Babb v. Ratledge
Filing
2
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/9/2017. (slt)
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
CLERI DF GE .
O F/
AT
t & DI COURT
l SK
DM VILE, V
L A
FI
LED
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
JUN 09 2 7
2
J A c.
ULI DUDLG c RK
B ; > <ô
Y>
TORYANO LEM ENT BABB,
DEPUI CL
Y ER
Pet toner,
ii
Ci lA c i n N o.7: c 0017
vi t o
17- v3
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I
N ON
C.RATLEDGE,
Re ponde .
s
nt
By:
H on.Jackson L .K i
ser
Se orUnie St e Dit c Judge
ni
t d at s srit
Tor no Le e Ba a f de ali epr e ng p oK ,tl d ape ii f awrtof
ya
m nt bb, e r nmat oce di r
ie
tton or
i
ha asc puspu s tt 28U. C.j2241.Peii raguest thi i aceai i
be or
ruan o
S.
ttone r
ha s nc r rton s
u c nsi to a be a et esn e cngc u ta ke jlidcin.Peiin rwa n tsn e c d
n o tt in l c us h e tn i o r lc d t s it
u
r
o
tto e s o e tn e
by t sco tbuti pr s l c i a a c r c i na f ciiy w ihi t sdi t i t Thi m a t ri
hi ur
s e enty onfned t or e t o l a lt t n hi s rc . s te s
b f r mefrp ei n r r v e p ru n t Ru e 1b a d4o teRulsGo enngj2 5
e oe o r l a y e iw u s a t o ls () n f h
mi
e v ri
24
tt o r s ubm i son, 1co l t tPe ii r f ist de onsr t
si
Cas . A fe r vi ng Pe ii ne ' s
es 1 t r e ewi
nc ude ha ttone a l o m ta e
a e t lme t or l fv aj2 41 a 1ds s t ep tto wi u p eu ie
n ni e n t ei i 2 , nd imis h eiin t t rj dc .
t
e
ho
1.
Pe ii ralege t thei unl wf ly i ione be us t Unied St t di no ha
ttone l s ha
s a u l mprs d ca e he t
aes d t ve
j rs ito o e t eça dt)o wh r t alg dci t)o c re pt s n t Til 40U. C.
u idcin v r h l n s f ee he l e rmes c u r d t ua t o te
l
e
r
S.
Se to 31 b)' Peiine f t ralge t thi i io ntvi aest Consiui
cin 12( . tto r urhe le s ha s mprs nme olt he
'
ttton,
f d rlsau e , n Ad msv. ie S ae , 9U. 31 31 ( 9 ) Peiin rs e s
e ea ttts a d a
Untd tts 31 S. 2, 2 1 43 . tto e e k
$
i e a er e e fom i a ce a i
mm dit elas r nc r r ton.
I
1.
A dsrc c t ynote eti aj2241peii almptngt i ldaeaco ci
itit our ma
ntran
tton te i o nvai t nviton
unl samoi ptrua t j2255i çi de t o i feci t ts t l lt ofgn
es
ton ls nt o
s çna quae r nef tve o et he egaiy a
1 l 1b p r t ac u't a l teRulsfrj2 5 Cae t aj2 41ha e sp tin a dRul 4pe uisa
Rue () emi o l o ppy h e o 2 4 s s o 2 b a eio , n e n t
s
t
t
c tt dim isaha speii whe i pli ya a st tapeii i no e ildt r le .
our o s s
bea tton
n t anl ppe r ha
ttoner s t ntte o eif
imae s d tn in- 28U. C. 2 5 /) S i v. r sly, 0U. 3 2, 1(9 7 . A
n t'l ee to '
'
S. j 2 5 ; wan P e se 43 S. 7 38 1 7 )
pr edla i di ntt j2255rle ,s , a t saut oflmiainsort r l a i t
oc tr lmpe me o
eif uc s he tt e i tto
h
he ue gans
s c si peiins d e n trn e 52 5rviw çn d q ae' rEnef ci . I r Vil
uc e sve t o , o s o e d r 25 e e ç a e u t'o t fe tve' n e a ,
t
i
i
'
1 5F.d 1 9 ,1 9 n5( t Ci. 9 7 .Th Untd Sae Co r o Ap e l f rteF u t
1 3 1 2 1 4 . 4h r 1 9 ) e ie tts u t f p as o h o rh
Cic thasf t tj2255i i quaea i fe tvet ts t l lt ofac ci
rui
ound ha
s nade t nd ne fci o e the egaiy
onviton
onl w he a p i one s ts s a t e - ts a r
y
n r s r a i ûe hr e par t nda d:
() g tt tme o c n cin s tld 1w o t scruto t e S p e Co r
1 Aj he i f o vito et a f hi ic i r h u rme u t
e
etb ihe t lg l y o t ec n ito ( )s bsq e tt t prs n rsdrc
sa ls d he e ai f h o v cin; 2 u e u n o he io e ' ie t
t
a al a frt j2255 moton,t s tntve lw c nge s h t t t
ppe nd is
i he ubsa i a ha d uc ha he
c
onduc ofwhih t prs ne was c vit d i de d no t be c i i l a
t
c he i o r
on c e s eme t o
rm na ; nd
( )t ep io e c n o stsyt eg tke pigp o iin o j2 5 be a et
3 h rs n r n n t aif h ae e n r vso s f 2 5 c us he
ne r e i no one of c tt tonall w .
w ul s t
ons iu i
a
l r J ,226F. 328, 34 ( h Ci.
n e ones
3d
333- 4t r 2000)
.
Peii rfist add e st s vi ca eorhow hei e ildt r le vi j2241fr
ttone al o r s he a ngs lus
s ntte o eif a
o
alg dd fcsi t c i na j d me t Ac o dn l Peiin rf i t me tteI r J n s
l e ee t n he rmi l u g n . c r igy, tto e al o e h n e o e
e
s
sa adt s o t a j2 5 i i d q aeo ie fciet ts t lg lt o h sc n ito s
tnd r o h w h t 2 5 s na e u t r n fe tv o e the e ai f i o vcin ,
y
hi cl msc nno bead e s unde j2241 a t peii mus bedimis d.
s ai n t
dr sed
r
, nd he tton t s se
111.
I c n l in, ds s tej2 41peiinwi u prj iebe a s Peiin rfist
n o cuso I imis h 2
t o t t eudc c u e t o e al o
t
ho
t
demonsr t a e il me t r i .
ta e n ntte nt o elef
ENTER:Ths61 dyo Jn 2017.
i k a fu e
,
.
S i rUnie Stt sDiti J
o
t d ae srct udge
)
'
' N
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?