Gorbey v. Kiser et al
Filing
9
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2017. (tvt)
nlFRK' OFFI U. DI OnIRT
S
CE S. ST. . I
AT RIAHOKE,
VA
1t.!J
-lFE
. $
I THE UNI
N
TED S
TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT
MA' 29 2 1
/
27
FO R TH E W EST ERN D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O AN O K E DI SI N
W O
JULI C -.Eu- C RK
A pi
'
BY;
MI
CHAEL S.OW LFEATHERGORBEY, )
)
Pl i if
antf,
)
v
.
)
)
J
UDGE J
ACKSON L. SER, AL.
KI
c
, )
)
Dee n .
fnda t
)
CASE NO.7:
17CV001
52
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By:Gln E. n a
e Co r d
ChifUnie St e Dit itJudge
e td ats src
M ih e S. fah rGo b y (Gobe ' , f d r limaepr c e ig p o. , ie t
c a l Owle t e- r e E r y' a e ea n t o e dn r K fld Ms
G
)
cvi rg t a to u d rBie sv.S x Un n wn Fe Nac t sAg ns 4 3 U. 3 8 ( 9 )
i l ih s cin n e v n
i ko
d. r oi
c e t, 0 S. 8 1 71 .
By o ni a or r e e e Aprl 1 201 t c utf nd t tGor y di no quaiy t
pi on nd de ntr d
i 4, 7, he ot ' ou ha
be d t lf o
p o e dt f r p u rst e 28U. C. 1 5 g a s mma i ds se tec s wi u
r c e q o ma a pei md r
S. j 91 ( ) nd u rl imisd h a e t t
y
ho
p eudc . Go b y no mo sfrr c n ieain o t a r l g, o t c u tsr c s l a t
rj ie r e w ve o e o sd r to f h t ui f r he o r' e u a, nd o
n
c oldae a r co i rs ve alofhi pa tc e t twe e as dimi s Fi i no good
ons i t nd e nsde e r
s s as s ha r lo s s ed. nd ng
c us t co tmus de aloft em oto .
a e, he ur
t ny l hes
i ns
Fis,Go b y sae nog o ndf rr c s lhee A j d emus r c s hms l wh n i
rt r e tts r u o e u a r. u g
t e u e i ef e t
he
h sapes n lba o p eudc c n enn ap ry'28U. C. 4 5 b ( )( 01 ) Th S iso
a
ro a is r rj ie o c r ig a t.
'
S. j 5 ( )1 2 2 . e G a r
b
p eu ie mus,a a g n rlmalr se fo G s u c o tie t j dca p o e d n a
rj dc
t s e e a te , tm r m a o r e u sd he u iil r c e i g t
h n ' Beu v Le e t a,6 0F.d 5 7 5 2 ( u tn Li k v. td S ae , 0 U. 5 0
a d.' l e . v nh l 4 3 6 , 7 q oig t v Uni tts 51 S. 4 ,
'
e
e
5 5 ( 9 4) ç ludca nlng a d Gpn o s f r d b te j d e o t e b ss o f cs
4 1 9 ). t l iil l s n o ii n o me y h u g n h a i f a t
g
i
i r ed ore nt oc uri i t c s o t c r ntpr ee ngs orofpro pr ee ngs
ntoduc
ve s c rng n he our e f he ure
oc di ,
i r oc di '
al tE ve c tt eavai ba i f abi orpa talt moton,'j a 573( i Lie
mos ne r onsiut
ld ss or as
ri iy i ''. t
;s
quotng tkv,
51 U. a 5 5 ,Gu ls t e ds a ad e s ae fvo iim o a tg n s t two dma e
0 S. t 5 ) l ne s h y iply e p-e td a rts r n a o im ha ul k
û
.
fi j d me ti osil,' Untd S ae v. nz 5 4F.d 5 ,5 0 (t Ci. 0 8 ( u tn
ar u g n mp sbe'' ie tts Le t, 2 3 01 3 4 h r 2 0 ) q oig
Li k 5 0U. a 5 5 .Thsc u t a n p ro a biso p eu iea an tGobe . I f c,
t y, 1 S. t 5 ) i o r h s o es n l a r rj d c g is r y n a t
e
t c tha no pe s na kno e ofhi outi t bor r oft s c s Ac di y, t
he our s
r o l wl dge
m
sde he de s hi a e. cor ngl he
c twilde Gor y' moton f r c alasfi ousa malcous
our l ny
be s i or e us
rvol
nd i i .
