Reedy et al v. The Bank of Wells Fargo et al
Filing
22
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/5/2018. (ck)
I TlI u w lrs o STATES D ISTRI CO U RT cL m
N -E
z
CT
ua
FOR THE W STERN DI UCT OF W RGI A
STI
NI
so o:uy as c a
Ao c
rR
ju or v
ROA
NOU DI SON
VII
/su'a
làiy
uo
x
NAZ û 2 1
22
REA GAN D W AYN E RE ED Y and
SU SAN AN N E TTE RE EDY ,
DU
B J L C.
:
DE
t LERK
,
i CLERK
Pi ntfs
ai if y
Ci lActon N o.7:7- 00
vi
i
1 CV- 238
V.
t
T H E BAN K O F W E LLS IARG O ,
R
et a1y
.
By:
Mi
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
Cli fUG t d St t sDi ti t udge
ze
e a e src l
D ef
endant
s.
M E M O RAN D U M O PI ION
N
-
Pr K pli f Re g n Dwa neRe d a S a An teRe d rRe d s' b i g
o
andfs a a
y
e y nd usn net e y f e y 7 rn
)
.
t i a to s edn i jnciea de lrt r rle a ii gou oft f r cos eoft er
hs cin e l g nu t nd ca ao y eif rsn t he o e l uz h i
v
pr r yl a ed i Pulsd,Vig ni ECF N o.1,a 2.The alge t tdef nda sTheBa
ope t oc t n a l r i a.
t
y le ha
e nt
nk
ofW el Fa g r el Fa g ? Mo ta eElcz i Re ita n S tm (MERS' S mua
l r o Y l r o), rg g e ton c gsrdo yse T
s
s
T
' a l
)
W hie Es , SA Funci Co1 ,a D oe 1- vi a ed t Trzh i Le ngA c
t , q.U
lng ' nd
p.
s 100 olt he tt n ndi
t
(< LA') oae t Re l tt Sete nta Pr e rsAc (RES ) a de a e
<
Tl ) viltd he a Esae tlme nd ocdu e t T PA'> n ng g d
f
i fa and unfi a dec ptvebusne spr c i s t Re
n r ud
ar nd e i
i s a tce ; he edysa s s k t qui tdea
lo ee o et i nd
cni unc c ona lt ECF N o.1,a 1 1 Cur e l pe lng bef e t c ta e t
lm
ons i biiy.
t , 4. r nty nci
or he our t he
Re d smoto f rtmp ayr sri n o d ra prl nayijnci a moin f
e y' in o e orr etanig r e nd ei r nu t nd to or
mi
on
s m mayjd m e ( No . & 6 , ndW el Fag a M ERS moto t c s s t
u r u g nt ECF s 2 )a
ls r o nd
' in o l mis he
i
c mpli u e Fe rl l ofCiiPr e u e1 $()a mot t srk pli ifs
o ant nd r dea Rue vl oc d r 24 6 nd i o tie antf'
on
f ngs ECF N os 7 & 16. s m otonsw e er e r d t U nied St t M a sr t Robe tS.
i .
.
The e
i
r ef r e o
t
a es gita e
r
Balufrrpo ta drc mme to pusa t 2 U. C. 6 6 $() . No. 1
l o e r n e o ndain, t u nt o 8 S. j 3 4 17) ECF
o
1.
I arpo ta rc
n e r nd eomme to is do De e r1 , 1 ,h maitaej g
ndain sue n cmbe 2 20 7 te gsrt ud e
rc mme de t g t c r d nyt eRe d s mot f zi j c i z l fa s
e o n d h t he ou t e - e y ' i o nun t ei nd umma y
h
ons
ve e
r
jd me , sns al ev ddee da swilo tprj ie a g a W elFag ' a
u g ntdiris lunsr e fn nt t u eudc , nd rnt ls ros nd
a
M ERS'm oton t dir s butal t Re 'l ve t fl a a ende c
i o snis
low he edys ea o ie n m
d ompl nt
ai
r gar ng a cam sf r c s i unde TI .ECF N o.18. r tga notc t t
e di ny li or es i son
r LA
The epor ve ie o he
p r st a t e ha f re n d y wi nwhih t f ea yo e do .TheRe d s
a ée h t h y d ou te a s t
hi c o l n bjc ns
l
ey
t e e fe fld lt o e to t t r po t( No 1 )1a W el Fag a MERS
h r atr i ae bjci ns o he e r ECF . 9 , nd ls r o nd
e
r s nde o a ua y3 20 8 ECF No. 0
e po d nl n r , 1 .
2.
Fort r as s f t beow ,t c twilAD O PT t r por and
he e ons et or h l
he our l
he e t
r c mme ai t t e tn c nsse wih t so i i n ( No. 8 ,
e o nd ton o he x e t o itnt t hi p n o ECF
1 ) GRANT i pa t
n r
W el Fag sa M ERS mot t dsnis( CF No. ) a DEN Y t Re d s mot
ls r o' nd
' i o ir s '
on
E
7 , nd
he e y ' i
on
frs mmayj g n a mot frtmpo ayrsrii o d ra dp ei nay
o u r ud me t nd i o e tr etanng r e n rl r
on
mi
ij do ECF Nos 2, . c ur as wi pr vi t Re d swih la t a ndt
nunc n.
