Graves v. Kiser

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/17/2018. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI u. Dl GDur
B
Ct ö, 5T.
AT DANVI E,
LL VA
FI
LED

I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DI
STR I C O UR T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRICT O F V IR G I IA
N
R O AN O K E DI SI N
W O

J 1? 2 1
UL
22
JL i I ,
u
j

BK

j

D

GR E G O RY D .G R AV ES,
Pe ii r
tt one ,

Ci lA ct on N o.
vi
i
Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00 3
vi t on
17- v- 26

V.

M EM OR AN DU M O PI ON
M

JEFFREY B.I SER,
G
R es
pondent.

By:

L

Hon.Jac o L.K ie
ks n
sr
Se or U nie St e D i t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

Gr r D .Gr ve ,a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl ape ii f wrtof
ego y
a s
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ied
tton or i
.

h b a c pusp ru n t 2 U. C. 2 5 , h l n i hi M a 4, 0 ,u g nse trdb
aes o
u s a t o 8 S. j 2 4 c al gng s y 20 0 j d me t ne e y
e
t Cic tCour oft Ciy ofDaw il f sa ut y btr a y,a tmpt d r pe,a a tmpt d
he r ui
t he t
l le or tt or lglr te e a
nd te e

s d my Ids se t ep tto wi o t rj d c a s c si i J l 2 7 a t eCo r o
o o . imis d h eiin t u p eu ie s uc e sve n uy 01 , nd h u t f
h
Appe l f t Fourh Ci c tdi m i s d t a alf l k ofa ce tf c t ofa a a lt a
a s or he
t r ui s s e he ppe or ac
rii a e ppe l biiy nd
de e a m o i n t fl a s ce sve pe ii
ni d
t o o ie uc s i
tton.

l J n 2 8 Peiin rfldamoinf rr c n ieainpls a t oRue6 ()a da
n u e 01 , tto e ie
to o e o sd rto t u n t l 0b n
r
m oton t a ntc
i o ppoi ouns l Pe ii rdoesnotc le t di pos ton oft pe ii butr t r
e . ttone
ha l nge he s ii
he tton
a he
r i es ane c ai a
as
w l m bouta a alf om t s a e ti lco t A c or ngl t e m oto a e
n ppe r he t t r a ur . c di y, hes
i ns r

pr ryc tue a ane colaealatc purua t 28U. C.j225 a t Clr s l
ope l onsr d s w ltr ta k s nt o
S.
4, nd he ek hal
pl c t m i a ne ci la ton. Se eM, l e o v. o o ,5 3U. 5 8 5 4 ( 9 8 ;.s
a e he n
w vi c i
e. ..Càd r n Th mps n 2 S. 3 , 5 1 9 ) P
.
f
-

Unie S ae v W i so k, 40F. d2 0 2 7( t Ci. 0 )
td tts . net c 3
3 0 , 0 4h r 20 3 .
Cour rc dsi c t t tPeii rprviusy fl aj2254peiin a t s me
t e or ndiae ha ttone e o l ied
tto bouthe a
convi i i Ci lA cton N o.7: cvctons n vi
i
03- 00255. Thus,Pettoner' cur entpett on i a
ii
s r
ii s

s b e u n o , al u d rt p o bto i 28U. C. 2 4 ( )a ans as c n o
u s q e t ne f lng n e he rhiiin n
i
S. j 2 4 b g i t e o d r
s ce svepeii Se e. ,Grve v.Commo a1h,No. 1
uc si tton. e, c. a s
nwe t
7:3cv486,si op. t1( . Va.
lp a W D.
J n. 201 ( s si j225 peii wihoutprj cea s c sve ,a aldimis d,
a 2, 4) dimisng
4 tton t
eudi s uc esi ) ppe s se No.

1 - 0 (t Ci. r 2 , 1 ) ls a t oj2 4 (9, fd r l ititc u t yc n ie a
4 6 71 4 h r Ap . 2 20 4 .Pt u n t 2 41 a e e a d src o r ma o sd r
r
s ondors c svej2254peii onl upons cfcçetfc ton fom aUniedSttsCour
ec
uc esi
tton y
pe ii riiai r
t ae
t
ofAppea s. Bec us Pe ii rhasnots it d a e de e t the hasobt i t t
l
a e ttone
ubm te ny vi nc ha
a ned ha

c riiai n 1ds s t n w c laea atc wi o t eu iea s c e sv .Ba e u o t
e t c to , imis he e oltr l ta k t u prj d c s u c si e sd p n he
f
h
fndi t tt Pe ii rha no ma t r ui ie s tnta s
i ng ha he ttone s t de he eq st ubsa il howi ofade a ofa
ng
ni l

c tmto lrg asrquie by28U. C.j2253/)a Sl kv.M c ni ,529U. 473,48
onsi ina iht e rd
S.
nd ac
Da el
S.
4

( 0 0 , c riiaeo a p aa ii i d ne
i 0 ) a e t c t f p e lb ly s e id.
f
t
Ex TsR : 'hi
r s

1 A
- .
..
.-

da ofJ y,201
y
ul
8.
o

a
p

'

x

Se i U nie St t sD i t i tJ e
or t d a e s rc udg

2