Babb v. Ratledge

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/9/2017. (slt)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

CLERI DF GE .
O F/
AT
t & DI COURT
l SK
DM VILE, V
L A
FI
LED

FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

JUN 09 2 7
2
J A c.
ULI DUDLG c RK

B ; > <ô
Y>

TORYANO LEM ENT BABB,

DEPUI CL
Y ER

Pet toner,
ii

Ci lA c i n N o.7: c 0017
vi t o
17- v3
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I
N ON

C.RATLEDGE,
Re ponde .
s
nt

By:

H on.Jackson L .K i
ser
Se orUnie St e Dit c Judge
ni
t d at s srit

Tor no Le e Ba a f de ali epr e ng p oK ,tl d ape ii f awrtof
ya
m nt bb, e r nmat oce di r
ie
tton or
i

ha asc puspu s tt 28U. C.j2241.Peii raguest thi i aceai i
be or
ruan o
S.
ttone r
ha s nc r rton s

u c nsi to a be a et esn e cngc u ta ke jlidcin.Peiin rwa n tsn e c d
n o tt in l c us h e tn i o r lc d t s it
u
r
o
tto e s o e tn e
by t sco tbuti pr s l c i a a c r c i na f ciiy w ihi t sdi t i t Thi m a t ri
hi ur
s e enty onfned t or e t o l a lt t n hi s rc . s te s

b f r mefrp ei n r r v e p ru n t Ru e 1b a d4o teRulsGo enngj2 5
e oe o r l a y e iw u s a t o ls () n f h
mi
e v ri
24
tt o r s ubm i son, 1co l t tPe ii r f ist de onsr t
si
Cas . A fe r vi ng Pe ii ne ' s
es 1 t r e ewi
nc ude ha ttone a l o m ta e

a e t lme t or l fv aj2 41 a 1ds s t ep tto wi u p eu ie
n ni e n t ei i 2 , nd imis h eiin t t rj dc .
t
e
ho
1.

Pe ii ralege t thei unl wf ly i ione be us t Unied St t di no ha
ttone l s ha
s a u l mprs d ca e he t
aes d t ve

j rs ito o e t eça dt)o wh r t alg dci t)o c re pt s n t Til 40U. C.
u idcin v r h l n s f ee he l e rmes c u r d t ua t o te
l
e
r
S.
Se to 31 b)' Peiine f t ralge t thi i io ntvi aest Consiui
cin 12( . tto r urhe le s ha s mprs nme olt he
'
ttton,

f d rlsau e , n Ad msv. ie S ae , 9U. 31 31 ( 9 ) Peiin rs e s
e ea ttts a d a
Untd tts 31 S. 2, 2 1 43 . tto e e k
$

i e a er e e fom i a ce a i
mm dit elas r nc r r ton.
I
1.

A dsrc c t ynote eti aj2241peii almptngt i ldaeaco ci
itit our ma
ntran
tton te i o nvai t nviton
unl samoi ptrua t j2255i çi de t o i feci t ts t l lt ofgn
es
ton ls nt o
s çna quae r nef tve o et he egaiy a
1 l 1b p r t ac u't a l teRulsfrj2 5 Cae t aj2 41ha e sp tin a dRul 4pe uisa
Rue () emi o l o ppy h e o 2 4 s s o 2 b a eio , n e n t
s
t
t
c tt dim isaha speii whe i pli ya a st tapeii i no e ildt r le .
our o s s
bea tton
n t anl ppe r ha
ttoner s t ntte o eif

imae s d tn in- 28U. C. 2 5 /) S i v. r sly, 0U. 3 2, 1(9 7 . A
n t'l ee to '
'
S. j 2 5 ; wan P e se 43 S. 7 38 1 7 )
pr edla i di ntt j2255rle ,s , a t saut oflmiainsort r l a i t
oc tr lmpe me o
eif uc s he tt e i tto
h
he ue gans

s c si peiins d e n trn e 52 5rviw çn d q ae' rEnef ci . I r Vil
uc e sve t o , o s o e d r 25 e e ç a e u t'o t fe tve' n e a ,
t
i
i
'

1 5F.d 1 9 ,1 9 n5( t Ci. 9 7 .Th Untd Sae Co r o Ap e l f rteF u t
1 3 1 2 1 4 . 4h r 1 9 ) e ie tts u t f p as o h o rh
Cic thasf t tj2255i i quaea i fe tvet ts t l lt ofac ci
rui
ound ha
s nade t nd ne fci o e the egaiy
onviton
onl w he a p i one s ts s a t e - ts a r
y
n r s r a i ûe hr e par t nda d:

() g tt tme o c n cin s tld 1w o t scruto t e S p e Co r
1 Aj he i f o vito et a f hi ic i r h u rme u t
e
etb ihe t lg l y o t ec n ito ( )s bsq e tt t prs n rsdrc
sa ls d he e ai f h o v cin; 2 u e u n o he io e ' ie t
t
a al a frt j2255 moton,t s tntve lw c nge s h t t t
ppe nd is
i he ubsa i a ha d uc ha he
c
onduc ofwhih t prs ne was c vit d i de d no t be c i i l a
t
c he i o r
on c e s eme t o
rm na ; nd

( )t ep io e c n o stsyt eg tke pigp o iin o j2 5 be a et
3 h rs n r n n t aif h ae e n r vso s f 2 5 c us he
ne r e i no one of c tt tonall w .
w ul s t
ons iu i
a

l r J ,226F. 328, 34 ( h Ci.
n e ones
3d
333- 4t r 2000)
.
Peii rfist add e st s vi ca eorhow hei e ildt r le vi j2241fr
ttone al o r s he a ngs lus
s ntte o eif a
o

alg dd fcsi t c i na j d me t Ac o dn l Peiin rf i t me tteI r J n s
l e ee t n he rmi l u g n . c r igy, tto e al o e h n e o e
e
s
sa adt s o t a j2 5 i i d q aeo ie fciet ts t lg lt o h sc n ito s
tnd r o h w h t 2 5 s na e u t r n fe tv o e the e ai f i o vcin ,
y
hi cl msc nno bead e s unde j2241 a t peii mus bedimis d.
s ai n t
dr sed
r
, nd he tton t s se
111.

I c n l in, ds s tej2 41peiinwi u prj iebe a s Peiin rfist
n o cuso I imis h 2
t o t t eudc c u e t o e al o
t
ho
t
demonsr t a e il me t r i .
ta e n ntte nt o elef

ENTER:Ths61 dyo Jn 2017.
i k a fu e
,

.

S i rUnie Stt sDiti J
o
t d ae srct udge

)

'

' N