. 6 The o t lo l o de he e y t e ve o me he
l
c pl i pur ua t t c tsopi on.
om ant s nt o he our' ni
1.
Rue7 oft Fe êl lso CiiPr c duep r t apat t Ce v a d fe
l 2$) he dea Rue f vl o e r emis ry o f r e n l
s
l
s cf wrte ob e ton 't ama itaej g ' pr e fncng a r c n e éo
pe ik, itn jci s; o gsrt ud es oposd l l s nd e o manda ns
i
wihi f t e da ofbe ng s r d wih acopy oft r por .Se a s 28U . C.
t n our e n ys
i e ve t
he e t e lo
S.
j6 6 $()Th Fou t Cic iha hedta a o e é p rymus d s f t s hce
3 q 1. e rh rut s l h t n bjc ng at
t o o f . uf int
wih
s ci t s a r a on bl t ae tt dsrc c u toft tu g ou f rt eo e t '
pe i y o s e s a y o lz he itit o r he r e r nd o h bjcbn.
ki
:
1 Re d ss b l tdt ero jcin atrt fu te - a d a l p o ie b 2 U.. j6 6
The e y u ni e h i b e t s fe he o te n d y e di z vd d y 8 SC. 3 .
t
o
ne
Ast objci aemeils a donotafc t c tsrviw oft ma itaej gesrpo t
he e tons r rtes nd
fe t he our' e e
he gsrt ud ' e r
a rc
nd e omme don,defnda saenotprj c dbyc i rdon oft objc .
nda
e nt r
eudie
onsdea
he e dons
Uni dSae v Mi et, 7 F. 61 ,6 (t Ci. 0 7, etde e 1 7S. . 0 2
t tts . d te 4 8 3d 6 22 4h r2 0 )c r nid, 2 Ct3 3
e
(0 7 .
20)
To c ude ot r s woul def a t put e ofr quii
oncl
he wie
d e t he pos
e rng
obe do . ewo l bepe itn apat y a pe la is e
jc ns W
ud
= tig ry o p a ny su
t a wa beo e t ma itae j g ,r g r ls oft e naur
h t s f r he gsr t ud e e a de s h t e
a sop ofobe t ma e t tema itaejd ' rpo t
nd c e
jci
ons d o h gsrt u ges e r.
Eihe t diti tcouz w oul t n ha t r viw e r i s
t r he src
t
d he ve o e e ve y s ue
i t ma itae j g ' p o e fn n s a d
n he
gsr t ud es z posd i dig
n
r com m e
e
ndaéons oz cot s of a a s woul be r t d t
ut
ppe l
d
equie o
r viw i s t tt diti tcouz ne r consde e I et r
e e s ues ha he stc
t ve
i r d. n ihe
c s ,jciilr s uz e wo l b wa td a d t dsrc c u ts
a e u l a e o c s ud e se n he itit o r'
c
e fci ne s b s d o h l fom ma itae j g s wo d be
fe t s a e n ep z
ve
g srt ud e ul
unde nane
r i d.
J.Thecsrc c t tmus deen i éqno o a ypo éo oft ma itaej d ' r po t
-a l tit oz
d
i
r t tt lne
v n r n he gsrt u ges e r
a drc
n e omme ai t whihap o e o jci h sbe nma e ff edstc c ur ma
nd ton o c r p r be t a e d .ç' itit o t y
on
'h
a c p,ee to mo f t r c mme dds i n; eevefrhe e ie c ; rtz
ce trjc, r diy he e o nde iposdo rci u t r vd n e or eun
t matrt t maitaej g wihi tu to . Fe R. v. 7 9 3; c o d28
he te o he gsrt ud e t nsz cins' d. Ci P. 2 $() ac r
'
U.. j6 69 1.' nea o e t t tmeeyrieaeagu n sprsne t'h
SC. 3 $() T rl bjci ha rl etr t r me t ee td ote
Ge
ons
ma itaejd lc t s cfct r q ie u e Rul 7 , ndha t smee f c a a
gsz t u ge a k he pe iiiy e u rd nd r e 2 a ve he a fe t s
fi r t o e t o a awave ofs h o e to 'M o n v.
al e o bjc , r s i r uc bjci n. o BWX Te hs, nc, 4 F. u
u
:
c .I .7 2 S pp.
2d8 , 29( D. . 1 )(ingVe v Asr e 5 F. u 2 8 ,8 5( D. .
27 8 W. Va 20 0 ci
ne . tu , 39 S pp. d 41 4 W. Va
20 8 a fd 49 F. ' 2 ( h Ci. 0 2 ; e as Tho sv. n, 7 U.. 4 , 5
0 :, f', 8 Appx 68 4t r 2 1 ) s e lo ma Ar 4 4 S 1 0 1 4
(9 5() (rl saut do sno r qz et j g t rv e a is ..no o i no
1 8 3) f lhe tt e e t e lr he ud e o e iw n sue4 v f
f
i
.
