Gorbey v. Kiser et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/14/2017. (tvt)

/

cœ e s OFFIE U. DI GG W
C S. SX
ATRO,NOKS,
A
VA
SI
LED

APR 1i 2 1
2?
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

MI
CHAEL S.OW LFEATHERGORBEY, )
)
Pl ntf,
ai if
)
v.
)
)
JUDGE J
ACKSON L. SER, AL.
KI
c
, )
)
De e da .
f n nt
)

J A C aDk c ,
ULI
' .
BY;
D
E

CA SE N O .7: 7C V0015
1
2

M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

By: Gln E.Conrad
e
Chi f Unied St e Di t i tJudge
e
t
at s s r c

M ihae S.OwleaherGor
c l
f t - bey,a f r i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld t s cvi rght
ede al nma e oc di
o
ie hi i l i s

a to t e Bie v.Sx Un no F d Nac tc Ag n s 4 3U. 3 8 (9 ) Go b y s s
cin md r v ns i k wn e . r ois e t, 0 S. 8 1 71 . r e ue

tr ef d r l u g s ap o e uo , n n me o fd r lp io o scas algngta t e h ve
h e e ea j d e , r s c tr a d u rus e e a rs n f il, le i h t h y a
co pie t pl e a ke p li i s r t housng a t Unied St t Pe tnta y i Lee
ns r d o ac nd e lm n eg egaed
i t he t
aes nie ir n

Co ny (US Le ' a t h v hi patcvi a to sd s se ,n ng oh rt n s Gob y
u t G P e' nd o a e s s i l ci n ilis d mo t e hig . r e
C
)
ha a i t pr ee L fr pa rs
s ppled o oc d q o ma upei.Uponrviw oft rco d,hec tfndst tGobe
e e
he e r t our i ha r y

d e no q aiyt pr c e j f r n u rsu e 28U. C. 1 5 g a ta t i c s mu t
o s t u l o o e d . o ma a pei nd r
f
q
S. j 91 () nd h t h s a e s
be sl a iy dimis d ac or ngl
lmm rl s s e c di y.

ThePrs Lii ton Reor Ac of1 s tntaly n ndedt L f mapa rs
ion tgai
f m t 995 ubsa i l me
he q or
upei

saue 28 U. C.j1 1 . Th p r s o t Ac wa t r q r a1p io e ltg n ss n
tt t,
S.
9 5 e u po e f he t s o e uie 1 rs n r i a t uig
i
gove n e e ii or ofk il t pa c tflng f es i 1 1,e t r t o
r m nt nttes
t a s o y our ii e n 1 ihe hr ugh pr pa e or
e ym nt

tr u h i tlme t wi hed fo t l ia ts i t t s a c u t j1 5 b . Se to
l o g nsal n s t l r m he i g n ' nmae nzt c o n . 91 ( ) cin
l
h
t
1 5g d nist i tl n pa me tmeh d t p io e swh h v Gh e srk s' t o e
91 ( ) e e he nsal t y n to o rs n r o a e l r e tie '- h s
me
t
prs r who ha ha t eepr vi c s sora
ione s
ve d hr
e ous a e
ppeasdim is d a fi ous malci ,orf
l s s e s rvol , i ous
or
f iur t sae a cam , unl s t t ee srke i a e s w s çm mi nt da r of s rous
al e o tt
li
e s he hr -ti r nm t ho G
i ne
nge
ei

p y ia ij r . j1 5 g .
h sc lnu y' 91 ( )
'

Go be ha br
r y s ought s h a tons or a al on t e or mor pror occ sons Se
uc c i
ppe s
hr e
e i
ai . e