The c ta s fndsno g ound t ale or a e t or r dimi sng t s c s t r
our lo i
r
o tr
m nd he de s s i hi a e mde
j1 5g ,b s d o t e fc t a Go b y ha h d ma y p ir lws isds se a fio o ,
91 ( ) a e n h a t h t r e s a n ro a u t imisd s rv lus
m ai i ,orf f iur t sae a c am . l add e sng t compl i a whehe Gor ha
lcous
or a l e o t t l i n r s i he
ant nd
t r bey d
alege f c s s
l d a t howi i mi ntda
ng m ne
nger ofphysc lha m s a t qualf t pr e d wihout
ia r o s o
iy o oc e
t
pr payi t slng c t f r t s a ton,t c t s i a l deci d t i or a e f c s
e ng he i os s o hi c i he our pecûc ly
lne o nc por t a t
alege i a of hi pr vi l fl c os d ci la tons a
l d n ny
s e ousy ied, l e vi c i
boutpa t e nt . The c ta s
s ve s
our lo
d ci st d s n w o amo in frr c n ie ain.Th c u tas fn n j si to f r
el o o o o n
ne
to o e o sd r to
e o r lo ids o u tt in o
ka
c olda i t s cl e a ton w ih o he c os d c e ,m a of w hi h w e e al o di m i s d
ons i tng hi os d c i
t t r l e as s
ny
c
r s s se
u d rj1 5g f rf i let s o i n n d n e .
n e 91 () o alr o h w mmie t a g r
t
Fi ly,Gor y cli si t sm oto t thi c
na l
be am n hi
i n ha s ompl i is l s wedt thef ce
ant te f ho
ha
a d
i mi ntda rofs rousphysc hn m.The c tc
m ne
nge
ei
i al r
our nnno ag e Assaed, o qualf t
t r e.
tt t
iy o
p o e dwi o tp e a me t md rj1 5 g , r e mus s o ta h wa i i n n
r c e t u rp y n t e 91 ( ) Go b y t h w h t e s n mmie t
h
d ng ro s ro sp sc lnur r ltdt t en me d fn a t a t t h fldt ecv l
a e f eiu hy ia ij y eae o h a d ee d n s the i e ie h ii
me
a to S eCh s v. M alv 4 6F. p' 1 5 1 6(t Ci. 1 )( tn t t rs ne mus
cin. e a e O' le , 6 Ap x 8 , 8 4 h r 20 2 noig ha p io r t
bes ki r leffo a de onsr t adange t ti i ne a t tm eofslng t
ee ng e i r m nd m ta e
r ha s mmi nt t he i
i he
c mplit; e t v. o g nh u 5 4F.d29 , 9 ( dCi. 0 9 ( oi gt a t q aiyf r
o an) P tus M r e ta , 5 3 3 2 6 2 r 2 0 ) n tn h t o u l o
f
i ne dange e e i unde j1 5( ,t c an mus r ve ane bet e t
mmi nt
r xc pton
r 91 g) he omplit t e al xus we n he
i ne dange i algesa t camsiase t)
mmi nt
r t le nd he li t s rs.Gor y' rpeae r la ons h
be s e td eince uc
boie pl t phr s sa G ni lo pr
lr ae a e s s a f opertm e ym e c lte t nt' nd Em mi ntda r'û r
de
i l di a r a me 'a G
i ne
ngç ' G e
a
m e e y E a l a co l i ' t ta e notf c ua a l ga i e il t a as um pton oft t
r l û be s nd nc usons' ha r
l
a t l le tons ntted o n s
i
nzh.
Bel l Co v. mbv, 5 U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7 .Rah r t me ttesa d r u e
lAt. p. Two l 5 0 S. 4 , 5 2 0 ) t e, o e h tn a d nd r
j1 5g , r e mus ma etpe ii f c alg to so o g igs ro sp y ia ijly o o
91 ( ) Go b y t k l cfc a t le ain f n on ei u h sc l nt , r f
s
r
apatr o mic n uc e d n igtel l o o i n n s ro sp y ia ij r . J h s n
te n f so d t vie cn h i i d f mmie t eiu h sc ln u y' o n o
ke ho
'
v. an r 20 F. p x2 0 2 2( t Ci. 0 6 .
W r e , 0 Ap ' 7 , 7 4h r 2 0 )
Gor y smpl f ist mee t ssa r
be i y a l o
t hi t nda d.Att mos,he saesi a co l or m a r
he
t
tt n
ncus y nne
t th h sb e G u frngto d dt iesEn )lc o v niain' o t mo t a d G e il
ha e a e n ç fei l o e olt a d a k f e tlto 'f r wo nhs n t n a
s
d
o pr rtm e y m e c lte t e ' f rt s cii m e c lpr e snc J y 201 Gor y
f ope i l
di a r am nt' o m pe fed di a obl ms i e ul
6.
be
as ha no a lge a i i ntors ro physc ha m lke y t f l fom t s va l
lo s t le d ny mm ne
e i us
ial r i l o olow r he e guey
de c i smatons Fi ng no gr und f t r ifr quese t c tmus de hi m oton
s rbed i i . ndi
o
or he ele e t d, he our
t ny s i
frrc nsd rto o t ds s a o t i a to u d r j1 5 g . An a p o rae o d rwi
o e o i eain f he imis l f hs cin n e 91 ( )
p r p it r e l
l
e e t sda
ntr hi y.
The Clr i diecedt s nd c e oft sm e a um opi on a ac om pa ng
e k s r t o e opis hi mor nd
ni nd c
nyi
o de t pl i if
r r o antf.
Ma
ENTER:Ths q V d yo- y 2 7
i
a f , 01 .
Chif nie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?