:
obe to ae fe p
jcins r i d.
l ).
Furh r obe ton t tonyr pe tag me t r ie be o et ma itaejdg a e
t e , jci s ha l e a r u n s as d f t he g sr t u e r
c nsd r d g nea o e to t t e tt t o t r po ta d r c
o i e e e rl bjc ins o he n iey f he e r n e omme do S eVe ,
nda n. e ne
539 F.Supp.2d a 845.Ast c ztnot d i Vene :
t
he otr
e n
A lowi a ltga t obt i dq novo rviw ofhe entt ca e
l ng ii nt o
an .
-e e
r ie s
.
b me eyr f matn a e rirb ifa a o e éo T kgs
y z l eor tig n al re s n bjc n f e)
e
ma
t i ta r e e t t m a itat us es .The f tons of
he nii l efr nce o he g sr e el s
unc i
t diti cour az e f évey duplc t as l0t1 t
he s rct
t e fec l
ia ed
n 1 he
m a s t t a t diti c tpe f m i ntc l t s .Thi
gita e nd he srct our r or de ia a ks
s
d lcton oft a efr watsj iilrs t e rt r
upiai
i nd fo t se udca e ouc s ahe
me
f
han s vi t , a r
a ng hem nd uns conta y t t pur es of t
r r o he
pos
he
M a itae Ac. Ho r g S c ofHe lh & Huma Se v .
gsrt s t' wa d v. e '
'
at
n r s,
)
9 2F.d g0 ) 5 9g6hCi.1 1
3 2 5 5, 0 (t r 99 j.
539 F.
Supp. a 8 A pl néf who r ie a e li pr vi l r ie a gu ent wilnotbe
2d t 46. ai f
et z t s ls e ousy as d r m s l
gve fhes c d bt a t a eg h s e . 1 . nse d hi t -le b ifwi bete td
i n f e on ie t he ppl j e e ks' d I ta , s e fld re l t ae
t
'
l
a ag nea obe to whihh st smeefc a afi z t o e t1
s e rl jcin, c a he a fe t s al e o bjc.d.
u
11 .
1
Thec ur ha rviwe t Re d s o e t t t ma itaej gesr po ta
o t s e e d he e y ' bjci o he gstt ud ' e r nd
ons
r c mme da n a f st i o jc
e o n éo nd i her b e donst bee tr l wih tme i. t rt n a d e s
nd
o n iey t ou rt Rahe ha d r s
t lg l i i e a c s lw s l l fa nn t ma itaejdg ' r po t n
he e a prncpls nd a e a oi y r ni g he gst t u es e r a d
d
rc mme dain,heRed sakt c ur t indt tilc sjrsito dept fl gs t
e o n to t e y s he o t o i ha ta k t idcin s ie in ui
z
i
i t scitit Se Ans t Re t& Re om m e ton by H on.
n hi ls rc . e wez o por
c
nda i
Robe tS. lou.ECF
r Bal
No.1 , t1 TheRe dy b oa l agu t tf d r l o rsd no ha ejds ito t he t
9a .
e s r dy r e ha e e a c u t o t v u dcin o a
ac i outi oft Diti tofCol bi .I a 1 6.
tons sde he szc
um a d. t -2,
Fe rlc urstpetdyh verjce ag me t ta t yb oa l lc jrs ido
dea o t e ae l a ee td r u ns h the z dy a k lidc n.
z
Se e .Unt dS ae v. r i , 71 CR0 00 , 0 3WL 1 3 6 , t* ( . Va
e . , ie t ts Had n No. :3 0 8 2 1
8 25 4 a 1 W D. .
Ma 1 2 3 (e iwig c s sr jcig smi zjrs ito lag me t a va e b
y , 01 ) r ve n a e ee tn i l u id cina r u n s d nc d y
a
p o nt oft s ve eg ctz nm o e e ) Quge v. ihne , o. : -CV- 3
r pone s he o r in iie v m nt; ily Get z N .09
1
29 -
REB, 0 0WL 3 1 9 , t 1 ( I a S pt 8 2 0 r e Eo e eg cdz n lg l h o y
21
6 3 01 a * D. d ho e . , 01 ) Th s v rin i e j e a t e r
(1al isvai usf r )ha be n stlkdo c itnt b t c urs'. c s t t
/ lof t ro o ms s e tnc wn onsse l y he o t. The a e ha
y
)
'
'
s
t Re dysct i t i obi donsdoe nots
he e
ie n her ec
s
uppor t i poséon.l Urie St t v.
t he. i
r
n lt d a es
Tr wb i e 5 F. p' 29 , 9 (t Ci. 01 ) t eFit Cic i Co r of pe l f un
o rd , 91 Ap x 8 2 9 5 h r 2 5, h fh r ut u t Ap as o d
t t def ndantsTa gum e t thei notactze oft U nied St e i e ly
hat he e
'
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?