Dotson v. Clarke

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 8/2/2017. (mlh)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI COUX
B
CE S. SI
AT DANVI LE,
L VA
FI
LED

I Tu E v x l o slw lx s m sTm cT c o c R'
x
u
r

.

FOR THE w ssl
xux ol Tm c' ol ucl A
s
r ?w
xl
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O
K EV I D O TSO N
N

,

AL -2 2 7
C
2
.

J
uL

BY:

l o .
c
: -

,

Ci lA c i n N o.7: : 00269 DE
vi t o
17- v-

Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O

DI ECT O R H A R O LD CL AR K E,
R
D ef
endant
.

By:

H on. ks L.K i e
Jac on
sr
Se or U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
ni
t d at
src

Ke n Doton,aVigi ai aepr e i pr #q c
vi
s
r ni nm t oc ed ng o , omm e dtlsci la ton ptrua t
nce li vi c i zs n
-

t 4 U.. j1 3b n e rirta Jme6 2 7 At h o s to t ea to t ec u t
o 2 SC. 98 y o ale h n t , 01 . t e n e f h cin,h o r
pe mitdPl ntf oa yt pr e L fr pau rsbuta s dPlitf ha s h
r te ai ift ppl o oce d q oma pei
dvie anift t uc
pe mison wo d ber s i d i Pli tf sha t e prorc esdim is d a f i ous
r si
ul
e cnde f a n ifha d hr e i as s s e s rvol ,

maiiu , rf rf ilet saeacam, t s a t o2 U. C. 1 5 g .
lco s o o alr o tt li pl u n t 8 S. j 91 ( )
t
r
Upon ar vi ofc 'r or , ta a sPl i ifhasha a l a tt e non- bea cvi
e ew
oul ec ds i ppe r antf
t
d t e s hr e
ha s i l
ac i o a al pr vi l d s i s d a f i o ,asm a i i ,orf f ii t s a e a c a m
tons r ppe s e ousy i m s e s rvol us
lc ous
or a lng o t t l i
be or com m e i t s a ton. Se D ot on v. a
f e
nc ng hi c i
e
s
Poc hont s St t Con' Ct . N o.7: 7c
a ae
. r,
1 v195,si
lp

o ( . Va Jme 1 2 7 ( imisdwi u p eudc a gi oo ) Do s nv. tdS ae
p.W D. . t , 01 ) d s se t t rj ie s v lus; to Uni tts
ho
e

Dit Co r, . 1 c 9 si o ( . Va Jme1 2 7 ( imisdwi u p eudc a
s. u tNo 7:7 v1 4, lp p.W D. . t , 01 ) ds se t t rj ie s
ho
fi lt ) Dos nv. le, . :3 v 7 , l o a 2( . Va De . , 01 )(imis d
rvoot ; to TelrNo 7 1 c 4 6 si p. t W D. . c 6 2 3 ds se
s
p
wih u p eu iea fi lu ) s eas Coe nv. les n 1 5S. . 7 9 1 6 ( 01 )
t o t rj dc s rvoo s; e lo lma To lfo , 3 Ct 1 5 , 7 3 2 5
(o dn aç tie' imis l sc u tdrg r ls t t tmigo as b e u n a p a) M c a
h l ig t rk 'd s s a i o n e e a de s o he i n f u s q e t p e l; Le n
s

v. ie Sae , 6 F.d3 , 9 ( t Ci. 0 9 ( tn d s saswih u p eu ief r
Untd tts 5 6 3 91 3 9 4h r 2 0 ) noig imis l t o t rj dc o
fi ous s s dnotbee mptdfom 28U. C.j1 5( )
rvol ne s houl
xe e '
r
S. 91 g).
A f e r vi w i Pl i i f s s i s o i t s c vi ac i n,i i cl a t tPl i ifdoe no
t r e e ng a ntf ubm s i ns n hi i l t o t s e r ha a ntf
s t
a l ge a f c si c tng t the i c r nty unde a i m i ntt ea ofa s r ousphysca
le ny a t ndi a i ha
s ur e l
r ny m ne hr t ny e i
i l

ij r wi nt me nn o 28U. C. 1 5 g .Ac o dn l , ds s t ea to . t o t
nu y t he n ig f
hi
S. j 91 () c r ig y I imis h cin wih u

.
'

.
.

.

p eudc d et Pli tf' f i r t p yt tln fea t tmeo fl t ec mpan .S e
rj ie u o anifs al e o a he iig e the i f i h o lit e .
u
ng
e:, p e v. l r 2 4F.d 1 3 ,1 3 ( 1hCi. 0 )(e s rn t tt efln fei d e
..Du re Pame , 8 3 2 4 2 7 1 t r 20 2 r a ol g ha h iig e s u
i
upo ûlngaci la tonFhe L fr pa rspr sonsdonota yt pli ifa t tt
n i
vi ci
n q o ma upei ovii
ppl o antf nd ha he
c ti no r quie t pe tpl i ifa opporuniy t pa t flng f eafe r c zi
our s t e r d o nni antf n
t t o y he ii e tr e ogni ng

pl ntf i i lgi et pr ee i f mapa rs.
ai if s nei bl o oc d q or
upei)
l

EN TER : Thi

da ofA ugus ,201
y
t
7.

'

'
*

<
'

2

*$

o U nie St t s D it i tJ
r t d a e s rc udge