Jackson v. Bennett
Filing
25
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/7/2018. (slt)
CLERKS OFFIE U. . ST.
C 3 DI COUR'
'
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT
FO R TH E W E STER N DI RI O F V I G I I
ST CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI
VI ON
MAY 22 2 1
28
J
ULW .
DUD
BY;
,
CLERK
K
CH A UN CEY X JA C K SO N ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
C i lA c i N o.7: 7- vvi t on
1 c 00166
V.
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M
ADRJANNE BENNETT,
D ef
endant
.
By:
Hon.M i hae F. bans
c l Ur
ki
C hi fUni e St t sD i t i tJudge
e
td a e src
Cha
unce J J c o aVigi a i aepr e ngpr K ,c m m e edt sa ton
y . a ks n, r ni nm t oce di
o
o
nc hi c i
pu s n t 4 U.. j1 3.Plitf n me Ad in eBe net wh i t eCh i ro o t e
rua t o 2 SC. 98 anif a s rn n n t o s h apes n f h
VignaPa oeBo r (t ad', stes l d fnd n.Pli t fa g e t a hee pe n e cu l
r i i r l a d ( r ' a h oe ee a t ani r u s h t x de c s r e
Bo )
f
a unus lpunihm e by be ng de e a m e ni ulopport iy t obt i pa ol r e e, n
nd
ua
s nt
i
ni d
a ngf
tm t o a n r e el as i
vi ai n oft Ei h and Foure nt Am e
ol to
he ght
te h
ndme soft Unie St t sCo tmton.
nt
he t d a e nsi i
De e d n fldamo inf rs mmayj d me tt whc Plitf rs n e o to tme1
fn a t i
e
to o u r u g n, o ih an if epo d d u f i .
Afe rviwigt rc r ,h c u t n sDee d n ' moinf rs mmayj g n .
tr e e n he e o d t e o r wa t fn a ts to o u r ud me t
1.
Pl i i fha c m it d m uli ef l es i udi homi i be or J n r 1 1
a ntf d om te
tpl e oni , ncl ng
cde, f e a ua y , 995,
,
a whiesxt n ye r ol Hewasc ced of i e ai ,fr tdeg e mur ra s nt nc
nd l i ee a s d.
onvi t
, nt r la is- r e
de nd e e ed
'
OnN O m be 28, 2001 t lf i p ionme f rt tcrm ez Pli ifhasbee e i bl f
ve r
o ie m rs
nt o ha i . antf
n lgi e or
,
dicei r par e, ruantt Vigi aCodej53.-65.,snc Ocobe 26,2007.
s rtona y ol pus
o r ni
11 1 i e t r
1 antf ha untl ove be 28 201 t fl hi r s ei oppo iin t t m oton f s m ay
Pli if d iN m r
7 o ie s e pons n
sto o he i or um r
j g n,u h ddn t a dit pio ofcasfrmal rutlateeris, nDee e 2120 7 Se...
udmetb t e i o h n to rsn fiil o ii ni,th al to cmbr , 1 . ee2,
n
e
Ho so v La k 4 7U. 2 6 2 5(9 8 (e ciigtep lo - i o r ll Gii ap o. c mpan te
u tn . c , 8 S. 6 , 7 1 8 ) d srbn h rs nmal x ue. vng r K o lith
b
be i ofalber co tucto doe notme t tt oc dur lr e i or nay cvi ltgaton s dbeit r ee
neft
i al nsr in s
an ha s e a uls n di r i l ii i houl
pr
n epr td
s ast exc em it sbyt ewhopr ee wihoutc el' M c elv.Unie Stt ,508U . 106,11
o o us sake
hos
oc d t
ouns .
' N i
td aes
S.
3
(9 3 ; vn v Jr s 1 7F.d1 98 1 0 ( 1hCi.1 9 )(liea c n tu to d e no menl rl
1 9 ) Wa e . avi, 9 3 0 , 1 4 1 t r 9 9 sa r l o srcin o s t a i a
tb
be
d a l e .) Plitf h sn tmo dfra e tn ino t , i e b fr o atrt d a l ep se .
e di s'. anif a o ve o n xe so f i et r eoe r fe he e di as d
n '
me h
n
Ac odn l t c utd e n tc n ie teu tmeyrs o s i o po io t temoinfrs mmayj d me t
c r igy,he o r o s o o sd r h ni l ep n e n p st n o h to o u r u g n.
i
2Pl ntf wa as c ce ofatm ptdr r , usng afr r d i af l a c pki t
ai if s lo onvitd te e obbe y i
ieam urng eony, nd ons ng o
c m i af ony.
om t el
Sn ea la t2 6 Plitf h srq e tdt a t eBo r c n ie h ssausa aj ve ie
ic t e s 01 , an if a e u se h t h ad o sd r i tt s u nl
ofe ra hi de opi m aurt ass c fcf t si s
f nde nd s vel ng t iy pe ii acor n uppor ofpa ol r e e. Pl i ifha
t
r e elas
antf s
e anedt t Boa d t theha r i d i r cto fe i prs f m a yea s a hi d
xpl i o he r ha
s ema ne nfa i n r e n ion or ny r , c eve
e u aina mi so e , itie ap io o f r n y asi dfe e t a iiis b e
d c to l l t n s manan d rs nj b o ma y e r n ifr n f clte , e n
e
hous d i at ii Be vi Uni, a be n m a red snceFe a y 21 201
e n E tve ha or t' nd e
pos
'
ri i
bnzr , 4.