Owle te - r e v.J c o No 2:6 c 0 5 ,si o a 4 ( D.Va S p .2 20 6
f ah rGo b y a ks n, . 1 -v- 0 51 lp p. t E.
. e t 2, 1 )
( s se frf lng t saeacaml Gor vv.TheStt ofVicni No.2: 1c 001 si
dimisd o aii o tt li ; be
ae
r i a,
1 -v- 64, lp

o a 4 ( D.Va M a .1 ,2 1 (imis d f rfiig t sae a cam) Gobe v Uni d
p. t E.
. r 7 01 ) d s s e o aln o tt li ; r y . t
e
S ae , 2:8 c - 01 ,si o a 3 4 ( D.W . .J y 7 2 0 .se eg,Go b y v. d.
tts No. 0 -v 0 21 l p. t - N.
p
Va ul , 01 ) e , .. r e Fe
,
Bur a ofAlohol To co.Fiea & Expl i s No.5: -v- 26,si op.a 5 0( D.
eu
c . bac
r nns
osve ,
11c 001 lp
t -1 N.

W . . a .1 2 2 ( .. S i e t (itn 2 c s st a q aiy a srke u d rj1 5g )
Va M r 4, 01 ) M J, eb r) l i g 5 a e h t u lf s ti s n e 91 ().
s
Ac o dn l Go b yma p o e dj f r pa p rs( to t e a me to t fl fe o l
c r igy, r e y r c e . o ma u ei wih u prp y n f he ii e ) ny
q
ng
i h c ns w t t efc si n n d n e o s ro p ysc ln u y j1 5 g .
f e a ho ha h a e mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r . 91 ( )
l hi c
n s ompl i ,Gor y r pe t dl a l s wiho sa i a f c s daes orde aisi
ant
be e a e y lege , t ut ttng ny a t, t ,
t l n
s
uppor,t tt de e nt ha c pied t pl c i hi Gi i nt d
t ha he f nda s ve ons r o a e n m ûmm ne ange e r me prs
r xte
ion

c n iin a o sg iia th r s is' ( mpl 1 ECF No.1) He c mp anst a v ro s
o dto s nd r i nfc n ad hp . Co . ,
'
.
o li h t a iu
de e nt ha , i t pa t G a pult d' or wr ul dim is hi pro c vi aci ns
f nda s ve n he s : t ni a e '
m
ongf ly s s ed s i r i l to '
,

f brca e dicplna y c r agans hi t tha de a d ori de hi ta f r hed hi i
a i t d s i i r ha ges i t m ha ve l ye
mpe d s r nse ; l m n
G trtooded c ls' t l rl ng t ie s' c
û e l
wa
e l'wih i fowi o lt i' omm itd orf l t pr ve uns ii d saf
ove
te
aied o e nt pecfe t f

G s o d c'o G eaito 'a an thm;Srid t a ljng a sut o d ah f rGo be b
t c n u t r ç tl ins' g is i t le ) o rra e sa ls r e t o r y y
mi
' r a
t
tyi t pl c hi i c ls wih i t s of dif r nt housng saus' i
r ng o a e m n e l t nma e
fe e
i tt i' mpos d ç
e i s of
hour

u iia (ijr srit h ri h swrssa d a k ls' d nid hm t r p rtmey me ia
mb l l sc etan s u t i it n ngqe i e e i f o e -i l d c l
c
ng
'
p
te t nsa o me iai n i a d ma eh m ç lmb t tp bmk ir s e tv o h l)lwe
r ame t nd r dc to s' n d i s i o o t s re p cie f is o r
'
c

b nkme ia sa rp ae l c u igpan a d ij re . (d a 2 5) Go b y sae ta tus
u
dc l tms e e td y a sn i n n u is' 1 . t - . r e tts h t j t
'
ben a US Le i a i n n d n e .1 (d 6)
ig t P e s n mmi e t a g r, 1 . .
,
Go b y' ls o p s,md tde ns wi n s e i ai no ij re s frdo lk l t
r e s it f a tt ae ve t, t o p cfc to f nu is ufee r iey o
h
oc ur i sm pl i ufk i ntt s
c , s i y ns t e o how t t a t tm e Gor y sld hi c pl nt he wa i
ha t he i
be e s om ai ,
s n

