Gorbey v. Kiser et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2017. (tvt)

nlFRK' OFFI U. DI OnIRT
S
CE S. ST. . I
AT RIAHOKE,
VA
1t.!J
-lFE
. $

I THE UNI
N
TED S
TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT

MA' 29 2 1
/
27

FO R TH E W EST ERN D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O AN O K E DI SI N
W O

JULI C -.Eu- C RK
A pi
'
BY;

MI
CHAEL S.OW LFEATHERGORBEY, )
)
Pl i if
antf,
)
v
.
)
)
J
UDGE J
ACKSON L. SER, AL.
KI
c
, )
)
Dee n .
fnda t
)

CASE NO.7:
17CV001
52

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By:Gln E. n a
e Co r d
ChifUnie St e Dit itJudge
e td ats src

M ih e S. fah rGo b y (Gobe ' , f d r limaepr c e ig p o. , ie t
c a l Owle t e- r e E r y' a e ea n t o e dn r K fld Ms
G
)
cvi rg t a to u d rBie sv.S x Un n wn Fe Nac t sAg ns 4 3 U. 3 8 ( 9 )
i l ih s cin n e v n
i ko
d. r oi
c e t, 0 S. 8 1 71 .
By o ni a or r e e e Aprl 1 201 t c utf nd t tGor y di no quaiy t
pi on nd de ntr d
i 4, 7, he ot ' ou ha
be d t lf o

p o e dt f r p u rst e 28U. C. 1 5 g a s mma i ds se tec s wi u
r c e q o ma a pei md r
S. j 91 ( ) nd u rl imisd h a e t t
y
ho
p eudc . Go b y no mo sfrr c n ieain o t a r l g, o t c u tsr c s l a t
rj ie r e w ve o e o sd r to f h t ui f r he o r' e u a, nd o
n
c oldae a r co i rs ve alofhi pa tc e t twe e as dimi s Fi i no good
ons i t nd e nsde e r
s s as s ha r lo s s ed. nd ng
c us t co tmus de aloft em oto .
a e, he ur
t ny l hes
i ns

Fis,Go b y sae nog o ndf rr c s lhee A j d emus r c s hms l wh n i
rt r e tts r u o e u a r. u g
t e u e i ef e t
he

h sapes n lba o p eudc c n enn ap ry'28U. C. 4 5 b ( )( 01 ) Th S iso
a
ro a is r rj ie o c r ig a t.
'
S. j 5 ( )1 2 2 . e G a r
b
p eu ie mus,a a g n rlmalr se fo G s u c o tie t j dca p o e d n a
rj dc
t s e e a te , tm r m a o r e u sd he u iil r c e i g t
h n ' Beu v Le e t a,6 0F.d 5 7 5 2 ( u tn Li k v. td S ae , 0 U. 5 0
a d.' l e . v nh l 4 3 6 , 7 q oig t v Uni tts 51 S. 4 ,
'
e
e
5 5 ( 9 4) ç ludca nlng a d Gpn o s f r d b te j d e o t e b ss o f cs
4 1 9 ). t l iil l s n o ii n o me y h u g n h a i f a t
g
i
i r ed ore nt oc uri i t c s o t c r ntpr ee ngs orofpro pr ee ngs
ntoduc
ve s c rng n he our e f he ure
oc di ,
i r oc di '

al tE ve c tt eavai ba i f abi orpa talt moton,'j a 573( i Lie
mos ne r onsiut
ld ss or as
ri iy i ''. t
;s
quotng tkv,

51 U. a 5 5 ,Gu ls t e ds a ad e s ae fvo iim o a tg n s t two dma e
0 S. t 5 ) l ne s h y iply e p-e td a rts r n a o im ha ul k
û
.

fi j d me ti osil,' Untd S ae v. nz 5 4F.d 5 ,5 0 (t Ci. 0 8 ( u tn
ar u g n mp sbe'' ie tts Le t, 2 3 01 3 4 h r 2 0 ) q oig
Li k 5 0U. a 5 5 .Thsc u t a n p ro a biso p eu iea an tGobe . I f c,
t y, 1 S. t 5 ) i o r h s o es n l a r rj d c g is r y n a t
e

t c tha no pe s na kno e ofhi outi t bor r oft s c s Ac di y, t
he our s
r o l wl dge
m
sde he de s hi a e. cor ngl he
c twilde Gor y' moton f r c alasfi ousa malcous
our l ny
be s i or e us
rvol
nd i i .
The c ta s fndsno g ound t ale or a e t or r dimi sng t s c s t r
our lo i
r
o tr
m nd he de s s i hi a e mde

j1 5g ,b s d o t e fc t a Go b y ha h d ma y p ir lws isds se a fio o ,
91 ( ) a e n h a t h t r e s a n ro a u t imisd s rv lus
m ai i ,orf f iur t sae a c am . l add e sng t compl i a whehe Gor ha
lcous
or a l e o t t l i n r s i he
ant nd
t r bey d
alege f c s s
l d a t howi i mi ntda
ng m ne
nger ofphysc lha m s a t qualf t pr e d wihout
ia r o s o
iy o oc e
t
pr payi t slng c t f r t s a ton,t c t s i a l deci d t i or a e f c s
e ng he i os s o hi c i he our pecûc ly
lne o nc por t a t
alege i a of hi pr vi l fl c os d ci la tons a
l d n ny
s e ousy ied, l e vi c i
boutpa t e nt . The c ta s
s ve s
our lo

