tons or a al on t e or mor pror occ sons Se
uc c i
ppe s
hr e
e i
ai . e
Owle te - r e v.J c o No 2:6 c 0 5 ,si o a 4 ( D.Va S p .2 20 6
f ah rGo b y a ks n, . 1 -v- 0 51 lp p. t E.
. e t 2, 1 )
( s se frf lng t saeacaml Gor vv.TheStt ofVicni No.2: 1c 001 si
dimisd o aii o tt li ; be
ae
r i a,
1 -v- 64, lp
o a 4 ( D.Va M a .1 ,2 1 (imis d f rfiig t sae a cam) Gobe v Uni d
p. t E.
. r 7 01 ) d s s e o aln o tt li ; r y . t
e
S ae , 2:8 c - 01 ,si o a 3 4 ( D.W . .J y 7 2 0 .se eg,Go b y v. d.
tts No. 0 -v 0 21 l p. t - N.
p
Va ul , 01 ) e , .. r e Fe
,
Bur a ofAlohol To co.Fiea & Expl i s No.5: -v- 26,si op.a 5 0( D.
eu
c . bac
r nns
osve ,
11c 001 lp
t -1 N.
W . . a .1 2 2 ( .. S i e t (itn 2 c s st a q aiy a srke u d rj1 5g )
Va M r 4, 01 ) M J, eb r) l i g 5 a e h t u lf s ti s n e 91 ().
s
Ac o dn l Go b yma p o e dj f r pa p rs( to t e a me to t fl fe o l
c r igy, r e y r c e . o ma u ei wih u prp y n f he ii e ) ny
q
ng
i h c ns w t t efc si n n d n e o s ro p ysc ln u y j1 5 g .
f e a ho ha h a e mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r . 91 ( )
l hi c
n s ompl i ,Gor y r pe t dl a l s wiho sa i a f c s daes orde aisi
ant
be e a e y lege , t ut ttng ny a t, t ,
t l n
s
uppor,t tt de e nt ha c pied t pl c i hi Gi i nt d
t ha he f nda s ve ons r o a e n m ûmm ne ange e r me prs
r xte
ion
c n iin a o sg iia th r s is' ( mpl 1 ECF No.1) He c mp anst a v ro s
o dto s nd r i nfc n ad hp . Co . ,
'
.
o li h t a iu
de e nt ha , i t pa t G a pult d' or wr ul dim is hi pro c vi aci ns
f nda s ve n he s : t ni a e '
m
ongf ly s s ed s i r i l to '
,
f brca e dicplna y c r agans hi t tha de a d ori de hi ta f r hed hi i
a i t d s i i r ha ges i t m ha ve l ye
mpe d s r nse ; l m n
G trtooded c ls' t l rl ng t ie s' c
û e l
wa
e l'wih i fowi o lt i' omm itd orf l t pr ve uns ii d saf
ove
te
aied o e nt pecfe t f
G s o d c'o G eaito 'a an thm;Srid t a ljng a sut o d ah f rGo be b
t c n u t r ç tl ins' g is i t le ) o rra e sa ls r e t o r y y
mi
' r a
t
tyi t pl c hi i c ls wih i t s of dif r nt housng saus' i
r ng o a e m n e l t nma e
fe e
i tt i' mpos d ç
e i s of
hour
u iia (ijr srit h ri h swrssa d a k ls' d nid hm t r p rtmey me ia
mb l l sc etan s u t i it n ngqe i e e i f o e -i l d c l
c
ng
'
p
te t nsa o me iai n i a d ma eh m ç lmb t tp bmk ir s e tv o h l)lwe
r ame t nd r dc to s' n d i s i o o t s re p cie f is o r
'
c
b nkme ia sa rp ae l c u igpan a d ij re . (d a 2 5) Go b y sae ta tus
u
dc l tms e e td y a sn i n n u is' 1 . t - . r e tts h t j t
'
ben a US Le i a i n n d n e .1 (d 6)
ig t P e s n mmi e t a g r, 1 . .
