Sovereign v. Stallard et al

Filing 7

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 5/11/2017. (tvt)

tLERK' oFgl u s Dl counm
:
cs
sm

,. A D x k ,A
: T A uli v
FIED
L

I THE UNI S
N
TED TATES DI CT COURT
STRI

MAt k j2 1
27

FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R o A N O K E D I SI N
VI O
JO N AH SO VER EI N ,
G
Pl ntff
ai i ,

V 2 Z O DU L cL t
' UL
'
c ERl

., s CLER q
us x
j
'DEPUFY

C i lA c i N o.7: c 0 60
vi ton
17- v- 01
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

V.

By: Jaclson L.K i er
t
s
Seni Uni St
or ted atesD i ri Judge
st ct

J. .STA LLA RD ,e al
B
t ,

De e a t)
f nd nts.
J na So rin, r c e igp oK, ie acvlrg t c mpan , t s a tt 42U. C.
o h veeg p o e dn r fld ii ih s o litpz u n o
r
S. j
1
983. By Or re e e Aprl1 201 t c tdie t dpl n ift s
de nt r d
i 4, 7, he our r c e aitf o ubmi wihi 20 da
t t n
ys
fo t da eoft Or ra im a eac ountf m ,a ace tfe co ofpl i ifst s f
r m he t
he de n n t c
or nd
rii d py
antf nlt und
a ot ts a e e f rt sx- ont pe i i m e at l pr ce ng t flng oft c pl i ,
cc m t t m nt o he i m h r od m di e y e di he ii
he om a nt
obt ned f om t a opr a e pr s n ofi i lofe h pr s a whi h pl i ifi orw asco i d
ai
r he ppr i t i o fc a
ac i on t c a ntf s
nfne

durngt tsx- ont pe i
i ha i m h rod.Pl ntf wasad s d t taf l et c pl woul r ul i
ai if
vi e ha aiur o om y
d es t n

d s sa o t sa to wi u p eudc .
imis l f hi cin t t rj ie
ho
M or t n 20 da ha e a e a pl i ifha f l t c pl w ih t des r be
e ha
ys ve l ps d, nd a ntf s aied o om y t he c i d

c n i o s Ac o dn l ,h c u t imis st a to wi u p eu iea dsrk stec s
o dt n . c r ig y te o r d s se he cin t t rj dc n ti e h a e
i
ho
fom t aci doc toft co t Pl i ifm a r fl t c am si as pa aeac i onc
r he tve ke he ur. antf y e ie he l i n e r t ton e
pl i ifi pr pa e t c
antf s e r d o ompl wih t not c tons
y t he ed ondii .
TheCl r i diecedt s nd acopy oft sM e a
ek s r t o e
hi mor ndum Opi on a a ompa ng
ni nd cc
nyi
Or rt pl n if
de o aitf.
EN TER : Thi
s

ttW dyo Ma 2017.
'
- a f y
t
,

N

N

k

Se o U nie St t D i ti tJ
r t d a es s r c udge