Ham v. United States of America

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/27/2017. (tvt)

G ERK' DFFI U. DI
S
CE S. 3T.
AT RO,>QKE.
'1
: . VA
i

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O UR T
C
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI
JO H N FO R RE ST H A M , .
JR ,

J 2? 2 1
UN
27
U - :.-.'1*
ULI . . ,

BY:

C A SE N O .7:
17CV 00295

Pe ii r,
t tone
V.

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

UNI
TED STATES OF AM ERI
CA,

By: H on.Gln E.Conr
e
ad
C hi fU nie St e D it i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

R e ponde .
s
nt
J l Fo r s H a , J . a i at a t U nied St t s Pe t nta y i Lee Count
om
r e t m r , n nm e t he
t
ae
nie i r n
y,

Vigi a,fl d t s a ton,pr s a a pe ii f a wrt of ha a cor unde 28 U . C.
r ni ie hi c i
o e, s
tton or
i
be s pus
r
S.

j2241 Hnm algest the s d ber s ntnc d,bec us hi fderlcrmi lsntnce i
.
le ha
houl
ee e e
a e s e a i na e e s
unlwf lt rM ahi v.Unied St t , U .
a u mde
t s
t
aes
S.
-

-

,

1 6 S Ct2 43( 01 )a dJ h o v Urtd
3 . . 2 2 6 n o ns n . l e
i

Sae , U. ,1 S.Ct 2551( 5) Upon rviw o t r or t c tc l st t
tts
S. 35
.
201 .
e e f he ec d, he our oncude ha
Hn s cam f r i unde j 2241 i t s c ti a opdaey c t ed a a moton t
m' li or elef
r
n hi our s ppr tl onsnz s
i o

v c t , e a i o c pe t h sn e c u d r2 U. C. 2 5 a dta ser dt t es n e cn
a ae st sde r o c t e e tn e n e 8 S. j 2 5 n rn fre o h e tn i g
cour .
t

Hn ' peii a co r co ds aval bl onlne i cae t tHn pl de guly i
m s tton nd urt e r
ia e i ndi t ha m ea d it n
201 i t Unied St t s Ditit Cotr f Sout Ca olna t pos e so of a fr r a a
0 n he
t
a e src
zt or
h r i o
s sin
iea m s

c n itd fln,c a k n ,a d p se so o a fr am i f rh rn e o a ci o vo e c .
o v ce eo mj c i g n o s sin f ie r n u tea c f rme f iln e
Th c u tsn e c d Ha t 31 mo t si pi o . Th j g n wa afr d o a p a, nd
e o r e tn q m o 9 nh n zs n e ud me t s fime n p e l a
Hn s j2 5 mo in i te So t Caoi DititCo r wa t u c s f l Assae ,Hn
m' 2 5 to n h uh r l
na src u t s ms c e su .
ttd m
no p tto st sc u tu d rj 2 41 f rh be sc r u r l fu d rt e M ah sa d J h o
w ei n hi o r n e 2 o a a o p s ei n e h
i
e
ti n o ns n
de i i ns H n bele s t t hi s nt nc i unco tt i lbe aus pr or c
c so . m
i ve ha s e e e s
ns i ona c e i onvi t o us d t
m
c i ns e o
e nc t s nt nc a l edl no l r qua iy aspr di a esunde t A r e Ca e r Crm i l
nha e he e e e leg y
onge
lf
e ct
r he m d r e i na

A c a t Ca ee Ofe rgui lne.
t nd he r r f nde
de i

Assa e Hn ' c am c le est l ga iy ofhi f de als nt nce a i
t t d, m s l i hal ng he e lt
s e r e e
s mpos d. Suc
e
h

cai mus nomal beried on a alori a j2255 moton i t s ntncng c t I r
l ms t r ly as
ppe
n
i n he e e i our. n e

J n s 2 6 F.d 3 8,3 2 (t Ci.2 0 ) Peio rs j 2 41peiin r iig s c cams i
o e , 2 3 2 3 4 h r 0 0 . tt ne ' 2
i
t o asn u h li s
t
bard t e si me t t srnge sandad ma td l rt J
re mls t es he ti nt t r ndae mde he onesdecso L=. t333iin. d a
34

(i dng t t c aln e t fd r lc n cin i b re fo rviw u d r j 2 41 a e ta
fn i ha h le g o e ea o vito s ar d r m e e n e
2 bs n
s
howi t tunde apos- onviton c
ng ha
r
tc c i hangei t lw,peii rsof e eco uc i no l er
n he a
ttone ' f ns nd t s ong

ci n l. Be a e n ih rt e M ah sd cso n rte J hn o d cso h d n efc o te
rmia) c us et e h t i e ii n o h o s n e ii n a o fe t n h
ci n ly o Hn sf d r lo fns c n u t h c n o p o e d wih h scam t e j 2 41
rmiai f m' e ea fe e o d c, e n n t r c e t i li md r 2 .
t
Theef e t c twilde r le unde j2241,c t e Ha ' s sin a a j 2255
r or, he our l ny eif
r
onsnz m s ubmiso s
m oton, a ta f r i t t Unie Stt Ditit Cour f So h Ca olna f r f rhe
i
nd r ns e t o he
t d aes src
t or ut
r i o ut r
pr e ngsi lghtoft r c ntc tde sonsHa cies
oc edi n i
he e e our cii
m t .TheCl r i die t d t s nd c e
e k s r c e o e opi s
oft sm e a
hi mor ndum o ni n a a co pa ng or rt peii r
pi o nd c m nyi
de o ttone .

s s Ti âqQa oln,07
xT R: hs
y fue2 1.
Chi fUrie St t Diti tJ
e lt d aes src udge

2