,
Go b y' ls o p s,md tde ns wi n s e i ai no ij re s frdo lk l t
r e s it f a tt ae ve t, t o p cfc to f nu is ufee r iey o
h
oc ur i sm pl i ufk i ntt s
c , s i y ns t e o how t t a t tm e Gor y sld hi c pl nt he wa i
ha t he i
be e s om ai ,
s n
i n n d ng r o a y s ro p y ia ij r rlt d t t na d d fn a t wi i te
mmie t a e f n eius h sc l nu y eae o he me e e d n s t n h
h
me n n o j 1 5 g . S eCh s v.O' aly 4 6 F. p' 1 5 1 6 (t Ci. 01 )( oi
a i g f 91 ( ) e a e
M le , 6 Ap x 8 , 8 4h r 2 2 n tng
t tprs rmus be s ki r iffom a demonsr t a da
ha ione
t ee ng ele r
nd
ta e
ngert ti i mi
ha s m nenta t tm e
t he i
o sln t ec mplit; tu v. o g nh u,5 4 F.d 2 3 29 ( d Ci. 0 9 ( oig ta t
f ig h o an) Pets M r e ta 5 3 9 , 6 2 r 2 0 ) n tn h t o
q aiy f r i n n d n e e e to t e j1 5 g ,t e c mp an mu tr v a a n x s
u l o mmie t a g r xc pi n md r 91 () h o lit s e e l e u
f
bewe n t ei ne td ng ri alg sa t ecamsi a srs. Gob y h sn talg d n r
t e h mmi n a e t le e nd h li t se t) r e a o le e , o
c n t co tfnd,a r pec i whi h havi hi pa tci la tonsdimis d plce hi i a
a he ur i ny es t n
c
ng s s vi c i
s s e a d m n ny
da r of physca ha m . Fi ly,hi r pea e r la e on t phr e lm mi nt da r'i
nge
i l r
nal s e t d e inc
he as ç
i ne
nge ' s
no hi mor t n a lbelo co l i t tt co tne d nota e asf m als
t ng
e ha a
r ncuson ha he ur e
cc pt ac
uppor f hi
t or s
cams S e BelAt.Co .v Two l,5 0 U. 5 4 5 5 ( 0 7 (i i t panifs
li . e l l p . mbv 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 ) fndng 1 litf
a
o iain t p o i et e tr u s o hi tnill n lt rle rq ie mo et n lbesa d
bl to o r v d h go nd ' f s e t e me t o eif e u rs r ha a l n
g
t
c l ins a af muli r iain o t ee nt o ac us ofa tonwilnotdo' (iato
oncuso , nd or ac ectto f he lme s f a e ci l
' ct in
)
o te )
mitd .
1 Gor y has alo t id t i por t , gener l uns fed i dent des i i s alpa t
be
s re o ncor a e
aly, pecii nci s crbed n ever s
ci l a i he has fl
vi ctons
ied. The cour declnes t s i t i a wil deci t s c onl on t
t
i
hi nviaton nd l
de hi ase y
he
alegatons sat i t s ac i l a event occurencesm entone i concl or f on i t scas
l i
t ed n hi ton. n ny
,
r
i dn
us y ashi n hi e
ar s rki y si l t t e Gor desc i i one pror lw s t Gor y v.Bow l ,No.78: 6e ti ngl miar o hos
bey
rbes n
i a ui, be
es
l cv00522,t cour di ss t cas on Decem ber6,2016,upon fndi t is alegatons di nots
. he
t smi ed hat e
i ng hat t l i
d
how
any i mi da
m nent ngerofs i physi har .
erous
cal m
Be a s t rc r sr fe tt tGo b y h sa lattr eç ti e 'u d rj 1 5 g a d
c u e he e o d elc ha r e a t e s l e G rk s' n e 91 ( ) n
l s
he ha not de onsr t t the was i i ne da r of physca ha m whe flng t s
s
m taed ha
n mmi nt nge
i l r
n ii hi
co ai ,t c tde esGor y t o ru t t pr ee t f mapa i a dimis
mpl nt he our ni
be he ppo tniy o oc d q or
upers nd s ses
t c mplitwi u p eudc u de j 1 5 g .An a p o raeo d rwil su t i d y.
he o an t t rj ie n r 91 ( )
ho
p r p it r e lis e h s a
TheClr i die t d t s nd c e oft sme or ndum o ni a a ompa ng
e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a
pi on nd cc
nyi
o de t pl ntf.
r r o ai if
s s Ti / %a oA r,07
xT R: hs + y f pi2 1.
l
ChifU ied St t sDititJ e
e
t
a e src udg
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?