Pl i t f ha be n de e pa ol r l a e e y ye rhe ha be n r vi w e I 201 t
a n if s e ni d r e e e s ver a
s e e e d. n
7, he
Boa d ex ai d isde alby notngt s rousna ur a c r um sa c ofhi c i ,t t
r pl ne t ni
i he e i
t e nd ic t h es
s rmes ha
r l a ewoul di nih t s ro ne sofhi c i e , ha hei silars t t co muniy.
ee s
d mi s he e i us s
s rm s t t s tl ik o he m
t
Pli tf c l , s ont r pe t d de as t thewilha aG f t s nt nc oflf
a n if oncudes ba ed he e a e ni l, ha
l ve d aco e e e ie
de
wihoutpa ol .'Asr le ,Pli ifwa st Boa d beco pe ld t s ii a l c i r
t
r e'
ei f a ntf nt he r
m le o pecfc ly onsde
tu nl o fnd rsa 'a afco frpaoer la e
j ve ie fe e tms' s a tr o r l ee s .
TheBoadrlesonisS r eDe ii Fa tr'(s cor' t deemi paol r l s
r ei
t û ol cson co s'çFa t s' o tr ne r e eea e.
pa
)
The Facor hep t Boa d de det pr ba lt t ta i t wilc
t s l he
r ci he o biiy ha n nma e l ompl wih co to of
y t ndii ns
r l as a l d al w- bi i lf i t c
e e e nd ea a a d ng ie n he ommuniy. To t te t Fa t sr quie
t
ha nd,he c or e r
c i r ton of a r l s pl n;f m iy a c m m uniy r s c 'a prore re e w hie on
ons de a i
: e ea e a a l nd o
t e our es ny i xpe i nc
,
l
s pe v s r l a e c nge i m otvai nsa be vi s i tt i lbe vi r t tm ear a
u r ied e e s ; ha s n
i to nd ha or ; nsiutona ha o ; he i le dy
s r edf a i
e v or n mpos s t nce'hec i e'o r l c i i lhit y r co d;a rs t t
ed en e ,
t rm , ve al rm na sor e r nd ik o he
c
omm t t The Boa d ha t dic ei t de pa ol r l as i i doe no ha s f int
miy.
r s he s r ton o ny r e e e e f t s t ve ufk e
c i ncei a i na e' a lt t s c d o doe no bei vepa ol r l s woul s r et
onfde
n n nf t s biiy o uc ee r s t le
r e eea e
d e v he
i e e t ofs i t a t i a e
nt r s s oc e y nd he nm t .
I
I.
A pat i e tte t s mmayj g n i t pla ig ,h d s ls dmaeil o fl,
ry s nild o u r ud me t f he e dn s t e ico e tras n ie
a a afi viss w t tt r i no ge nediput a t a m ae ilf c . Fe R.Ci P.
nd ny fda t ho ha he e s
pui
s e s o ny tra a t d.
v.
5 () M aeil a t aet o en c sayt etb iht eee n so ap ry sc u eo a to
6 a . tra fcs r h s e e s r o sa ls h lme t f a t' a s f cin.
An e s nv. b ryLo b I c, 7U. 2 2 2 8( 9 6 .A g n i ed s u eo maeil a t
d ro Lie t b y,n .47 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) e u n ip t f tra f c
e ssi,i vi wi a s i ee de e a a lr as bl i e e esdr t r fom i alght
xit f n e ng dmi sbl vi nc nd 1 e ona e nf r nc
awn he e r n i
mos f vo a et t non- ovi pa t ar s
t a r bl o he
m ng ry, ea onabl f tfnde c dr t n ave ditf rt
e ac-i r oul eur
r c o he
non- nt J. Themovi pa t ha t bur nofs wi -çha i, ntngou t t
mova . I
L
ng ry s he de
ho ng d t s poi i t o he
t
diti tc t t tt r i a abs nceofe de e t s ppo tt nonm ovi pary' c s '
src our - ha he e s n e
vi nc o u r he
ng t s a e.