i n n d ng r o a y s ro p y ia ij r rlt d t t na d d fn a t wi i te
mmie t a e f n eius h sc l nu y eae o he me e e d n s t n h
h
me n n o j 1 5 g . S eCh s v.O' aly 4 6 F. p' 1 5 1 6 (t Ci. 01 )( oi
a i g f 91 ( ) e a e
M le , 6 Ap x 8 , 8 4h r 2 2 n tng
t tprs rmus be s ki r iffom a demonsr t a da
ha ione
t ee ng ele r
nd
ta e
ngert ti i mi
ha s m nenta t tm e
t he i

o sln t ec mplit; tu v. o g nh u,5 4 F.d 2 3 29 ( d Ci. 0 9 ( oig ta t
f ig h o an) Pets M r e ta 5 3 9 , 6 2 r 2 0 ) n tn h t o
q aiy f r i n n d n e e e to t e j1 5 g ,t e c mp an mu tr v a a n x s
u l o mmie t a g r xc pi n md r 91 () h o lit s e e l e u
f
bewe n t ei ne td ng ri alg sa t ecamsi a srs. Gob y h sn talg d n r
t e h mmi n a e t le e nd h li t se t) r e a o le e , o
c n t co tfnd,a r pec i whi h havi hi pa tci la tonsdimis d plce hi i a
a he ur i ny es t n
c
ng s s vi c i
s s e a d m n ny
da r of physca ha m . Fi ly,hi r pea e r la e on t phr e lm mi nt da r'i
nge
i l r
nal s e t d e inc
he as ç
i ne
nge ' s
no hi mor t n a lbelo co l i t tt co tne d nota e asf m als
t ng
e ha a
r ncuson ha he ur e
cc pt ac
uppor f hi
t or s

cams S e BelAt.Co .v Two l,5 0 U. 5 4 5 5 ( 0 7 (i i t panifs
li . e l l p . mbv 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 ) fndng 1 litf
a
o iain t p o i et e tr u s o hi tnill n lt rle rq ie mo et n lbesa d
bl to o r v d h go nd ' f s e t e me t o eif e u rs r ha a l n
g
t
c l ins a af muli r iain o t ee nt o ac us ofa tonwilnotdo' (iato
oncuso , nd or ac ectto f he lme s f a e ci l
' ct in
)

o te )
mitd .

1 Gor y has alo t id t i por t , gener l uns fed i dent des i i s alpa t
be
s re o ncor a e
aly, pecii nci s crbed n ever s
ci l a i he has fl
vi ctons
ied. The cour declnes t s i t i a wil deci t s c onl on t
t
i
hi nviaton nd l
de hi ase y
he
alegatons sat i t s ac i l a event occurencesm entone i concl or f on i t scas
l i
t ed n hi ton. n ny
,
r
i dn
us y ashi n hi e
ar s rki y si l t t e Gor desc i i one pror lw s t Gor y v.Bow l ,No.78: 6e ti ngl miar o hos
bey
rbes n
i a ui, be
es
l cv00522,t cour di ss t cas on Decem ber6,2016,upon fndi t is alegatons di nots
. he
t smi ed hat e
i ng hat t l i
d
how
any i mi da
m nent ngerofs i physi har .
erous
cal m

Be a s t rc r sr fe tt tGo b y h sa lattr eç ti e 'u d rj 1 5 g a d
c u e he e o d elc ha r e a t e s l e G rk s' n e 91 ( ) n
l s
he ha not de onsr t t the was i i ne da r of physca ha m whe flng t s
s
m taed ha
n mmi nt nge
i l r
n ii hi

co ai ,t c tde esGor y t o ru t t pr ee t f mapa i a dimis
mpl nt he our ni
be he ppo tniy o oc d q or
upers nd s ses

t c mplitwi u p eudc u de j 1 5 g .An a p o raeo d rwil su t i d y.
he o an t t rj ie n r 91 ( )
ho
p r p it r e lis e h s a
TheClr i die t d t s nd c e oft sme or ndum o ni a a ompa ng
e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a
pi on nd cc
nyi
o de t pl ntf.
r r o ai if

s s Ti / %a oA r,07
xT R: hs + y f pi2 1.
l
ChifU ied St t sDititJ e
e
t
a e src udg

4