Coulson v. Gardner et al

Filing 18

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/7/2017. (tvt)

CL
ERK: OFFI ù. DI COURT
CE s. sT.
AT DANVILE,
L VA
FI
LED

d 27 2 1
2V ' 07
I TH E UN I D STA TE S D I
N
TE
STR I CO UR T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON

TR AVI DALE COULSON,
S
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

ajlcxDR c R
YLH L L K
aA
;
u
.

x pt u nk
nyc

C i lAc i N o.7: 7- vvi t on
1 c 00264
M EM O M ND U M O PI I N
N O

J.B.G A RD N ER ,e al,
t .
D efendant
s.

By:

H on.Jackson L .K i
ser
.
Se or U nie St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

Tr vi Da eCoulon,aVig ni prs rpr e ng pr K ,fld a cvi rght aci n
a s l
s
r i a ione oc edi
o
ie
i l i s to

purua tt 42U. C.j1 3.OnSe e r29;201 t dee t fl amoi t dimis
s n o
S.
98
ptmbe
7,he fndans ied
ton o s s.
On t ne busne sda t Clr i s d aNotc t ta s d Pl ntf t tt m o i t
he xt i s y, he e k s ue
i e ha dvie ai if ha he ton o
dimi swa ûld o Se e r29,201 a t tPl ntf ha t nt o da fom t N o i
s s s e n pt mbe
7, nd ha ai if d we y- ne ys r he tce
t f l a r pons The N otc f r he a s
o ie es
e.
i e u t r dvi ed:

I Pl i if doe no r s
f antf
s t e pond .., t Co twil a s
. he ur l s ume t t Pl i if ha l t
ha antf s os
i e e ti t c e,a o t tPl i ifag e swih wha t De e ntsa e ....
nt r s n he as nd/ r ha antf r e t
t he f nda t t s
I Pli ifwihest c i wih t c s ,i i ne e s r t tPl i ifr pond i
f antf s o ontnue t he a e t s c s a y ha antf es
n
a a oprae f hi .... Howe r i Pli if doe not fl s m e r s ns
n ppr i t as on
ve . f antf
s
ie o
e no e

wi nt et n y o e ( )d y p ro ste Co r ma d s s t ec s frfize
t h we t - n 21 a e id h u t y imis h a e o alr
hi
l
t pr ecut
o os e.

Notc ( No.1 (rgi e
ie ECF
7) o i nal mpha i)
ss.
Pl ntf di notr po t t Notc ort moton t dim is a t Notc wasnot
ai if d
es nd o he i e he i o s s , nd he ie
r t ne t t co 'a unde i r bl Plrua tt t Notc e e ed on Ocobe 2,
e ur d o he ul s
t
lve a e. zs n o he i e nt r
t r 2017, fnd
Ii
t tPl ntf ha f ie t pr e t t s c s A c di y, he c pl i i di m i s w ihout
ha ai i f s a l d o os cu e hi a e. cor ngl t om a nt s s s ed t

p eu ief rPlitf' f i r t p o e u e pt s n t F d R. v. 41b , n al e dng
rj d c o anifs al e o r s c t, l ua t o e . Ci P. ( ) a d lp n i
u
r
moinsa ed n e wi o t eudc a mo t Se Li lv W a ahR. Co, 7 U. 6 6 6 0
to r e id t u prj ie s o. e nt . b s R. .3 0 S. 2 , 3 h
31( 962)Ct' a hort ofac tt dimiss s ef l k ofpr e utonhasge r ly
1
xhe ut iy
our o s s ua pont or ac
os c i
ne al
be n c i r d a Snhe entpow e , ... e s rl ves e i co t t m a ge t i ow n afais
e ons de e n i r
r ' nec s a iy t d n urs o na he r
f r

s a t a hivet or rya e dii dipostonofca e .
o s o c e he de l nd xpe tous s ii
s s'
).
+
ENTER : s '
Thi

a ofN ove r 201
y
mbe , 7.
e
$

Se rUnie St t sDititJ
n'
t d a e src udge