'
Ceoe Co p v. tet4 7U. 3 7, 25( 9 6 .l temo a tstsist i bld n t nt e
ltx r . Cart, 7 S. 1 3 1 8 ) f h v n aife hs t e ,he h
r
non- ova m us s tf t s cii f c s t tde onsr t t e s e e ofa ge ne di put of
m nt
t e orh pe fc a t ha m t a e he xi t nc
nui
s e
fc frtil I a 3 2 2 .A pat i e tte t s mmayj d me ti t ea misb ee ie e
a t o ra. d. t 2 - 4
ry s n ild o u r u g n f h d s il vd nc
a >whol c d notlad ar tona tiro f c t fnd i f vo oft non- ova . W iln sv.
s
e oul
e
a i l re f a t o i n a r he
m nt lim
Grfi, 5 F.d 8 0 8 ( t Ci.1 91.S eeu s p o td s e ulto . .sn te o g t
ifn 9 2 2 2 , 23 4h r 9 ) ç r n u p re p c ain . i o n u h o
M
d fa asl r u g n mo in' En sv. tl sno Bus & Ed c Ra i I c, 3F.d
ee t l
mmayj d me t to . ni Na' As' f . u . do.n .5 3
'
5 , 2( t Ci.1 9 ) A p an ifc nn tu ear s o s t amoi nfrsl r j d me t o
5 6 4h r 9 5 . litf a o s e p n e o
to o l
mma y u g n t
n n o c re tac mplitc alng dbyt emoinf rs mmayj d me t Cl a i e v.
me d r o r c o an h l e
e
h to o u r u g n . o nng r
M c vit 555F. 324,336( hCi. )
De t
3d
4t r 2009 .
111.
Pli ifprncpal r le onGrl v. orda,560U. 48 68( 0) a M ilrv.
antf i i ly eis
amm Fl i
S. , 201 , nd le
Alba ,567U. 460,465( 2) a t ma tr pr c n rquii t Boadt
a ma
S.
201 , s he ndao y e ede t e rng he r o
s cfc l c nsd rh s u e i o fn e sau .Th c u t id ta n ih rGrh m n rM i e
pe iial o i e i j v nl fe d r tt s e o r fn s h t et e a a o l r
y
e
l
c nr l a dt tDee a t se tte t j d me ta amatro lw.
o tos n ha fnd n i n ild o u g n s te f a
Gr h m h l t t h EihhAme me t e urssae t pr vd aj v nieo fn e
a a ed ha t e g t
nd n r q ie tts o o ie u e l fe d r
c n ce o an n o cd o fn eç o me nn f l p o tn t t o ti rla e(r m
o vitd f o h mii e fe s ç me a ig' o p ru iy o ban ee s fo
s
u
prs bas o de tae maurt a rha ltton. Grhn 560U. a 75.Pli if
ion) ed n monsrtd t iy nd e biiai ' a m,
'
S. t
antf
wa c
s onvi t d o , i e ala fr tde e homi i a t sGr mm doe no a yhe e.
c e f ntr i , s - gr e
cde, nd hus al
s t ppl r 3
M ilrhe d t tt Ei h Am e
le l ha he ght
ndme f r dsas ntncngs he et tm a t salf
nt o bi
e e i c m ha nda e ie
s ne ewih u p si ii o p r l f r u ni sc n itdo ho cd o fns s M ilr 5 7
e tnc t o t o sblt f a oe o j ve l o v ce f miie fe e . le , 6
y
e
U. 48 .W hl Pli t fma h v be naj ve iec n itdo ah miieo fn e h c n o
S. 9 ie ani y a e e u nl o v ce f o cd fe s , e n n t
f
e t iht thewass ntnc t ma t ylf a wiho aposi lt ofpa ol Se jaa
sabls ha
e e ed o ndaor ie nd t ut
sbiiy
r e. e ..t
l
476( i ma t ys ntncngsam e ,d t i naur pr cudeas ntnc rfo tki
notng ndaor e e i tt s G her t e, e l
by
e e e r m a ng
a c u t fa o fn e ' a ea dt we lho c aa trsisa d cru tn e atn a t oi'.
c o n o n fe d rs g n he at f h r ce itc n ic msa c s te d n t t)
'
Vigi adi no ma t ama t y lf s nt e, onesv.
r ni d t ndae
ndaor ie e enc J
Comm onwe 1h,293 Va 29,40at
.