d ci st d s n w o amo in frr c n ie ain.Th c u tas fn n j si to f r
el o o o o n
ne
to o e o sd r to
e o r lo ids o u tt in o
ka
c olda i t s cl e a ton w ih o he c os d c e ,m a of w hi h w e e al o di m i s d
ons i tng hi os d c i
t t r l e as s
ny
c
r s s se

u d rj1 5g f rf i let s o i n n d n e .
n e 91 () o alr o h w mmie t a g r
t
Fi ly,Gor y cli si t sm oto t thi c
na l
be am n hi
i n ha s ompl i is l s wedt thef ce
ant te f ho
ha
a d
i mi ntda rofs rousphysc hn m.The c tc
m ne
nge
ei
i al r
our nnno ag e Assaed, o qualf t
t r e.
tt t
iy o

p o e dwi o tp e a me t md rj1 5 g , r e mus s o ta h wa i i n n
r c e t u rp y n t e 91 ( ) Go b y t h w h t e s n mmie t
h
d ng ro s ro sp sc lnur r ltdt t en me d fn a t a t t h fldt ecv l
a e f eiu hy ia ij y eae o h a d ee d n s the i e ie h ii
me
a to S eCh s v. M alv 4 6F. p' 1 5 1 6(t Ci. 1 )( tn t t rs ne mus
cin. e a e O' le , 6 Ap x 8 , 8 4 h r 20 2 noig ha p io r t
bes ki r leffo a de onsr t adange t ti i ne a t tm eofslng t
ee ng e i r m nd m ta e
r ha s mmi nt t he i
i he

c mplit; e t v. o g nh u 5 4F.d29 , 9 ( dCi. 0 9 ( oi gt a t q aiyf r
o an) P tus M r e ta , 5 3 3 2 6 2 r 2 0 ) n tn h t o u l o
f
i ne dange e e i unde j1 5( ,t c an mus r ve ane bet e t
mmi nt
r xc pton
r 91 g) he omplit t e al xus we n he
i ne dange i algesa t camsiase t)
mmi nt
r t le nd he li t s rs.Gor y' rpeae r la ons h
be s e td eince uc
boie pl t phr s sa G ni lo pr
lr ae a e s s a f opertm e ym e c lte t nt' nd Em mi ntda r'û r
de
i l di a r a me 'a G
i ne
ngç ' G e
a
m e e y E a l a co l i ' t ta e notf c ua a l ga i e il t a as um pton oft t
r l û be s nd nc usons' ha r
l
a t l le tons ntted o n s
i
nzh.

Bel l Co v. mbv, 5 U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7 .Rah r t me ttesa d r u e
lAt. p. Two l 5 0 S. 4 , 5 2 0 ) t e, o e h tn a d nd r

j1 5g , r e mus ma etpe ii f c alg to so o g igs ro sp y ia ijly o o
91 ( ) Go b y t k l cfc a t le ain f n on ei u h sc l nt , r f
s
r
apatr o mic n uc e d n igtel l o o i n n s ro sp y ia ij r . J h s n
te n f so d t vie cn h i i d f mmie t eiu h sc ln u y' o n o
ke ho
'
v. an r 20 F. p x2 0 2 2( t Ci. 0 6 .
W r e , 0 Ap ' 7 , 7 4h r 2 0 )
Gor y smpl f ist mee t ssa r
be i y a l o
t hi t nda d.Att mos,he saesi a co l or m a r
he
t
tt n
ncus y nne

t th h sb e G u frngto d dt iesEn )lc o v niain' o t mo t a d G e il
ha e a e n ç fei l o e olt a d a k f e tlto 'f r wo nhs n t n a
s
d
o pr rtm e y m e c lte t e ' f rt s cii m e c lpr e snc J y 201 Gor y
f ope i l
di a r am nt' o m pe fed di a obl ms i e ul
6.
be
as ha no a lge a i i ntors ro physc ha m lke y t f l fom t s va l
lo s t le d ny mm ne
e i us
ial r i l o olow r he e guey
de c i smatons Fi ng no gr und f t r ifr quese t c tmus de hi m oton
s rbed i i . ndi
o
or he ele e t d, he our
t ny s i

frrc nsd rto o t ds s a o t i a to u d r j1 5 g . An a p o rae o d rwi
o e o i eain f he imis l f hs cin n e 91 ( )
p r p it r e l
l
e e t sda
ntr hi y.
The Clr i diecedt s nd c e oft sm e a um opi on a ac om pa ng
e k s r t o e opis hi mor nd
ni nd c
nyi
o de t pl i if
r r o antf.

Ma
ENTER:Ths q V d yo- y 2 7
i
a f , 01 .
Chif nie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge