Dutton v. Unknown

Filing 20

ORDER denying 18 Motion to Eradicate; denying 19 Motion to Reverse. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/27/2018. (aab)

CLERK' OFFI U. . ST COURT
S
CE S DI .
AT m
Oc ,V
A
FI
LED

I TH E UN I ED STATE S D I
N
T
STR I C O U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O

d2v 22 2 1
22
JUL

.
DU EY CLERK

BY:

.

EPUW CIE .
.

ROBERT ALLEN DUTTON ,
Pettoner,
ii
V.

U N K N OW N ,
R e po nt
s nde .

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Ci lA c i n N o.7: 7c 258
vi t o
1 v00

By:M i hae F.U r
c l
bansd
l
Chi fU ni e St esD i t i tJudge
e
t d at
src

Thi m a tri be or t cour on pr #tpe ii ne Robe t l n Du t stfh a sxt
s te s f e he
t
o
tto r
r Ale
ton' s t nd i h
..

m oto f r c i e ai n oft or re t r d onAug t1, 7, s isnghi peii f a
i ns or e ons d r to
he de n e e
us 201 dim s i s tton or
wltofha asco pusasuntmel Duton not hi dis tsaci n wih t dimis la t
i
be
r
i y. t
es s s ai f to t he s s a nd he
denil ofhi va i s e
as
s rous ubs quen motons a a tmpt t r - r cai sr ied i hi orgi
t i , nd te s o e a gue l m a s n s i nal

p t in.çlq fr ap ryma s e rle u d rRu e6 09, p rymu tfrts o ii ln s ,
ei o tB e o e a t y e k eif n e l 0 a a t s is h w t ie s
t
g
me

ameio iusd fns , lc o t arp eu iet t o p sn pa t, n e c pina
rt ro ee e a a k f mfi rj dc o he p o ig ry a d x e to l
cru tn e .'Do l v. aeFnm Fie& Ca . t .ns Co.9 3F.d4 , 8( t Ci.
ic msa c s' wel Stt r r
'
s Au o I . , 9 2 6 4 4h r
1 9 )(uoigW e n rv Cabo 7 F.d2 4 2 7(t Ci. 98 ).Du tnfist ma et i
9 3 q tn r e . r , 31 2 0 , 0 4h r 1 4 ) to al o k hs
s wi a a moton f r c i r to t t%i not ngm o et n ar que tt tt d src
ho ng, nd
i or e onsde ai n ha ss hi
r ha e s ha he itit

c u t ha g ismid'sno a to ie UntdS ae v. il ms 6 4F.d31 , 3( t Ci.
o r c n e t n 'i t uh rz d. ie tts W li , 7 2 0 31 4h r
n
1 8 ) M o e ve, to d dn ta p a teds s a o d r a dt eç ln ay d lb rt,r e
9 2 . r o r Du tn i o p e lh imis l r e, n h ç u tr , ei eae fe
vo

(n jt r mmee c oc no t a pe lheo iia j g n o o d rc n tetb ihab ss
a d mtn ld h ie t o p a t rgn lud me t r r e n no sa ls a i
f rRul 6 r l f' Aie sv I r m, 2F.d4 6 5 ( t Ci. 1 (ne l u tto
o e 0 ei . k n .nc n 65 3 9 , 01 4h r 201 ) i tma q oain
e'
mak o te ) Fnal , to fist etbl hav ldb ssf r h u esg e src s l
r s mitd . i ly Du tn al o sa i ai a i o t e nd rin d' e u a.
s
Se pe. , uev. ve ha, F. 567,572- (t Ci. 1 ( susi r uie nt fr
e g.Bel Le nt l640 3d
74 4h r 201 ) dic sng eq rme s o

j d ca rc s l.Ac o dngy ii hee yORDERED t a Du tn' ffh a dsxhmoin fr
u iil e u a) c r i l ,t s r b
h t to s it n i t to s o
rc nsd r to ( No .1 a d 1 )a eDENI
e o i eain ECF s 8 n 9 r
ED.

ENTER:ThsJ 7 d yo No mb r20 8
i
a f ve e, 1 .

f
*f

D rV '
V

Chi fU nie t e D i ti tJ
e
te a s sr c udge
.

.

'