Graves v. Kiser

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/11/2017. (mlh)

Gk Nl@gF I M..14,çQKV
: . FCR h 4 7 '
f
:

htR C ,' '.
r INVIW'Y
FI:R
L

.

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROANOKX DI SI
VI ON

.

- *

J l$ 2 1
%L
C?
*

.

JULI C. U E% CLERK
A

BY;

.

E

GREG ORY D.GM VES,
Pe ii r
tt one ,

CL

Ci lA c i n N o.7: - vvi t o
17 c 00263
M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

JEFFREY B.K I
SER,
R espondent
.

By:

H on. ks n L.K i e
Jac o
sr
Se or Unied St esD i t i Judge
ni
t
at
s r ct

Gr gor D . r ves a V i gi a i a e pr ee ng pr K , ie apeii n f wrtof
e y G a , r ni nm t oc di
o fld
tto or i
.

h be sc r u pls n t 2 U. C. 2 4, haln igh sM a 4 2 0 ,ud me t e trdb
a a o p s t ua t o 8 S. j 25 c le gn i y , 0 0 j g n s n ee y
r
t Ci c tCo toft Ciy ofD a le f r s a ut r bur l r a t m pt d r pe a a tm p e
he r ui ur
he t
nvil o t t o y g a y, te e a , nd te t d

s
odomy.Pe ii rst c am sr lt t det i nc e a r ntbe or t sa ec i i l
ttone ' wo l i ea e o k e i s ppa e
f e he t t rm na

j d me twa e tr d.Cf UntdS ae v. iso 7 4F.d2 , 6 ( t Ci. 01 )
u g n s ne e
. ie tts Hartn, 5 3 58 2 2 4h r 2 0 .
Co r rc r si iaet a p tto e p e o syfldaj2 5 p tto a o t h s me
u t e o d ndc t h t eiin r rviu l ie
2 4 eiin b u t e n
c c i nji Ci lAc i N o.7: - vonvi t o n vi ton
03 c 00255. Thus pe ii r sc r ntpe ii i a
, ttone ' ur e
tton s

s eq ntone, alngunde t pr biin i 28U. C.j2244(9 a i tas co or
ubs ue
f li
r he ohi to n
S.
1 gans e nd

s c siep t in.S e eg,Gr v sv. mmo at No. 1 c,8 , l o a 1( . Va
uc e sv ei o e , .. a e Co nwe 1
t
h, 7:3 5 6 si p. t W D. .
4
p
J n 2 2 4 ( imisn j2 5 p t inwi u prj d c a s c e sv ) a p a d s se ,
a . , 01 ) d s s ig 2 4 ei o t t eu ie s u c si e, p e l imis d No.
t
ho
1 - 0 (t Ci. r 22 2 1 ) Pu s a t o j2 4 ( , fd r l ititc u t yc n i e a
4 6 71 4h r Ap . , 0 4 . ru n t 2 4 1 a e e a d src o r ma o sd r
$
s c ors ce svej2254peii onl upons cfcce tfc tonfom aUniedStt Cour
e ond uc si
tton y
pe ii riiai r
t aes
t
ofAppe l .Bec us peii rha nots itd a e de et thehasobt ne t t
as
a e ttone s
pbm te ny vi nc ha
ài d ha

c ri ain Ids s t p tto wih u p eu iea s c e sv .Ba e u nt etn igta
e t to , imis he eii n t o t rj dc s u c s ie s d po h t dn h t
fc
t pe ii rha no m ade t r qui ie s t nta s i ofa de a o a c tt i nalrght
he ttone s t
he e st ubs a i l how ng
ni l f ons iuto
i

a rquie by28U. C.j2253/)a Sl kv.M c nil 529U. 473,48 (
s e rd
S.
nd ac
Da e,
S.
4 2000) a
,
c r ii a e ofa
e tf c t
ppea a lt i de e
l biiy s ni d.

.
;

E E T i 1 . dyo Jl,07
NT R: hs l - a fuy2 1.
#

,

e o Unie St esD i t tJ ge
ni
td a
s dc u

2