Knight v. Cutchens et al

Filing 24

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/27/2017. (tvt)

z FRK' oFFlz :, nmm r. r
N S
ce y.
G
AT ROANOK:,
'VA

Flio
t
-

J 2? 2 1
UL
27
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I C O U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E D I SI N
VI O

W I ER JEROM E KM GHT,
LM

B I ,
Y
#ULA
:

CASE NO.7:
17CV002
31

Pl ntif
ai f ,

M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

V.

A.
CUTCHENS, AL.
c
,
D ef
endant
.

By: G l n E.C onrad
e
U nie St t D i t c Judge
t d a es s ri t

W ime J r
l r e ome Kni ,a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl d t s aci n t r42
ght
r ni nma e oc edi
o
ie hi to mde
.

U. C.j1 3 algi t tprs ofii sbr
S.
98 le ng ha ion fcal oughtaf s dici i y chage a ns hi f
ale s plnm' r gai t m or
o c neac s r t it d a i thi by brngi an addii na dicplna y c r a ns hi f
bs e
t, eala e gans m
i ng
to l s i i r ha ge gai t m or

flngc mpli saboutt i ta i i n unde t Pds Ra Elmi tonAc (TREA') a
ii o ant
he niil ncde t r he on pe i nai
t1
', nd
ca e hi t be pl c i s e t d c
us d m o
a ed n egr ga e onfne
ment Kni tha notpr pad t r quiie flng
.
gh s
e i he e st ii

f a a i t pr e L f mapa rs
ee nd pples o oce d q or
upei.Uponr viw oft rc d,t c ttndst tt
ee
he e or he our i ha he

a to mu tbes mmmiy d s se wi u prj d c b s d o Kng tsp ircvi a to st a
cin s u
l imis d t t eu ie a e n ih ' ro i l cin h t
ho
ha bee dimi s d asfi ousorf rf itr t sae cai .
ve n s s e
rvol
o alle o tt l m

ThePrs Lii to Reonn Actof 1 s tntal n nde t t f ma pa rs
ion tgain f
995 ubsa ily me d he q or
upei

sate 28 U.. j 1 5 Th p r s o t e Ac wa t rq ie alp io rl ia t s i
ttt,
z
SC. 91 . e upo e f h t s o e ur l rs ne i g n s ung
t
gover nte ii s o ofi a st pa flng f s i 1 1,eihe t ough pr pay e ort oug
nme ntte r fcil o y i ee n 1 t r hr
e m nt hr h

i sal ns wih ed fo t e l ia ts imae tu ta c u t j 1 5 b . S cin 1 5 g
n tlme t t h l ' m h i g n ' n t r s c o n . 91 ( ) e to 91 ()
r
t
de est i t lm e pa e m ehod t prs r who ha Ghr e srkes'- t epls ne s
ni he nsal nt ym nt t
o ione s
ve ç e ti '
t
hos i o r
w ho ha ha t e pr vi ca es or a al di m i s as f i ous m a i i ,orf f l e t
ve d hr e e ous s
ppe s s s ed r vol , lc ous
or aiur o

saeacam, ne stet re srk ri maes o tmmie t a e o s ro sp y ia ij r .
tt li u ls h h e -tie n t h ws l n n d ng r f eiu h sc ln u y'
i
'
j 1 5( .
91 g)

,

.

Kni hasbr ugh s h a tonsora a son t e orm or prorocc sons Se Kni ht
ght
o t uc c i
ppe l
hr e
e i
ai . e g

v Va o e , .7 1 CV0 3 7( . Va Oc.1 , 01 )( imisd wi o tp eu ieu d r2
. n v r No :2 0 3 W D. . t 9 2 2 d s se t u rj dc n e 8
h
U. C.j1 1 A( )1 a fi oo s;Knc tv W o d No.3:0 0 51 ( D.Va J n.
S.
9 5 b ( ) s rv lu ) ih . o v,
1 CV0 3 E.
.a
2 2 ( imis dt e 2 U.. j 1 5 b ( )f rf i let saea cam a tro po t t t
01 ) ds s e md r 8 SC. 91 A()1 o alr o tt li fe p rt y o
t
mi
n n ) Kn g tv. o n o , . 1 CV6 ( D. . e t 1 2 1 ( imisd u d r2 . S.
me d ; ih J h sn No 3:0 48 E. Va S p . 4, 01 d s se n e 8U. C.
)
j1 5 b ( )f rf i l t saeacam a tro p ru t t n n ) Ac o dngy Kng tma
91 A( )1 o alr o tt li fe p o tni o me d . c r i l, ih y
te
y
pr e j f mapaupei ( t prpay ntoft flng fe onl i he c s t the
oc ed . or
n
rs wihout e me
he ii e ) y f an how ha

fc si ne t a e o s ro p y ia ij r .j 1 5 g .
a e mmi n d ng r f eius h sc ln u y 91 ( )
Kni ht s c r nt a l ga i do not s
g ' ur e le tons
ugge t t he w as i i m i nt dange of a
s hat
n m ne
r
ny

p ysc lijly rltd t h scams a t tme h fld h s c mp an . Be a s t rc r s
h ia nt eae o i li t he i e ie i o lit c u e he e o d
r
r fe tt tKn g th sa lattr eçt s' nd rj 1 5 g a dheh sno d mo tae t t
elc ha i h a t e s h e G dke'u e 91 ( ) n
s
a t e nsr td ha
hei i i ne da rofphysc lhnm,t cou tdeni hi t opporuniy t pr ee L
s n mmi nt nge
ia r he r
es m he
t t o oc d q

f r p u ei a d ds se t ec mplitwih u p eu iet e j 1 5 g . An a p o rae
o ma a p rs n imis s h o an to t rj dc md r 91 ( )
p r p it
or rwilis t sda
de l s ue hi y.
The Clr i diec e t s nd c e oft sm e andum opi on a ac ompa ng
e k s r t d o e opi s hi mor
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .
EN TER: Thi
s

$* d yo J y 2017.
a f ul,
Unie St t sDititJ e
t d a e src udg