42,
7 S. 2 70 , 1 1 ( 0 7 , n P an ifa l wld e h i eiil f rp r l.S e
95 E.d 5 71 - 2 2 1 ) a d litf cc e g s e s lgb e o a oe e
no
M o to r v Lo iin ,1 6S. . 8 7 7 ( 1 )( Saema r me yaM i e vo ai n
nR mey . u sa a 3 Ct 71 , 3 20 6 ç tt y e d
W
l r ilto
l
b p r ti j v nl h mii eo fn e st b c n i ee f rp r l,ah rt nb
y emi ng u e ie o cd fe d r o e o sd rd o a oe rt e ha y
t
rs ntnci t m.'.
e e e ng he '
)
Pl i ifa ksw he he i w o d be be t rf t Fac o s t s cii a l c i rhi
a ntf s
t r t ul
te or he t r o pe f c ly ons de s
d veo me tsn ec mmit ci sa aj v nl .Ho ve, et e Grhn n rM i e
e lp n ic o ti rme s u e ie we r n ih r a m o l r
ng
l
co pe sar a we t t quesi t ough t lnsoft Ei h Ame
m l l ns r o hat
ton hr
he e
he ght
ndme ,a Pl ntf s
nt nd ai if
3Pl ntf r la onadititt rtc s 9om t Ea tr D ititofN orh Car i i sm ial
ai ifs eince
src ou a e
he se n src
t
olna s i lry
miplc d Theplitf i Ha d nv. l r l 4F. up 3 1 0 ,1 01( D. C. 01 )s c esul c aln e
s ae .
anif n v e Kel , 3 S p. d 0 0 0 E. N. 2 5, u csf l h le g d
e
y
ap r l po esa aj v nl ofn e wh c mmie an n o cd ci a drc ie alf sne c wi o the
aoe r c s s u e ie fe d r o o t d o h miie rme n e ev d ie e tn e t u t
t
h
pos i lt ofpar e.
sbiiy
ol
r le le wih Vigi a' e c i a lgil tveofii l .Ac r ngl De e nti e ild
e if is t r ni s xe utve nd e sai
fc a s co di y, f nda s ntte
t s mmayj g n a amatro 1w f rteEihhAme d n cam.
o u r ud me t s te f a o h g t
n me t li
I .
V
Pl ntf i
ai if nvokest DuePr e sCl us oft Foure nt Am e
he
oc s a e he
te h
ndme butr t aest t
nt
eier t ha
h sa g me t(sn t h tg )h gqb e u a l t o ti p r l . Co e ue ty t ec u tr as
i r u n t o t a he as e n n b e o b an a oe' ns q nl ,h o r te t
i
'
t c a m a a pr ed a ,a nota s t ntve due pr e s c le
he l i s oc ur l nd
ubs a i ,
oc s ha l nge.
Toesa ih m i malpr e alduepr s r quie nt a
t bls ni
oc dur
oce s e r me s boutpa ol t Boa d mus
r e,he r
t
d ç mo et ng r vd qasae n o ra o sid c t t teimaewh p r l h sb e
oç
no r ha p o ie ttme t f e s n n iai o h n t y ao e a e n
ng
de e ' Bl
nid. oodgoodv.Garght 783F. 470,473( hCi.1 ) s eVn v. lne 73
'
ra y,
2d
4t r 986 ; e nn Anceo ,
F.d51 , 2 ( t Ci.1 9 )(G c u ep r l c n ie aina dpaoeis lt p c lyhn eo
3 9 5 2 4h r 9 6 ç a s ao e o sd rto n r l tef y ial ig n
Be
t di c e i r de i i ofpa ol aut ii s i a esge a l pos es no e il m e ,but
he s r tona y c s ons
r e horte , nm t
ner ly s s
ntte nt
o l ad sr ,h tap r l b adwil e iei t erfvo .) s eas Ga tnv. yo , 4 F.d
ny e ie t a ao e o r l d cd n h i a r'; e lo so Ta lr 9 6 2
.
'
3 0, 4 ( t Ci. 9 )( ba c ( oi teei noc n tmto a rg t op r l p rs a d
4 3 4 4h r 1 91 0 n ) n t h r s o si in l ih t ao e e e nd ue
ng
pr s i r uiedonl whe asa ehasc e t d ç l gii aec am ofe il me 't s e
oce s s eq r
y
n tt
r a e ç e tm t l i
a
ntte nt' o om
a p c o paoe .l i n t ip tdt tPlitf r c i dnoie fo teBo r e pli n te
s e t f r l) t s o d s u e ha anif e eve tc s ' m h ad x anig h
r
b s sf rd nyn d sr to r paoe Ac o dn l , fn a t se tte t s mmayj d me t
a e o e ig iceinay r l. c r ig y De e d n i n ild o u r u g n
asa m a t r o 1 w f t Four e nt Am e e c ai .
te f a or he
te h
ndm nt l m
V.
Fo t f rg i r a o s t ec u t rn sDee a tsmoi nfrs mma yj g n .
r he o e ong e s n ,h o r g a t fnd n ' to o u r ud me t
y
E NTER : Thi 7t da ofM a ,2018.
s h y
@
*
*
*
.
Chi fU rie t t
e lt
ae
.
.
7
.
.
. .
' . . ..
i rc J
l t udge '
,
y-')
.k,
1q
5
)
,p
t
$
-' . .
'
'
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?